This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Romford-Eagle
Could see your eyes lit up then. Anyone else sit through that dross in Hungary, first defeat to them in 60 years, no urgency from players earning mega bucks each week, you must question Southgate's tactical prowess, he reminds me so much of a younger Roy, yarn. He picks players who should be nowhere near an England team, Justin who? and sorry, but that bloke from Leeds, Phillips, way out of his depth. I think we would be Euro Champions if negative Southgate, was not manager, he made Italy look good. And at the end of the match, rather that criticise his team selection and tactics, all he did was talk about booing taking the knee. I would sack him in morning, he is far to WOKE. I do understand your post and I do broadly agree. This isn't a counter to what you've stated, just my opinion on a few things: 1. This post may be best placed on 'Football Talk'. I wouldn't bet against the mods moving it at some point. 2. I think Southgate has done a very good job, or did do, for a period, I'll explain my stance: - I think he came into the England set-up with a relaxed attitude which has helped the players. The shirt has certainly, to a degree, looked less burdensome the last few years. - He has blooded a lot of new/younger players... a lot! - Furthermore, he hasn't rigidly stuck to certain players who despite numerous failings still maintained their place in the squad, as other managers have done. - He has a very approachable and non-prima donna quality to him, something the England managerial role has seriously lacked in the past few decades. - He has implemented a style of play that seems far less rigid than certainly I had grown accustom to, although admittedly that did come roaring back against the Magyars. However, he has been in the role a while... and: - He still seems to be adopting the same approach, which was effective, exciting and refreshing at first however cannot continue otherwise you'll run out of player to introduce to the national set up and you'll never know your 'best team'. He had his minor revolution which was great but now 'fans' want results. - We do have a lot of talented players eligible for England atm. The old argument and perspective that the players may be of a higher quality than the manager and therefore results are disappointing is certainly possible. - Perhaps he is 'too nice'? Perhaps he is just yet another FA 'yes man'? Perhaps he is a 'one trick pony' and what he did was impressive however there's not much beyond that? Perhaps he does not command the respect of the players that may be necessary of a manager? Just my impression of course so could be totally wrong but I think there's substance to that notion. I think Southgate did fantastically for a while however I think he has enough in the bank to warrant a least a notable and awful fall from grace before a 'sacking'. Playin Justin ahead of Mitchell may warrant that however. If he was sacked tomorrow (now today) perhaps we could bring in Ragnick on an interim basis and see how deep any rot runs for perspective?
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I do understand your post and I do broadly agree. This isn't a counter to what you've stated, just my opinion on a few things: 1. This post may be best placed on 'Football Talk'. I wouldn't bet against the mods moving it at some point. 2. I think Southgate has done a very good job, or did do, for a period, I'll explain my stance: - I think he came into the England set-up with a relaxed attitude which has helped the players. The shirt has certainly, to a degree, looked less burdensome the last few years. - He has blooded a lot of new/younger players... a lot! - Furthermore, he hasn't rigidly stuck to certain players who despite numerous failings still maintained their place in the squad, as other managers have done. - He has a very approachable and non-prima donna quality to him, something the England managerial role has seriously lacked in the past few decades. - He has implemented a style of play that seems far less rigid than certainly I had grown accustom to, although admittedly that did come roaring back against the Magyars. However, he has been in the role a while... and: - He still seems to be adopting the same approach, which was effective, exciting and refreshing at first however cannot continue otherwise you'll run out of player to introduce to the national set up and you'll never know your 'best team'. He had his minor revolution which was great but now 'fans' want results. - We do have a lot of talented players eligible for England atm. The old argument and perspective that the players may be of a higher quality than the manager and therefore results are disappointing is certainly possible. - Perhaps he is 'too nice'? Perhaps he is just yet another FA 'yes man'? Perhaps he is a 'one trick pony' and what he did was impressive however there's not much beyond that? Perhaps he does not command the respect of the players that may be necessary of a manager? Just my impression of course so could be totally wrong but I think there's substance to that notion. I think Southgate did fantastically for a while however I think he has enough in the bank to warrant a least a notable and awful fall from grace before a 'sacking'. Playin Justin ahead of Mitchell may warrant that however. If he was sacked tomorrow (now today) perhaps we could bring in Ragnick on an interim basis and see how deep any rot runs for perspective? A nuanced and fair assessment. I'm in agreement that he certainly has enough in the bank to see us through to the World Cup and it'd be very knee jerk to ditch him now. It's not a performance to remember, but it's also one that will be relatively quickly forgotten as the World Cup approaches. May as well put out a more tried and tested team for the other Nations League games and just see what comes of it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Romford-Eagle
Could see your eyes lit up then. Anyone else sit through that dross in Hungary, first defeat to them in 60 years, no urgency from players earning mega bucks each week, you must question Southgate's tactical prowess, he reminds me so much of a younger Roy, yarn. He picks players who should be nowhere near an England team, Justin who? and sorry, but that bloke from Leeds, Phillips, way out of his depth. I think we would be Euro Champions if negative Southgate, was not manager, he made Italy look good. And at the end of the match, rather that criticise his team selection and tactics, all he did was talk about booing taking the knee. I would sack him in morning, he is far to WOKE.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Romford-Eagle
Could see your eyes lit up then. Anyone else sit through that dross in Hungary, first defeat to them in 60 years, no urgency from players earning mega bucks each week, you must question Southgate's tactical prowess, he reminds me so much of a younger Roy, yarn. He picks players who should be nowhere near an England team, Justin who? and sorry, but that bloke from Leeds, Phillips, way out of his depth. I think we would be Euro Champions if negative Southgate, was not manager, he made Italy look good. And at the end of the match, rather that criticise his team selection and tactics, all he did was talk about booing taking the knee. I would sack him in morning, he is far to WOKE.
|
|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
He is a good player manager but a useless coach! What would you suggest as an alternative? Go back to playing meaningless friendlies like wot happened before?
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by YT
What would you suggest as an alternative? Go back to playing meaningless friendlies like wot happened before? I agree the friendlies were a waste of time. IMO the players should now be on a break and these games are nothing but money spinners for the powers that be.
|
|
|
Lacklustre performance from a team still on the beach in a meaningless compo created to make more money. Nearly as bad as friendlies.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
Southgate is and always will be a crap manager/player, but does anyone really care about international football, for me its unimportant. I only care about the mighty PALACE is the correct answer. Southgate will never help us kick politics out of football. Another Gary Linekar.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer
A miserable game to watch. A bit harsh to put the blame on Southgate though. He's done a reasonable job in his time and will be replaced after Qatar. Some of those players, already mentioned, looked either out of their depth or out of sorts. Couldn't decide which. For sure they won't figure much in the important games. Poor selection, poor tactics, players out of position. All seen previously against Italy and against Croatia. Not a good manager, not even an average one. Some kid who had played FIFA twice, could have picked a better side and tactics.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
I'd be peed off if I was obliged to play a meaningless game in a vaguely hostile stadium when I'd rather be on the beach. They're allowed a holiday, surely.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.