You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Aston Villa vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread
November 16 2026 3.02am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Aston Villa vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread


Page 10 of 13 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 17 Sep 23 10.19am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Woken up more angry about this, despite my rather athletic night in with the missus. Oh well, rugby today and then ten pints or so should do it.

Edited by ASCPFC (17 Sep 2023 10.14am)

Those were the days

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 17 Sep 23 10.47am

Well according to former referee Chris Foy we are all wrong. Surprise surprise he backs Darren England all the way and says it was a penalty.


 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 17 Sep 23 10.54am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Well according to former referee Chris Foy we are all wrong. Surprise surprise he backs Darren England all the way and says it was a penalty.


Having now seen it several times, if that’s a penalty then the game of football is slowly becoming fcuked. How they can sod about for so long with so many different angles and still come to the wrong decision. VAR is amusing when you’re on the right end of it, but seriously it is ruining the game

Bring back the days where you get a good honest referee fcuk up, at least we know where we all stood and the games finished the same day they actually started

 

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 17 Sep 23 11.03am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Woken up more angry about this, despite my rather athletic night in with the missus. Oh well, rugby today and then ten pints or so should do it.

Edited by ASCPFC (17 Sep 2023 10.14am)

schmoozed her with Buckfast & a chippy tea no doubt.
Cunning ASCPFC , poor woman stood no chance.

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

YT Flag Oxford 17 Sep 23 11.06am

The treading on Eze's foot by a Wolves player two weeks ago was 'far more of a penalty' than yesterday.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 17 Sep 23 11.09am

Originally posted by monkey

Having now seen it several times, if that’s a penalty then the game of football is slowly becoming fcuked. How they can sod about for so long with so many different angles and still come to the wrong decision. VAR is amusing when you’re on the right end of it, but seriously it is ruining the game

Bring back the days where you get a good honest referee fcuk up, at least we know where we all stood and the games finished the same day they actually started

VAR were telling D. England to change his decision, they knew it wasn't a pen. MOTD & Sky also said it wasn't, England decided he was right( prob get a smarmy apology from POGMOL now).

Wasn't it the good old fashioned ref fcuk up the reason we all wanted something 'better'? Careful what you wish for springs to mind.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Hannes Flag Vienna 17 Sep 23 11.26am

I’ m fully in sympathy with the idea of going back to the “good , old days” without VAR. On the other hand, I strongly suspect that we would have have been 0:1 down by the 18th minute yesterday, had VAR not been introduced.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 17 Sep 23 11.29am

When it comes to issues similar to yesterday's penalty decisions, it's back in the realm of opinion.

VAR is useful in terms of offside, where - if used correctly - it can result in a correct call.

But as we saw yesterday, the Richards incident becomes subjective. And the majority think England got it wrong, as do I.

As for the performance, a classic ' smash and grab ' looked on the cards. More clinical finishing could have put the game beyond Villa. It's hugely disappointing to have resisted so well for the majority of the game only to concede so late.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 17 Sep 23 12.00pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

VAR were telling D. England to change his decision, they knew it wasn't a pen. MOTD & Sky also said it wasn't, England decided he was right( prob get a smarmy apology from POGMOL now).

Wasn't it the good old fashioned ref fcuk up the reason we all wanted something 'better'? Careful what you wish for springs to mind.

I don’t think they tell the refs to change their decisions, they just suggest they might want to go to the screen and have a look. Which is obviously a massive hint that they might want to think again. I think some refs stick with their decision now despite being told to go to the screen as a power trip, it’s an ‘I’m in charge’ sort of thing, even if the evidence is clear.

I suppose in this case before VAR England would’ve given the penalty and it would’ve been a fcuk up we all would’ve been moaning about it, but at least we wouldn’t have had the chance that the decision could be reversed dangled in front of us for 5 minutes and then it’s still given even though it’s clearly wrong, which makes things a heck of a lot worse and more frustrating. At least before VAR you could understand why and how he fcuked up with one look and the speed of the game, but now there shouldn’t be any excuse which makes ut even more frustrating for fans

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 Sep 23 12.41pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

VAR were telling D. England to change his decision, they knew it wasn't a pen. MOTD & Sky also said it wasn't, England decided he was right( prob get a smarmy apology from POGMOL now).

Wasn't it the good old fashioned ref fcuk up the reason we all wanted something 'better'? Careful what you wish for springs to mind.

In the last 11 games England has reffed Villa he has awarded them 7 penalties. Palace have never won when he has been in charge. Just saying.

 

IMMER PALACE Flag BIELEFELD 17 Sep 23 12.49pm

You normally come up with an interesting or thought provoking post - but this is pony.

Football, for a club our size, with the constraints we operate in is ultra competitive. There is an average of less than 3 goals scored per game. The idea that Palace should be so much better than the better funded opposition away from home that we can easily overcome terrible decisions like that is delusional.

The ref done us. Short and simple. Mistake or ego or bent.


Originally posted by tonymikejoe

I do have a soft spot for this American attitude to 'sports'.
We are always moaning on about "the referee!" "the lino!" "we had an injury!" but I think the American attitude is not to be so tolerant of excuses.
For instance, why wasn't it one of our forwards breaking into their box and forcing a desperate last ditch sliding tackle?
If we were doing that down their end we may have got a dodgy pen.
We were hostages to fortune in this game and exposed ourselves to the consequences of a ropey decision.
We have to be good enough to overcome the questionable decisions of the officials.

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 17 Sep 23 12.50pm

My take on the game there were a lot of decisions particularly in the first half that went our way. I thought Hughes should have been booked for pulling or trying to pull one of there players back when they were breaking away early on and the disallowed goal was also a very tight call. A split second either with the timing of the run or the frame of the video when the ball left the foot and it could easily have stood. Once we went a head we looked more likely to score a second than they were going to get an equaliser. Ward's miss was the pick of the decent chances we created at that time.
I thought the reason we ultimately lost were down was due to fatigue and not having suitable players on the bench. If we had not lost Lerma and Guehi we would have had Hughes and Richards on the bench. Similarly if Ayew had not got injured Mateta would have been brought on later possibly instead of another midfielder. Where as Villa were just bringing on people like Baily and Tilemans who continued to stetch our tiring midfield.
I thought the penalty call was correct. I think Richards went with his wrong foot and although it was a tight one he made contact with leg first and then ball.
A shout to Doucoure - thought he was supurb. Particularly offensively when we got in front. I can see why Liverpool are keen and big money is been talked about. Eze was not as effective as he can be. Villa were showing him the left side but he always wanted to come in side on his right foot and often got crowded out because of it.

 

YT Flag Oxford 17 Sep 23 12.52pm

Originally posted by monkey

I don’t think they tell the refs to change their decisions, they just suggest they might want to go to the screen and have a look. Which is obviously a massive hint that they might want to think again. I think some refs stick with their decision now despite being told to go to the screen as a power trip, it’s an ‘I’m in charge’ sort of thing, even if the evidence is clear.

I suppose in this case before VAR England would’ve given the penalty and it would’ve been a fcuk up we all would’ve been moaning about it, but at least we wouldn’t have had the chance that the decision could be reversed dangled in front of us for 5 minutes and then it’s still given even though it’s clearly wrong, which makes things a heck of a lot worse and more frustrating. At least before VAR you could understand why and how he fcuked up with one look and the speed of the game, but now there shouldn’t be any excuse which makes ut even more frustrating for fans

Except even before VAR, you were only supposed to award a penalty if you (or the line-o) were absolutely certain an offence had been committed. You weren't supposed to award one because you thought "it might be" an offence. Now refs can award a soft penalty in the knowledge that VAR will look at it anyway, so there will be a "get out of jail card", even though that 'card' nevertheless exposes a wrong decision. In this example, however, the ref somehow decided that there was enough of a case for a penalty for him to save face. Bizarre.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

dreamwaverider Flag London 17 Sep 23 1.07pm

What are the exact rules on penalties?
If the defender touches the ball before the man, and I mean slightly, is that still a penalty if the attacker then trips over the defender? Maybe touching the ball very slightly doesn't count as touching it. It didn't yesterday.

Secondly what is the rule on attackers entering the penalty box before the penalty taker shoots? The Villa man was well inside the box way before the penalty was kicked.
If the rule says he is allowed but he can't interfere if the ball doesn't go in, then players should start running in early to put the keeper off.

It's all so ambiguous and muddling. Does the game no favours. The refs and VAR blokes should follow the rules properly and they should have to explain to the viewers their take on what they saw and why they made their decision.

Six minutes to decide a penalty decision is way too long. Yesterday there was 16 minutes of extra time. I had a train to catch.

Edited by dreamwaverider (17 Sep 2023 1.08pm)

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 17 Sep 23 1.11pm

Originally posted by YT

Except even before VAR, you were only supposed to award a penalty if you (or the line-o) were absolutely certain an offence had been committed. You weren't supposed to award one because you thought "it might be" an offence. Now refs can award a soft penalty in the knowledge that VAR will look at it anyway, so there will be a "get out of jail card", even though that 'card' nevertheless exposes a wrong decision. In this example, however, the ref somehow decided that there was enough of a case for a penalty for him to save face. Bizarre.

That’s why it’s all turned into a farce and is ruining the game, I don’t think even the refs know which way to turn sometimes.
Also If that had been at Selhurst yesterday would he have stuck to his decision? Or did he just bottle it in front of the Villa fans?

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 17 Sep 23 1.35pm

Originally posted by monkey

That’s why it’s all turned into a farce and is ruining the game, I don’t think even the refs know which way to turn sometimes.
Also If that had been at Selhurst yesterday would he have stuck to his decision? Or did he just bottle it in front of the Villa fans?

I don't think he 'bottled' it as you infer, he was the one that immediately gave the pen, VAR suggested he went & have another look, he decided he was right, no 'bottling' imo.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 17 Sep 23 1.47pm

I genuinely think he did bottle it. I was there and the longer his deliberations went on the more the Villa crowd got on his back. I totally think he bottled overturning the decision because he was becoming more and more conscious of what the home crowd reaction would be like.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 17 Sep 23 2.09pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

I genuinely think he did bottle it. I was there and the longer his deliberations went on the more the Villa crowd got on his back. I totally think he bottled overturning the decision because he was becoming more and more conscious of what the home crowd reaction would be like.

Sadly, that’s my view on it as well. Been down the other end the penalty wouldn’t have been given in my opinion :-(

 

Robk Flag 17 Sep 23 2.36pm

Unfortunately Darren England isn’t one of the better Referees... Oliver or Taylor wouldn’t have given it....

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 17 Sep 23 2.36pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

I don't think he 'bottled' it as you infer, he was the one that immediately gave the pen, VAR suggested he went & have another look, he decided he was right, no 'bottling' imo.

Only he’ll know for sure, but can you imagine the wrath of the home crowd if he had changed his decision? I do think it was more of an ego thing though, ‘I’m right and I’m not changing my mind’ it’s got to be that because no one is surely that stupid to still think that was a penalty after looking at it again

 

Page 10 of 13 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Aston Villa vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread