This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle
Then we're going to have to agree to disagree..!! My issue with Roy ATM is that he is starting players irrespective of how badly they are playing/performing. Ward is a prime example - there was an instance yesterday where he got absolutely rinsed (again) and he was trying to get back but looked like he was running in treacle..!! Hughes is simply not Prem standard - too lightweight - defensively yesterday he was awful - which culminated in him not tracking his runner for their 3rd goal. Schlupp is not a left sided attacking player - as I've said before I'm still not sure what he is - other than a half decent bench utility player. I get that some other players are untried - but if you don't try them when other players are not performing how are you going to find anything out about them - and how do they gain experience..?? Therein lies my issue with Roy ATM - clearly players in certain positions aren't good enough he has other/younger options but won't give them a go..!! Look it's not a Roy thing - I was one that supported he should be given another year after what he achieved last season - but ATM he seems to have descended back into "old Roy" rather than the Roy of last season that got the best out of younger players as in Eze and Olise..!! His recent comments on younger players tells you all you need to know about his current mindset on younger players - hence continuing to play under performing elder/more experienced players. On the injuries - get the whole thing about being match fit etc - my personal view is that you are fit enough to be on the bench you're fit enough to be playing..!! Even if you allow for putting them on the bench to start with - then make the Sub's early when clearly things aren't working don't wait until 60 odd minutes and you are losing and chasing the game..!! Look we played some good stuff yesterday and IMO Everton were there for the taking - but poor initial team selection - exacerbated by making substitutions cost us..!! And that's down to Roy..!! It's a personal opinion - not asking everyone to agree with me - but that's the way I saw yesterday..!! On another subject so far as I can see no one has mentioned Eze's penalty shout when he got booked for diving - VAR replays showed clear contact - so why wasn't it referred for review..?? Worse still why did the booking for diving still stand..?? Just another example of VAR inconsistencies that are getting so infuriating and make no sense..!! All of that said there were signs yesterday of good things to come..!! COYP Funny how people see things differently. For me, Hughes has shown over the last few weeks how good he is. Breaks things up keeps things tidy. He wasn't at his destructive best yesterday, but thought he did well. Schlupp for me is a left sided attacking player - if he's anything at all. But yes probably bench utility is his best role. I actually thought we were decent yesterday. Some of the build up play was exquisite. Just one of those things were bad finishing and a few defensive lapses cost us. I want Dwight Gayle back. As an aside. He'd be banging in some of those chances Eduoard is fluffing.
|
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
I actually thought we were decent yesterday. Some of the build up play was exquisite. Just one of those things were bad finishing a I want Dwight Gayle back. As an aside. He'd be banging in some of those chances Eduoard is fluffing. Funny that , I would say Hughes has shown over the past few weeks ,well rather confirmed that he is a back up player at best ,the third goal was due in part to one of his many defensive lapses ,he's just too slow covering the ground and often loses his man .Like Gale Hughes is Championship standard ,we have to be better than that ,
|
|
|
Originally posted by Elpis
Funny that , I would say Hughes has shown over the past few weeks ,well rather confirmed that he is a back up player at best ,the third goal was due in part to one of his many defensive lapses ,he's just too slow covering the ground and often loses his man .Like Gale Hughes is Championship standard ,we have to be better than that , ANother poster spreading nonsense & has no clue I agree with sprites. Hughes was the only one helping Mitchell at times and you cant expect him to cover every area (Schlupp should be the one doing more others have to pick up his slack) You do not play as many games he has for England u21 if you are Championship quality. You have missed one of the big factors Roy does not use a lot of peoples strengths and plays people out of positions.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle
Then we're going to have to agree to disagree..!! My issue with Roy ATM is that he is starting players irrespective of how badly they are playing/performing. Ward is a prime example - there was an instance yesterday where he got absolutely rinsed (again) and he was trying to get back but looked like he was running in treacle..!! Schlupp is not a left sided attacking player - as I've said before I'm still not sure what he is - other than a half decent bench utility player. I get that some other players are untried - but if you don't try them when other players are not performing how are you going to find anything out about them - and how do they gain experience..?? Therein lies my issue with Roy ATM - clearly players in certain positions aren't good enough he has other/younger options but won't give them a go..!! Look it's not a Roy thing - I was one that supported he should be given another year after what he achieved last season - but ATM he seems to have descended back into "old Roy" rather than the Roy of last season that got the best out of younger players as in Eze and Olise..!! His recent comments on younger players tells you all you need to know about his current mindset on younger players - hence continuing to play under performing elder/more experienced players. On the injuries - get the whole thing about being match fit etc - my personal view is that you are fit enough to be on the bench you're fit enough to be playing..!! Even if you allow for putting them on the bench to start with - then make the Sub's early when clearly things aren't working don't wait until 60 odd minutes and you are losing and chasing the game..!! Look we played some good stuff yesterday and IMO Everton were there for the taking - but poor initial team selection - exacerbated by making substitutions cost us..!! And that's down to Roy..!! It's a personal opinion - not asking everyone to agree with me - but that's the way I saw yesterday..!! On another subject so far as I can see no one has mentioned Eze's penalty shout when he got booked for diving - VAR replays showed clear contact - so why wasn't it referred for review..?? Worse still why did the booking for diving still stand..?? Just another example of VAR inconsistencies that are getting so infuriating and make no sense..!! All of that said there were signs yesterday of good things to come..!! COYP We don't really have any alternatives for ward. The old Roy knows how to get results when we are playing badly or have a limited squad. It's exactly what we need right now.
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
Ahamada essentially plays in the Lerma and Doucoure roles. He is currently behind Hughes in the pecking order of replacements if one or both are injured. He was injured for part of this season. He has had a couple of 20 minute sub appearances since returning from injury. As for Richards, he's not going to replace either Guehi or Andersen in the 1st XI. He's not a RB and as Midland has suggested, he'll be the replacement for Guehi or Andersen when the first of those leave. Edited by doombear (12 Nov 2023 3.20pm) Ahamada offers something different from Lerma or Doucoure, in particular his ability to carry the ball going forward, something we lacked when neither Eze or Olise was available. He could have been given a chance rather than stick with the same old options. Equally there have been times when bringing him on as a sub for either of the 2 you mention would have been reasonable. Edited by Palacesince64 (13 Nov 2023 12.33am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by grumpymort
ANother poster spreading nonsense & has no clue I agree with sprites. Hughes was the only one helping Mitchell at times and you cant expect him to cover every area (Schlupp should be the one doing more others have to pick up his slack) You do not play as many games he has for England u21 if you are Championship quality. You have missed one of the big factors Roy does not use a lot of peoples strengths and plays people out of positions. Quite simply, no, you are wrong. Hughes is too slow to play in that important spot next to Lerma. He also does not read the game as well as Doucoure. I can virtually guarantee we would not have conceded that third goal if Doucoure was on the pitch. It’s also ridiculous to say he helped out Mitchell. Of course he did, he’s the left sided of the holding two, he’s supposed to do that. Yes, Schlupp should be tracking back but if a wide man cuts inside early then it is Hughes job to intercept and he cost us the last goal by failing to track back. The pundits know their stuff, he got an outfield dead last 5.9 rating and the next lowest was Mitchell with a 6.3 He is very much a poor man’s Jimmy Mc and yet another of our make do players. My opinion but if you are going to call people’s opinions nonsense then I’m going to call you out on it and explain why they are not.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Quite simply, no, you are wrong. Hughes is too slow to play in that important spot next to Lerma. He also does not read the game as well as Doucoure. I can virtually guarantee we would not have conceded that third goal if Doucoure was on the pitch. It’s also ridiculous to say he helped out Mitchell. Of course he did, he’s the left sided of the holding two, he’s supposed to do that. Yes, Schlupp should be tracking back but if a wide man cuts inside early then it is Hughes job to intercept and he cost us the last goal by failing to track back. The pundits know their stuff, he got an outfield dead last 5.9 rating and the next lowest was Mitchell with a 6.3 He is very much a poor man’s Jimmy Mc and yet another of our make do players. My opinion but if you are going to call people’s opinions nonsense then I’m going to call you out on it and explain why they are not. I agree, but certainly a type of player we need on the bench. Sadly we have him and a couple more playing regularly that also should be on the bench. Until we have a better 11 those weaknesses that presently are starting will cause result like Saturday’s.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wilbraham413
Edouard is like Benteke, in that he is abject sh-t, but will be playing for us for the next 5 years. I can't imagine a future where OE will not be our starting striker every match. It’s no coincidence that any striker we sign struggles to score consistently. our style of play doesn’t create enough clear chances and we rarely get enough bodies in the opponents box unlike say Brentford.I think the overall lack of goals comes from our limited squad.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I for one never departed Selhurst Park feeling I had been "Entertained", I exited sullen faced and at my splenetic worst after a defeat and mulling over the fact that we had won only 1 of our 6 home games and lost 3 out of our last 4 games.
Edited by Willo (12 Nov 2023 10.06am) While disappointed to lose I was certainly entertained,that was a good football match!
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
I note with interest that of the home games against teams currently below us, Fulham, Forest, and Everton, we didn't win a single one. Two lame 0-0 draws and a defeat. Two point out of a possible nine. That's form that will see you slide done the table, as we appear to be doing. I'm inclined to agree at this point in time where I am concerned. It feels as though they have somewhat tried to follow the old model in reliance upon Wilf but this time with Eze/Olise taking up that mantle. What we're left with is a couple decent players providing all our threat and a lot of 'filling' elsewhere in the squad. The Franca one seems like a wild gamble with no real thought process behind it and Henderson purely a financial thing where they thought we were getting a player below his market worth for ROI (Ferguson may also come into this bracket, where their quality may be worth more than their fee, but their ability to stay/get fit renders the whole thing a complete waste of money). I would suggest trying to pull together a top half PL squad on a minimal budget is an endeavour with very limited chance of success. You'll either look like a genius or, more than likely, face criticism for a lot of your choices. It sometimes looks as though we've tried to pick up a load of bargains but many of these begin to show why such players were available at lower prices in the first place. You hope Roy can keep the ship afloat for the time being but we all knew, consciously or subconsciously, the reason why he was brought back to begin with. It was never to 'see out the season' whilst they re-strategised, it was always reflective of trying to do as much with as little resource as possible. It's a very small pool of managers willing/able to do that.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by grumpymort
ANother poster spreading nonsense & has no clue I agree with sprites. Hughes was the only one helping Mitchell at times and you cant expect him to cover every area (Schlupp should be the one doing more others have to pick up his slack) You do not play as many games he has for England u21 if you are Championship quality. You have missed one of the big factors Roy does not use a lot of peoples strengths and plays people out of positions.
Playing for England u21 is no barometer to your future level in the game . All its saying is you have performed well in that age bracket . Indeed you only have to look at the U21 squad Hughes was in (2015 euros) and you will find players now playing in the USA and Australia ,Salford city , Stevenage ,Norwich , Sunderland and Exeter city ,Championship at best . I haven't missed anything with regard Roy's team selection . He uses what he has got in the best way he can . We may have a difference of opinion in certain positions but we all basically pick the same players in the 'team for next week thread' .We really don't have a lot of options .
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I'm inclined to agree at this point in time where I am concerned. It feels as though they have somewhat tried to follow the old model in reliance upon Wilf but this time with Eze/Olise taking up that mantle. What we're left with is a couple decent players providing all our threat and a lot of 'filling' elsewhere in the squad. The Franca one seems like a wild gamble with no real thought process behind it and Henderson purely a financial thing where they thought we were getting a player below his market worth for ROI (Ferguson may also come into this bracket, where their quality may be worth more than their fee, but their ability to stay/get fit renders the whole thing a complete waste of money). I would suggest trying to pull together a top half PL squad on a minimal budget is an endeavour with very limited chance of success. You'll either look like a genius or, more than likely, face criticism for a lot of your choices. It sometimes looks as though we've tried to pick up a load of bargains but many of these begin to show why such players were available at lower prices in the first place. You hope Roy can keep the ship afloat for the time being but we all knew, consciously or subconsciously, the reason why he was brought back to begin with. It was never to 'see out the season' whilst they re-strategised, it was always reflective of trying to do as much with as little resource as possible. It's a very small pool of managers willing/able to do that. Well made points and I totally agree. Edited by southnorwoodhill (13 Nov 2023 9.52am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Quite simply, no, you are wrong. Hughes is too slow to play in that important spot next to Lerma. He also does not read the game as well as Doucoure. I can virtually guarantee we would not have conceded that third goal if Doucoure was on the pitch. It’s also ridiculous to say he helped out Mitchell. Of course he did, he’s the left sided of the holding two, he’s supposed to do that. Yes, Schlupp should be tracking back but if a wide man cuts inside early then it is Hughes job to intercept and he cost us the last goal by failing to track back. The pundits know their stuff, he got an outfield dead last 5.9 rating and the next lowest was Mitchell with a 6.3
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Quite simply, no, you are wrong. Hughes is too slow to play in that important spot next to Lerma. He also does not read the game as well as Doucoure. I can virtually guarantee we would not have conceded that third goal if Doucoure was on the pitch. It’s also ridiculous to say he helped out Mitchell. Of course he did, he’s the left sided of the holding two, he’s supposed to do that. Yes, Schlupp should be tracking back but if a wide man cuts inside early then it is Hughes job to intercept and he cost us the last goal by failing to track back. The pundits know their stuff, he got an outfield dead last 5.9 rating and the next lowest was Mitchell with a 6.3 He is very much a poor man’s Jimmy Mc and yet another of our make do players. My opinion but if you are going to call people’s opinions nonsense then I’m going to call you out on it and explain why they are not. 100% correct, one of the 3 key players.
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by grumpymort
ANother poster spreading nonsense & has no clue I agree with sprites. Hughes was the only one helping Mitchell at times and you cant expect him to cover every area (Schlupp should be the one doing more others have to pick up his slack) You do not play as many games he has for England u21 if you are Championship quality. You have missed one of the big factors Roy does not use a lot of peoples strengths and plays people out of positions. I don't dislike Hughes, but he is so slow and his overall game is average at best. Playing the advanced midfield position when we had a few injuries highlighted his limitations. There is a reason why Watford weren't prepared to give him a big payrise when he was in the last year of his contract and also why Palace only gave him a 3 year contract (so he can leave on a free next summer). He is now in his 3rd year with us, has never been a regular and although he made a decent number of appearances last season, many were as sub. On Sat he was slow to react for the first goal (albeit a number of others were at fault too) and the 3rd goal was shocking - the guy who walked passed him to score was an ageing defensive midfielder. Yes, Schlupp has been a disaster and seems to go missing on the left, in both attacking and defensive situations, but let's be honest Hughes is just not good enough. Yes he played for England U21 regularly, however, so did Bruce Dyer, so i think that says it all. Edited by palace99 (13 Nov 2023 10.32am) Edited by palace99 (13 Nov 2023 10.33am)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.