You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Team for Liverpool - Match Thread
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Team for Liverpool - Match Thread


Page 10 of 14 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
JRW2 Flag Dulwich 10 Dec 23 12.58pm

Originally posted by Willo

I have always asserted that referees err from time to time having to make split-second decisions under pressure in a fast moving game.

Finally, I am comfortable with my use of "Ablomb" in the context you highlighted.

Yes, exactly what I predicted you would say - willing to admit that referees "err", but never, never willing to agree with criticism of specific errors by individual referees.

I'm curious about your determination to keep using a word wrongly. Just stubbornness, I suppose - not a very attractive quality.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 10 Dec 23 1.00pm


We should give up on any game reffed by the Madley brothers - we never got much change out of Bobby either.

 

PatrickA Flag London 10 Dec 23 1.09pm

One of the so called benefits of 'VAR' was that it was supposed to remove the perceived bias towards the bigger teams in the event of contentious decisions; the reasoning being that the objectivity of VAR would remove doubt.
I can't claim VAR did or didn't achieve this aim yesterday.

However, I do think the standard of refereeing has deteriorated since the introduction of VAR, as well as spoiling the game as a spectacle.
Pre- VAR, for good or bad, the decision maker was clear as the referee was in sole control.
Now it's open to interpretation in many cases and the inconsistencies and controversies seem greater than ever.
There are divergences as to what constitutes handball, where lines should be drawn,whether there is interference in play and what is a foul.

At games the rhythm is continually disrupted with hold ups in play for VAR.
The spontaneity and excitement of the game can be ruined and feelings of injustice increased (think of Wolves at the wrong ebd of a number of critical decisions this season).

The only people who seem to benefit are the technology companies who seek to make continual inroads in their attempts to exploit the game and the broadcasters who are gleeful at the controversies.

As a final point, I don't believe VAR has eradicated bias towards the big clubs.
They continue to benefit from decisions from referees just has been the case since I started watching football over 50 years ago.


 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 10 Dec 23 1.11pm

I think the first penalty should have stood.

I didn’t see any identification of the exact moment a foul was committed. Hughes hassled their guy off the ball, he elected to fall over, it’s a contact sport. Furthermore the ref played on and had to stare at a VAR screen for some duration of time. It’s therefore a million miles from ‘clear and obvious’ before even considering it a foul in a first instance, in a contact sport.

The JPM penalty is stonewall, there’s no debate. There were an equal amount of fouls between the sides however a sincerely disproportionate issuing of cards. Both Ayew yellows were dubious and where the ambiguity of the rules and their application favours a cheating ref to assist the bigger team. Giving them two yellows in the dying embers is evidence for me of an attempt to cook the books in acknowledgment of this.

There’s ambiguity, subjective decision making, mistakes etc aplenty in football. When the script reads ‘overturned penalty, dodgy sending off and severely lopsided disciplinary action favours the title challengers to come from behind against their minnow opponents’, you know what is taking place. It’s a corrupt sport and a financial and commercial powerhouse. It’s not an even playing field.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Dec 23 1.13pm

Originally posted by JRW2

Yes, exactly what I predicted you would say - willing to admit that referees "err", but never, never willing to agree with criticism of specific errors by individual referees.

I'm curious about your determination to keep using a word wrongly. Just stubbornness, I suppose - not a very attractive quality.

With the greatest of respect, some might deem certain specific decisions "Errors" whilst others view them in a more positive light, accordingly those in the latter cohort will not agree with the former.

Apropos "Stubborness" far more negative terms have been hurled in my direction,indeed my self-deprecation has allowed me to admit to my plethora of limitations.In the final analysis I am not the Patron Saint of self-righteousness.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Dec 23 1.15pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I think the first penalty should have stood.

I didn’t see any identification of the exact moment a foul was committed. Hughes hassled their guy off the ball, he elected to fall over, it’s a contact sport. Furthermore the ref played on and had to stare at a VAR screen for some duration of time. It’s therefore a million miles from ‘clear and obvious’ before even considering it a foul in a first instance, in a contact sport.

The JPM penalty is stonewall, there’s no debate. There were an equal amount of fouls between the sides however a sincerely disproportionate issuing of cards. Both Ayew yellows were dubious and where the ambiguity of the rules and their application favours a cheating ref to assist the bigger team. Giving them two yellows in the dying embers is evidence for me of an attempt to cook the books in acknowledgment of this.

There’s ambiguity, subjective decision making, mistakes etc aplenty in football. When the script reads ‘overturned penalty, dodgy sending off and severely lopsided disciplinary action favours the title challengers to come from behind against their minnow opponents’, you know what is taking place. It’s a corrupt sport and a financial and commercial powerhouse. It’s not an even playing field.

With the greatest respect I do not agree with the general 'Thrust' of your message regards honesty and integrity.

Edited by Willo (10 Dec 2023 1.16pm)

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 10 Dec 23 1.38pm

Originally posted by Willo

With the greatest respect I do not agree with the general 'Thrust' of your message regards honesty and integrity.

Edited by Willo (10 Dec 2023 1.16pm)

I know what you think, or rather your stance Willo. I’ll write to the rest of the world and let them know football is an incorruptible sport, full of dignity and the upmost respect for the law. I should have done so when the World Cup was on in the great footballing nation of Qatar come to think of it. Both the tooth fairy and Santa had agreed to it but I was so busy correctly sorting my recycling and obeying speed limits.

Edited by Nicholas91 (10 Dec 2023 1.38pm)

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Dec 23 1.47pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I know what you think, or rather your stance Willo. I’ll write to the rest of the world and let them know football is an incorruptible sport, full of dignity and the upmost respect for the law. I should have done so when the World Cup was on in the great footballing nation of Qatar come to think of it. Both the tooth fairy and Santa had agreed to it but I was so busy correctly sorting my recycling and obeying speed limits.

Edited by Nicholas91 (10 Dec 2023 1.38pm)

Clearly we are on 'Opposite sides of the House' on the matter of honesty and integrity.

I do not believe that football in general is corrupt to the core and I certainly do not hold the view that referees purposely favour the bigger teams.

Edited by Willo (10 Dec 2023 1.52pm)

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 10 Dec 23 2.48pm

Originally posted by Willo

With the greatest of respect, some might deem certain specific decisions "Errors" whilst others view them in a more positive light, accordingly those in the latter cohort will not agree with the former.

Apropos "Stubborness" far more negative terms have been hurled in my direction,indeed my self-deprecation has allowed me to admit to my plethora of limitations.In the final analysis I am not the Patron Saint of self-righteousness.

Yes, some may regard some decisions as erroneous, but you will never admit to a single specific refereeing decision discussed on this site as wrong - not a single one. Instead you hide behind the same predictable and irrelevant guff that referees are only human and can err - which is a shame because it adds nothing to the debate.

By the way, I have always - rightly or wrongly - agreed with you on one thing. I'd be astonished if corruption didn't exist in football, but, without any grounds for saying this, I simply don't accept that referees are corrupt. Sometimes incompetent yes, but that takes us back to the first point........

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Dec 23 3.02pm

Originally posted by JRW2

Yes, some may regard some decisions as erroneous, but you will never admit to a single specific refereeing decision discussed on this site as wrong - not a single one. Instead you hide behind the same predictable and irrelevant guff that referees are only human and can err - which is a shame because it adds nothing to the debate.

By the way, I have always - rightly or wrongly - agreed with you on one thing. I'd be astonished if corruption didn't exist in football, but, without any grounds for saying this, I simply don't accept that referees are corrupt. Sometimes incompetent yes, but that takes us back to the first point........

With respect, it is not irrelevant as I have consistently stated a fact that referees err from high to time, having to make split-second decisions in fast moving situations.
Furthermore I am not minded to 'Rubber stamp' comments regarding specific refereeing decisions if I don't agree with them !

Apropos, "Adds nothing to the debate", I have been consistent in my messaging and whether my comments have added value to the discussion is for others to conclude.
Perhaps the consensus is that my sentiments are a heaving load of old codswallop !

Edited by Willo (10 Dec 2023 3.03pm)

 

peterg Flag Anerley 10 Dec 23 3.06pm

Originally posted by Willo

I have always asserted that referees err from time to time having to make split-second decisions under pressure in a fast moving game.

I have concluded that had we not conceded a goal in the dying embers of the game there would not be the furore about the performance of Andy Madley.
His performance will of course be the subject of 'Forensic' analysis as are the performances of referees throughout the PL.

Finally, I am comfortable with my use of "Ablomb" in the context you highlighted.

Interesting word that Willo is comfortable with. I can't find Ablomb in any dictionary. Could it be an abbreviation of a love bomb or love bombing, which means to influence someone by showing them attention or affection? In which case, does that describe Willo's attitude towards the wretched Madley and his illustrious predecessor, Mark Clusterf***?

 


The right place at the right time

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards berlinpalace Flag berlin 10 Dec 23 3.15pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I think the first penalty should have stood.

I didn’t see any identification of the exact moment a foul was committed. Hughes hassled their guy off the ball, he elected to fall over, it’s a contact sport. Furthermore the ref played on and had to stare at a VAR screen for some duration of time. It’s therefore a million miles from ‘clear and obvious’ before even considering it a foul in a first instance, in a contact sport.

The JPM penalty is stonewall, there’s no debate. There were an equal amount of fouls between the sides however a sincerely disproportionate issuing of cards. Both Ayew yellows were dubious and where the ambiguity of the rules and their application favours a cheating ref to assist the bigger team. Giving them two yellows in the dying embers is evidence for me of an attempt to cook the books in acknowledgment of this.

There’s ambiguity, subjective decision making, mistakes etc aplenty in football. When the script reads ‘overturned penalty, dodgy sending off and severely lopsided disciplinary action favours the title challengers to come from behind against their minnow opponents’, you know what is taking place. It’s a corrupt sport and a financial and commercial powerhouse. It’s not an even playing field.


It was a really weak bit of play by the Liverpool lad who just panicked when he realised he’d f***ed up, threw himself to the ground and tried to grab the ball. I really don’t see how anyone who’s played the game at any decent level can think Hughes fouled him? There’s no reason for VAR to get involved, the referee was right on top of it and waved play on. There’s no contact on the feet or hands in the back.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 10 Dec 23 3.34pm

Originally posted by berlinpalace


It was a really weak bit of play by the Liverpool lad who just panicked when he realised he’d f***ed up, threw himself to the ground and tried to grab the ball. I really don’t see how anyone who’s played the game at any decent level can think Hughes fouled him? There’s no reason for VAR to get involved, the referee was right on top of it and waved play on. There’s no contact on the feet or hands in the back.

Agree with this 100% went to ground really easily.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 10 Dec 23 3.38pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Agree with this 100% went to ground really easily.

. . . & Ayew doesn't?

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Norbury Old Git Flag London 10 Dec 23 3.40pm

Referees are under greater pressure than ever to make decisions in favour of the big television money earners of the League. This is not to say that all referees are corrupt but a select few can be relied upon to ensure the “right” result. It is my opinion that former head of PGMOL, Mike Riley, promoted mainly those referees based within 75 miles of his Sheffield home to keep a close eye on their compliance with his directives. Two that have been revealed by whistleblowers and aired on radio are that referees must follow the directions of VAR and that where possible not to send off the high profile players because those are the ones television viewers want to see. Jordan Ayew is definitely not one of these.

Whether yesterday’s referee fell into this category one can only speculate. There is also, however, the issue of incompetence. If you pick 18 out of 22 referees from such a small area you are inevitably going to pick up quite a bit of dross. We now have only two referees based south of Birmingham, that is more than half the population of England, professional football clubs ( the National League North is supplemented by southern teams to make up numbers) and 10 of 20 Premier League sides. There are no referees from the London area with Tim Robinson of West Sussex being the nearest representative.

If Durham and Fylde can have 6 of the 20 Select Group 2 referees the chances of us getting a fair, nationally balanced and neutral referees panel is a long way off.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 10 Dec 23 3.43pm

Just to add insult to injury, Palace have been fined £25k for indiscipline . . . [Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 10 Dec 23 3.46pm

Originally posted by Norbury Old Git

Referees are under greater pressure than ever to make decisions in favour of the big television money earners of the League. This is not to say that all referees are corrupt but a select few can be relied upon to ensure the “right” result. It is my opinion that former head of PGMOL, Mike Riley, promoted mainly those referees based within 75 miles of his Sheffield home to keep a close eye on their compliance with his directives. Two that have been revealed by whistleblowers and aired on radio are that referees must follow the directions of VAR and that where possible not to send off the high profile players because those are the ones television viewers want to see. Jordan Ayew is definitely not one of these.

Whether yesterday’s referee fell into this category one can only speculate. There is also, however, the issue of incompetence. If you pick 18 out of 22 referees from such a small area you are inevitably going to pick up quite a bit of dross. We now have only two referees based south of Birmingham, that is more than half the population of England, professional football clubs ( the National League North is supplemented by southern teams to make up numbers) and 10 of 20 Premier League sides. There are no referees from the London area with Tim Robinson of West Sussex being the nearest representative.

If Durham and Fylde can have 6 of the 20 Select Group 2 referees the chances of us getting a fair, nationally balanced and neutral referees panel is a long way off.

May I just say, what an excellent post NOG.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Dec 23 4.12pm

Originally posted by berlinpalace


It was a really weak bit of play by the Liverpool lad who just panicked when he realised he’d f***ed up, threw himself to the ground and tried to grab the ball. I really don’t see how anyone who’s played the game at any decent level can think Hughes fouled him? There’s no reason for VAR to get involved, the referee was right on top of it and waved play on. There’s no contact on the feet or hands in the back.

VAR is entitled to intervene as it was the attacking phase leading up to the penalty decision.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 10 Dec 23 4.12pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I think the first penalty should have stood.

I didn’t see any identification of the exact moment a foul was committed. Hughes hassled their guy off the ball, he elected to fall over, it’s a contact sport. Furthermore the ref played on and had to stare at a VAR screen for some duration of time. It’s therefore a million miles from ‘clear and obvious’ before even considering it a foul in a first instance, in a contact sport.

The JPM penalty is stonewall, there’s no debate. There were an equal amount of fouls between the sides however a sincerely disproportionate issuing of cards. Both Ayew yellows were dubious and where the ambiguity of the rules and their application favours a cheating ref to assist the bigger team. Giving them two yellows in the dying embers is evidence for me of an attempt to cook the books in acknowledgment of this.

There’s ambiguity, subjective decision making, mistakes etc aplenty in football. When the script reads ‘overturned penalty, dodgy sending off and severely lopsided disciplinary action favours the title challengers to come from behind against their minnow opponents’, you know what is taking place. It’s a corrupt sport and a financial and commercial powerhouse. It’s not an even playing field.

Not to mention Van Dick should have been shown a red not a yellow for tripping Eddie .

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards berlinpalace Flag berlin 10 Dec 23 4.26pm

Originally posted by Willo

VAR is entitled to intervene as it was the attacking phase leading up to the penalty decision.


And you will be able to point out the obvious error? No trip, no push that would cause a grown man to fall over. Just a well executed press by Hughes.

 

Page 10 of 14 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Team for Liverpool - Match Thread