You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > VAT on school fees
November 21 2026 9.17pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

VAT on school fees


Page 1 of 7 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 02 Jun 24 9.18pm

Endless Shadow Ministers unable/unwilling to say where the students forced into the state education sector will go in September.

This is a purely ideological policy based on jealousy.

Logistically it can't work if you think about it at all.

I can't remember an election where politicians from all sides have wheeled out more BS and simply refused to answer major questions assuming the voters are stupid.

2019 you had the likes of Rebecca Long-Bailey moaning the Labour vote had " not understood the manifesto "

#prayfortheuk

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

The Dolphin Flag 02 Jun 24 9.23pm

I read - who knows it true - that Labour expect no more than 3% of pupils to drop out.
The article suggests that it could be as high as 40%.
Say it is somewhere inbetween meaning many people will lose their jobs and the state system will be flooded and unable to cope.
Should be interesting!!!

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 02 Jun 24 9.36pm

@600K students so 3% is 18,000 or around 20-25 news schools depending on class size and perhaps 900 teachers.

The private schools will tend to be in similar geographic areas .

Suppose Alleyns and JAGS closed, that puts over 2500 students looking for state places in one area of South London

3% of the students would be 70-80, The more likely 20% would be 500


Edited by HKOwen (02 Jun 2024 9.38pm)

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

YT Flag Oxford 03 Jun 24 7.28am

On the other hand, think of the scope for a re-boot of 'The Inbetweeners'.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 03 Jun 24 11.32am

'Pray for the UK' because someone is suggesting we shouldn't subsidise the richest in society going to better schools than the rest of us do.

I'm sure some people just oppose things because it comes from Labour - there is no coherent argument where a society claiming to be fair and meritocratic structures its education system as we do.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 03 Jun 24 12.08pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

'Pray for the UK' because someone is suggesting we shouldn't subsidise the richest in society going to better schools than the rest of us do.

I'm sure some people just oppose things because it comes from Labour - there is no coherent argument where a society claiming to be fair and meritocratic structures its education system as we do.

Bring back The East India Company.

 


Red and Blue Army!

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 03 Jun 24 10.04pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

'Pray for the UK' because someone is suggesting we shouldn't subsidise the richest in society going to better schools than the rest of us do.

I'm sure some people just oppose things because it comes from Labour - there is no coherent argument where a society claiming to be fair and meritocratic structures its education system as we do.

No Labour Shadow Minister has been able to say where the displaced students will be schooled is the point.

I have no problem with the policy as it lets the market do it's work.

The problem is it is being done for ideological reasons, has not been thought through and will unlikely produce the extra available money to spend on state education.

The average govt spend per pupil is 7000 per year. Every student who quits private school where the annual fees are less than 35K means a net loss.

This is simple maths

I do not disagree with everything Labour does, I think Wes Streeting has a lot to offer in terms of NHS reform for example.

I don't think you can run an election campaign on " we are not the Conservatives "


Edited by HKOwen (03 Jun 2024 10.08pm)

Edited by HKOwen (03 Jun 2024 11.02pm)

Edited by HKOwen (03 Jun 2024 11.03pm)

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

eaglesdare Flag 03 Jun 24 10.12pm

Originally posted by YT

On the other hand, think of the scope for a re-boot of 'The Inbetweeners'.

It definitely wouldn't be 4 straight white male friends in the reboot...

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 04 Jun 24 9.45am

Originally posted by HKOwen

No Labour Shadow Minister has been able to say where the displaced students will be schooled is the point.

I have no problem with the policy as it lets the market do it's work.

The problem is it is being done for ideological reasons, has not been thought through and will unlikely produce the extra available money to spend on state education.

The average govt spend per pupil is 7000 per year. Every student who quits private school where the annual fees are less than 35K means a net loss.

This is simple maths

I do not disagree with everything Labour does, I think Wes Streeting has a lot to offer in terms of NHS reform for example.

I don't think you can run an election campaign on " we are not the Conservatives "


Edited by HKOwen (03 Jun 2024 10.08pm)

Edited by HKOwen (03 Jun 2024 11.02pm)

Edited by HKOwen (03 Jun 2024 11.03pm)

Surely this is the opposite of 'we are not the Conservatives'?

It's a specific policy which is what everyone has been asking from Labour for months.

You keep saying 'ideological reasons' as if that's a bad thing - the 'ideology' of our society being fair and meritocratic is shared by the majority of the population. I see no issue with policies pursuing that aim.

The whole thing about state school places is a complete red herring - the reality is hardly any of these parents are going to pull their kids out of the school over a few grand a year difference. The schools will swallow some of the cost, the parents will begrudgingly pay the balance passed onto them, and hardly anything will change beyond the schools making a bit less profit and paying an appropriate level of tax.

Can you make a case as to why the taxpayer should be subsidising the richest in society to go to better schools? Not logistical challenges that a change might produce (a la state school places), but an actual case as to why the current status quo is a good thing?

 

Behind Enemy Lines Flag Sussex 04 Jun 24 11.47am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Surely this is the opposite of 'we are not the Conservatives'?

It's a specific policy which is what everyone has been asking from Labour for months.

You keep saying 'ideological reasons' as if that's a bad thing - the 'ideology' of our society being fair and meritocratic is shared by the majority of the population. I see no issue with policies pursuing that aim.

The whole thing about state school places is a complete red herring - the reality is hardly any of these parents are going to pull their kids out of the school over a few grand a year difference. The schools will swallow some of the cost, the parents will begrudgingly pay the balance passed onto them, and hardly anything will change beyond the schools making a bit less profit and paying an appropriate level of tax.

Can you make a case as to why the taxpayer should be subsidising the richest in society to go to better schools? Not logistical challenges that a change might produce (a la state school places), but an actual case as to why the current status quo is a good thing?

Personally I don’t have an objection to VAT being applied; where I have a problem is when so many Labour MPs have sent their own children to private schools when some of them have been looking to close them down as being too elite; it’s the hypocrisy.
Most parents will probably absorb it, the clever ones will claim it as a deductible expense in their company accounts for training future staff as Junior joins his dad’s business. Me? I’d buy shares in a portacabin company; they are going to be needed!

 


hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 04 Jun 24 11.51am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Surely this is the opposite of 'we are not the Conservatives'?

It's a specific policy which is what everyone has been asking from Labour for months.

You keep saying 'ideological reasons' as if that's a bad thing - the 'ideology' of our society being fair and meritocratic is shared by the majority of the population. I see no issue with policies pursuing that aim.

The whole thing about state school places is a complete red herring - the reality is hardly any of these parents are going to pull their kids out of the school over a few grand a year difference. The schools will swallow some of the cost, the parents will begrudgingly pay the balance passed onto them, and hardly anything will change beyond the schools making a bit less profit and paying an appropriate level of tax.

Can you make a case as to why the taxpayer should be subsidising the richest in society to go to better schools? Not logistical challenges that a change might produce (a la state school places), but an actual case as to why the current status quo is a good thing?


It's not really a one size fits all situation. A lot of Grammar schools, for example, take in a large percentage of non fee paying kids and give them a better education. They are sometimes ran on a non profit basis with profits (if there are any) being used for more scholarships or investment in facilities that often the wider community can access. However, we also have places like Eton and Gordonstoun which are the elite - however, in those I think many have the total wrong idea about who goes there. It used to be the government and royalty set but it's a lot more diverse these days. I would agree with places like Eton and Gordonstoun being charged more - they often cry poverty which seems unlikely. However, your local grammar school is likely a completely different case.

 


Red and Blue Army!

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 04 Jun 24 11.55am

Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines

Personally I don’t have an objection to VAT being applied; where I have a problem is when so many Labour MPs have sent their own children to private schools when some of them have been looking to close them down as being too elite; it’s the hypocrisy.
Most parents will probably absorb it, the clever ones will claim it as a deductible expense in their company accounts for training future staff as Junior joins his dad’s business. Me? I’d buy shares in a portacabin company; they are going to be needed!

Well yeah but that's obviously a completely separate point - there is no proposal from Labour to close down private schools, so I don't think we should conflate the two.

Who are the Labour MPs who have sent their own children to private schools while looking to close them down?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Jun 24 11.57am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Surely this is the opposite of 'we are not the Conservatives'?

It's a specific policy which is what everyone has been asking from Labour for months.

You keep saying 'ideological reasons' as if that's a bad thing - the 'ideology' of our society being fair and meritocratic is shared by the majority of the population. I see no issue with policies pursuing that aim.

The whole thing about state school places is a complete red herring - the reality is hardly any of these parents are going to pull their kids out of the school over a few grand a year difference. The schools will swallow some of the cost, the parents will begrudgingly pay the balance passed onto them, and hardly anything will change beyond the schools making a bit less profit and paying an appropriate level of tax.

Can you make a case as to why the taxpayer should be subsidising the richest in society to go to better schools? Not logistical challenges that a change might produce (a la state school places), but an actual case as to why the current status quo is a good thing?

I would agree that it's fairer, however it certainly isn't meritocratic.

Of course these schools, places at which will be prized, will increase fees.

I also take issue with this, painless and no harm, idea that this isn't going to pull children out of better schools into the state system. Of course it is, there are going to be a bottom percent of aspirational middle class families who were stretching their incomes to send their children to these schools. For them the increases will be the straw that breaks that back.

Now I agree, there is a wider discussion to be had over the nature of private/public education....something that has been touched upon many times before.

However, let's not play here, the left's direction of travel is always towards an equalized education system and the abolition of privilege.....as equality is their obsession and desire in all things regardless of its averaged outcomes (and hated by the aspirational).

However, to paraphrase the biblical proverb, 'iron sharpens iron', or in other words if you wish to produce the best minds you must surround them with the best.

As Socrates taught Plato, who taught Aristotle, who taught Alexander.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 04 Jun 24 12.01pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC


It's not really a one size fits all situation. A lot of Grammar schools, for example, take in a large percentage of non fee paying kids and give them a better education. They are sometimes ran on a non profit basis with profits (if there are any) being used for more scholarships or investment in facilities that often the wider community can access. However, we also have places like Eton and Gordonstoun which are the elite - however, in those I think many have the total wrong idea about who goes there. It used to be the government and royalty set but it's a lot more diverse these days. I would agree with places like Eton and Gordonstoun being charged more - they often cry poverty which seems unlikely. However, your local grammar school is likely a completely different case.

The data does not really support that; [Link]

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 04 Jun 24 12.07pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

The data does not really support that; [Link]

The data does support it. There are a quarter that don't let in non-fee paying students. The other three quarters do. Some even target the poorest children. I should know as I was one of them. The article is somewhat misleading in its findings when read in its entirety. As I said, it's nowhere near to being a one size fits all situation.

 


Red and Blue Army!

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 04 Jun 24 12.08pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I would agree that it's fairer, however it certainly isn't meritocratic.

Of course these schools, places at which will be prized, will increase fees.

I also take issue with this, painless and no harm, idea that this isn't going to pull children out of better schools into the state system. Of course it is, there are going to be a bottom percent of aspirational middle class families who were stretching their incomes to send their children to these schools. For them the increases will be the straw that breaks that back.

Now I agree, there is a wider discussion to be had over the nature of private/public education....something that has been touched upon many times before.

However, let's not play here, the left's direction of travel is always towards an equalized education system and the abolition of privilege.....as equality is their obsession and desire in all things regardless of its averaged outcomes (and hated by the aspirational).

However, to paraphrase the biblical proverb, 'iron sharpens iron', or in other words if you wish to produce the best minds you must surround them with the best.

As Socrates taught Plato, who taught Aristotle, who taught Alexander.

You're correct on the meritocracy point.

There will be a tiny percentage of families as you describe who may now be priced out of it... so what? Why should the taxpayer subsidise a luxury they cannot afford?

Maybe we can release some useful pamphlets about how to make your weekly shop cheaper, or how to cook dinners, like we do with the poor. They can just cut out the smartphones and Netflix subscriptions.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 04 Jun 24 12.15pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

The data does support it. There are a quarter that don't let in non-fee paying students. The other three quarters do. Some even target the poorest children. I should know as I was one of them. The article is somewhat misleading in its findings when read in its entirety. As I said, it's nowhere near to being a one size fits all situation.

I think we're talking about different things here - to my knowledge, grammar schools are state-funded and so not relevant to Labour's policy on private school fees.

Happy to be corrected but I didn't think grammar schools were the target.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Jun 24 12.23pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

You're correct on the meritocracy point.

There will be a tiny percentage of families as you describe who may now be priced out of it... so what? Why should the taxpayer subsidise a luxury they cannot afford?

Maybe we can release some useful pamphlets about how to make your weekly shop cheaper, or how to cook dinners, like we do with the poor. They can just cut out the smartphones and Netflix subscriptions.

I have some sympathy with this view.

However, this topic is always a bit like the 'legalise/ban it all to hell' issue I have with drugs.

Despite both sides of the argument claiming that they are correct personally I feel that whatever side of the fence you fall it will condemn a percent to worse outcomes, many permanently.

My settled position is the exclusive education should and very much needs to exist...but as with politics...the money aspect ruins it.

I would have the state completely pay all costs for the very brightest minds as measured by IQ at eleven plus for the top ten percent of the population.

The wealth of the family would not be a factor.

No foreign students or buy in.

The decline or rise of a society is ultimately decided by meritocracy.

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Jun 2024 12.25pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 04 Jun 24 12.31pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I have some sympathy with this view.

However, this topic is always a bit like the 'legalise/ban it all to hell' issue I have with drugs.

Despite both sides of the argument claiming that they are correct personally I feel that whatever side of the fence you fall it will condemn a percent to worse outcomes, many permanently.

My settled position is the exclusive education should and very much needs to exist...but as with politics...the money aspect ruins it.

I would have the state completely pay all costs for the very brightest minds as measured by IQ at eleven plus for the top ten percent of the population.

The wealth of the family would not be a factor.

No foreign students or buy in.

The decline or rise of a society is ultimately decided by meritocracy.

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Jun 2024 12.25pm)

If you mean Grammar Schools I have no problem with that but I doubt Labour will agree.

 


One more point

Behind Enemy Lines Flag Sussex 04 Jun 24 1.19pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Well yeah but that's obviously a completely separate point - there is no proposal from Labour to close down private schools, so I don't think we should conflate the two.

Who are the Labour MPs who have sent their own children to private schools while looking to close them down?

Diane Abbott for one, who when questioned about it replied that her culture always wanted to do the best for their children. Presumably, white culture doesn’t.

 


hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing.

Page 1 of 7 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > VAT on school fees