Quote legaleagle at 08 Feb 2015 9.33pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Feb 2015 9.23pm
Quote legaleagle at 08 Feb 2015 8.55pm
Its certainly no less simplistic than saying the benefits have been all one way.
The analysis you put forward is very similar to that often heard in the 1950-'s-60's re immigration then from the West Indies and the Indian sub-continent.Just to use one silly example of a "benefit", many people now think of going to an "Indian Restaurant" (actually mainly Bangla Deshi) as an integral part of "British" cuisine and way of life,not to mention corner shops open after 6pm.
Regarding "traditional" Labour ideals (not seen much in the party leadership nowadays), one traditional ideal was to encourage people to see the real reasons for their woes as opposed to falling for diversionary stuff scapegoating others,usually "outsiders",N. Ireland 1900 ish-1969 ish being but one example.
Edited by legaleagle (08 Feb 2015 9.08pm)
Where did I say it was all one way?....I started out my post recognizing how an ever increasing population allows for a situation that is marginally better for business....Though that report makes extremely debatable chooses over its profit and cost areas.
Also to answer another of your points there is no connection in terms of numbers between what's been happening since 2004 and the immigration in number from immigration
Where is this similarity?.....Where you around to hear it? I think you are possibly showing your prejudices here.
I'm 45, how old are you?....I don't remember commentary on 50/60s immigration.
What was the population then? What was the housing situation then? I have no idea.
As for you commentary on my opinions they appear to be stereotypical caricatures......Quite amusing really considering all the moaning you've done about how I pigeon-hole the left......You seem to be just what you complain about.
I'm older than you,Stirling.
You were responding to a post of mine,responding to someone who said there were no benefits to recent immigration.I then used an example of a benefit from past immigration to illustrate a point,given that you make similar arguments to many of those who were very anti-immigration in the late 1950's/60's.I do recall the arguments from the 60's, though I wasn't a "grown up" then.
I'm not stereotyping you.I go merely on what you have written in your posts.If your analysis is more varied/different than your posts,am happy to read and consider it.
If you recognise there are benefits,I'm delighted.
If you are worried about your child being able to ever buy a house,do have a look,just as one non-immigration example, at the ongoing disastrous effect of the repeal of almost all rent control legislation by Maggie's government in 1980.
Edited by legaleagle (08 Feb 2015 10.21pm)