You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 22 2026 4.09am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

ukip (LOCKED)


Page 103 of 187 < 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 >
Stirlingsays Flag 08 Feb 15 6.41pm

Quote legaleagle at 08 Feb 2015 11.36am

There's a legitimate debate to be had about that,since some would say the benefits have not been only "entirely one way":

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (08 Feb 2015 11.38am)

It's a simplistic headline that misses the fact that the meat of the argument is actually pretty negative for the people with least.

Of course significantly increasing the population is good for business, it keeps wages down, makes getting a good job more competitive (increasing the size of the underclass or working poor) and it puts house prices and rents up.

It's terrible for social cohension and for people without access to social housing or enough jobs that pay enough to provide a standard of living.

Building houses is expensive and long term with no short term benefits......It was always going to happen.

High level immigration has been terrible for those with least (I grew up in a Stockwell council estate) and comfortable people who defend it yet are supposedly left wing are way short of traditional Labour ideals.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 08 Feb 15 7.17pm

Forgive me if I'm wrong Enoch, sorry Stirlingsays, are you attributing the woes of different areas of our proud nation on immigration?
That's both wrong and naive. People are struggling on low pay because employers have been able to get away with it. People are struggling not because of immigration but from lack of investment in the right areas. No job creation, benefits cut and wealth transfer to the richest. This is not the fault of the immigrants, nor those already here.
If you really think a load of ex Tories are going to be on the side of the worst off I think you are sorely mistaken.

 

legaleagle Flag 08 Feb 15 8.55pm

.

Edited by legaleagle (08 Feb 2015 9.22pm)

 

legaleagle Flag 08 Feb 15 9.17pm

Quote legaleagle at 08 Feb 2015 8.55pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Feb 2015 6.41pm

Quote legaleagle at 08 Feb 2015 11.36am

There's a legitimate debate to be had about that,since some would say the benefits have not been only "entirely one way":

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (08 Feb 2015 11.38am)

It's a simplistic headline that misses the fact that the meat of the argument is actually pretty negative for the people with least.

Of course significantly increasing the population is good for business, it keeps wages down, makes getting a good job more competitive (increasing the size of the underclass or working poor) and it puts house prices and rents up.

It's terrible for social cohension and for people without access to social housing or enough jobs that pay enough to provide a standard of living.

Building houses is expensive and long term with no short term benefits......It was always going to happen.

High level immigration has been terrible for those with least (I grew up in a Stockwell council estate) and comfortable people who defend it yet are supposedly left wing are way short of traditional Labour ideals.


Its certainly no less simplistic than saying the benefits have been all one way.

The analysis you put forward is very similar to that often heard in the 1950-'s-60's re immigration then from the West Indies and the Indian sub-continent.Just to use one silly example of a "benefit", many people now think of going to an "Indian Restaurant" (actually mainly Bangla Deshi) as an integral part of "British" cuisine and way of life,not to mention corner shops open after 6pm. When I lived very close to Stockwell in the 1980's,the Indian restaurants/take aways were well frequented by the locals

Regarding "traditional" Labour ideals (not seen much in the party leadership nowadays), one traditional ideal was to encourage people to see the real reasons for their woes as opposed to falling for diversionary stuff scapegoating others,usually "outsiders",N. Ireland 1900 ish-1969 ish being but one example.

Edited by legaleagle (08 Feb 2015 10.20pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 08 Feb 15 9.23pm

Quote legaleagle at 08 Feb 2015 8.55pm

Its certainly no less simplistic than saying the benefits have been all one way.

The analysis you put forward is very similar to that often heard in the 1950-'s-60's re immigration then from the West Indies and the Indian sub-continent.Just to use one silly example of a "benefit", many people now think of going to an "Indian Restaurant" (actually mainly Bangla Deshi) as an integral part of "British" cuisine and way of life,not to mention corner shops open after 6pm.

Regarding "traditional" Labour ideals (not seen much in the party leadership nowadays), one traditional ideal was to encourage people to see the real reasons for their woes as opposed to falling for diversionary stuff scapegoating others,usually "outsiders",N. Ireland 1900 ish-1969 ish being but one example.

Edited by legaleagle (08 Feb 2015 9.08pm)

Where did I say it was all one way?....I started out my post recognizing how an ever increasing population allows for a situation that is marginally better for business....Though that report makes extremely debatable chooses over its profit and cost areas.

Also to answer another of your points there is no connection in terms of numbers between what's been happening since 2004 and the immigration in number from immigration

Where is this similarity?.....Where you around to hear it? I think you are possibly showing your prejudices here.

I'm 45, how old are you?....I don't remember commentary on 50/60s immigration.

What was the population then? What was the housing situation then? I have no idea.

As for you commentary on my opinions they appear to be stereotypical caricatures......Quite amusing really considering all the moaning you've done about how I pigeon-hole the left......You seem to be just what you complain about.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 08 Feb 15 9.33pm

.

Edited by legaleagle (08 Feb 2015 10.19pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 08 Feb 15 9.33pm

Quote nickgusset at 08 Feb 2015 7.17pm

Forgive me if I'm wrong Enoch, sorry Stirlingsays, are you attributing the woes of different areas of our proud nation on immigration?
That's both wrong and naive. People are struggling on low pay because employers have been able to get away with it. People are struggling not because of immigration but from lack of investment in the right areas. No job creation, benefits cut and wealth transfer to the richest. This is not the fault of the immigrants, nor those already here.
If you really think a load of ex Tories are going to be on the side of the worst off I think you are sorely mistaken.


How do I put this Nick......You're wrong and incredibly naive......But I like you.

Bring back Dick Emery.

Seriously though but in short....As I must get ready for tomorrow's lessons but I think you're missing the obvious reality of the situation.

More workers, less pay packet...It's simple economics.
More people to house than the rate of housing growth......less housing for the least able.

You deflecting these problems onto political decision makers has a partial truth to it......And no one sensible ever blames the actual immigrant themselves for trying to improve their lives.

But I'm a realist and I want my son to grow up in a country which has a realistic possibility of him getting a house of his own.

Your ideology says it wants that but what you believe in would make it impossible to become reality.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 08 Feb 15 9.36pm

.

Edited by legaleagle (08 Feb 2015 9.52pm)

 

legaleagle Flag 08 Feb 15 9.43pm

Quote legaleagle at 08 Feb 2015 9.36pm

Quote legaleagle at 08 Feb 2015 9.33pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Feb 2015 9.23pm

Quote legaleagle at 08 Feb 2015 8.55pm

Its certainly no less simplistic than saying the benefits have been all one way.

The analysis you put forward is very similar to that often heard in the 1950-'s-60's re immigration then from the West Indies and the Indian sub-continent.Just to use one silly example of a "benefit", many people now think of going to an "Indian Restaurant" (actually mainly Bangla Deshi) as an integral part of "British" cuisine and way of life,not to mention corner shops open after 6pm.

Regarding "traditional" Labour ideals (not seen much in the party leadership nowadays), one traditional ideal was to encourage people to see the real reasons for their woes as opposed to falling for diversionary stuff scapegoating others,usually "outsiders",N. Ireland 1900 ish-1969 ish being but one example.

Edited by legaleagle (08 Feb 2015 9.08pm)

Where did I say it was all one way?....I started out my post recognizing how an ever increasing population allows for a situation that is marginally better for business....Though that report makes extremely debatable chooses over its profit and cost areas.

Also to answer another of your points there is no connection in terms of numbers between what's been happening since 2004 and the immigration in number from immigration

Where is this similarity?.....Where you around to hear it? I think you are possibly showing your prejudices here.

I'm 45, how old are you?....I don't remember commentary on 50/60s immigration.

What was the population then? What was the housing situation then? I have no idea.

As for you commentary on my opinions they appear to be stereotypical caricatures......Quite amusing really considering all the moaning you've done about how I pigeon-hole the left......You seem to be just what you complain about.

I'm older than you,Stirling.

You were responding to a post of mine,responding to someone who said there were no benefits to recent immigration.I then used an example of a benefit from past immigration to illustrate a point,given that you make similar arguments to many of those who were very anti-immigration in the late 1950's/60's.I do recall the arguments from the 60's, though I wasn't a "grown up" then.

I'm not stereotyping you.I go merely on what you have written in your posts.If your analysis is more varied/different than your posts,am happy to read and consider it.

If you recognise there are benefits,I'm delighted.

If you are worried about your child being able to ever buy a house,do have a look,just as one non-immigration example, at the ongoing disastrous effect of the repeal of almost all rent control legislation by Maggie's government in 1980.


Edited by legaleagle (08 Feb 2015 10.21pm)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 08 Feb 15 9.44pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Feb 2015 9.33pm

Quote nickgusset at 08 Feb 2015 7.17pm

Forgive me if I'm wrong Enoch, sorry Stirlingsays, are you attributing the woes of different areas of our proud nation on immigration?
That's both wrong and naive. People are struggling on low pay because employers have been able to get away with it. People are struggling not because of immigration but from lack of investment in the right areas. No job creation, benefits cut and wealth transfer to the richest. This is not the fault of the immigrants, nor those already here.
If you really think a load of ex Tories are going to be on the side of the worst off I think you are sorely mistaken.


How do I put this Nick......You're wrong and incredibly naive......But I like you.

Bring back Dick Emery.

Seriously though but in short....As I must get ready for tomorrow's lessons but I think you're missing the obvious reality of the situation.

More workers, less pay packet...It's simple economics.
More people to house than the rate of housing growth......less housing for the least able.

You deflecting these problems onto political decision makers has a partial truth to it......And no one sensible ever blames the actual immigrant themselves for trying to improve their lives.

But I'm a realist and I want my son to grow up in a country which has a realistic possibility of him getting a house of his own.

Your ideology says it wants that but what you believe in would make it impossible to become reality.

It's not about immigration. It's about the economy (stupid) What I believe in is impossible with the people we have running the country/world . f*** the banks. Instead of bailing them out, put the money into house building, green or renewable energy or subsidising decent pay.

If the banks were not bailed out what would have happened? Would society have fallen apart? I doubt it. Banks that came in to take over would have made damn sure they didn't lend to all and sundry and resold and resold toxic debts.

Any time there's a recession or austerity the smokescreen of immigration is brought out to deflect from what the real issues are. People are getting so foammy mouthed at the 'Muslamics' and Poles and Rumanians that they are blind to what is happening.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 08 Feb 15 11.15pm

Quote nickgusset at 08 Feb 2015 9.44pm


It's not about immigration. It's about the economy (stupid) What I believe in is impossible with the people we have running the country/world . f*** the banks. Instead of bailing them out, put the money into house building, green or renewable energy or subsidising decent pay.

If the banks were not bailed out what would have happened? Would society have fallen apart? I doubt it. Banks that came in to take over would have made damn sure they didn't lend to all and sundry and resold and resold toxic debts.

Any time there's a recession or austerity the smokescreen of immigration is brought out to deflect from what the real issues are. People are getting so foammy mouthed at the 'Muslamics' and Poles and Rumanians that they are blind to what is happening.


Saying feck the banks is pointless....Though a discussion on what would have happened without the bailouts would be interesting....If there is anyone knowledgeable enough out there to put forward an opinion.

As for being against immigrants or blaming them I've already answered that.

It's a continual disfigurement against the actual argument..Or maybe Nick you just don't read these replies...It's a disfigurement designed to paint people into corners that don't exist.

I'm not against immigration.....I'm against open door immigration with no set numbers....The free movement of peoples.....Yeah, I'm not particularly for the wealthy British taking the piss in Spain and France either....The one foot in and one foot out brigade.

I want to go back to being in control of our borders.....Not closing the door to Poles or Muslims.....That's a caricature and not fair.

Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Feb 2015 11.26pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 08 Feb 15 11.25pm

Quote legaleagle at 08 Feb 2015 9.43pm

I'm not stereotyping you.I go merely on what you have written in your posts.If your analysis is more varied/different than your posts,am happy to read and consider it.


Edited by legaleagle (08 Feb 2015 10.21pm)

You do in my opinion stereotype and you have in regards to me. As I say, you do what you yourself complain about and it's hypocritical.

I answered your implication of me holding racist views on the previous page...You apparently haven't read it.....I'm offended by what you said....I thought we had moved on and I tried to do that in a post to you but then you repeated your opinion... Anyway I've responded and now I see you in a different light.

As for Thatcher's council house selling scheme....Yes I've always criticised that......But this was over thirty years ago and not one government dealt with the damage from it.....Then Labour allowed...via the EU...the flooding into the country of poor Eastern Europeans...By proxy restricting the access to housing to the working classes.

Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Feb 2015 11.40pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 09 Feb 15 9.59am

.

Edited by legaleagle (09 Feb 2015 10.56am)

 

legaleagle Flag 09 Feb 15 10.14am

Quote legaleagle at 09 Feb 2015 9.59am

Its you that repeatedly infers suggestions of racism and stereotyping Stirling when I respond to your posts. That's stereotyping me in its own way.I simply comment (and you are free to agree or not of course) on what you yourself post.If I genuinely think what you post is similar to aspects of analyses of the perils of immigration from 45-55 years ago,doesn't mean I am inferring you are a racist. Just like I have explained why I was not inferring you are a racist when I wrote about ethnicity. They are not automatically one and the same.But,if you are convinced I am and pigeon hole me that way,not a lot I can do.

If that's changed your view of me,I'm sorry.My view of you as basically an ok person (though with views I find polar opposite to many of mine) remains unchanged from when I was horrified when you,as a welcome fixture IMO on general talk (and if I really thought you were a "racist",I wouldn't regard you in that way), got unfairly red carded x 2.

Re Maggie,I wasn't talking about selling off council houses but rather the Housing Act 1980:

"Rent regulation covered the whole of the UK private sector rental market from 1915 to 1980. However, from the Housing Act 1980, it became the Conservative Party's policy to deregulate the housing market, starting with abolition of all price controls, leaving a basic regulatory framework of freedom of contract. Rent regulations survive among a small number of council houses, and often the rates set by local authorities mirror escalating prices in the non-regulated private market". Only Wikipedia,I appreciate.


 

Stirlingsays Flag 09 Feb 15 10.41am


Quote legaleagle at 09 Feb 2015 9.59am

Its you that repeatedly infers suggestions of racism and stereotyping Stirling when I respond to your posts. That's stereotyping me in its own way.I simply comment (and you are free to agree or not of course) on what you yourself post.If I genuinely think what you post is similar to aspects of analyses of the perils of immigration from 45-55 years ago,doesn't mean I am inferring you are a racist. Just like I have explained why I was not inferring you are a racist when I wrote about ethnicity. They are not automatically one and the same.But,if you are convinced I am and pigeon hole me that way,not a lot I can do.

If that's changed your view of me,I'm sorry.My view of you as basically an ok person (though with views I find polar opposite to many of mine) remains unchanged from when I was horrified when you,as a welcome fixture IMO on general talk (and if I really thought you were a "racist",I wouldn't regard you in that way), got unfairly red carded x 2.

Re Maggie,I wasn't talking about selling off council houses but rather the Housing Act 1980:

"Rent regulation covered the whole of the UK private sector rental market from 1915 to 1980. However, from the Housing Act 1980, it became the Conservative Party's policy to deregulate the housing market, starting with abolition of all price controls, leaving a basic regulatory framework of freedom of contract. Rent regulations survive among a small number of council houses, and often the rates set by local authorities mirror escalating prices in the non-regulated private market". Only Wikipedia,I appreciate.


I'll tell you something we appear to have in common Legal......And that's getting this posting thingy right.

Maybe because I've always working and not on here so often or some setting has been changed on the html but like you I've been cocking up and double posting.

I wish there was a delete option.

As for Maggie's affect on the housing market and the housing act I can only agree with you.

Thatcher for me was very much a mixed bag PM.

Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Feb 2015 10.44am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 09 Feb 15 10.57am

Quote Stirlingsays at 09 Feb 2015 10.41am


Quote legaleagle at 09 Feb 2015 9.59am

Its you that repeatedly infers suggestions of racism and stereotyping Stirling when I respond to your posts. That's stereotyping me in its own way.I simply comment (and you are free to agree or not of course) on what you yourself post.If I genuinely think what you post is similar to aspects of analyses of the perils of immigration from 45-55 years ago,doesn't mean I am inferring you are a racist. Just like I have explained why I was not inferring you are a racist when I wrote about ethnicity. They are not automatically one and the same.But,if you are convinced I am and pigeon hole me that way,not a lot I can do.

If that's changed your view of me,I'm sorry.My view of you as basically an ok person (though with views I find polar opposite to many of mine) remains unchanged from when I was horrified when you,as a welcome fixture IMO on general talk (and if I really thought you were a "racist",I wouldn't regard you in that way), got unfairly red carded x 2.

Re Maggie,I wasn't talking about selling off council houses but rather the Housing Act 1980:

"Rent regulation covered the whole of the UK private sector rental market from 1915 to 1980. However, from the Housing Act 1980, it became the Conservative Party's policy to deregulate the housing market, starting with abolition of all price controls, leaving a basic regulatory framework of freedom of contract. Rent regulations survive among a small number of council houses, and often the rates set by local authorities mirror escalating prices in the non-regulated private market". Only Wikipedia,I appreciate.


I'll tell you something we appear to have in common Legal......And that's getting this posting thingy right.

Maybe because I've always working and not on here so often or some setting has been changed on the html but like you I've been cocking up and double posting.

I wish there was a delete option.

As for Maggie's affect on the housing market and the housing act I can only agree with you.

Thatcher for me was very much a mixed bag PM.

Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Feb 2015 10.44am)


Yes,we seem to have that in common.Bring on the delete option!

 

imbored Flag UK 09 Feb 15 4.26pm

Quote legaleagle at 07 Feb 2015 5.55pm

Clearly I have hit a raw nerve. I did not use the word "racist" anywhere in my post.As for "ethnicity",purely as an example, no significant racial differences between many English and, say, many Polish people,but differing "ethnicity".You are a courteous and non-abusive poster and I respect you for that.I won't respond to anything else you post this evening so as not to annoy you further.Have a good evening,Stirling.

Edited by legaleagle (07 Feb 2015 6.10pm)

Farage himself differentiates between his German wife and Romanians with his 'wouldn't like to live next door to' guff. Definitely an ethnocentric aspect to UKIP support.

Edited by imbored (14 Feb 2015 4.27pm)

 

imbored Flag UK 09 Feb 15 4.40pm

Quote bright&wright at 06 Feb 2015 5.25pm

Yet more proof that socialists will do absolutely everything they can to stop anyone else having a voice.

Everything except get a job and go to work of course...

Yes, because only UKIP supporters have jobs don't they?

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Feb 15 6.27pm

[Link]

Who is voting UKIP... Mainly male and over 45 it would seem.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Feb 15 6.28pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 Feb 2015 6.27pm

[Link]

Who is voting UKIP... Mainly male and over 45 it would seem.


Who, among those intending to vote UKIP on here, are mainly male?

 

Page 103 of 187 < 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic