This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Well spotted, thanks - post edited. I guess semantics can be helpful sometimes I will doubtless quote that in our future debates
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by NJ CLOCKTOWER
Israel generally receives more tourists compared to Palestine due to its larger infrastructure, marketing efforts, and variety of attractions. In recent years, Israel has welcomed millions of tourists annually, while Palestine's tourism industry, though growing, typically sees fewer visitors. However, some tourists visiting Israel also explore Palestinian territories, contributing indirectly to tourism in those areas.Then they are never seen again Palestine losing out on the pink dollar "Palestine has been identified by Forbes as one of the 20 worst destinations places for gay travellers in 2021, noticing that hostility towards the LGBTQ+ community is significant, with penalties for homosexual acts reaching up to ten years in prison. Activists for LGBTQ+ rights are under threat by Palestinian authorities, who deem such orientations as contrary to the core values of Palestinian society."
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by NJ CLOCKTOWER
In any conflict, it is crucial to examine the sequence of events and identify the party that initially instigated the conflict. This party, often referred to as the aggressor Hamas, bears primary responsibility for instigating the violence and creating the conditions that led to the conflict. For example, in a situation where one country invades another and carries out massacres, the invading country would be considered the initial aggressor. The responsibility of the initial aggressor is significant because their actions provoked a retaliatory response from the attacked country, Israel. It is also essential to acknowledge that the response of the retaliating party can have consequences that further escalate tensions and violence. These consequences may include a broader conflict, increased loss of life, and destruction of infrastructure. The retaliating country's response is shaped by a variety of factors, such as the need to defend its people and territory, the desire for justice, and the pressure to maintain its reputation and credibility. It is important to note the blame and responsibility in the Palestinian Israeli conflict are in the hands of Hamas.The severity of Hama's actions, started this war. I appreciate you've joined the thread late, but this 'analysis' has been done to death and is frankly about 5 months out of date. Israel absolutely had the right to respond to October 7th, I don't think anyone denies that, but what we have seen in the 6 months following has vastly exceeded what could be considered a proportionate military response in any objective reality. I'm sure you agree that being the victim of a terror attack does not give a nation carte blanche to act however they see fit - international law does not cease to exist because you have suffered an attack, and so the travesty of October 7th in no way justifies the conduct of Israel since.
|
|
| NJ CLOCKTOWER |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I appreciate you've joined the thread late, but this 'analysis' has been done to death and is frankly about 5 months out of date. Israel absolutely had the right to respond to October 7th, I don't think anyone denies that, but what we have seen in the 6 months following has vastly exceeded what could be considered a proportionate military response in any objective reality. I'm sure you agree that being the victim of a terror attack does not give a nation carte blanche to act however they see fit - international law does not cease to exist because you have suffered an attack, and so the travesty of October 7th in no way justifies the conduct of Israel since. Absolutely, you're correct. International law remains crucial even in the face of terror attacks. Retaliation should be proportional and within the bounds of established legal frameworks. Each nation must uphold human rights standards even amidst challenging circumstances. When you say proportionally what do you actually mean? So what you're saying. Is that Israel should have waited till the morning at no specific day date or time. Not giving any warnings through leaflets thrown from airplanes, to tell the civilians to avoid this area. What you're saying is Israel should have invaded Palestine, attacked an open air festival or Muslim prayer let's say, shoot indiscriminately at civilians. Then after that go into a town in Palestine. Knock down every door and shoot the inhabitants and then call their mums telling their mum's how proud they are for killing a Palestinian.
|
|
| NJ CLOCKTOWER |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I appreciate you've joined the thread late, but this 'analysis' has been done to death and is frankly about 5 months out of date. Israel absolutely had the right to respond to October 7th, I don't think anyone denies that, but what we have seen in the 6 months following has vastly exceeded what could be considered a proportionate military response in any objective reality. I'm sure you agree that being the victim of a terror attack does not give a nation carte blanche to act however they see fit - international law does not cease to exist because you have suffered an attack, and so the travesty of October 7th in no way justifies the conduct of Israel since. Sorry, I was trying to paraphrase Douglas Murray on my previous post. so, I thought I post you what he actually thinks on this matter of proportionality. which I find ridiculous as well. Mr Murray insisted: "There is some deep perversion in Britain whenever Israel is involved in a conflict, and is the word you just used proportion, proportionate proportionality, only Britain is really obsessed with this. "But if we were to decide that we should have this fetish about proportionality, then that would mean that in retaliation for what Hamas did in Israel on Saturday, Israel should try to locate a music festival in Gaza and rape precisely the number of women that Hamas raped on Saturday, kill precisely the number of young people that Hamas killed on Saturday.
"It's a very strange British concept which we've had only the Israelis in a conflict when they are attacked are expected to have precisely the proportionate response."
|
|
|
Originally posted by NJ CLOCKTOWER
Sorry, I was trying to paraphrase Douglas Murray on my previous post. so, I thought I post you what he actually thinks on this matter of proportionality. which I find ridiculous as well. Mr Murray insisted: "There is some deep perversion in Britain whenever Israel is involved in a conflict, and is the word you just used proportion, proportionate proportionality, only Britain is really obsessed with this. "But if we were to decide that we should have this fetish about proportionality, then that would mean that in retaliation for what Hamas did in Israel on Saturday, Israel should try to locate a music festival in Gaza and rape precisely the number of women that Hamas raped on Saturday, kill precisely the number of young people that Hamas killed on Saturday.
"It's a very strange British concept which we've had only the Israelis in a conflict when they are attacked are expected to have precisely the proportionate response." Ok, quite a reductive argument. You don't think, for example, there would be a better way for Israel to approach this now?
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Ok, quite a reductive argument. You don't think, for example, there would be a better way for Israel to approach this now? This is sort of Israel’s 9/11, in that it initially gave them a free hand at going after anybody who had p1ssed them off. The US did it and now Israel are doing the same. It’s the collateral damage to civilians that we are seeing that is the problem. But did the allies do just as much damage post 9/11 in their attempts to go after their bad guy?
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by NJ CLOCKTOWER
Absolutely, you're correct. International law remains crucial even in the face of terror attacks. Retaliation should be proportional and within the bounds of established legal frameworks. Each nation must uphold human rights standards even amidst challenging circumstances. When you say proportionally what do you actually mean? So what you're saying. Is that Israel should have waited till the morning at no specific day date or time. Not giving any warnings through leaflets thrown from airplanes, to tell the civilians to avoid this area. What you're saying is Israel should have invaded Palestine, attacked an open air festival or Muslim prayer let's say, shoot indiscriminately at civilians. Then after that go into a town in Palestine. Knock down every door and shoot the inhabitants and then call their mums telling their mum's how proud they are for killing a Palestinian. I'd appreciate if you could stop telling me what I'm saying, particularly when it's nothing close to what I'm actually saying. Your first paragraph is entirely at odds with Israel's conduct - if you do accept that international law remains crucial, retaliation should be proportional and within legal frameworks and that human rights should be respected - there is simply no logical conclusion other than a condemnation of Israel's action. Israel's ability to take a moral high ground in this has long since passed and your attempts to do so above are not at all convincing - you reference the death toll as some way of assessing proportionality... conservatively, Israel have killed 20x as many Palestinians as Hamas did Israelis. The final death toll will be considerably higher than that. In what way is that proportional?
|
|
|
Originally posted by NJ CLOCKTOWER
Sorry, I was trying to paraphrase Douglas Murray on my previous post. so, I thought I post you what he actually thinks on this matter of proportionality. which I find ridiculous as well. Mr Murray insisted: "There is some deep perversion in Britain whenever Israel is involved in a conflict, and is the word you just used proportion, proportionate proportionality, only Britain is really obsessed with this. "But if we were to decide that we should have this fetish about proportionality, then that would mean that in retaliation for what Hamas did in Israel on Saturday, Israel should try to locate a music festival in Gaza and rape precisely the number of women that Hamas raped on Saturday, kill precisely the number of young people that Hamas killed on Saturday.
"It's a very strange British concept which we've had only the Israelis in a conflict when they are attacked are expected to have precisely the proportionate response." Just pure nonsense - even for Murray, this is a terrible argument. Proportionality in conflict is not a British fetish nor any other weird description - it's a long-accepted, key principle of international humanitarian law; [Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
This is sort of Israel’s 9/11, in that it initially gave them a free hand at going after anybody who had p1ssed them off. The US did it and now Israel are doing the same. It’s the collateral damage to civilians that we are seeing that is the problem. But did the allies do just as much damage post 9/11 in their attempts to go after their bad guy? During the war in Afghanistan from 2001-2021, the 'Costs of War Project' estimate that 46,319 civilians were killed. That's in a 20-year campaign. Israel have already massacred at least half that total, probably a lot more, in 6 months. Do you see the difference?
|
|
| NJ CLOCKTOWER |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I'd appreciate if you could stop telling me what I'm saying, particularly when it's nothing close to what I'm actually saying. Your first paragraph is entirely at odds with Israel's conduct - if you do accept that international law remains crucial, retaliation should be proportional and within legal frameworks and that human rights should be respected - there is simply no logical conclusion other than a condemnation of Israel's action. Israel's ability to take a moral high ground in this has long since passed and your attempts to do so above are not at all convincing - you reference the death toll as some way of assessing proportionality... conservatively, Israel have killed 20x as many Palestinians as Hamas did Israelis. The final death toll will be considerably higher than that. In what way is that proportional? Well, if you have any solutions. Let the world know. I certainly haven't. And, it's not like Palestine hasn't been given the chance of peace. They have literally rejected every peace deal since 1948. Hamas, has also said openly that, it wants to eradicate israel. That's basically calling for genocide. I say enough is enough. If you give them any more leeway. The violence will continue. [Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by NJ CLOCKTOWER
Well, if you have any solutions. Let the world know. I certainly haven't. And, it's not like Palestine hasn't been given the chance of peace. They have literally rejected every peace deal since 1948. Hamas, has also said openly that, it wants to eradicate israel. That's basically calling for genocide. I say enough is enough. If you give them any more leeway. The violence will continue. [Link]
You're back to telling me about Hamas for some reason. As stated, I do not support Hamas - my position is simply that I want the killing of civilians to end. To that end, I focus more attention towards the side now doing the overwhelming majority (if not all) of the killing of civilians. I also hold an elected military superpower who have signed the Geneva convention to a higher standard of conduct, than I do a terrorist organisation.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
During the war in Afghanistan from 2001-2021, the 'Costs of War Project' estimate that 46,319 civilians were killed. That's in a 20-year campaign. Israel have already massacred at least half that total, probably a lot more, in 6 months. Do you see the difference? Yes, I can see the difference. I also see the difference in the size of the territories in both instances; one being far more civilian concentrated than the other. But your point is valid as far as numbers and timescales are involved although I would add that the allies were probably partially a peace keeping force during those twenty years, particularly in the later years.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
Yes, I can see the difference. I also see the difference in the size of the territories in both instances; one being far more civilian concentrated than the other. But your point is valid as far as numbers and timescales are involved although I would add that the allies were probably partially a peace keeping force during those twenty years, particularly in the later years. I think an ambition of eradicating the enemy in this context is pointless - you don’t defeat an ideology on the battlefield and the current course of action does nothing but radicalise a whole new generation of Palestinians, many of whom probably end up in Europe as a result of Israel’s ongoing displacement.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I think an ambition of eradicating the enemy in this context is pointless - you don’t defeat an ideology on the battlefield and the current course of action does nothing but radicalise a whole new generation of Palestinians, many of whom probably end up in Europe as a result of Israel’s ongoing displacement. You are right, defeating an ideology is difficult, hence the objections on this forum by some posters that question the trend to import that ideology into the UK. But the multicultural experiment must continue.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
You are right, defeating an ideology is difficult, hence the objections on this forum by some posters that question the trend to import that ideology into the UK. But the multicultural experiment must continue. To be clear, I am referring to the ideology of Hamas, not Islam as a whole.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
Yes, I can see the difference. I also see the difference in the size of the territories in both instances; one being far more civilian concentrated than the other. But your point is valid as far as numbers and timescales are involved although I would add that the allies were probably partially a peace keeping force during those twenty years, particularly in the later years. You might want to delve a little deeper into your history books. Try, for instance, looking at the Wiki pages on the 30 Year War. One positive policy introduced by Wellington was bring your own food. Looters and rapists from his own numbers were summarily executed. That was a revolutionary change. Prior to that, armies were fed on what they could plunder from the locality. This was policy ordered by the generals, not some indiscipline of ragged squaddies. Given the precarious, marginal existence at that time, this usually meant that anyone within a 20 mile radius of the battle or who were unlucky enough to live en route for the marching heroes, had all their meagre provisions taken, daughters ravaged and, as a consequence, those who barely survived the endorsed pillaging, generally starved to death.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Mate we’re not in a court of law - if you have a view or something to say, just say it - it’s a lot of telling people what they should and shouldn’t do when discussing this topic, without actually going into any detail. You say I shouldn’t generalise but frankly that is all you’re doing; making huge general statements about ‘conflicts’ without acknowledging any of the specifics of this conflict - if you want to provide context or nuance to go against my criticisms of Israel, by all means provide it, but don’t just vaguely hint that they exist. I agree it’s fair to criticise any country for multiple violations of international law or disregard for civilian protection, hence why I am criticising Israel.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
To be clear, I am referring to the ideology of Hamas, not Islam as a whole. Where the west and how it acts is involved what is the difference in the ideology and beliefs. .
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.