Quote jamiemartin721 at 17 Feb 2015 11.03am
Quote Stirlingsays at 17 Feb 2015 10.37am
Quote Seth at 17 Feb 2015 1.41am
Quote Stirlingsays at 17 Feb 2015 12.34am
Quote Seth at 17 Feb 2015 12.24am
Not just northern Europe old chap. We English are made of broader stock than that. The great thing about us is we're made up of peoples from all over the world, all living together on one little island.
Yes, we need to make sure there are jobs and services for people who come here, and that the host community are looked after too, but to be English is to be part of, and made up of, the world.
That's what makes us so great
We wouldn't quite agree there Seth.
To be English is to be born here.....Though I'll accept someone who wants to become English and works at adapting and accepting the norms of the majority culture can become English.....That's more than the Japanese would for example.
Something tells me that we wouldn't agree on what being English means.
That's ok....Tolerance is apart of the culture.
Boris Johnson wasn't born in England. Nor were Bradley Wiggins, George Orwell or Rudyard Kipling. I'm not sure how much "working at adapting or accepting the norms of the majority culture" any of them would have had to do.
You're right though, we probably won't agree on our definitions of Englishness, and that tolerance is one of our hallmarks. Long may it continue 
Obviously if your parents are English or steeped in the Anglo Saxon culture than there isn't much adapting that needs to be done.
However if you come from a significantly different culture and haven't been raised here it's a valid point.
Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Feb 2015 10.45am)
There never really was that much of an Anglo-Saxon culture per se. The era of the Angles and the Saxons is largely a series of conflicting kingdoms throughout the dark ages, which were by no means a unified 'culture' (particually given that they were in contrast to the post-Roman Cymri as well as influences from the Jutes, Danes, Irish and Pictish).
From the period of the collapse of Roman Britain, till the arrival of the Normans, England is really much more a series of fractured kingdoms, of which the Angles and Saxons were largely an influence the South and East of the land (and even then they were largely occupying kingdoms in which the main cultures was post-roman cymri).
Although towards the end of the dark ages, the emergence of unified England is looking more and more a reality, the arrival of the Normans is really the first point post Roman Empire, that you could really start to point at a dominant English culture.
A convenience has seen the Angles and Saxons as 'the dominant culture', post Rome, but its basis was never really established as a unified 'identity' it was far to fractured to really call it a country.
Even by that point, the 7th century Christianisation is probably much more a factor of cultural unification than the Angles or Saxons. Its only really as late as the 8th century that the Germanic people see themselves as separate from the Angles, Saxons, Franks etc.
At best I'd say that the idea of an Anglo-Saxon 'nation' of England has about 100-150 years, before the arrival of the Normans, who really re-established what would become England. Largely a result of this conquest is the adoption of the Anglo-Saxon identity as Englishry.
Prior to that, I think you really have to go back to the Roman Britain.