You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy
November 22 2026 2.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy


Page 109 of 174 < 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 >
Badger11 Flag Beckenham 01 Sep 23 7.18pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Not by the ONS which is what was intimated. Of course figures can get corrected as more data becomes available. What would have them do, ignore it? It doesn’t mean they are unreliable at all. It just means they are released in stages and refined as time clarifies.

We all know that the economy has been impacted by a series of events in the past few years. Brexit was but one, being closely followed by the pandemic and then by the war. Trying to apportion the impact of each seems to me to be near to impossible and capable of generating political footballs to be kicked around to little purpose.

What looks blindingly obvious is that Brexit has not seen the promised flurry of trade deals and that the deal we did with the EU was not over ready and remains half baked. The only conclusion to be drawn from that must be that Brexit has been a drain on our economy. So if we are avoiding a recession the question ought to be how much better it would have been without Brexit.

I would expect the ONS to come up with a better and more accurate way of collecting data rather than telling us we heading into recession when we had growth.

No surprise that yet again you stick up for the establishment and defend incompetency.


 


One more point

eaglesdare Flag 01 Sep 23 11.19pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Since when are comments about the reasons why videos are made “ad hominems”? Those making them aren’t users of this site so nothing said can be regarded as personal.

No-one questions what Campbell did prior to making videos, or indeed that his original intention and early videos wasn’t honourable. It was. What has happened since has been described by me, and many others better qualified than any here to make informed, objective judgements, as far from honourable. He has found a hungry, lucrative market eager for scraps to feed their prejudices. It’s clever, even admirable, but not honourable.

When the obnoxious term “anti-white” rears its ugly head in a comment you know that the whole argument has failed. It’s nonsense.

If people don’t believe that there is, and has been for several years, manipulation of opinion here, and in the west as a whole, by countries who wish us harm, then I suggest they need to do more research. Our security services know it and have counter measures in place to try to mitigate it. It’s real though.

Denying it exists or that their own views are incapable of being influenced by it, is to deny the obvious.

I thought you were above "conspiracy theories" ...........

 

eaglesdare Flag 01 Sep 23 11.20pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Since when are comments about the reasons why videos are made “ad hominems”? Those making them aren’t users of this site so nothing said can be regarded as personal.

No-one questions what Campbell did prior to making videos, or indeed that his original intention and early videos wasn’t honourable. It was. What has happened since has been described by me, and many others better qualified than any here to make informed, objective judgements, as far from honourable. He has found a hungry, lucrative market eager for scraps to feed their prejudices. It’s clever, even admirable, but not honourable.

When the obnoxious term “anti-white” rears its ugly head in a comment you know that the whole argument has failed. It’s nonsense.

If people don’t believe that there is, and has been for several years, manipulation of opinion here, and in the west as a whole, by countries who wish us harm, then I suggest they need to do more research. Our security services know it and have counter measures in place to try to mitigate it. It’s real though.

Denying it exists or that their own views are incapable of being influenced by it, is to deny the obvious.

I thought you were above "conspiracy theories" .........

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 01 Sep 23 11.28pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I would expect the ONS to come up with a better and more accurate way of collecting data rather than telling us we heading into recession when we had growth.

No surprise that yet again you stick up for the establishment and defend incompetency.


Did they actually say that or was that the spin that the media put on it? So far as I am aware before a recession is declared there has to be a series of months of negative growth. Early results usually come with caveats advising that they need to be treated with caution.

The only thing I am sticking up for is a realistic and cool appraisal rather than one that is looking for mud to sling.

The ONS don’t have a political agenda. The collect and publish data. They then sometimes try to explain what it might indicate.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 01 Sep 23 11.31pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

I thought you were above "conspiracy theories" .........

Above isn’t the right word. Sceptical might be better.

This though is not one. There is strong supporting evidence that it exists. Just do some research.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

eaglesdare Flag 01 Sep 23 11.37pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Above isn’t the right word. Sceptical might be better.

This though is not one. There is strong supporting evidence that it exists. Just do some research.

Hahahahaha it's a conspiracy theory! You have joined us "conspiracy theorists" it took you long enough!

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 02 Sep 23 12.41am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Campbell cites a new study from Israel (where independent studies seem common) that shows that natural immunity after infection is significantly better than vaccine induced immunity on beating off reinfection.

[Link]

Are certain people going to start calling for the ban of vaccinated people from social events? Blame them for taking up hospital beds for example.

Hopefully not because only awful people would do something like that.


Edited by Stirlingsays (31 Aug 2023 10.50pm)

Campbell is a bit of a hack, and I think you quote one source far too often when there are thousands of others available from the same stable. Although RFK is certainly not one of them. Avoid him at all costs.

However

Yes there are several studies that suggest natural immunity can be stronger than vaccine immunity. Key there is ‘can’, rather than ‘is’. It may well be the case for immediate aftermath of infection but doesn’t appear to be the case long term.

As always these things are never as simple as a catchy headline.

There are also plenty of studies that show vaccination + infection provides the strongest possible immunity defence, and for the longest period of time. I covered this in an earlier post but effectively your germinal centres produce more antibodies and for longer with both. This has the dual benefit of keeping your immunity higher for longer AND making you more able to combat future mutations due to the type of antibodies the vaccines prompt your germinal centres to produce.

Most people under 60 / healthy shouldn’t need boosters this season. And they’re not being asked to come forward and get them either.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Stirlingsays Flag 03 Sep 23 12.25pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Campbell is a bit of a hack, and I think you quote one source far too often when there are thousands of others available from the same stable. Although RFK is certainly not one of them. Avoid him at all costs.

Well, I don't think he's a hack.

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

However

Yes there are several studies that suggest natural immunity can be stronger than vaccine immunity. Key there is ‘can’, rather than ‘is’. It may well be the case for immediate aftermath of infection but doesn’t appear to be the case long term.

As always these things are never as simple as a catchy headline.

If I remember correctly the vaccines only deal with the spike protein....they look for one aspect, the most important one but that single identifying aspect.

Natural immunity is more nunanced than that so personally while there are always specifics to individual cases I don't regard it as a 'can' and more of an 'is'.

And as regards catchy headlines go I regard the misinformation spread by...and enforced by official sources as far more misleading and dangerous.....telling people that masks were important...enough to arrest people...telling people that vaccines stopped transmission when that was always a lie....with that lie meaning that logically vaccinated people's guard would drop along with their social distancing and more infections would occur not less.

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

There are also plenty of studies that show vaccination + infection provides the strongest possible immunity defence, and for the longest period of time. I covered this in an earlier post but effectively your germinal centres produce more antibodies and for longer with both. This has the dual benefit of keeping your immunity higher for longer AND making you more able to combat future mutations due to the type of antibodies the vaccines prompt your germinal centres to produce.

Most people under 60 / healthy shouldn’t need boosters this season. And they’re not being asked to come forward and get them either.

Well as that conclusion goes pretty much against the conclusion reached in this study it comes down to what you believe is accurate.

Personally I go with which studies are independent of 'interested' funding sources.....and Israel seems to contain more of them. And they are hardly anti vaccine as they are amongst the most vaccinated countries.

Also, the fact that our own government went from 60 to zero on enforcing vaccines tells its own story. Covid did require a serious response but what happened wasn't only a financial crime and destruction of wealth.....it was an attack on civil liberties....an attack on mental health....on children's education...and on vulnerable's people healthcare.

The excess deaths that have occurred since all these actions.....far larger than anything covid....is a damning indictment of everything that happened.

Some of us spoke up at the time and underwent the scourge of the frightened majority. However, I believe that we have been proven right.

But there is no enjoyment or celebration in tragedy.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 03 Sep 23 11.39pm

Really worth watching as an evidence study on how liars spread misinformation with language manipulation and word salads and cover for the terrible things they supported.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 04 Sep 23 7.38am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Really worth watching as an evidence study on how liars spread misinformation with language manipulation and word salads and cover for the terrible things they supported.

What you mean like this

[Link]

 


One more point

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Sep 23 2.58pm

Originally posted by Badger11

What you mean like this

[Link]

The level of degeneracy that is enabled by our mainstream institutions and laws makes me sick.

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Sep 2023 2.59pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 04 Sep 23 3.59pm

Originally posted by Badger11

What you mean like this

[Link]

It might be better to learn why from the BBC and their lawyers themselves, rather than rely on a report in the Mail. I don’t know, or why they haven’t explained, but I guess it is all down to legal considerations. Publishing information not discussed in Court opens up the possibilities of a libel claim so I suspect they were instructed to modify the report to avoid that happening.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 04 Sep 23 4.54pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Well as that conclusion goes pretty much against the conclusion reached in this study it comes down to what you believe is accurate.

Personally I go with which studies are independent of 'interested' funding sources.....and Israel seems to contain more of them. And they are hardly anti vaccine as they are amongst the most vaccinated countries.

Also, the fact that our own government went from 60 to zero on enforcing vaccines tells its own story. Covid did require a serious response but what happened wasn't only a financial crime and destruction of wealth.....it was an attack on civil liberties....an attack on mental health....on children's education...and on vulnerable's people healthcare.

The excess deaths that have occurred since all these actions.....far larger than anything covid....is a damning indictment of everything that happened.

Some of us spoke up at the time and underwent the scourge of the frightened majority. However, I believe that we have been proven right.

But there is no enjoyment or celebration in tragedy.

I'd be interested to read that study in more detail as I'd be surprised if the conclusion was that natural immunity on its own is more effective than natural immunity + vaccination. Feel free to share the link.

Whilst you're right re. spike protein, what you're not factoring in to your own conclusion is the biology behind how the body reacts to a single covid variant naturally vs. how it reacts to a vaccine designed to counteract multiple variants, and the significant compound effect of both.

Natural infection provides strong immunity to a particular strain, but leaves you more vulnerable to other strains or future mutations. Vaccines help to produce more countermeasures both in terms of volume and variety, leaving you better prepared for future mutations and therefore infection.

Current consensus is stronger with both natural and vaccinated responses combined. I'm yet to read anything that credibly counters that.

Also re. Israel – all studies need to be funded, and I don't think it's ever possible to claim any properly run study (which are time consuming and expensive) is truly independent. I take your point on big pharma etc. as we've seen it all before with things like Oxycontin but the consensus appears to be broad and varied on this conclusion.

As for lockdowns – hindsight is a wonderful thing. But I would agree that measures went too far, looking back with a totally unqualified eye I'd have said the first one was sufficient, but ultimately that's a guess. Arguably you could say that worst case having no further lockdowns could have tipped the NHS over the edge and you'd end up with the same level of backlog anyway, operations being delayed, funding being pushed elsewhere.

I don't think it's as simple as 'no lockdowns = better outcome'. Too many factors at play there. Overly simplistic view IMO but one worth debating

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 04 Sep 23 6.01pm

I see that the misleading ideas about the excess mortality statistics that continue to be recorded, as promoted by one of our poster’s favourite producer of dodgy daily videoes, have surfaced again.

No one argues that the pandemic caused excess deaths and that they continue to be seen. Indeed they are a better way of measuring the impact than trying to attribute deaths directly from the virus alone.

What is so misleading is the claim being made that this indicates a failure of the measures that were taken. Nothing could be further from the truth. The truth being that, bad as they undoubtedly are, they indicate just how much worse things would have been without those measures.

For those wanting to actually understand them and their relevance these links provide some interesting analyses:-

[Link]

[Link]

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Teddy Eagle Flag 04 Sep 23 7.11pm


Collateral damage of lockdowns.

[Link]

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 04 Sep 23 8.15pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle


Collateral damage of lockdowns.

[Link]

This kind of analysis seems illogical to me. We all know that lockdowns caused immense collateral damage so there is no point in keep repeating it. What we don’t, and cannot, know is whether not locking down would have produced a better result but it seems pretty obvious to me that it was highly likely to be worse, quite possibly much worse.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Teddy Eagle Flag 04 Sep 23 8.26pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

This kind of analysis seems illogical to me. We all know that lockdowns caused immense collateral damage so there is no point in keep repeating it. What we don’t, and cannot, know is whether not locking down would have produced a better result but it seems pretty obvious to me that it was highly likely to be worse, quite possibly much worse.

We also don't know for how many years the damaging effects will be felt, both in terms of the societal damage and the hundreds of billions spent which could have been put to better use.
It might be obvious to some but not to all those whose job it is to study such matters.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Sep 23 9.03pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

I'd be interested to read that study in more detail as I'd be surprised if the conclusion was that natural immunity on its own is more effective than natural immunity + vaccination. Feel free to share the link.

Whilst you're right re. spike protein, what you're not factoring in to your own conclusion is the biology behind how the body reacts to a single covid variant naturally vs. how it reacts to a vaccine designed to counteract multiple variants, and the significant compound effect of both.

Natural infection provides strong immunity to a particular strain, but leaves you more vulnerable to other strains or future mutations. Vaccines help to produce more countermeasures both in terms of volume and variety, leaving you better prepared for future mutations and therefore infection.

Current consensus is stronger with both natural and vaccinated responses combined. I'm yet to read anything that credibly counters that.

Also re. Israel – all studies need to be funded, and I don't think it's ever possible to claim any properly run study (which are time consuming and expensive) is truly independent. I take your point on big pharma etc. as we've seen it all before with things like Oxycontin but the consensus appears to be broad and varied on this conclusion.

As for lockdowns – hindsight is a wonderful thing. But I would agree that measures went too far, looking back with a totally unqualified eye I'd have said the first one was sufficient, but ultimately that's a guess. Arguably you could say that worst case having no further lockdowns could have tipped the NHS over the edge and you'd end up with the same level of backlog anyway, operations being delayed, funding being pushed elsewhere.

I don't think it's as simple as 'no lockdowns = better outcome'. Too many factors at play there. Overly simplistic view IMO but one worth debating

Well, I can't really say we agree on conclusions here but I of course respect your reasoning.

Here is the link to the study:
[Link]

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 05 Sep 23 1.54pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Well, I can't really say we agree on conclusions here but I of course respect your reasoning.

Here is the link to the study:
[Link]


Good read.

So a couple of things to highlight from that study in context of what I was saying. There’s a bit of comparing apples with pears from your side here.

1) The study only compares natural immunity vs. vaccinated immunity. Not Naturally infected + vaccinated (hybrid) which provides the greatest strength of immune protection which was my point.

2) I have already acknowledged earlier that there appears to be little difference in immune response between natural and vaccinated when focusing on one type of infection (eg. Delta). There are several studies on which of the two prevent serious illness though, which is less clear and seemingly more in favour of the vaccines (There are several factors that combine to create an immune response – antibodies, T cells etc.)

3) Which brings us to the issue with the study vs what I was saying – it only focuses on one strain, Delta. It does not investigate how long immunity lasts for between both groups and which type of immunity would provide the strongest response in case of future reinfection by different strains / mutations, which formed the basis of what I was saying.

4) Also, FYI, The conclusions made in this study do not go against the points I was making, as they're not testing for them.
.
.
.
Some quotes direct from the study that reflect my position or are worth noting…

'vaccinated individuals are more protected against severe disease than unvaccinated ones, even if a breakthrough infection (infection after vaccination) occurs'

'Our study has several limitations. First, as the Delta variant was the dominant strain in Israel during the outcome period, the decreased long-term protection of the vaccine compared to that afforded by previous infection cannot be ascertained against other strains, including the Omicron variant. Second, our analysis addressed protection afforded solely by the BioNTech/Pfizer mRNA BNT162b2 vaccine and therefore does not address other vaccines or long-term protection following a third dose, an assessment that might require more data before carrying out.'

'SARS-CoV-2-naive vaccinees had more COVID-19-related-hospitalization compared to those who were previously infected, although the numbers are too small to determine statistical significance.'

This one is interesting to me, as it's possibly more likely that vulnerable people would have taken up the vaccine, with less vulnerable people deciding to avoid it. Therefore leading to a skew of slightly more vaccinated individuals being hospitalised than unvaccinated. Hypothetical though, would need to be considered.

Although they do then say

'adjusting for obesity, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, hypertension, chronic kidney disease, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, cancer, and immunosuppression had only a small impact on the estimated effect as compared to the unadjusted OR. Therefore, residual confounding by unmeasured factors is unlikely.'
.
.
.
They caveat their findings heavily here

'The advantageous protection afforded by naturally acquired immunity that this analysis demonstrates could be explained by the more extensive immune response to the SARS-CoV-2 proteins than that generated by the anti-spike protein immune activation conferred by the vaccine [19, 20]. However, as a correlate of protection is yet to be proven [1, 21], including the role of B-Cell [22] and T-cell immunity [23, 24], this remains a hypothesis.'

So still very hypothetical in it would seem (in 2022 anyway).
.
.
.
'Our study matches the CDC report [10], examining cohorts in California and New York, demonstrating that infection-induced protection was more substantial than vaccine induced immunity during the Delta period. The report demonstrates an opposite trend during the previous Alpha dominant period; however, a significant limitation, addressed as such by the researchers of this report as well, pertains to the lack of addressing the varying times-since-vaccination, which could bias the result, especially in the early stages of the follow-up.'

So during the Alpha wave vaccines were judged to provide stronger immunity. Delta wave, the opposite happened. What's mentioned here is that the measuring method might have created this anomaly. Again, a fairly strong caveat.

They admit to clear limitations, which match my earlier points around immunity timescales, strength and protection against one strain vs future strains.

'Our study has several limitations. First, as the Delta variant was the dominant strain in Israel during the outcome period, the decreased long-term protection of the vaccine compared to that afforded by previous infection cannot be ascertained against other strains, including the Omicron variant.'
.
.
.
Re. funding 'There was no external funding for this project'. Great – so how was it funded and who funded it? And what are their motives? It's never as simple as 'independent = better'. For what it's worth this research appears balanced and they mention limitations and caveat where required.
.
.
.
My conclusions after reading the study

• Natural vs vaccine induced immunity for specific strains appears to be more or less the same, but it's not clear for how long.

• The added benefit of the vaccine(s) is that you don't have to go through the symptoms with no immunity whatsoever and expose yourself to the risk of a bad reaction to infection in order to achieve that immunity. This is a point that I don't often hear raised or countered from people who have refused.

• This study only covers one vaccine type, Pfizer.

• The dataset used may not be that reliable by their own admission seeing as studies on the Alpha variant produced the opposite outcome (vaccines providing more protection).

• There is nothing in the study to counter the current consensus around natural infection + vaccination (hybrid immunity) = best possible immunity which was my point. There are plenty of studies, including Israeli ones, that back this up.
.
.
.
Conclusion – your position of 'natural immunity = same protection as vaccination' to make you feel better about rejecting the vaccine eg. why would I need it then... on the surface appears true, but doesn't hold water under detailed analysis.

For clarity to you and others – My issue is not with whether you want to be vaccinated or not, it's whether the reasoning you're pushing more widely or buying into personally as to why, and whether that's actually valid or not. It's a nuance but it's an important one, and others often don't seem to get it when I counter and they then take personal offence. Usually that's the sort of reaction you get from religious people trapped in belief systems. Just saying

Edited by SW19 CPFC (05 Sep 2023 1.59pm)

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Stirlingsays Flag 05 Sep 23 5.07pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Conclusion – your position of 'natural immunity = same protection as vaccination' to make you feel better about rejecting the vaccine eg. why would I need it then... on the surface appears true, but doesn't hold water under detailed analysis.

For clarity to you and others – My issue is not with whether you want to be vaccinated or not, it's whether the reasoning you're pushing more widely or buying into personally as to why, and whether that's actually valid or not. It's a nuance but it's an important one, and others often don't seem to get it when I counter and they then take personal offence. Usually that's the sort of reaction you get from religious people trapped in belief systems. Just saying

Edited by SW19 CPFC (05 Sep 2023 1.59pm)

Make me feel better?

You think I regret not taking those vaccines? Mmmm....perhaps you're the one who needs the validation, I'm as fit as a fiddle.

You seem to have spent a lot of time here essentially trying to debunk the main point but you haven't really. All you're showing is that they make a statement up to a point.

Your belief systems based on studies you think are true is something I've already answered. That's fine but from where I'm standing you're the one desperate to prove that what you supported was valid.

Whereas I regard what was done as a massive over reaction that generations now have to pay for both in death and taxes.

Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Sep 2023 5.27pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 109 of 174 < 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy