You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Steve Browett on January Signings
November 16 2026 1.41pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Steve Browett on January Signings


Page 11 of 11 << First< 7 8 9 10 11
peterg Flag Anerley 24 Jan 14 10.58am

Quote Kermit8 at 24 Jan 2014 10.10am

Quote sydtheeagle at 24 Jan 2014 9.56am

Good post, Rudi. Only thing I would say is that I agree winning the playoffs was not luck, but getting into them in the first place (given our form between December and May) most certainly was luck. Very few teams on the sort of run we had for four months will ever make the playoffs. That we took our chance once we got there, though, was not at all down to luck. That was grabbing the opportunity with both hands.


Spot on sydenham

Agree with these posts. I am still puzzled that we scraped into the playoffs and think we were lucky that our rivals were dropping points too. We won the playoffs thanks to two inspired performances - Brighton away and Wembley. I just wonder how that happened. Did IH suddenly find a way to motivate the players and/or come up with the right technical advice? Or did the players give themselves a collective lift? I think it was a lot to do with Zaha, wanting to go out on a high and also feeling he could deliver a great performance for Palace as thanks for what it had done for him.

 


The right place at the right time

est1905 Flag 24 Jan 14 4.31pm

Quote Hambo at 23 Jan 2014 9.33pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jan 2014 8.12pm

Quote est1905 at 23 Jan 2014 5.34pm

I'm not complaining about that but lets not all start pretending it was all down to business acumen!

Absolutely correct. I'm sure that our current owners are astute businessmen in so far as you don't achieve success or amass a fortune (either/or) as they have without a degree of astuteness, but they haven't particularly shown it, or needed to show it, at Palace.

On the playing side, hiring a manager with a reputation for enjoying a heavy night out wasn't particularly astute. Replacing him with a home grown novice was either astute or lucky or a bit of both. Losing that novice when he turned out to be highly capable certainly wasn't astute, and getting promoted given our form after he'd left was far more luck than judgment. Losing the replacement manager in less than a year was many things and astute wasn't one of them. Taking four weeks to replace him was a mixed bag; the final choice of replacement was astute; had we persuaded him to come four weeks earlier, we might be in the top 10 by now.

On the playing side, the Zaha sale was luck more than judgment (the current owners merely cashed in on him; they didn't develop him) though you could argue they were astute to sell when his value was high. In terms of incoming players they've brought in a mixed bag. Not much astute business there, though.

On the non-playing side they've done what's required to bring the ground up to Premiership requirements; they had no choice but to do that so it's not astute. I believe some improvements have been made to facilities generally and if so, that would be a sensible step. But it's not astute as it so obviously needed doing that only a fool would not have done so.

All in all, our owners have done a good, professional, competent job off the pitch. Astuteness not really required; an idiot can tell most of our facilities are paleolithic and that negatively impacts prospective revenue. They've actually done an average to poor job with managers but they've had real rub of the green and the team has punched above its weight, good fortune they've benefitted from too.

We have decent owners who support the club, work hard, and have their hearts in the right place. They're far more good than bad and many clubs have a lot worse, But heroes, Gods, perfect, or deserving of unquestioned praise? Not for me.

Excellent post - and Steve P has said on a number of occasions that he finds constructive criticism/discussion useful, as you would expect.

I think this thread has, in the main, been understood as a discussion, which is refreshing by recent standards. Too often people see a post as a defining opinion.

For example I get accused of being a sycophant - but the truth is that I only engage with certain types of posts (to stop myself being on HOL as much as I used to be - I have a job and a sort of life, plus I do the radio so don't want to give out Hambo overkill) . The threads/posts I pick tend to be where I think someone has something wrong or is being unfair.

So when I, or others, defend the board for example, automatically some people assume that this means a lack of acceptance of criticism.

The same is often true when I observe people making salient, but perceptibly "negative" posts. There is tendency for people to dismiss those out of hand way too often rather than to engage/

HOL is at it's best when people are willing to discuss an issue - and accept that the end result is not always going to be an agreement. Trolls can sometimes make that a little tricky (you know who you are) - but most of the time it's just people talking, united by a shared interest/obsession.

Some of my favourite posters, past and present, have been those I disagree with more often than not but who debate issues properly. It's what the site is all about IMO.

More please.

Well I always disagree with everything you say Hambo but on this occasion.....

 

Green Bin Flag Carshalton Beeches 24 Jan 14 4.58pm

Quote alffy at 23 Jan 2014 3.24pm

I'm pretty sure Pulis said at the end of December that we needed to do our business early but as there's about a week to go and no one has come in I'm a little concerned that we don't act like we did in the summer. Personally I'd prefer no one to come in than do mad dash deals on the final day for anyone and everyone that is willing to come to us. Surely we had targets before the window opened and some to fall back on? It seems we are now trudging through the Championship for some half decent buys...if there are any?

TBH that can be said about virtually every other PL team other than Hull (two over-priced deals). Chelsea and Man U have managed to get one deal each, and Cardiff seem to have a job-lot of Scandinavians.

Still think we only need one CB, a striker if poss and a decent wide player (actually if Thomas could stay fit for the rest of the season, I don't think we would need another wideman).

However if we end up with no new strikers but have Murray and Wibs in the 25 to support Jerome/Chamakh/Gayle, I don't think that's the end of the world...think we will make an interesting last day signing though


 

Page 11 of 11 << First< 7 8 9 10 11

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Steve Browett on January Signings