Quote serial thriller at 04 Dec 2014 2.08pm
The idea of charisma politics articulated through one individual is pretty prevalent right now. I mean, Farage is a clear example of it, being so uniquely representative of his party alone, and we have seen numerous attacks on him about his activities in the European Parliament and his background, which have done little to deflate his image being generally quite positive for those who sympathise with his ideas. Similarly Boris Johnson is a man who seems to be able to ride the wave of personal criticism, although he's far less representative of any particular ideology.
I guess it all comes down to your own stance. If you are on the left, you see hypocrisy within the Tory party as representative of the flaws in their philosophy. Similarly if you're on the right, attacking Russell Brand for his lifestyle and success appears a legitimate response. And that extends from him giving money to a dodgy landlord to wanting to, as Johnny says, appear in the media and further his career. I think both approaches are wrong. It is intellectually redundant and actually pretty cowardly to attack the person without engaging with the ideas.
Russell Brand could be a Millwall-supporting top hat wearing rapist billionaire but if the ideas he as a human being channels are sympathetic to mine I see no reason that those personal facts should come in to it, just as I think it's puerile to have a go at David Cameron for going to Eton. His ideas are such bullsh*t you're almost letting him off the hook by attacking him.
I disagree with this.
If someone speaks for an ideal publicly and is seeking to change public opinion through their words and ideas, surely they should adhere to those words and ideas?
A politician I disagree with but admire was Tony Benn because he followed through with his ideas and renounced his hereditary peerage to allow him to pursue his words and ideas.
Brand is saying that rent prices are too high in London, saying that things should change, yet is adhering to the status quo by paying a high rent in a trendy area to a faceless landlord. If he really wanted to adhere to this words and ideas he would buy a one bed place in Croydon.
Hypocrisy highlights the flaws in the mettle of the politician. Brand has showed his true colours. He is the same as most of the rest of them - a do as I say not do as I do merchant.
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02
|