You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Ched Evans saga part ???
November 22 2026 1.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ched Evans saga part ???


Page 11 of 19 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >
topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 09 Oct 15 10.24am

Quote dannyh at 09 Oct 2015 9.11am

Quote topcat at 08 Oct 2015 10.12am

Quote dannyh at 08 Oct 2015 9.03am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Oct 2015 9.57am

I hadn't heard about Facebook but there were lots of rumours (whether true or not) about how she behaved pre and post incident.


Quote dannyh at 08 Oct 2015 9.03am

Spunk Sponge who had an eye for a pay day.

That's an awful thing to say about a victim of rape.

What sort of pay day does a victim of rape get?

Edited by topcat (08 Oct 2015 10.13am)

It would be if I believed she was a "victim", But I don’t. Based on the reports available including elements of the court case, I believe her to be nothing more than a cheap hoe bag, who was in it from the beginning to get some cash.

She even went on facebook and admitted as much. Don't get me wrong Ched Evans, like most modern young footballers is a reprehensible pr1ck, however he is IMO guilty of nothing more than having a pissed shag (havn't we all ?) and fell foul of a legal system that allows for this sort of buffoonery.

I come across this a lot in my particular job role, A lot of Army bases are in rural area’s and those who serve normally have a bit more cash on the hip than those local lads who do not. With all the perks a young soldier is a meal ticket for a lot of young women, and we have to verbalise to young guys to box clever. It’s a sad state of affairs when I have to brief young lads on the dangers of copping off with the local girls in case they a) get accused of rape, as has happened recently where the case was thrown out as the women was lying her arse off. Or b) they say they are on contraception but aren’t and then hit the guys for CSA.

Of course what this actually does, is make it even harder for real victims of rape to prove their case, but equally this mentality were all women are innocent victims is I’m afraid to say, utter bollicks.

Whilst I can't comment on the middle part of your post, I still can't see how you can have more knowledge of the case than the jury that found him guilty of rape and her therefore a victim of rape, a crime that is notoriously difficult to get a conviction for.

There is a lot of apparent evidence out there on the internet but as you know you can find evidence of anything on the internet if you look hard enough but it doesn't make it true.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 Oct 15 11.10am

Quote Cucking Funt at 06 Oct 2015 7.00pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Oct 2015 4.27pm

Evans biggest problem has always been that he admitted having sex with her, under caution and oath. The police couldn't prove sex had taken place, but both defendants admitted it.

I think his only real recourse is to either prove she wasn't drunk, or discredit her and witnesses that say she was.

Apparently its evidence the original defense didn't submit, which is questionable, and some new evidence that has come to light. The latter is likely his best bet, because if the defense didn't submit something, its usually because its potentially incriminating or damaging. Especially when they didn't submit it to the first appeal application.


Whatever it is, it's sufficiently game-changing to go back to the Court of Appeal.

Potentially is the key word. A new witness for example might be available, who wasn't before, but that individual also wouldn't have been cross examined by prosecution either.

To go to the Court of Appeal it only has to fulfill the requirements for an appeal, not that it 'exonerates' and individual.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 Oct 15 11.23am

Quote dannyh at 09 Oct 2015 9.11am

Quote topcat at 08 Oct 2015 10.12am

Quote dannyh at 08 Oct 2015 9.03am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Oct 2015 9.57am

I hadn't heard about Facebook but there were lots of rumours (whether true or not) about how she behaved pre and post incident.


Quote dannyh at 08 Oct 2015 9.03am

Spunk Sponge who had an eye for a pay day.

That's an awful thing to say about a victim of rape.

What sort of pay day does a victim of rape get?

Edited by topcat (08 Oct 2015 10.13am)

It would be if I believed she was a "victim", But I don’t. Based on the reports available including elements of the court case, I believe her to be nothing more than a cheap hoe bag, who was in it from the beginning to get some cash.

She even went on facebook and admitted as much. Don't get me wrong Ched Evans, like most modern young footballers is a reprehensible pr1ck, however he is IMO guilty of nothing more than having a pissed shag (havn't we all ?) and fell foul of a legal system that allows for this sort of buffoonery.

I come across this a lot in my particular job role, A lot of Army bases are in rural area’s and those who serve normally have a bit more cash on the hip than those local lads who do not. With all the perks a young soldier is a meal ticket for a lot of young women, and we have to verbalise to young guys to box clever. It’s a sad state of affairs when I have to brief young lads on the dangers of copping off with the local girls in case they a) get accused of rape, as has happened recently where the case was thrown out as the women was lying her arse off. Or b) they say they are on contraception but aren’t and then hit the guys for CSA.

Of course what this actually does, is make it even harder for real victims of rape to prove their case, but equally this mentality were all women are innocent victims is I’m afraid to say, utter bollicks.

The issue with Chad Evans though, is that he didn't have a 'drunk shag'. He turned up knowing that his friend had gotten a girl back, and that it was reasonable to assume that she was too drunk to give consent, and that it was unreasonable for Ched Evans, by his actions, to believe he had consent by actions.

The context of the situation is vitally important. His mate was not guilty, because it was reasonable for him by his actions and the girls, to believe he had consent (he met the girl, asked her to come back with him to the hotel room etc). Where as Ched Evans had never met the girl till he turned up, uninvited when he received a text from McDonald, about the girl. By his actions, if she was intoxicated, it is unreasonable for him to assume consent by way of actions and behavior.

Its different than if you met a girl who is drunk or gets drunk with you, and you go back and have sex. Its reasonable in that case to believe you have consent.

Ironically he'd have been found not guilty if he hadn't admitted to the police that he'd had sex with her. There is no evidence other than his own statement that he had sex with the girl.

He needs really to prove that she planned the event in advance of his arrival to some degree, was not sufficiently intoxicated and planned to accuse him. Even if she found out afterwards he was a footballer, and decided to 'earn of it', he is still guilty of rape (making the most of being a victim of crime might be unethical but its not illegal).


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 09 Oct 15 12.20pm

Quote topcat at 09 Oct 2015 10.24am

Quote dannyh at 09 Oct 2015 9.11am

Quote topcat at 08 Oct 2015 10.12am

Quote dannyh at 08 Oct 2015 9.03am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Oct 2015 9.57am

I hadn't heard about Facebook but there were lots of rumours (whether true or not) about how she behaved pre and post incident.


Quote dannyh at 08 Oct 2015 9.03am

Spunk Sponge who had an eye for a pay day.

That's an awful thing to say about a victim of rape.

What sort of pay day does a victim of rape get?

Edited by topcat (08 Oct 2015 10.13am)

It would be if I believed she was a "victim", But I don’t. Based on the reports available including elements of the court case, I believe her to be nothing more than a cheap hoe bag, who was in it from the beginning to get some cash.

She even went on facebook and admitted as much. Don't get me wrong Ched Evans, like most modern young footballers is a reprehensible pr1ck, however he is IMO guilty of nothing more than having a pissed shag (havn't we all ?) and fell foul of a legal system that allows for this sort of buffoonery.

I come across this a lot in my particular job role, A lot of Army bases are in rural area’s and those who serve normally have a bit more cash on the hip than those local lads who do not. With all the perks a young soldier is a meal ticket for a lot of young women, and we have to verbalise to young guys to box clever. It’s a sad state of affairs when I have to brief young lads on the dangers of copping off with the local girls in case they a) get accused of rape, as has happened recently where the case was thrown out as the women was lying her arse off. Or b) they say they are on contraception but aren’t and then hit the guys for CSA.

Of course what this actually does, is make it even harder for real victims of rape to prove their case, but equally this mentality were all women are innocent victims is I’m afraid to say, utter bollicks.

Whilst I can't comment on the middle part of your post, I still can't see how you can have more knowledge of the case than the jury that found him guilty of rape and her therefore a victim of rape, a crime that is notoriously difficult to get a conviction for.

There is a lot of apparent evidence out there on the internet but as you know you can find evidence of anything on the internet if you look hard enough but it doesn't make it true.

Have a munch on this.


When the trial started in Caernarfon, the main thrust of the Prosecution’s case was that the complainant was so intoxicated that she would have been unable to consent and that spotting her vulnerability the two accused targeted her in a predatory fashion.

When interviewed by the Police following his arrest, Ched had stated that, as a well known footballer, if he wanted to have sex with a girl, there were plenty of opportunities for him to do so. This comment was not a boastful claim but merely an observation on the society we live in.


Of course, the Police knew exactly how these comments made under the extreme pressure of questioning at a Police station will play out in Court many months later in front of a Jury. Composed from a society that is constantly bombarded with anti-footballer media articles relating to the perceived arrogance and bad behaviour of some – they were not disappointed – the prosecution skilfully presented Ched’s words to the Jury in such a way as to make him look arrogant and conceited. And to complete the circle, the media reported Ched’s perceived arrogance to the society from which further Juries will be drawn.

The Prosecution produced CCTV of the complainant walking to and from the kebab shop. She was certainly swaying and unsteady on her feet. Further CCTV of the complainant turning her ankle and stumbling over in the kebab shop was put before the Jury. Finally, CCTV footage of the complainant entering the foyer of the Premier Inn and walking across the reception area was produced.

To counter this argument the Defence pointed out that within the CCTV footage there were numerous incidents that indicated that the complainant was capable of rational thought and decision making. Bearing in mind that the complainant’s intoxication was diminishing as time passed, it is notable that in the hour leading up to the incident in the hotel room, the CCTV footage showed the complainant was capable of:

Squatting down and rummaging through her handbag and getting back up in high heels;
Walking unaided;
Holding a conversation with other people;
Spurning the advances of another male;
Helping herself to food from other people in the kebab shop;
Ordering food;
Paying with the correct coinage;
Squatting in a doorway to urinate;
Reacting to a car flashing its lights; and
Remembering that she had left a pizza outside the Premier Inn and going back to retrieve it.

Further evidence showed that she was capable of:

Composing a coherent text message, correctly spelt and capitalized. (text sent to her friend at 02:54)
Responding to requests – she was asked by the taxi driver to get out of the back seat and get in the front because she was eating a pizza.
Requesting Clayton not to leave her – “you are not going to leave me are you”.

The agreed toxicology report evidenced the following:
blood alcohol levels of approximately 203mg of alcohol/100ml of blood or approximately 2.5 times the drink drive limit;
traces of cocaine;
traces of cannabis; and
no evidence of the complainant having been spiked.

Under cross examination the complainant claimed she was not a regular user of drugs and had taken the cocaine found in her system more than 1 week before the incident but could not remember exactly when, where or how she had procurred it. She was adamant that she did not and would not have taken cocaine in the night club on the night in question.

Expert evidence proved that the complainant was lying on oath on the stand about her cocaine consumption. The expert evidence suggested that either she was a very heavy user of cocaine or that she had taken the cocaine only 3-5 days before the incident. Either way, what she said on the stand did not correspond with the expert analysis.

Exactly why she lied about her cocaine use is not clear but the important point to note here is that there was no evidence to suggest that her intoxication levels were increased either through drugs or alcohol on the night in question.

Notwithstanding the above, in his summing up to the Jury the Judge introduced the theory that the complainant’s level of intoxication could have been increased by the consumption of more alcohol and/or drugs into her system after she had lost her memory. There was absolutely no evidence to support this theory.

At Caernarvon Crown Court the evidence was presented to the Jury over 8 days. The sitting Jury had been on Jury duty for 3 weeks. On Friday 20th April the Jury members left the Court to deliberate. After 4 hours, the Jury sent a message to the Judge saying that they could not come to a unanimous decision on both counts. The Judge chose not to exercise his discretion to give the Jury the option to return a majority verdict and sent them back out to further deliberate the case. It was clear that should the Jury not reach a unanimous decision by the end of that Friday session they would have to come back to the Court the following Monday and start what was for some a fourth week of service.

Approximately 50 minutes later the Jury returned two unanimous decisions - finding Clayton McDonald innocent and Ched Evans guilty. Clayton McDonald was acquitted. Ched Evans was sentenced to 5 years imprisonment.
After the jury reached its verdict, the Judge immediately went on to sentence Ched Evans. During the course of his sentencing comments, it was apparent that he had not accounted for the eventual verdicts being one of guilty and one of not guilty.

One could conclude that if the jury found that the complainant had consensual sex with Clayton McDonald then the sex that occurred with Ched would be consensual as well as the issue was over her ability to consent and she of course could remember no sexual activity at all.

After Ched was sentenced, Philpott the prosecuting barrister went over to Ched's parents and said 'I am so sorry'.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 Oct 15 1.25pm

The one innocent, one guilty is entirely explained by the law on consent. It was reasonable, for McDonald, on the evidence, to believe that he had consent because the woman when 'back to his' and they were both intoxicated.

However, Evans wasn't there, he arrived much later, on discovery that McDonald was with the woman, in the hotel room. By his actions, its unreasonable for him to consider her consent (provided she can be show to be intoxicated), because her actions give him no reasonable basis to believe he had consent.

This is the key of the case. Evans, to get it overturned either needs prove that it was reasonable for him to believe he had consent, either by the actions of his accuser, or by her not being intoxicated, and that sex occurred (or the tried and test classic of showing the accuser to have lied about events).

Remember the prosecution doesn't have to prove that she was paralytic falling down black out drunk, only that she was intoxicated to a degree sufficient to be unable to give 'informed consent', and that Evans took advantage of that situation sexually.

Its generally considered 'not reasonable to assume consent' if turn up at your friends hotel room, which you booked, to have sex with a woman, you've never met, and then leave.

If Evans can demonstrate his innocence, then good for him, he is legally entitled to appeal the verdict, but I'm happy to accept that until that time the decision of the jury and judge are fair.

Edited by jamiemartin721 (09 Oct 2015 1.34pm)

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 09 Oct 15 3.06pm

Quote dannyh at 09 Oct 2015 12.20pm

Quote topcat at 09 Oct 2015 10.24am

Quote dannyh at 09 Oct 2015 9.11am

Quote topcat at 08 Oct 2015 10.12am

Quote dannyh at 08 Oct 2015 9.03am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Oct 2015 9.57am

I hadn't heard about Facebook but there were lots of rumours (whether true or not) about how she behaved pre and post incident.


Quote dannyh at 08 Oct 2015 9.03am

Spunk Sponge who had an eye for a pay day.

That's an awful thing to say about a victim of rape.

What sort of pay day does a victim of rape get?

Edited by topcat (08 Oct 2015 10.13am)

It would be if I believed she was a "victim", But I don’t. Based on the reports available including elements of the court case, I believe her to be nothing more than a cheap hoe bag, who was in it from the beginning to get some cash.

She even went on facebook and admitted as much. Don't get me wrong Ched Evans, like most modern young footballers is a reprehensible pr1ck, however he is IMO guilty of nothing more than having a pissed shag (havn't we all ?) and fell foul of a legal system that allows for this sort of buffoonery.

I come across this a lot in my particular job role, A lot of Army bases are in rural area’s and those who serve normally have a bit more cash on the hip than those local lads who do not. With all the perks a young soldier is a meal ticket for a lot of young women, and we have to verbalise to young guys to box clever. It’s a sad state of affairs when I have to brief young lads on the dangers of copping off with the local girls in case they a) get accused of rape, as has happened recently where the case was thrown out as the women was lying her arse off. Or b) they say they are on contraception but aren’t and then hit the guys for CSA.

Of course what this actually does, is make it even harder for real victims of rape to prove their case, but equally this mentality were all women are innocent victims is I’m afraid to say, utter bollicks.

Whilst I can't comment on the middle part of your post, I still can't see how you can have more knowledge of the case than the jury that found him guilty of rape and her therefore a victim of rape, a crime that is notoriously difficult to get a conviction for.

There is a lot of apparent evidence out there on the internet but as you know you can find evidence of anything on the internet if you look hard enough but it doesn't make it true.

Have a munch on this.


When the trial started in Caernarfon, the main thrust of the Prosecution’s case was that the complainant was so intoxicated that she would have been unable to consent and that spotting her vulnerability the two accused targeted her in a predatory fashion.

When interviewed by the Police following his arrest, Ched had stated that, as a well known footballer, if he wanted to have sex with a girl, there were plenty of opportunities for him to do so. This comment was not a boastful claim but merely an observation on the society we live in.


Of course, the Police knew exactly how these comments made under the extreme pressure of questioning at a Police station will play out in Court many months later in front of a Jury. Composed from a society that is constantly bombarded with anti-footballer media articles relating to the perceived arrogance and bad behaviour of some – they were not disappointed – the prosecution skilfully presented Ched’s words to the Jury in such a way as to make him look arrogant and conceited. And to complete the circle, the media reported Ched’s perceived arrogance to the society from which further Juries will be drawn.

The Prosecution produced CCTV of the complainant walking to and from the kebab shop. She was certainly swaying and unsteady on her feet. Further CCTV of the complainant turning her ankle and stumbling over in the kebab shop was put before the Jury. Finally, CCTV footage of the complainant entering the foyer of the Premier Inn and walking across the reception area was produced.

To counter this argument the Defence pointed out that within the CCTV footage there were numerous incidents that indicated that the complainant was capable of rational thought and decision making. Bearing in mind that the complainant’s intoxication was diminishing as time passed, it is notable that in the hour leading up to the incident in the hotel room, the CCTV footage showed the complainant was capable of:

Squatting down and rummaging through her handbag and getting back up in high heels;
Walking unaided;
Holding a conversation with other people;
Spurning the advances of another male;
Helping herself to food from other people in the kebab shop;
Ordering food;
Paying with the correct coinage;
Squatting in a doorway to urinate;
Reacting to a car flashing its lights; and
Remembering that she had left a pizza outside the Premier Inn and going back to retrieve it.

Further evidence showed that she was capable of:

Composing a coherent text message, correctly spelt and capitalized. (text sent to her friend at 02:54)
Responding to requests – she was asked by the taxi driver to get out of the back seat and get in the front because she was eating a pizza.
Requesting Clayton not to leave her – “you are not going to leave me are you”.

The agreed toxicology report evidenced the following:
blood alcohol levels of approximately 203mg of alcohol/100ml of blood or approximately 2.5 times the drink drive limit;
traces of cocaine;
traces of cannabis; and
no evidence of the complainant having been spiked.

Under cross examination the complainant claimed she was not a regular user of drugs and had taken the cocaine found in her system more than 1 week before the incident but could not remember exactly when, where or how she had procurred it. She was adamant that she did not and would not have taken cocaine in the night club on the night in question.

Expert evidence proved that the complainant was lying on oath on the stand about her cocaine consumption. The expert evidence suggested that either she was a very heavy user of cocaine or that she had taken the cocaine only 3-5 days before the incident. Either way, what she said on the stand did not correspond with the expert analysis.

Exactly why she lied about her cocaine use is not clear but the important point to note here is that there was no evidence to suggest that her intoxication levels were increased either through drugs or alcohol on the night in question.

Notwithstanding the above, in his summing up to the Jury the Judge introduced the theory that the complainant’s level of intoxication could have been increased by the consumption of more alcohol and/or drugs into her system after she had lost her memory. There was absolutely no evidence to support this theory.

At Caernarvon Crown Court the evidence was presented to the Jury over 8 days. The sitting Jury had been on Jury duty for 3 weeks. On Friday 20th April the Jury members left the Court to deliberate. After 4 hours, the Jury sent a message to the Judge saying that they could not come to a unanimous decision on both counts. The Judge chose not to exercise his discretion to give the Jury the option to return a majority verdict and sent them back out to further deliberate the case. It was clear that should the Jury not reach a unanimous decision by the end of that Friday session they would have to come back to the Court the following Monday and start what was for some a fourth week of service.

Approximately 50 minutes later the Jury returned two unanimous decisions - finding Clayton McDonald innocent and Ched Evans guilty. Clayton McDonald was acquitted. Ched Evans was sentenced to 5 years imprisonment.
After the jury reached its verdict, the Judge immediately went on to sentence Ched Evans. During the course of his sentencing comments, it was apparent that he had not accounted for the eventual verdicts being one of guilty and one of not guilty.

One could conclude that if the jury found that the complainant had consensual sex with Clayton McDonald then the sex that occurred with Ched would be consensual as well as the issue was over her ability to consent and she of course could remember no sexual activity at all.

After Ched was sentenced, Philpott the prosecuting barrister went over to Ched's parents and said 'I am so sorry'.

Most of, if not all of, this is from the Ched Evans website. Obviously it puts a positive spin on the trial however the jury still found him guilty.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

kent675 Flag Bromley, Kent 09 Oct 15 3.19pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Oct 2015 1.25pm

The one innocent, one guilty is entirely explained by the law on consent. It was reasonable, for McDonald, on the evidence, to believe that he had consent because the woman when 'back to his' and they were both intoxicated.

However, Evans wasn't there, he arrived much later, on discovery that McDonald was with the woman, in the hotel room. By his actions, its unreasonable for him to consider her consent (provided she can be show to be intoxicated), because her actions give him no reasonable basis to believe he had consent.

This is the key of the case. Evans, to get it overturned either needs prove that it was reasonable for him to believe he had consent, either by the actions of his accuser, or by her not being intoxicated, and that sex occurred (or the tried and test classic of showing the accuser to have lied about events).

Remember the prosecution doesn't have to prove that she was paralytic falling down black out drunk, only that she was intoxicated to a degree sufficient to be unable to give 'informed consent', and that Evans took advantage of that situation sexually.

Its generally considered 'not reasonable to assume consent' if turn up at your friends hotel room, which you booked, to have sex with a woman, you've never met, and then leave.

If Evans can demonstrate his innocence, then good for him, he is legally entitled to appeal the verdict, but I'm happy to accept that until that time the decision of the jury and judge are fair.

Edited by jamiemartin721 (09 Oct 2015 1.34pm)

Thank you jamiemartin721. I'm sure I'm not the only one who finds your posts in regard to legal issues very clear and understandable (I'm not taking the piss here).

 


Four wheels drives the body - Two wheels drives the soul

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 09 Oct 15 3.29pm

Quote topcat at 09 Oct 2015 3.06pm

Quote dannyh at 09 Oct 2015 12.20pm

Quote topcat at 09 Oct 2015 10.24am

Quote dannyh at 09 Oct 2015 9.11am

Quote topcat at 08 Oct 2015 10.12am

Quote dannyh at 08 Oct 2015 9.03am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 07 Oct 2015 9.57am

I hadn't heard about Facebook but there were lots of rumours (whether true or not) about how she behaved pre and post incident.


Quote dannyh at 08 Oct 2015 9.03am

Spunk Sponge who had an eye for a pay day.

That's an awful thing to say about a victim of rape.

What sort of pay day does a victim of rape get?

Edited by topcat (08 Oct 2015 10.13am)

It would be if I believed she was a "victim", But I don’t. Based on the reports available including elements of the court case, I believe her to be nothing more than a cheap hoe bag, who was in it from the beginning to get some cash.

She even went on facebook and admitted as much. Don't get me wrong Ched Evans, like most modern young footballers is a reprehensible pr1ck, however he is IMO guilty of nothing more than having a pissed shag (havn't we all ?) and fell foul of a legal system that allows for this sort of buffoonery.

I come across this a lot in my particular job role, A lot of Army bases are in rural area’s and those who serve normally have a bit more cash on the hip than those local lads who do not. With all the perks a young soldier is a meal ticket for a lot of young women, and we have to verbalise to young guys to box clever. It’s a sad state of affairs when I have to brief young lads on the dangers of copping off with the local girls in case they a) get accused of rape, as has happened recently where the case was thrown out as the women was lying her arse off. Or b) they say they are on contraception but aren’t and then hit the guys for CSA.

Of course what this actually does, is make it even harder for real victims of rape to prove their case, but equally this mentality were all women are innocent victims is I’m afraid to say, utter bollicks.

Whilst I can't comment on the middle part of your post, I still can't see how you can have more knowledge of the case than the jury that found him guilty of rape and her therefore a victim of rape, a crime that is notoriously difficult to get a conviction for.

There is a lot of apparent evidence out there on the internet but as you know you can find evidence of anything on the internet if you look hard enough but it doesn't make it true.

Have a munch on this.


When the trial started in Caernarfon, the main thrust of the Prosecution’s case was that the complainant was so intoxicated that she would have been unable to consent and that spotting her vulnerability the two accused targeted her in a predatory fashion.

When interviewed by the Police following his arrest, Ched had stated that, as a well known footballer, if he wanted to have sex with a girl, there were plenty of opportunities for him to do so. This comment was not a boastful claim but merely an observation on the society we live in.


Of course, the Police knew exactly how these comments made under the extreme pressure of questioning at a Police station will play out in Court many months later in front of a Jury. Composed from a society that is constantly bombarded with anti-footballer media articles relating to the perceived arrogance and bad behaviour of some – they were not disappointed – the prosecution skilfully presented Ched’s words to the Jury in such a way as to make him look arrogant and conceited. And to complete the circle, the media reported Ched’s perceived arrogance to the society from which further Juries will be drawn.

The Prosecution produced CCTV of the complainant walking to and from the kebab shop. She was certainly swaying and unsteady on her feet. Further CCTV of the complainant turning her ankle and stumbling over in the kebab shop was put before the Jury. Finally, CCTV footage of the complainant entering the foyer of the Premier Inn and walking across the reception area was produced.

To counter this argument the Defence pointed out that within the CCTV footage there were numerous incidents that indicated that the complainant was capable of rational thought and decision making. Bearing in mind that the complainant’s intoxication was diminishing as time passed, it is notable that in the hour leading up to the incident in the hotel room, the CCTV footage showed the complainant was capable of:

Squatting down and rummaging through her handbag and getting back up in high heels;
Walking unaided;
Holding a conversation with other people;
Spurning the advances of another male;
Helping herself to food from other people in the kebab shop;
Ordering food;
Paying with the correct coinage;
Squatting in a doorway to urinate;
Reacting to a car flashing its lights; and
Remembering that she had left a pizza outside the Premier Inn and going back to retrieve it.

Further evidence showed that she was capable of:

Composing a coherent text message, correctly spelt and capitalized. (text sent to her friend at 02:54)
Responding to requests – she was asked by the taxi driver to get out of the back seat and get in the front because she was eating a pizza.
Requesting Clayton not to leave her – “you are not going to leave me are you”.

The agreed toxicology report evidenced the following:
blood alcohol levels of approximately 203mg of alcohol/100ml of blood or approximately 2.5 times the drink drive limit;
traces of cocaine;
traces of cannabis; and
no evidence of the complainant having been spiked.

Under cross examination the complainant claimed she was not a regular user of drugs and had taken the cocaine found in her system more than 1 week before the incident but could not remember exactly when, where or how she had procurred it. She was adamant that she did not and would not have taken cocaine in the night club on the night in question.

Expert evidence proved that the complainant was lying on oath on the stand about her cocaine consumption. The expert evidence suggested that either she was a very heavy user of cocaine or that she had taken the cocaine only 3-5 days before the incident. Either way, what she said on the stand did not correspond with the expert analysis.

Exactly why she lied about her cocaine use is not clear but the important point to note here is that there was no evidence to suggest that her intoxication levels were increased either through drugs or alcohol on the night in question.

Notwithstanding the above, in his summing up to the Jury the Judge introduced the theory that the complainant’s level of intoxication could have been increased by the consumption of more alcohol and/or drugs into her system after she had lost her memory. There was absolutely no evidence to support this theory.

At Caernarvon Crown Court the evidence was presented to the Jury over 8 days. The sitting Jury had been on Jury duty for 3 weeks. On Friday 20th April the Jury members left the Court to deliberate. After 4 hours, the Jury sent a message to the Judge saying that they could not come to a unanimous decision on both counts. The Judge chose not to exercise his discretion to give the Jury the option to return a majority verdict and sent them back out to further deliberate the case. It was clear that should the Jury not reach a unanimous decision by the end of that Friday session they would have to come back to the Court the following Monday and start what was for some a fourth week of service.

Approximately 50 minutes later the Jury returned two unanimous decisions - finding Clayton McDonald innocent and Ched Evans guilty. Clayton McDonald was acquitted. Ched Evans was sentenced to 5 years imprisonment.
After the jury reached its verdict, the Judge immediately went on to sentence Ched Evans. During the course of his sentencing comments, it was apparent that he had not accounted for the eventual verdicts being one of guilty and one of not guilty.

One could conclude that if the jury found that the complainant had consensual sex with Clayton McDonald then the sex that occurred with Ched would be consensual as well as the issue was over her ability to consent and she of course could remember no sexual activity at all.

After Ched was sentenced, Philpott the prosecuting barrister went over to Ched's parents and said 'I am so sorry'.

Most of, if not all of, this is from the Ched Evans website. Obviously it puts a positive spin on the trial however the jury still found him guilty.


Genuine question, if the court of appeal overturn his conviction will you consider him innocent or think of him as still being guilty and having got away with it? I am asking as I am not convinced he raped her but if he is found not guilty I wont be convinced he's innocent either.


 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 Oct 15 3.53pm

Personally, my opinion, McDonald got away with it on reasonable doubt, and that the two of them more or less planned it, and intended to get away with it by saying 'she consented' (and that maybe they'd done it before).

I think he did what some people might have done (more or less), and those people don't want to think that they're rapists. We've probably all 'taken advatage' at some point, but the key here is that it goes beyond taking advantage of a situation you found yourself in, and into manufacturing of the opportunity.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 10 Oct 15 12.10pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 09 Oct 2015 3.29pm

Genuine question, if the court of appeal overturn his conviction will you consider him innocent or think of him as still being guilty and having got away with it? I am asking as I am not convinced he raped her but if he is found not guilty I wont be convinced he's innocent either.

A very good question as I'm not sure of what the answer is. I hope that I'll accept his innocence.

Completely unrelated but I still can't see how Rebekah Brooks is innocent when we was found not guilty.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 10 Oct 15 7.04pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Oct 2015 3.53pm

Personally, my opinion, McDonald got away with it on reasonable doubt, and that the two of them more or less planned it, and intended to get away with it by saying 'she consented' (and that maybe they'd done it before).

I think he did what some people might have done (more or less), and those people don't want to think that they're rapists. We've probably all 'taken advatage' at some point, but the key here is that it goes beyond taking advantage of a situation you found yourself in, and into manufacturing of the opportunity.

Your opinion and nothing more.

The stuff I posted may be from the Ched evans website, but it is based on facts from the defence case. I also love the fact that all of a sudden Jury's are infalible to suit counter opinion. OJ Simpson anyone ?

He admitted shagging the bint, is that the actions of someone who know sthey f***ed up ? of course it isnt.

This women was a goldidgging coke head who got lucky, I hope the court appeal finds in his favour, and she is brought to justice.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

OldFella Flag London 10 Oct 15 8.47pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Oct 2015 1.25pm

The one innocent, one guilty is entirely explained by the law on consent. It was reasonable, for McDonald, on the evidence, to believe that he had consent because the woman when 'back to his' and they were both intoxicated.

However, Evans wasn't there, he arrived much later, on discovery that McDonald was with the woman, in the hotel room. By his actions, its unreasonable for him to consider her consent (provided she can be show to be intoxicated), because her actions give him no reasonable basis to believe he had consent.

This is the key of the case. Evans, to get it overturned either needs prove that it was reasonable for him to believe he had consent, either by the actions of his accuser, or by her not being intoxicated, and that sex occurred (or the tried and test classic of showing the accuser to have lied about events).

Remember the prosecution doesn't have to prove that she was paralytic falling down black out drunk, only that she was intoxicated to a degree sufficient to be unable to give 'informed consent', and that Evans took advantage of that situation sexually.

Its generally considered 'not reasonable to assume consent' if turn up at your friends hotel room, which you booked, to have sex with a woman, you've never met, and then leave.

If Evans can demonstrate his innocence, then good for him, he is legally entitled to appeal the verdict, but I'm happy to accept that until that time the decision of the jury and judge are fair.

Edited by jamiemartin721 (09 Oct 2015 1.34pm)

This is a very clear and well thought out post - thanks for the insight.


 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

lankygit Flag Lincoln 10 Oct 15 9.25pm

Quote dannyh at 10 Oct 2015 7.04pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Oct 2015 3.53pm

Personally, my opinion, McDonald got away with it on reasonable doubt, and that the two of them more or less planned it, and intended to get away with it by saying 'she consented' (and that maybe they'd done it before).

I think he did what some people might have done (more or less), and those people don't want to think that they're rapists. We've probably all 'taken advatage' at some point, but the key here is that it goes beyond taking advantage of a situation you found yourself in, and into manufacturing of the opportunity.

Your opinion and nothing more.

The stuff I posted may be from the Ched evans website, but it is based on facts from the defence case. I also love the fact that all of a sudden Jury's are infalible to suit counter opinion. OJ Simpson anyone ?

He admitted shagging the bint, is that the actions of someone who know sthey f***ed up ? of course it isnt.

This women was a goldidgging coke head who got lucky, I hope the court appeal finds in his favour, and she is brought to justice.


I just hope that finally, one way or the other, justice is served.

 


Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link]

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 10 Oct 15 9.54pm

Quote dannyh at 10 Oct 2015 7.04pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Oct 2015 3.53pm

Personally, my opinion, McDonald got away with it on reasonable doubt, and that the two of them more or less planned it, and intended to get away with it by saying 'she consented' (and that maybe they'd done it before).

I think he did what some people might have done (more or less), and those people don't want to think that they're rapists. We've probably all 'taken advatage' at some point, but the key here is that it goes beyond taking advantage of a situation you found yourself in, and into manufacturing of the opportunity.

Your opinion and nothing more.

The stuff I posted may be from the Ched evans website, but it is based on facts from the defence case. I also love the fact that all of a sudden Jury's are infalible to suit counter opinion. OJ Simpson anyone ?

He admitted shagging the bint, is that the actions of someone who know sthey f***ed up ? of course it isnt.

This women was a goldidgging coke head who got lucky, I hope the court appeal finds in his favour, and she is brought to justice.

It will be interesting to see what the new evidence is. I would imagine it is something substantial

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Stirlingsays Flag 10 Oct 15 11.55pm

I said at the time of the conviction that I felt that the justice system had over extended itself here.

I don't believe you can safety convict someone on the assumptions.....And that's what they are....That the state made.

Jamie thinks the evidence represents a safe conviction.....Not for me.

Having had a six month stint as a bouncer in my early life my opinions and experience upon what happens makes me recoil from such a black and white verdict.

I just don't think this qualifies as beyond reasonable doubt.....There's doubt here because the case is built upon subjectivity over a person's state.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

MochMon Flag Croydon 11 Oct 15 1.09pm

The mirror reporting in today's paper on what this allegedly new evidence is.
No suprise to me or anyone who has had dealings with North Wales police & there role in this conviction the way they conduct business is abysmal & corrupt to the core.

[Link]

 


Nid oes Bradwr yn y ty hwn

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Oct 15 10.34am

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 Oct 2015 11.55pm

I said at the time of the conviction that I felt that the justice system had over extended itself here.

I don't believe you can safety convict someone on the assumptions.....And that's what they are....That the state made.

Jamie thinks the evidence represents a safe conviction.....Not for me.

Having had a six month stint as a bouncer in my early life my opinions and experience upon what happens makes me recoil from such a black and white verdict.

I just don't think this qualifies as beyond reasonable doubt.....There's doubt here because the case is built upon subjectivity over a person's state.

There are no assumptions in the case though. The prosecution showed beyond reasonable doubt that the woman was intoxicated and unable to consent.

They then showed that the actions of McDonald were not those of an unreasonable man (hence not guilty, it was reasonable for him to believe he had consent) but that Ched Evans, actions were unreasonable for him to believe he had consent (his actions in response to McDonalds text were not those of a reasonable man).


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Oct 15 10.37am

Quote MochMon at 11 Oct 2015 1.09pm

The mirror reporting in today's paper on what this allegedly new evidence is.
No suprise to me or anyone who has had dealings with North Wales police & there role in this conviction the way they conduct business is abysmal & corrupt to the core.

[Link]

The classic defense, attack the victim's character, to undermine their credibility. The classic rape defense - character assassination.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 12 Oct 15 10.54am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 10.34am

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 Oct 2015 11.55pm

I said at the time of the conviction that I felt that the justice system had over extended itself here.

I don't believe you can safety convict someone on the assumptions.....And that's what they are....That the state made.

Jamie thinks the evidence represents a safe conviction.....Not for me.

Having had a six month stint as a bouncer in my early life my opinions and experience upon what happens makes me recoil from such a black and white verdict.

I just don't think this qualifies as beyond reasonable doubt.....There's doubt here because the case is built upon subjectivity over a person's state.

There are no assumptions in the case though. The prosecution showed beyond reasonable doubt that the woman was intoxicated and unable to consent.

They then showed that the actions of McDonald were not those of an unreasonable man (hence not guilty, it was reasonable for him to believe he had consent) but that Ched Evans, actions were unreasonable for him to believe he had consent (his actions in response to McDonalds text were not those of a reasonable man).


Yes there is. And it would appear the court of appeal agree.

From reading the articles floating around and the court transcripts how any one can still think this wasn’t a fit up is beyond me.

I Mean FFS she didn’t even report it as rape until she found out who it was she’d had sex with, as apparently she couldn't remember anything, because she was spiked, funny how the toxicology report showed no such thing, only that she was a massive coke head, and a liar.

Now I'm no druggie, but I do know that one or two whiffs of the old devils dandruff puts you straight even if your pissed. Seeing as she was only 2.5 times the limit, which is f*** all, and she'd had a nose full there is no doubt in my mind at all that this women was coherent, and in complete control of her actions. Maybe she was coached by another on what a gold mine she was sitting on who knows, but the truth will out as they say and I have no doubt she will be shown to be the opportunistic snake with tits that she really is.

Victim my arse.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Oct 15 5.15pm

Quote dannyh at 12 Oct 2015 10.54am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Oct 2015 10.34am

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 Oct 2015 11.55pm

I said at the time of the conviction that I felt that the justice system had over extended itself here.

I don't believe you can safety convict someone on the assumptions.....And that's what they are....That the state made.

Jamie thinks the evidence represents a safe conviction.....Not for me.

Having had a six month stint as a bouncer in my early life my opinions and experience upon what happens makes me recoil from such a black and white verdict.

I just don't think this qualifies as beyond reasonable doubt.....There's doubt here because the case is built upon subjectivity over a person's state.

There are no assumptions in the case though. The prosecution showed beyond reasonable doubt that the woman was intoxicated and unable to consent.

They then showed that the actions of McDonald were not those of an unreasonable man (hence not guilty, it was reasonable for him to believe he had consent) but that Ched Evans, actions were unreasonable for him to believe he had consent (his actions in response to McDonalds text were not those of a reasonable man).


Yes there is. And it would appear the court of appeal agree.

From reading the articles floating around and the court transcripts how any one can still think this wasn’t a fit up is beyond me.

I Mean FFS she didn’t even report it as rape until she found out who it was she’d had sex with, as apparently she couldn't remember anything, because she was spiked, funny how the toxicology report showed no such thing, only that she was a massive coke head, and a liar.

Now I'm no druggie, but I do know that one or two whiffs of the old devils dandruff puts you straight even if your pissed. Seeing as she was only 2.5 times the limit, which is f*** all, and she'd had a nose full there is no doubt in my mind at all that this women was coherent, and in complete control of her actions. Maybe she was coached by another on what a gold mine she was sitting on who knows, but the truth will out as they say and I have no doubt she will be shown to be the opportunistic snake with tits that she really is.

Victim my arse.

Depends who you want to rely on, a jury of peers, or personal assumptions. The toxicology report showed she was 2.5 times over the legal limit, the following day. You have to then compensate for the pace at which alcohol is metabolized (although cocaine will affect that).

Also, lets not get carried away in terms of 'opportunity' its Ched Evans, who played for Wales and a league 1 side. And of course its irrelevant to whether she was raped anyhow. Hardly a gold mine, plus of course there is the fact that when she was going back to the hotel, McDonald by his own statement never told her about Evans, nor let Evans into the room.

So its irrelevant as to whether she could give consent, you'd have to prove she was not intoxicated significantly (which the prosecution presented independent witnesses and video of, as well as Evans own statement to a member of staff on departure).

If someone decides to prosecute because they find out who the assailant was, that is generally considered how most rape cases a pursued.

Also its a massive deception that cocaine 'sets you straight', its an illusion created by the rush of the stimulant. It feels like your no longer drunk, but your now under the influence of cocaine and alcohol (and I was a right old druggie). Also how much cocaine showed up in her toxicology is really important, as would be when.

Of course even if she was intoxicated with cocaine and alcohol, it makes no difference to the case. She would still be unable to consent, and by his actions it would be unreasonable for Ched Evans to believe he had consent. Its also debatable whether she would have passed out if she'd been chaining lines of cocaine.

The problem is obfuscation around who the person might be, doesn't change the events of the night. Nor does her decision when discovering that the individual was Ched Evans.

And that's Evans real problem. Unless he can either demonstrate that she wasn't intoxicated, that he lied about having sex with her (under oath), then it doesn't really change the case.

She could be the biggest liar liar pants on fire. The fact of the matter is that as long as the prosecution shows sufficient intoxication and that its unreasonable for Evans to believe he had consent, its rape. Attacking the character of the accuser is just a tactic that is very useful in rape cases, the last defense usually of the guilty.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 11 of 19 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Ched Evans saga part ???