This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Leader's debates
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Stuk Top half 17 Apr 15 6.33pm |
|
Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 5.34pm
Just heard Bennett on the radio. She reckons Britain has a "historic moral duty" to reduce carbon emissions because of the industrial revolution and "most of the carbon already up there came from us."

These people are dangerous.
"Us"?
She's Australian...
Optimistic as ever
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 17 Apr 15 6.37pm |
|
Quote Stuk at 17 Apr 2015 6.33pm
Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 5.34pm
Just heard Bennett on the radio. She reckons Britain has a "historic moral duty" to reduce carbon emissions because of the industrial revolution and "most of the carbon already up there came from us."

These people are dangerous.
"Us"?
She's Australian... And a British citizen
|
Stuk Top half 17 Apr 15 6.45pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 17 Apr 2015 6.37pm
Quote Stuk at 17 Apr 2015 6.33pm
Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 5.34pm
Just heard Bennett on the radio. She reckons Britain has a "historic moral duty" to reduce carbon emissions because of the industrial revolution and "most of the carbon already up there came from us."

These people are dangerous.
"Us"?
She's Australian... And a British citizen
And bonkers.
Optimistic as ever
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 17 Apr 15 7.13pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 17 Apr 2015 5.54pm
Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 2.24pm
Quote OknotOK at 17 Apr 2015 2.05pm
Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 12.04pm
Quote OknotOK at 17 Apr 2015 11.15am
Quote Pussay Patrol at 17 Apr 2015 9.49am
What an embarrasment last night's charade was.
The BBC made it as left wing as was humanly possible.
Labour, SNP, Plaid Cymru and Greens all trotting out the 'get the Tories out' line and asked questions from a specially selected audience, probably Guardian readers.
We should all be embarrased, this is a general election debate where impartiality should be key and this is a public service broadcaster.
To be fair UKIP have confirmed they are not making any complaint about the makeup of the audience - aside from Farage's comments - and the BBC pointed out they did not select the audience.
But even if they had, given the majority of the panel were left-wing it probably made more sense to have a left-wing audience. That is the voters those parties are trying to appeal to?
Given the nature of the panel Miliband did really well. He was always going to be attacked as both the establishment candidate and as being too right wing or too left wing from the fringe parties. He handled himself well. The Labour party will be very happy today.
Edited by OknotOK (17 Apr 2015 11.22am)
You what?
It's a public broadcaster with a statutory duty to be impartial, so the questions should be, er, impartial.
BBC studio audiences are almost always left wing anyway. Every week the audience on 'Any Questions' is like a horde of Gussets. Anything vaguely leftist populist always gets a massive cheer.
I accept the BBC should be impartial. That doesn't mean the audience has to be.
But my point was more that if practically the point of the debates is to help determine people how they should vote,very few people would have been watching those debates who were "right wing" (or if they were then their decision wouldn't have really been altered by the debates among primarily left wing leaders). So maybe the questions should be more left-wing as it will help shape the opinion of those voting more?
The BBC didn't select the audience (although presumably they may have had an influence on it) so there is no reason to suggest they weren't impartial.
Fair point. The audience should (if it *should* be anything at all) a reasonable reflection of society. The BBC is doing its job if it just randomly selects from the applicants. What they tend to do is pick a mixture. Often it's the mad lefties who are just louder than the rest (empty vessels make the most noise).
Same applies to the questions they select. I'm often a bit suspicious about the questions they choose (I'm basing all my comments on 'Any Questions' because sometimes they seem deliberately chosen to appeal to lefties. But they're just the ones I notice. The ones which appeal to right-wingers I probably just think are sensible!
The audience isn't selected for any questions, you apply on a first come first served basis.
Talking of which...
Attachment: IMG_20150417_190711.jpg (404.46Kb)
|
| Hoof Hearted 18 Apr 15 10.38am |
|
Quote Stuk at 17 Apr 2015 6.45pm
Quote nickgusset at 17 Apr 2015 6.37pm
Quote Stuk at 17 Apr 2015 6.33pm
Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 5.34pm
Just heard Bennett on the radio. She reckons Britain has a "historic moral duty" to reduce carbon emissions because of the industrial revolution and "most of the carbon already up there came from us."

These people are dangerous.
"Us"?
She's Australian... And a British citizen
And bonkers.
And has a funny mouth, all wet and slobbery from eating too much pussy.
|
legaleagle 18 Apr 15 11.04am |
|
Quote Hoof Hearted at 18 Apr 2015 10.38am
Quote Stuk at 17 Apr 2015 6.45pm
Quote nickgusset at 17 Apr 2015 6.37pm
Quote Stuk at 17 Apr 2015 6.33pm
Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 5.34pm
Just heard Bennett on the radio. She reckons Britain has a "historic moral duty" to reduce carbon emissions because of the industrial revolution and "most of the carbon already up there came from us."

These people are dangerous.
"Us"?
She's Australian... And a British citizen
And bonkers.
And has a funny mouth, all wet and slobbery from eating too much pussy.
its an outrage;anyone sensible knows that an immigrant to our fair shores speaking english with an accent cannot possibly ever be regarded as equal to one of "us" regardless of being a citizen and should be banned from being a parliamentary candidate
sooner UKIP get in power and ban this sort of outrage the better
|
| Hoof Hearted 18 Apr 15 11.09am |
|
Quote legaleagle at 18 Apr 2015 11.04am
Quote Hoof Hearted at 18 Apr 2015 10.38am
Quote Stuk at 17 Apr 2015 6.45pm
Quote nickgusset at 17 Apr 2015 6.37pm
Quote Stuk at 17 Apr 2015 6.33pm
Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 5.34pm
Just heard Bennett on the radio. She reckons Britain has a "historic moral duty" to reduce carbon emissions because of the industrial revolution and "most of the carbon already up there came from us."

These people are dangerous.
"Us"?
She's Australian... And a British citizen
And bonkers.
And has a funny mouth, all wet and slobbery from eating too much pussy.
its an outrage;anyone sensible knows that an immigrant to our fair shores speaking english with an accent cannot possibly ever be regarded as equal to one of "us" regardless of being a citizen and should be banned from being a parliamentary candidate
sooner UKIP get in power and ban this sort of outrage the better
That bonkers eco lezza needs to shut up and enjoy life here rather than trying to impose her chosen lifestyle on the indigenous population legal.
|
legaleagle 18 Apr 15 12.22pm |
|
|
So,she's a "lezza" is she Hoof? Based on what,your detailed knowledge of all matters sexual?
Double whammy for you,immigrant and sexuality...No wonder you can't stand her
Bloody immigrants,coming over here and then even having the nerve to "impose her chosen life style" on us!
Only thing is,it might be news to her long-term life partner,who happens to be a bloke by the name of Jim...
But,don't let any of that affect your knee jerk blind prejudice...
Remind me,what party was it you intend voting for Hoof because they chime with your views?
|
imbored UK 18 Apr 15 12.40pm |
|
|
It's all going on here!
Edited by imbored (18 Apr 2015 3.09pm)
|
pefwin Where you have to have an English ... 18 Apr 15 2.10pm |
|
Quote legaleagle at 18 Apr 2015 12.22pm
So,she's a "lezza" is she Hoof? Based on what,your detailed knowledge of all matters sexual?
Double whammy for you,immigrant and sexuality...No wonder you can't stand her
Bloody immigrants,coming over here and then even having the nerve to "impose her chosen life style" on us!
Only thing is,it might be news to her long-term life partner,who happens to be a bloke by the name of Jim...
But,don't let any of that affect your knee jerk blind prejudice...
Remind me,what party was it you intend voting for Hoof because they chime with your views?
I think he was more hoping to watch.
"Everything is air-droppable at least once."
"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."
|
| Hoof Hearted 19 Apr 15 10.20am |
|
Quote pefwin at 18 Apr 2015 2.10pm
Quote legaleagle at 18 Apr 2015 12.22pm
So,she's a "lezza" is she Hoof? Based on what,your detailed knowledge of all matters sexual?
Double whammy for you,immigrant and sexuality...No wonder you can't stand her
Bloody immigrants,coming over here and then even having the nerve to "impose her chosen life style" on us!
Only thing is,it might be news to her long-term life partner,who happens to be a bloke by the name of Jim...
But,don't let any of that affect your knee jerk blind prejudice...
Remind me,what party was it you intend voting for Hoof because they chime with your views?
I think he was more hoping to watch.
Spot on Peffers!
There's nothing like a bit of girl on girl action and while she's eating muff she aint telling us how to live our lives!
|
imbored UK 19 Apr 15 11.07pm |
|
|
I know some take their politics very seriously, but this is going too far 
Attachment: CC5G7VhWMAA3Thi.jpg (31.92Kb)
|
Seth On a pale blue dot 20 Apr 15 1.23am |
|
Quote Hoof Hearted at 18 Apr 2015 10.38am
Quote Stuk at 17 Apr 2015 6.45pm
Quote nickgusset at 17 Apr 2015 6.37pm
Quote Stuk at 17 Apr 2015 6.33pm
Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 5.34pm
Just heard Bennett on the radio. She reckons Britain has a "historic moral duty" to reduce carbon emissions because of the industrial revolution and "most of the carbon already up there came from us."

These people are dangerous.
"Us"?
She's Australian... And a British citizen
And bonkers.
And has a funny mouth, all wet and slobbery from eating too much pussy.
You're better than that Hoof. Disappointed.
"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down" FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16
|
| Hoof Hearted 20 Apr 15 10.34am |
|
Quote Seth at 20 Apr 2015 1.23am
Quote Hoof Hearted at 18 Apr 2015 10.38am
Quote Stuk at 17 Apr 2015 6.45pm
Quote nickgusset at 17 Apr 2015 6.37pm
Quote Stuk at 17 Apr 2015 6.33pm
Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 5.34pm
Just heard Bennett on the radio. She reckons Britain has a "historic moral duty" to reduce carbon emissions because of the industrial revolution and "most of the carbon already up there came from us."

These people are dangerous.
"Us"?
She's Australian... And a British citizen
And bonkers.
And has a funny mouth, all wet and slobbery from eating too much pussy.
You're better than that Hoof. Disappointed.
Sorry Seth I know you like the Greens...... was only joking, but to be fair my hero Farage has been taking dogs abuse on here and I've not complained.
Not worth falling out with a good mate like you though, especially today with the news we've all had to suffer.
|
Seth On a pale blue dot 20 Apr 15 12.59pm |
|
Quote Hoof Hearted at 20 Apr 2015 10.34am
Quote Seth at 20 Apr 2015 1.23am
Quote Hoof Hearted at 18 Apr 2015 10.38am
Quote Stuk at 17 Apr 2015 6.45pm
Quote nickgusset at 17 Apr 2015 6.37pm
Quote Stuk at 17 Apr 2015 6.33pm
Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 5.34pm
Just heard Bennett on the radio. She reckons Britain has a "historic moral duty" to reduce carbon emissions because of the industrial revolution and "most of the carbon already up there came from us."

These people are dangerous.
"Us"?
She's Australian... And a British citizen
And bonkers.
And has a funny mouth, all wet and slobbery from eating too much pussy.
You're better than that Hoof. Disappointed.
Sorry Seth I know you like the Greens...... was only joking, but to be fair my hero Farage has been taking dogs abuse on here and I've not complained.
Not worth falling out with a good mate like you though, especially today with the news we've all had to suffer.
Apology accepted old mate.
Yes we have bigger things to think about today. A really sad loss to the whole HOL family. RIP staffie 
"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down" FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16
|
OknotOK Cockfosters, London 20 Apr 15 1.40pm |
|
Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 2.24pm
Fair point. The audience should (if it *should* be anything at all) a reasonable reflection of society. The BBC is doing its job if it just randomly selects from the applicants. What they tend to do is pick a mixture. Often it's the mad lefties who are just louder than the rest (empty vessels make the most noise).
Same applies to the questions they select. I'm often a bit suspicious about the questions they choose (I'm basing all my comments on 'Any Questions' because sometimes they seem deliberately chosen to appeal to lefties. But they're just the ones I notice. The ones which appeal to right-wingers I probably just think are sensible!
I agree that audiences for these sort of things should in principle be balanced or selected randomly. But in this instance I actually think any real anger over the audience selection is a bit unnecessary as this debate will primarily have helped shape the view points of left-wing voters, so the questions and audience being primarily left wing (which does appear to have been the case), seems much less important.
I actually don't know what the selection criteria was on the questions though - there could have been a bias.
Then "lefties" could argue it was just levelling up the fairly obvious bias shown in the Sky debates - especially by the rather fawning Kay Burley.
Will be interesting to see if the final "debate" on QT is framed with a similar audience and slant of questioning.
"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show
|
The Sash Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 20 Apr 15 3.11pm |
|
Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 5.34pm
Just heard Bennett on the radio. She reckons Britain has a "historic moral duty" to reduce carbon emissions because of the industrial revolution and "most of the carbon already up there came from us."

These people are dangerous.
Sadly for the Greens they seem to have chosen a real anchor in terms of leader. Every word out of her mouth is a candidate for Pseuds Corner and she cannot answer specifics to save her life. Shame, they could have made some small inroads but hey ho.
As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014
|
imbored UK 20 Apr 15 3.20pm |
|
|
Miliband now officially slight odds on with the bookies to be prime minister. Interesting election ahead.
|
| Hoof Hearted 20 Apr 15 3.51pm |
|
Quote OknotOK at 20 Apr 2015 1.40pm
Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 2.24pm
Fair point. The audience should (if it *should* be anything at all) a reasonable reflection of society. The BBC is doing its job if it just randomly selects from the applicants. What they tend to do is pick a mixture. Often it's the mad lefties who are just louder than the rest (empty vessels make the most noise).
Same applies to the questions they select. I'm often a bit suspicious about the questions they choose (I'm basing all my comments on 'Any Questions' because sometimes they seem deliberately chosen to appeal to lefties. But they're just the ones I notice. The ones which appeal to right-wingers I probably just think are sensible!
I agree that audiences for these sort of things should in principle be balanced or selected randomly. But in this instance I actually think any real anger over the audience selection is a bit unnecessary as this debate will primarily have helped shape the view points of left-wing voters, so the questions and audience being primarily left wing (which does appear to have been the case), seems much less important.
I actually don't know what the selection criteria was on the questions though - there could have been a bias.
Then "lefties" could argue it was just levelling up the fairly obvious bias shown in the Sky debates - especially by the rather fawning Kay Burley.
Will be interesting to see if the final "debate" on QT is framed with a similar audience and slant of questioning.
On the night Dimbleby insisted that the audience selection was fair and had been carefully selected by an independent polling company.
Since then the BBC have admitted that people with leftwing views/opinions made up 67% of the audience... so Farage was right to highlight it... it was pretty obviously a leftwing bias though.
|
imbored UK 20 Apr 15 4.24pm |
|
Quote Hoof Hearted at 20 Apr 2015 3.51pm
Quote OknotOK at 20 Apr 2015 1.40pm
Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 2.24pm
Fair point. The audience should (if it *should* be anything at all) a reasonable reflection of society. The BBC is doing its job if it just randomly selects from the applicants. What they tend to do is pick a mixture. Often it's the mad lefties who are just louder than the rest (empty vessels make the most noise).
Same applies to the questions they select. I'm often a bit suspicious about the questions they choose (I'm basing all my comments on 'Any Questions' because sometimes they seem deliberately chosen to appeal to lefties. But they're just the ones I notice. The ones which appeal to right-wingers I probably just think are sensible!
I agree that audiences for these sort of things should in principle be balanced or selected randomly. But in this instance I actually think any real anger over the audience selection is a bit unnecessary as this debate will primarily have helped shape the view points of left-wing voters, so the questions and audience being primarily left wing (which does appear to have been the case), seems much less important.
I actually don't know what the selection criteria was on the questions though - there could have been a bias.
Then "lefties" could argue it was just levelling up the fairly obvious bias shown in the Sky debates - especially by the rather fawning Kay Burley.
Will be interesting to see if the final "debate" on QT is framed with a similar audience and slant of questioning.
On the night Dimbleby insisted that the audience selection was fair and had been carefully selected by an independent polling company.
Since then the BBC have admitted that people with leftwing views/opinions made up 67% of the audience... so Farage was right to highlight it... it was pretty obviously a leftwing bias though.
They likely had a certain percentage of supporters of each party. Most of the parties there were left wing. There are several ways of working it so the fairness point is subjective. Farage attacking the audience was probably preplanned. It was a clever move and he's a clever politician.
Edited by imbored (20 Apr 2015 4.25pm)
|