You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Richard Dawkins Hero
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Richard Dawkins Hero


Page 11 of 14 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
derben Flag 17 Jun 15 9.23pm

Quote TheJudge at 17 Jun 2015 7.33pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 17 Jun 2015 7.17pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 10.48pm

About sums up the level of scientific knowledge being shown here. In science, the term 'theory' is only used for well-established principles. What you are thinking of is a hypothesis.


Any debate about creationism over evolution / big bang, should start with this tiny, but oh-so important, clarification.

There is no debate. Creationism is a non starter.

If the Universe was "designed" the designer would be so far removed from the Biblical that the two would not withstand any sort of comparison.
As an example, take the latest rehashed idea that the universe as we see it is just a copy or recreation made by beings (maybe humans) that have advanced to the required level of technology. They would be creators from our perspective. The logical question would then be; Who created the creators ? The same question could be asked of God, if he were real.

But if God is omnipotent, God has unlimited powers. This would include the power to create itself or even retrospectively make itself exist from eternity!

 

TheJudge Flag 17 Jun 15 9.53pm

Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 9.23pm

Quote TheJudge at 17 Jun 2015 7.33pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 17 Jun 2015 7.17pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 10.48pm

About sums up the level of scientific knowledge being shown here. In science, the term 'theory' is only used for well-established principles. What you are thinking of is a hypothesis.


Any debate about creationism over evolution / big bang, should start with this tiny, but oh-so important, clarification.

There is no debate. Creationism is a non starter.

If the Universe was "designed" the designer would be so far removed from the Biblical that the two would not withstand any sort of comparison.
As an example, take the latest rehashed idea that the universe as we see it is just a copy or recreation made by beings (maybe humans) that have advanced to the required level of technology. They would be creators from our perspective. The logical question would then be; Who created the creators ? The same question could be asked of God, if he were real.

But if God is omnipotent, God has unlimited powers. This would include the power to create itself or even retrospectively make itself exist from eternity!

OK. Accepting for the sake of argument that there were such an entity, it would not be the God of the Bible and consequently would have no real relation to religion. You could of course argue that point i an intellectual way but religion has little to do with intellectualism. The idea that some scientists claim to believe in God is a bit of a myth. Any who really do need to be pushed as to exactly how that plays out.


Edited by TheJudge (17 Jun 2015 9.54pm)

 

derben Flag 17 Jun 15 10.01pm

Quote TheJudge at 17 Jun 2015 9.53pm

Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 9.23pm

Quote TheJudge at 17 Jun 2015 7.33pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 17 Jun 2015 7.17pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 10.48pm

About sums up the level of scientific knowledge being shown here. In science, the term 'theory' is only used for well-established principles. What you are thinking of is a hypothesis.


Any debate about creationism over evolution / big bang, should start with this tiny, but oh-so important, clarification.

There is no debate. Creationism is a non starter.

If the Universe was "designed" the designer would be so far removed from the Biblical that the two would not withstand any sort of comparison.
As an example, take the latest rehashed idea that the universe as we see it is just a copy or recreation made by beings (maybe humans) that have advanced to the required level of technology. They would be creators from our perspective. The logical question would then be; Who created the creators ? The same question could be asked of God, if he were real.

But if God is omnipotent, God has unlimited powers. This would include the power to create itself or even retrospectively make itself exist from eternity!

OK. Accepting for the sake of argument that there were such an entity, it would not be the God of the Bible and consequently would have no real relation to religion. You could of course argue that point i an intellectual way but religion has little to do with intellectualism. The idea that some scientists claim to believe in God is a bit of a myth. Any who really do need to be pushed as to exactly how that plays out.


Edited by TheJudge (17 Jun 2015 9.54pm)

Not necessarily, an omnipotent God can do absolutely anything, including setting various religious hares running.

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 17 Jun 15 10.01pm

Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 9.23pm

But if God is omnipotent, God has unlimited powers. This would include the power to create itself or even retrospectively make itself exist from eternity!


This is where the difference between "hypothesis" and "theory" becomes really important. In fact, your claims don't even rise to the level of hypothesis - something based on limited evidence; they're merely speculation - conjecture lacking evidence.

Claiming that "my God can beat up your science" does not make it so.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

derben Flag 17 Jun 15 10.07pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 17 Jun 2015 10.01pm

Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 9.23pm

But if God is omnipotent, God has unlimited powers. This would include the power to create itself or even retrospectively make itself exist from eternity!


This is where the difference between "hypothesis" and "theory" becomes really important. In fact, your claims don't even rise to the level of hypothesis - something based on limited evidence; they're merely speculation - conjecture lacking evidence.

Claiming that "my God can beat up your science" does not make it so.

Not saying it is my God. Just saying that if there is an omnipotent God, then God's omnipotence defeats all arguments.

 

TUX Flag redhill 17 Jun 15 10.35pm

Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 10.07pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 17 Jun 2015 10.01pm

Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 9.23pm

But if God is omnipotent, God has unlimited powers. This would include the power to create itself or even retrospectively make itself exist from eternity!


This is where the difference between "hypothesis" and "theory" becomes really important. In fact, your claims don't even rise to the level of hypothesis - something based on limited evidence; they're merely speculation - conjecture lacking evidence.

Claiming that "my God can beat up your science" does not make it so.

Not saying it is my God. Just saying that if there is an omnipotent God, then God's omnipotence defeats all arguments.[/quote]

What created God?


 

derben Flag 18 Jun 15 7.28am

Quote TUX at 17 Jun 2015 10.35pm

Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 10.07pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 17 Jun 2015 10.01pm

Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 9.23pm

But if God is omnipotent, God has unlimited powers. This would include the power to create itself or even retrospectively make itself exist from eternity!


This is where the difference between "hypothesis" and "theory" becomes really important. In fact, your claims don't even rise to the level of hypothesis - something based on limited evidence; they're merely speculation - conjecture lacking evidence.

Claiming that "my God can beat up your science" does not make it so.

Not saying it is my God. Just saying that if there is an omnipotent God, then God's omnipotence defeats all arguments.[/quote]

What created God?


As the omnipotent God has unlimited powers, ie: God can do anything, then it could have created itself.


Edited by derben (18 Jun 2015 7.31am)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Jun 15 8.06am

Quote derben at 18 Jun 2015 7.28am

Quote TUX at 17 Jun 2015 10.35pm

Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 10.07pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 17 Jun 2015 10.01pm

Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 9.23pm

But if God is omnipotent, God has unlimited powers. This would include the power to create itself or even retrospectively make itself exist from eternity!


This is where the difference between "hypothesis" and "theory" becomes really important. In fact, your claims don't even rise to the level of hypothesis - something based on limited evidence; they're merely speculation - conjecture lacking evidence.

Claiming that "my God can beat up your science" does not make it so.

Not saying it is my God. Just saying that if there is an omnipotent God, then God's omnipotence defeats all arguments.[/quote]

What created God?


As the omnipotent God has unlimited powers, ie: God can do anything, then it could have created itself.


Edited by derben (18 Jun 2015 7.31am)

You see why that's not scientifically acceptable though.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Jun 15 8.08am

Quote Ray in Houston at 17 Jun 2015 7.17pm

Quote ChuFukka at 12 Jun 2015 10.48pm

About sums up the level of scientific knowledge being shown here. In science, the term 'theory' is only used for well-established principles. What you are thinking of is a hypothesis.


Any debate about creationism over evolution / big bang, should start with this tiny, but oh-so important, clarification.

Technically its not really a hypothesis, as a hypothesis should really be constructed around disproving a stated null hypothesis, and establish the basis of the hypothesis, and reference supporting research on which the argument has been built. You can't just have a hypothesis without a proposal as to why your testing it.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Jun 15 8.14am

Quote TheJudge at 17 Jun 2015 7.22pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 17 Jun 2015 12.32pm

Quote TheJudge at 17 Jun 2015 11.19am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 17 Jun 2015 9.27am

Quote TheJudge at 17 Jun 2015 8.49am

Quote reborn at 17 Jun 2015 8.36am

LOL sadly for you I live it, I spend all my days when I am not working trying to help other people and significant amounts of my money. You see its not a club, its a way of life.

I think the thing that irritates you the most is I don't fit into your close minded and prejudiced view of what a Christian is.

I will pray for you, not least for a sense of humour. Lighten up man, you seem so angry at everything.


I fail to see how god has anything to do with being charitable. Anyone can be charitable.
I have always thought that people who are always helping strangers are really doing it for themselves anyway.
Is there really such thing as a selfless act ? Not according to Dawkins. I 100% agree with him.

Edited by TheJudge (17 Jun 2015 8.51am)

Dawkins would be incorrect, except on a genetic level (however we cannot presume that genetics defines all behavior and genes are sentient), as such degrees of altruism exist and what is more the case is that people who don't believe resort to rhetoric and abstraction of the individual, in order to demonstrate this.

Its a move the goal posts argument, similar to that used in religion, by saying god creates evolution or the big bang, its hiding in the semantic limitations of proof (ie that you can neither truly prove or disprove something).

Granted no act is truly selfless, as existence is experienced existentially, so it must tie back to the individual making the action, but that doesn't distract from the fact that its more selfless than selfish (and we shouldn't mistake selfish for egocentric either, a selfish act is not immoral, unless it is committed egocentrically).


Wow. Where to begin.

Firstly, genes determine behavior for their own survival using the animal as a vehicle. Not very romantic I concede. Human behavior is complex but we must not let that cloud the reality of existence.

As for proof of anything. You must realise that just because you cannot disprove something does not make it more or less likely. This is the kind of absurd argument that followers of religion use. The fact that you cannot disprove god is irrelevant. As Dawkins would say: You cannot disprove the flying spaghetti monster either.

Only if you discount evidence from psychological sciences, that demonstrate quite adequately that genes at best have a influence on behavior and in no what categories it. The paradigm limitations of Biology, which has limited capacity to study behavior, relates to species not individual behavior. Its convenient when dealing with species and generations, but ultimately its reductionist and unsupported from outside of biology.

There is a relationship between genetics and behaviors, but in no way is it definitive, and evidence suggests that experience plays a far more important role in determining how we react than genetics. Even neurology suggests that the role of genes in behavior is limited to structural influence, rather than determinism.

Whilst humans do not possess free will, its equally absurd to suggest that they lack agency.



This is rather applying a macro explanation to a micro system. I don't really accept that biology has the limitations of which you speak. Our very consciousness is biological/physiological and all behaviors must ultimately be biological in nature. The gene is the only thing that must survive for life to continue in it's current form. (There may only be one)
You might prefer a more fluffy interpretation, but its only man's own arrogance that allows him the luxury of delusion regarding his consciousness and his significance beyond being some animate matter.

Mechanisms don't explain the whole of the process, but the basis on why the system operates, and its limitations. Also because something is biological doesn't follow that its genetically directed, genes create the system, and its flaws, but behaviour certainly has a fail safe of agency and consciousness, that can and does manipulate behaviour - The fact we are capable of learning, demonstrates a degree of agency is required and that in that process of learning (and reflection on what we experienced) we adapt the biological machine. The mind is a product of the brain, but its also capable of changing that brain by its decisions.

I'm a middle ground guy, that the reality lies between the two arguments. Agency-Structure, as the individual-self dualism breaks down when we look at groups as individuals, rather than as a species.

Genetics correlates with behaviour, its not causal.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Jun 15 9.31am

Quote TheJudge at 17 Jun 2015 7.22pmThis is rather applying a macro explanation to a micro system. I don't really accept that biology has the limitations of which you speak. Our very consciousness is biological/physiological and all behaviors must ultimately be biological in nature. The gene is the only thing that must survive for life to continue in it's current form. (There may only be one)
You might prefer a more fluffy interpretation, but its only man's own arrogance that allows him the luxury of delusion regarding his consciousness and his significance beyond being some animate matter.

I think its more or less true, that a macro model will differ from a micro model because of the different assumptions, variables discounted and how observation and study is undertaken. However one must also account for reductionism.

A degree of sentience and agency, also makes sense as a evolutionary benefit (it massively aids adaptability). I don't think we have free will, that's nonsense, but I also think that the paradims of biological science cannot function when determining individuals (simply because of the scale) and so it abstracts.

Biology often refers to things we can demonstrate that are learned from our peers as hereditary, without them being genetic.

I don't think this is unique to humans either, just its most pronounced, because we're humans - and that we reduce this phenomena in other mammals because its convenient to our ego. Its also not active on an autonomic scale, we react in the moment, but reflect and plan our actions out and prepair in advance by running scenarios, that allow us to adapt our reactive self.

Essentially, we can, on some level, reprogram our own behavior, according to our experiences and desired outcomes. When faced in the moment we react.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

derben Flag 18 Jun 15 11.06am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Jun 2015 8.06am

Quote derben at 18 Jun 2015 7.28am

Quote TUX at 17 Jun 2015 10.35pm

Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 10.07pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 17 Jun 2015 10.01pm

Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 9.23pm

But if God is omnipotent, God has unlimited powers. This would include the power to create itself or even retrospectively make itself exist from eternity!


This is where the difference between "hypothesis" and "theory" becomes really important. In fact, your claims don't even rise to the level of hypothesis - something based on limited evidence; they're merely speculation - conjecture lacking evidence.

Claiming that "my God can beat up your science" does not make it so.

Not saying it is my God. Just saying that if there is an omnipotent God, then God's omnipotence defeats all arguments.[/quote]

What created God?


As the omnipotent God has unlimited powers, ie: God can do anything, then it could have created itself.


Edited by derben (18 Jun 2015 7.31am)

You see why that's not scientifically acceptable though.


I guess an omnipotent God could make it scientifically acceptable if that God chose to.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 18 Jun 15 1.00pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 17 Jun 2015 3.22pm

Quote Lyons550 at 17 Jun 2015 2.41pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 17 Jun 2015 10.44am

Quote SirPeanut at 17 Jun 2015 10.30am

One of the strong arguments (there are many!) against religion and belief in God come from locality.

Every religion currently being practiced on this planet, as well as every past religion which no longer has followers, has a definite, discernible origin in time and space. Even if the exact beginnings of a religion are murky, that religion still originated in a definite area and in a definite time period.

Surely any god or gods which existed and which desired to reveal themselves to humanity would not do this - they would not provide a revelation to only one culture, at one time, in one place.

The fact that all religions originated in one specific culture, at one specific time and place, tells us that they are the product of that culture, time and place - and not the product of divine revelation.

What is the fate of those who never heard about the supposed one and true God? Did they all go to Hell when they died, simply because God chose not to tell them the way to salvation? Or did they somehow get to Heaven without the redemptive powers of Jesus or even the Jewish law? And if so, if this is possible, then what was the point of sending Jesus or giving the law at all?

Or that they all tie into a greater cosmic reality, that people of ages, including this one, are attempting to relay. One should always accept the very strong likelihood that people thousands of years ago might have been very much 'filling in the gaps' and relying on their knowledge of the times and existent knowledge's / experiences.

The Catholic church struggled a long time with many of these arguments, and came to a number of interesting to absurd conclusions, based on their faith, some of which were quite surprising (they saw the pagan faiths as evidence of the age of the Nephilim in genesis, for example) and the idea or purgatory and the harrowing of hell etc.

We're always limited by what our 'situated knowledge's', and we will likely as not look as limited in our capacity to people in several hundred years.



Such as visiting Aliens

Pending sufficient evidence, yes. At present its a no, on the basis that there is no credible evidence of extra terrestrial life, let alone visitations to earth


Same with God I suppose

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

TheJudge Flag 18 Jun 15 1.25pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Jun 2015 9.31am

Quote TheJudge at 17 Jun 2015 7.22pmThis is rather applying a macro explanation to a micro system. I don't really accept that biology has the limitations of which you speak. Our very consciousness is biological/physiological and all behaviors must ultimately be biological in nature. The gene is the only thing that must survive for life to continue in it's current form. (There may only be one)
You might prefer a more fluffy interpretation, but its only man's own arrogance that allows him the luxury of delusion regarding his consciousness and his significance beyond being some animate matter.

I think its more or less true, that a macro model will differ from a micro model because of the different assumptions, variables discounted and how observation and study is undertaken. However one must also account for reductionism.

A degree of sentience and agency, also makes sense as a evolutionary benefit (it massively aids adaptability). I don't think we have free will, that's nonsense, but I also think that the paradims of biological science cannot function when determining individuals (simply because of the scale) and so it abstracts.

Biology often refers to things we can demonstrate that are learned from our peers as hereditary, without them being genetic.

I don't think this is unique to humans either, just its most pronounced, because we're humans - and that we reduce this phenomena in other mammals because its convenient to our ego. Its also not active on an autonomic scale, we react in the moment, but reflect and plan our actions out and prepair in advance by running scenarios, that allow us to adapt our reactive self.

Essentially, we can, on some level, reprogram our own behavior, according to our experiences and desired outcomes. When faced in the moment we react.


I understand your view point but I'm inclined to think that in the same way that technology is an extension of nature, so is the complex nature of animals,including humans. I can't separate the agency of the animal from the genetic survival mechanism.
How can we really know if the ability of a person to use the abstract or learned behaviour is genuinely separate from a pre programmed instinct ?
I would point to the sometimes unpredictable nature of survival strategies and the apparent sliding scale of protecting genes belonging to ones self, children, cousins and sometimes the community. There seem to be very subtle rules in place that guide these things and they are not always obvious. It might be that the genetic control is so complex in its nature that it seems to be separate from simple biology. Maybe we just can't comprehend fully the reach of the gene and it's control of it's biological vehicle in the same way that that it seems incredible that nature produces highly complex interactions between species using only evolution.

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 18 Jun 15 3.51pm

Quote TUX at 17 Jun 2015 10.35pm

What created God?


The Babel Fish.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Mapletree Flag Croydon 18 Jun 15 3.53pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 18 Jun 2015 3.51pm

Quote TUX at 17 Jun 2015 10.35pm

What created God?


The Babel Fish.

You are confusing God with Cod.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 19 Jun 15 9.16am

Quote derben at 18 Jun 2015 11.06am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Jun 2015 8.06am

Quote derben at 18 Jun 2015 7.28am

Quote TUX at 17 Jun 2015 10.35pm

Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 10.07pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 17 Jun 2015 10.01pm

Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 9.23pm

But if God is omnipotent, God has unlimited powers. This would include the power to create itself or even retrospectively make itself exist from eternity!


This is where the difference between "hypothesis" and "theory" becomes really important. In fact, your claims don't even rise to the level of hypothesis - something based on limited evidence; they're merely speculation - conjecture lacking evidence.

Claiming that "my God can beat up your science" does not make it so.

Not saying it is my God. Just saying that if there is an omnipotent God, then God's omnipotence defeats all arguments.[/quote]

What created God?


As the omnipotent God has unlimited powers, ie: God can do anything, then it could have created itself.


Edited by derben (18 Jun 2015 7.31am)

You see why that's not scientifically acceptable though.


I guess an omnipotent God could make it scientifically acceptable if that God chose to.

No it couldn't, not without ceasing to exist, as it would prove faith, and obviously any deity, no matter how omnipotent, is not more powerful than the first two books of the Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 19 Jun 15 9.33am

Quote TheJudge at 18 Jun 2015 1.25pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Jun 2015 9.31am

Quote TheJudge at 17 Jun 2015 7.22pmThis is rather applying a macro explanation to a micro system. I don't really accept that biology has the limitations of which you speak. Our very consciousness is biological/physiological and all behaviors must ultimately be biological in nature. The gene is the only thing that must survive for life to continue in it's current form. (There may only be one)
You might prefer a more fluffy interpretation, but its only man's own arrogance that allows him the luxury of delusion regarding his consciousness and his significance beyond being some animate matter.

I think its more or less true, that a macro model will differ from a micro model because of the different assumptions, variables discounted and how observation and study is undertaken. However one must also account for reductionism.

A degree of sentience and agency, also makes sense as a evolutionary benefit (it massively aids adaptability). I don't think we have free will, that's nonsense, but I also think that the paradims of biological science cannot function when determining individuals (simply because of the scale) and so it abstracts.

Biology often refers to things we can demonstrate that are learned from our peers as hereditary, without them being genetic.

I don't think this is unique to humans either, just its most pronounced, because we're humans - and that we reduce this phenomena in other mammals because its convenient to our ego. Its also not active on an autonomic scale, we react in the moment, but reflect and plan our actions out and prepair in advance by running scenarios, that allow us to adapt our reactive self.

Essentially, we can, on some level, reprogram our own behavior, according to our experiences and desired outcomes. When faced in the moment we react.


I understand your view point but I'm inclined to think that in the same way that technology is an extension of nature, so is the complex nature of animals,including humans. I can't separate the agency of the animal from the genetic survival mechanism.
How can we really know if the ability of a person to use the abstract or learned behaviour is genuinely separate from a pre programmed instinct ?
I would point to the sometimes unpredictable nature of survival strategies and the apparent sliding scale of protecting genes belonging to ones self, children, cousins and sometimes the community. There seem to be very subtle rules in place that guide these things and they are not always obvious. It might be that the genetic control is so complex in its nature that it seems to be separate from simple biology. Maybe we just can't comprehend fully the reach of the gene and it's control of it's biological vehicle in the same way that that it seems incredible that nature produces highly complex interactions between species using only evolution.

The agency of the animal feeds into the genetic survival of the species, our survival instincts and drives are very strong, and they are improved by the capacity of agency, more than they are failed by it, because they enable us to improve our capacity for flight or fight, through learning strategies and capacity to adapt on the fly.

The selfish gene isn't really controlling peoples behavior per se, but that the way our agency and biological interaction works, improves that capacity to pass on genetic material and the benefits of our agency (sort of like a meme to a gene).

Of course agency is generated on a biological mechanism, through the interaction of numerous systems, and maybe illusionary, but our experience suggests that what it does is serve as a capacity to override or fine tune things stimulus-response.

In terms of a mechanistic system, I don't subscribe to that - Its a modernist concept that breaks down under a post-modern scientific analysis, and a by product of laboratory bias. In reality I believe systems to be gear more towards Chaotic and fuzzy logic, than to a simple stimulus-response mechanism.

Mechanistic models of nature invariable lack a suitable predictive capacity to suggest that they are true, outside of strict controls. I also would argue that all mammals, at least, have a degree of agency and self awareness, along with a capacity to learn and adapt, that agency creates.

If evolution is about 'species best fitted to the environment' agency is an inevitable conclusion of any evolutionary process, as it creates the capacity for a creature to adapt its behavior to fit changes in its environment.

Of course any model of agency, would appear to mechanistic, because in describing the properties of any model, the capacity of the whole is reduced to the function of its parts.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

palace_in_frogland Flag In a broken dream 19 Jun 15 9.39am

Quote Mapletree at 18 Jun 2015 3.53pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 18 Jun 2015 3.51pm

Quote TUX at 17 Jun 2015 10.35pm

What created God?


The Babel Fish.

You are confusing God with Cod.

So, perhaps it's not a real God, but a cod God?


 

TheJudge Flag 19 Jun 15 12.22pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 19 Jun 2015 9.33am

Quote TheJudge at 18 Jun 2015 1.25pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Jun 2015 9.31am

Quote TheJudge at 17 Jun 2015 7.22pmThis is rather applying a macro explanation to a micro system. I don't really accept that biology has the limitations of which you speak. Our very consciousness is biological/physiological and all behaviors must ultimately be biological in nature. The gene is the only thing that must survive for life to continue in it's current form. (There may only be one)
You might prefer a more fluffy interpretation, but its only man's own arrogance that allows him the luxury of delusion regarding his consciousness and his significance beyond being some animate matter.

I think its more or less true, that a macro model will differ from a micro model because of the different assumptions, variables discounted and how observation and study is undertaken. However one must also account for reductionism.

A degree of sentience and agency, also makes sense as a evolutionary benefit (it massively aids adaptability). I don't think we have free will, that's nonsense, but I also think that the paradims of biological science cannot function when determining individuals (simply because of the scale) and so it abstracts.

Biology often refers to things we can demonstrate that are learned from our peers as hereditary, without them being genetic.

I don't think this is unique to humans either, just its most pronounced, because we're humans - and that we reduce this phenomena in other mammals because its convenient to our ego. Its also not active on an autonomic scale, we react in the moment, but reflect and plan our actions out and prepair in advance by running scenarios, that allow us to adapt our reactive self.

Essentially, we can, on some level, reprogram our own behavior, according to our experiences and desired outcomes. When faced in the moment we react.


I understand your view point but I'm inclined to think that in the same way that technology is an extension of nature, so is the complex nature of animals,including humans. I can't separate the agency of the animal from the genetic survival mechanism.
How can we really know if the ability of a person to use the abstract or learned behaviour is genuinely separate from a pre programmed instinct ?
I would point to the sometimes unpredictable nature of survival strategies and the apparent sliding scale of protecting genes belonging to ones self, children, cousins and sometimes the community. There seem to be very subtle rules in place that guide these things and they are not always obvious. It might be that the genetic control is so complex in its nature that it seems to be separate from simple biology. Maybe we just can't comprehend fully the reach of the gene and it's control of it's biological vehicle in the same way that that it seems incredible that nature produces highly complex interactions between species using only evolution.

The agency of the animal feeds into the genetic survival of the species, our survival instincts and drives are very strong, and they are improved by the capacity of agency, more than they are failed by it, because they enable us to improve our capacity for flight or fight, through learning strategies and capacity to adapt on the fly.

The selfish gene isn't really controlling peoples behavior per se, but that the way our agency and biological interaction works, improves that capacity to pass on genetic material and the benefits of our agency (sort of like a meme to a gene).

Of course agency is generated on a biological mechanism, through the interaction of numerous systems, and maybe illusionary, but our experience suggests that what it does is serve as a capacity to override or fine tune things stimulus-response.

In terms of a mechanistic system, I don't subscribe to that - Its a modernist concept that breaks down under a post-modern scientific analysis, and a by product of laboratory bias. In reality I believe systems to be gear more towards Chaotic and fuzzy logic, than to a simple stimulus-response mechanism.

Mechanistic models of nature invariable lack a suitable predictive capacity to suggest that they are true, outside of strict controls. I also would argue that all mammals, at least, have a degree of agency and self awareness, along with a capacity to learn and adapt, that agency creates.

If evolution is about 'species best fitted to the environment' agency is an inevitable conclusion of any evolutionary process, as it creates the capacity for a creature to adapt its behavior to fit changes in its environment.

Of course any model of agency, would appear to mechanistic, because in describing the properties of any model, the capacity of the whole is reduced to the function of its parts.


We essentially agree on this.

We only slightly disagree on the meaning of mechanistic.

Surely a system sufficiently complex would look less and less like a mechanism and more chaotic ?
Take for example a flow chart for a particular behaviour. If it only had a few boxes it would appear simple, but add enough complexity and it would appear chaotic because of the sheer magnitude of it's complexity. Think about weather systems. They appear chaotic but every action must be the result of another which with enough computing power could be predicted. The fact that such a feat is way beyond us does not change its nature.
I would suggest that there is no current way to tell the true nature, complexity and extent of genetic survival mechanism strategy.

 

Page 11 of 14 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Richard Dawkins Hero