You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tunisia Terrorism - It's time to get tough
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Tunisia Terrorism - It's time to get tough


Page 11 of 12 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
TheJudge Flag 04 Jul 15 9.29am

Quote legaleagle at 03 Jul 2015 7.01pm

Quote TheJudge at 03 Jul 2015 2.42pm

Quote legaleagle at 03 Jul 2015 2.36pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Jul 2015 12.25pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 03 Jul 2015 11.06am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Jul 2015 10.38am

Quote leggedstruggle at 03 Jul 2015 9.48am

Quote legaleagle at 03 Jul 2015 1.17am

An interesting point of view.You would have been invaluable in assisting the US with its counter-insurgency strategy in Vietnam.

If you want to change the subject to Vietnam, they could have tried to win the hearts and minds of the communists by introducing a one-party state, gulags, the worship of Ho Chi Minh, the collectivisation of farmland (6,000 peasants massacred during a revolt), land 'reform' (at least 120,000 executed), rent 'reduction' (at least 200,000 executed).

ARVN, US and Allies caused between 420 and 1m civilian deaths. The South Vietnamese government, during the war, ordered the deaths of 50-200,000 people (the US 4-10,000 people).

Willbanks and Levy's research suggests as many as 220,000 civilian deaths were counted as 'VC casualties' rather than civilian casualties.

A result of the use of Agent Orange was nearly half a million child birth defects.

Turns out war and civil war is never nice.


The figures I quoted are the tip of the iceberg. Suffice to say that the Vietnam communist regime launched the usual bloodbath, along with the usual total repression of peoples' freedoms, along with the emperor-style worship of the glorious pastry-cook leader, along with the the usual insane 'economics'.

Civil war massacres, shocking. Whatever will they think of next. Wow its so fortunate that Western Nations only ever employed good honest totalitarian allies and absolutely never did anything naughty or bad in order to promote their interests abroad....


Maybe we should recommission our "torture" techniques from the early 1950's in Kenya which I believe even then classified official records described as "Gestapo techniques":rape, castration, amputation, electrocution...


Estimate eventual death toll from the "insurgency" generally was about 30,000-150,000 Africans dead and less than 50 settlers.

Enough of this woosy bleeding heart "hearts and minds" tosh!It's taking the "Great" out of Great Britain

Nasty eh ?

Electrocution's a doddle.


Especially via the testicles...

I freely admit you will know much more than me about the ins and outs of electrocuting people and the ease of doing so.

As for Kenya,long term outcome,the corrupt elite in secure control post independence having taken over the elite farms and homes the torture was to "protect" from being seized, the same people responsible for so many of the country's problems today,including funnily enough results of failure over decades to win "hearts and minds" of the muslim minority in the north as "equal participants" in the national project...But then it was us who "taught them" how "tribalism" was a useful device to exacerbate divisions to divide and rule

funny old world...

Edited by legaleagle (03 Jul 2015 7.19pm)

So you are suggesting what ? It would have been better to exterminate all of them ?

 

legaleagle Flag 04 Jul 15 10.20am


No, positing merely an option between "torture/electrocution" and "extermination" as the only viable scenarios was not any part of my point.

Ultimately,in the early 1950's Kenya example,the approach (and its balance) we adopted arguably did more harm than good and is another reason in support of why seeking to win "hearts and minds" of a general local populace or part of the populace, as part of the "psychological warfare" part of any "counter-insurgency" situation is not some "woosy liberal nonsense" but is very important, as is having an overall long-term thought through strategy.

It is also an important part of lessening the risk of such a situation arising or expanding."Traditional military" aspects are of course not irrelevant per se but often ,while appearing superficially attractive, on their own coupled with "strong arm" aspects can lessen the prospects of long term success. Similar lessons can be learned from looking at Central and Latin America in the 20th century,

Malaya was an example of where we possibly got it more "right" (the odd massacre aside),as opposed to a rather more mass level of alienating the entire local populace by recourse amongst other things to way OTT "security" and questioning "techniques" of the many.

What we face today IMO with "violent salafist jihadism" is not precisely like classic colonial-type insurgency situations,not least because of its spread in pockets over a wide area globally and not being solely confined to people and events thousands of miles away,but if you strip out the specific ideological element,it has many similarities in terms of the "psychological" aspects of countering (including not exacerbating and incubating) it as opposed to just the more traditional military/police aspects.This is all the more so given modern technology such as the growth of things like social media and its effect on the "battle for hearts and minds"

Just an opinion

Adios

Edited by legaleagle (04 Jul 2015 10.52am)

 

TheJudge Flag 04 Jul 15 11.51am

Quote legaleagle at 04 Jul 2015 10.20am


No, positing merely an option between "torture/electrocution" and "extermination" as the only viable scenarios was not any part of my point.

Ultimately,in the early 1950's Kenya example,the approach (and its balance) we adopted arguably did more harm than good and is another reason in support of why seeking to win "hearts and minds" of a general local populace or part of the populace, as part of the "psychological warfare" part of any "counter-insurgency" situation is not some "woosy liberal nonsense" but is very important, as is having an overall long-term thought through strategy.

It is also an important part of lessening the risk of such a situation arising or expanding."Traditional military" aspects are of course not irrelevant per se but often ,while appearing superficially attractive, on their own coupled with "strong arm" aspects can lessen the prospects of long term success. Similar lessons can be learned from looking at Central and Latin America in the 20th century,

Malaya was an example of where we possibly got it more "right" (the odd massacre aside),as opposed to a rather more mass level of alienating the entire local populace by recourse amongst other things to way OTT "security" and questioning "techniques" of the many.

What we face today IMO with "violent salafist jihadism" is not precisely like classic colonial-type insurgency situations,not least because of its spread in pockets over a wide area globally and not being solely confined to people and events thousands of miles away,but if you strip out the specific ideological element,it has many similarities in terms of the "psychological" aspects of countering (including not exacerbating and incubating) it as opposed to just the more traditional military/police aspects.This is all the more so given modern technology such as the growth of things like social media and its effect on the "battle for hearts and minds"

Just an opinion

Adios

Edited by legaleagle (04 Jul 2015 10.52am)


So it's all our fault.....as usual ?

Trying to retrospectively judge policy and decry the draconian tactics of previous administrations is of little use. Yes, lessons can be learned from history but circumstances are rarely the same,although they might appear superficially so, and personalities are not the same.
We sit here in our comfortable civilised society able to bleat on about the so called evils of the World and our British past precisely because of the so called evils.
This little paradise we occupy,mostly free from barbarity, was created on the back of tyranny,slavery,torture and empire building. No one likes to hear it in the wonderfully enlightened 21st century but the luxury of being "liberal" and wise after the event is entirely dependent on it. In short, this is a dog eat dog World.

 

legaleagle Flag 04 Jul 15 12.25pm

IMO,only a person with extreme tunnel vision and a single frame of reference outlook who hasn't (perhaps my fault) understood what I am saying about "counter-insurgency" could possibly think I am suggesting any problems arising from "violent salafist jihadism" are all "our fault".That's regardless of whether my actual points and opinions (which is all they are) have any objective merit or not.

It may (or may not) be inherently and in every case a dog eat dog world.That would make us both dogs and no hope of acting other than as dogs. Some dogs may be smarter than others at avoiding having the whole of the other dog's "pack" alienated (where this may be avoidable or can be mitigated )and rounding on them in a frenzy at the same time.

I've put my opinion.You are perfectly entitled to your opinion.But,there is little point debating along completely different frames of reference and questions.

Now, adios.

Edited by legaleagle (04 Jul 2015 12.35pm)

 

TheJudge Flag 04 Jul 15 6.22pm

If you are making an unbiased observation then all power to it, but what is the foundation of your observation ? Where did you acquire this seemingly solid grasp of military tactics ?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Jul 15 6.59pm

In legal's world, if you don't alienate people they won't wish ill or attack you.

It goes back to my description of people who don't really understand the nature of humanity. Only people who have never really had to fight for anything really think like this.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 04 Jul 15 7.11pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 04 Jul 2015 6.59pm

In legal's world, if you don't alienate people they won't wish ill or attack you.

It goes back to my description of people who don't really understand the nature of humanity. Only people who have never really had to fight for anything really think like this.

If you are a Christian they will come and get you and do away with your head without a hint of your alienating them. I guess Legal is not an infidel so feels he is safe as he mingles with the vicious scum!.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Jul 15 7.15pm

Quote blind eagle at 04 Jul 2015 7.11pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 04 Jul 2015 6.59pm

In legal's world, if you don't alienate people they won't wish ill or attack you.

It goes back to my description of people who don't really understand the nature of humanity. Only people who have never really had to fight for anything really think like this.

If you are a Christian they will come and get you and do away with your head without a hint of your alienating them. I guess Legal is not an infidel so feels he is safe as he mingles with the vicious scum!.


Oh he wouldn't mingle within a thousand miles of them given the choice.

But he'd die for their rights no doubt.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 04 Jul 15 10.32pm

Stirling, old bean,you carry on playing the person not the point,though I can quite see why since you appear to not actually have a clue what the point is

 

legaleagle Flag 04 Jul 15 10.52pm

Quote TheJudge at 04 Jul 2015 6.22pm

If you are making an unbiased observation then all power to it, but what is the foundation of your observation ? Where did you acquire this seemingly solid grasp of military tactics ?

A reasonable and sensible question merits a sensible response in my book.

It has nothing whatsoever to do with "military" tactics.Counter-insurgency, as other posters have noted, concerns a lot more than just the purely military aspects.Bit more to it than just Stirling's a real man's a real man so lets stick it up 'em and have a real men's "fight" approach.That begun to become passe as a cure all circa post 1917-39 and more so from the early 50's onards ,but that's in keeping with Stirling's era of mind set.Stirling might be amazed to meet some of the people who deal with this "quasi psych-ops" stuff in the real world hands on,often in my experience nothing like his stereotype of a "real man",some are even women (or his ideological mindset,or your own for that matter).

I despair of some knee jerk responses to situations like the current one. I have no particular special experience,I studied counter insurgency in the British Empire post WW2 a long time ago and have retained an interest,that's all.And through my travels and work I've been exposed to some of this stuff overseas and also to stuff re the "salafist jihadist" ideological modus operandi.Stuff you don't get from the newspapers.And as a "leftie" I was interested in theorists like Gramsci who stressed the battle for "hearts and minds" in the "battle of ideologies".

As for "unbiased",of course I have biases; we all do. Very few things about this are truly objective.I think what is important to have an increased prospect of a better outcome is to try and understand the other "side" and historical roots, and not to be blind to one's "side's" own shortcomings, including historically, and after all, propaganda comes from all directions including one's own. Importantly,not to needlessly alienate and demonise those its important not to. That way,there is IMO a better chance of coming up with a coherent strategy with any prospect of success, rather than just blasting a few people from the face of the earth (however understandable it might be to wish for that at times) but alter the bigger picture and longer term not necessarily a jot.

Edited by legaleagle (04 Jul 2015 11.48pm)

 

legaleagle Flag 04 Jul 15 11.11pm

Quote blind eagle at 04 Jul 2015 7.11pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 04 Jul 2015 6.59pm

In legal's world, if you don't alienate people they won't wish ill or attack you.

It goes back to my description of people who don't really understand the nature of humanity. Only people who have never really had to fight for anything really think like this.

If you are a Christian they will come and get you and do away with your head without a hint of your alienating them. I guess Legal is not an infidel so feels he is safe as he mingles with the vicious scum!.

You have so missed my point, its frightening


 

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Jul 15 11.36pm

Quote legaleagle at 04 Jul 2015 10.32pm

Stirling, old bean,you carry on playing the person not the point,though I can quite see why since you appear to not actually have a clue what the point is


Just thought I'd tease you, seeing how you're so obsessed with me.

On cue, you come right in.....with your stereotypes of what I think.....Like for like I suppose.

Still, thanks for the smile it afforded.


Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Jul 2015 11.39pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 04 Jul 15 11.47pm

Being serious,I enjoy your presence on here but you can do much better than some of that silly stuff earlier


 

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Jul 15 11.49pm

Legal thinks a 'hearts and minds' strategy can be implemented with people who don't like us in the middle east.

I'm recommending legal for instant drafting into the 'intelligence' team for this.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Jul 15 11.52pm

Quote legaleagle at 04 Jul 2015 11.47pm

Being serious,I enjoy your presence on here but you can do much better than some of that silly stuff earlier



I thought you wanted to play.

None of us are above a little mockery surely.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 04 Jul 15 11.57pm

Agree and I think you agree I'm not one who only gives out but doesn't take it too,but at the current time I think counter insurgency is serious stuff...so forgive me if buffoonery (leaving the "mocking" bits out since they're nothing) as a response didn't appeal in the current heat

Edited by legaleagle (05 Jul 2015 12.07am)

 

legaleagle Flag 05 Jul 15 12.02am

Quote Stirlingsays at 04 Jul 2015 11.49pm

Legal thinks a 'hearts and minds' strategy can be implemented with people who don't like us in the middle east.

I'm recommending legal for instant drafting into the 'intelligence' team for this.

Blimey,a recommendation from Stirling is where things really start to get frightening!

Being serious (and I know you weren't), if you'd actually read my posts today rather than being on auto colonel blimp mode,I was thinking as much about within Europe including the UK as the Middle East,Africa or Asia

Do you want to join the AW "hearts and minds" team? Only problem could be it requires both a heart and a mind


Edited by legaleagle (05 Jul 2015 12.08am)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 05 Jul 15 12.59am

Quote legaleagle at 05 Jul 2015 12.02am

Quote Stirlingsays at 04 Jul 2015 11.49pm

Legal thinks a 'hearts and minds' strategy can be implemented with people who don't like us in the middle east.

I'm recommending legal for instant drafting into the 'intelligence' team for this.

Blimey,a recommendation from Stirling is where things really start to get frightening!

Being serious (and I know you weren't), if you'd actually read my posts today rather than being on auto colonel blimp mode,I was thinking as much about within Europe including the UK as the Middle East,Africa or Asia

Do you want to join the AW "hearts and minds" team? Only problem could be it requires both a heart and a mind


Edited by legaleagle (05 Jul 2015 12.08am)

As long as the job came with an endless supply of JD & coke and a few saucy long legged admin assistants......Hang on I think I've signed us up for another department.

To be serious though....the old 'hearts and minds' routine has been made obsolete by the Internet.

No cigar nowadays.

What works is trade and jobs.....That's always worked and it's something I've always supported.....But you can only do that once you have a functioning state to begin with.

Sometimes war is the least bad option.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 05 Jul 15 11.03am

"hearts and minds" has been made no less important by the internet...arguably a lot more important given the skilled use of social media by the "opposition"...

And "terrorism" doesn't equate with a nicely parcelled up conflict against a national state model..

and counter insurgency was never about conflict against a national state...

Edited by legaleagle (05 Jul 2015 11.09am)

 

TheJudge Flag 05 Jul 15 11.03am

Quote legaleagle at 04 Jul 2015 10.52pm

Quote TheJudge at 04 Jul 2015 6.22pm

If you are making an unbiased observation then all power to it, but what is the foundation of your observation ? Where did you acquire this seemingly solid grasp of military tactics ?

A reasonable and sensible question merits a sensible response in my book.

It has nothing whatsoever to do with "military" tactics.Counter-insurgency, as other posters have noted, concerns a lot more than just the purely military aspects.Bit more to it than just Stirling's a real man's a real man so lets stick it up 'em and have a real men's "fight" approach.That begun to become passe as a cure all circa post 1917-39 and more so from the early 50's onards ,but that's in keeping with Stirling's era of mind set.Stirling might be amazed to meet some of the people who deal with this "quasi psych-ops" stuff in the real world hands on,often in my experience nothing like his stereotype of a "real man",some are even women (or his ideological mindset,or your own for that matter).

I despair of some knee jerk responses to situations like the current one. I have no particular special experience,I studied counter insurgency in the British Empire post WW2 a long time ago and have retained an interest,that's all.And through my travels and work I've been exposed to some of this stuff overseas and also to stuff re the "salafist jihadist" ideological modus operandi.Stuff you don't get from the newspapers.And as a "leftie" I was interested in theorists like Gramsci who stressed the battle for "hearts and minds" in the "battle of ideologies".

As for "unbiased",of course I have biases; we all do. Very few things about this are truly objective.I think what is important to have an increased prospect of a better outcome is to try and understand the other "side" and historical roots, and not to be blind to one's "side's" own shortcomings, including historically, and after all, propaganda comes from all directions including one's own. Importantly,not to needlessly alienate and demonise those its important not to. That way,there is IMO a better chance of coming up with a coherent strategy with any prospect of success, rather than just blasting a few people from the face of the earth (however understandable it might be to wish for that at times) but alter the bigger picture and longer term not necessarily a jot.

Edited by legaleagle (04 Jul 2015 11.48pm)

You are an intelligent fellow and within your rather wordy posts I get the thrust of your thinking, but really old chap surely you can see that your impression of humanity might bot really apply to all.
Do you really think that the likes of ISIL care a jot for anyone else ? The are conditioned and desensitised to humanity. They are completely ruthless soldiers of a totally alien philosophy and their only objective is destruction. We did not create them. We have to stop blaming ourselves for all the worlds ills, stop second guessing ourselves and recognise that the World as a whole will breath a sigh of relief when these people are erased. Applying your left wing ideals to this situation will only prolong the pain.
Do you think Hitler would have come around if we had tried to win him over ? He was a pussycat compared to ISIL. You might even say he was one of us. Diplomacy fails when it falls on deaf ears.

 

Page 11 of 12 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tunisia Terrorism - It's time to get tough