Quote legaleagle at 04 Jul 2015 10.52pm
Quote TheJudge at 04 Jul 2015 6.22pm
If you are making an unbiased observation then all power to it, but what is the foundation of your observation ? Where did you acquire this seemingly solid grasp of military tactics ?
A reasonable and sensible question merits a sensible response in my book.
It has nothing whatsoever to do with "military" tactics.Counter-insurgency, as other posters have noted, concerns a lot more than just the purely military aspects.Bit more to it than just Stirling's a real man's a real man so lets stick it up 'em and have a real men's "fight" approach.That begun to become passe as a cure all circa post 1917-39 and more so from the early 50's onards ,but that's in keeping with Stirling's era of mind set.Stirling might be amazed to meet some of the people who deal with this "quasi psych-ops" stuff in the real world hands on,often in my experience nothing like his stereotype of a "real man",some are even women
(or his ideological mindset,or your own for that matter).
I despair of some knee jerk responses to situations like the current one. I have no particular special experience,I studied counter insurgency in the British Empire post WW2 a long time ago and have retained an interest,that's all.And through my travels and work I've been exposed to some of this stuff overseas and also to stuff re the "salafist jihadist" ideological modus operandi.Stuff you don't get from the newspapers.And as a "leftie" I was interested in theorists like Gramsci who stressed the battle for "hearts and minds" in the "battle of ideologies".
As for "unbiased",of course I have biases; we all do. Very few things about this are truly objective.I think what is important to have an increased prospect of a better outcome is to try and understand the other "side" and historical roots, and not to be blind to one's "side's" own shortcomings, including historically, and after all, propaganda comes from all directions including one's own. Importantly,not to needlessly alienate and demonise those its important not to. That way,there is IMO a better chance of coming up with a coherent strategy with any prospect of success, rather than just blasting a few people from the face of the earth (however understandable it might be to wish for that at times) but alter the bigger picture and longer term not necessarily a jot.
Edited by legaleagle (04 Jul 2015 11.48pm)
You are an intelligent fellow and within your rather wordy posts I get the thrust of your thinking, but really old chap surely you can see that your impression of humanity might bot really apply to all.
Do you really think that the likes of ISIL care a jot for anyone else ? The are conditioned and desensitised to humanity. They are completely ruthless soldiers of a totally alien philosophy and their only objective is destruction. We did not create them. We have to stop blaming ourselves for all the worlds ills, stop second guessing ourselves and recognise that the World as a whole will breath a sigh of relief when these people are erased. Applying your left wing ideals to this situation will only prolong the pain.
Do you think Hitler would have come around if we had tried to win him over ? He was a pussycat compared to ISIL. You might even say he was one of us. Diplomacy fails when it falls on deaf ears.