You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Rugby world cup 2015
November 22 2026 1.33am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rugby world cup 2015


Page 11 of 26 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >
sydtheeagle Flag England 28 Sep 15 6.57pm

Very good analysis of Saturday by no less than Graham Henry: [Link]

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

puliscap Flag croydon 28 Sep 15 7.15pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 28 Sep 2015 6.57pm

Very good analysis of Saturday by no less than Graham Henry: [Link]


Graham Henry and SCW both flopped at their first attempt at winning the World Cup, but learnt by their mistakes and went on to win it 4 years later.
They might be wise old sages in the media now, but they experienced failure and learnt.
No point bombing out Bomber and starting again, give him time.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 28 Sep 15 7.55pm

Quote puliscap at 28 Sep 2015 7.15pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 28 Sep 2015 6.57pm

Graham Henry and SCW both flopped at their first attempt at winning the World Cup, but learnt by their mistakes and went on to win it 4 years later.
They might be wise old sages in the media now, but they experienced failure and learnt.
No point bombing out Bomber and starting again, give him time.

Up to a point, yes. But neither SCW or GH were burdened by blind loyalty or a lack of vision. Their early mistakes were clear, but they were "progressive" mistakes. Both trusted their own judgment even when things went wrong, a quality Lancaster clearly lacks. Lastly, Woodward played international rugby and Henry came to the ABs job with vast international coaching experience. Bomber had neither before he took the job, perhaps one reason why he doesn't trust his own judgment and is constantly deferring to the likes of Faz. Don't get me wrong, he was the right coach at the right time four years ago and he did a fine job of pulling us back together. But I see nothing to convince me he's the right man for the next stage of the job. Look at it this way: explain to me what is Lancaster's tactical vision? We have no idea. Nor, Saturday showed, has he. That is a question we never needed to ask of SCW. Even if we disagreed with his selections, we knew what he was trying to do. A balanced midfield, a highly mobile back row, etc.

Edited by sydtheeagle (28 Sep 2015 7.57pm)

Edited by sydtheeagle (28 Sep 2015 7.57pm)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 28 Sep 15 8.34pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 28 Sep 2015 4.50pm

James Hook & Gareth Anscombe have been called up for Wales. I was starting to think that Hook was only marginally ahead of me in the pecking order.

Another tough game against Fiji and Henson will get the call

The way things are going Phil Bennett must fancy his chances


 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

sydtheeagle Flag England 28 Sep 15 9.56pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 28 Sep 2015 4.50pm

James Hook & Gareth Anscombe have been called up for Wales. I was starting to think that Hook was only marginally ahead of me in the pecking order.

Another tough game against Fiji and Henson will get the call

Looks like you were right: [Link]

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

johnno42000 Flag 28 Sep 15 10.41pm

I think Shaun Edwards misunderstood what his priest was doing. He was actually saying he was available for selection. [Link]

Edited by johnno42000 (29 Sep 2015 12.22am)

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 29 Sep 15 8.08am

Quote sydtheeagle at 28 Sep 2015 9.56pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 28 Sep 2015 4.50pm

James Hook & Gareth Anscombe have been called up for Wales. I was starting to think that Hook was only marginally ahead of me in the pecking order.

Another tough game against Fiji and Henson will get the call

Looks like you were right: [Link]

that is bloody brilliant

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 29 Sep 15 9.32am

Quote sydtheeagle at 28 Sep 2015 6.57pm

Very good analysis of Saturday by no less than Graham Henry: [Link]


Good article that and if nothing else validates what us armchair generals had said before a ball was even kicked...

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 29 Sep 15 1.45pm

All you egg chasers have far more in depth tactical Knowledge than me, I am a football player that occasionally plays rugby, knows the rules, and can have a good game at second row.

However all the flack Lancaster is getting seems a bit unfair.

Look at it from a football view point and you may get what I'm saying, Pardew makes some iffy subs at times (Mutch for Wilf, leaving Jedi out, playing Yannick up top instead of Gayle etc etc. And yet Pards get no s*** what so ever, because in the main he has been brilliant for Palace.

In the main Lancaster has been brilliant for England, I know the subs he made were "odd" but he must've done it for a reason, if I remember rightly Wales had already started turning the screw before he made the changes.

As for the Kick at goal that never was to suggest that is Lancasters fault is plain daft, he was miles away in seats, Rob Shaw was on the pitch and it was his choice, at that minute in time it was his choice, he needed to make a comand decision and he f***ed it up.

He kicks for goal, we maybe get three points but whatever the Welsh have to kick back to us and a draw was a very likely result with that much time left.

You can prepare the players as best you can, but when they cross the line of chalk you can do no more, look at that dick that took the penalty from Gareth Barry and then smashed it at the keeper ?

I know there was more to the game and Englands failure than one descion by Rob Shaw, but that was the catalyst for Wales to win. Do you really think Lancasters advice with minutes left on the clock, with a kickable penalty, level on points, would be to go for a set peice ?????? I think not

The Captain has to take this one.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 29 Sep 15 1.49pm

Is it over yet?

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

DanH Flag SW2 29 Sep 15 1.50pm

Quote dannyh at 29 Sep 2015 1.45pm

All you egg chasers have far more in depth tactical Knowledge than me, I am a football player that occasionally plays rugby, knows the rules, and can have a good game at second row.

However all the flack Lancaster is getting seems a bit unfair.

Look at it from a football view point and you may get what I'm saying, Pardew makes some iffy subs at times (Mutch for Wilf, leaving Jedi out, playing Yannick up top instead of Gayle etc etc. And yet Pards get no s*** what so ever, because in the main he has been brilliant for Palace.

In the main Lancaster has been brilliant for England, I know the subs he made were "odd" but he must've done it for a reason, if I remember rightly Wales had already started turning the screw before he made the changes.

As for the Kick at goal that never was to suggest that is Lancasters fault is plain daft, he was miles away in seats, Rob Shaw was on the pitch and it was his choice, at that minute in time it was his choice, he needed to make a comand decision and he f***ed it up.

He kicks for goal, we maybe get three points but whatever the Welsh have to kick back to us and a draw was a very likely result with that much time left.

You can prepare the players as best you can, but when they cross the line of chalk you can do no more, look at that dick that took the penalty from Gareth Barry and then smashed it at the keeper ?

I know there was more to the game and Englands failure than one descion by Rob Shaw, but that was the catalyst for Wales to win. Do you really think Lancasters advice with minutes left on the clock, with a kickable penalty, level on points, would be to go for a set peice ?????? I think not

The Captain has to take this one.


Blatant euphemism.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 29 Sep 15 2.00pm

Quote dannyh at 29 Sep 2015 1.45pm

All you egg chasers have far more in depth tactical Knowledge than me, I am a football player that occasionally plays rugby, knows the rules, and can have a good game at second row.

However all the flack Lancaster is getting seems a bit unfair.

Look at it from a football view point and you may get what I'm saying, Pardew makes some iffy subs at times (Mutch for Wilf, leaving Jedi out, playing Yannick up top instead of Gayle etc etc. And yet Pards get no s*** what so ever, because in the main he has been brilliant for Palace.

In the main Lancaster has been brilliant for England, I know the subs he made were "odd" but he must've done it for a reason, if I remember rightly Wales had already started turning the screw before he made the changes.

As for the Kick at goal that never was to suggest that is Lancasters fault is plain daft, he was miles away in seats, Rob Shaw was on the pitch and it was his choice, at that minute in time it was his choice, he needed to make a comand decision and he f***ed it up.

He kicks for goal, we maybe get three points but whatever the Welsh have to kick back to us and a draw was a very likely result with that much time left.

You can prepare the players as best you can, but when they cross the line of chalk you can do no more, look at that dick that took the penalty from Gareth Barry and then smashed it at the keeper ?

I know there was more to the game and Englands failure than one descion by Rob Shaw, but that was the catalyst for Wales to win. Do you really think Lancasters advice with minutes left on the clock, with a kickable penalty, level on points, would be to go for a set peice ?????? I think not

The Captain has to take this one.


Mirallas from Baines.

Lancaster record against the Welsh is unacceptable, and downright awful against South Africa. Apart from that he's done okay.

 


Optimistic as ever

sydtheeagle Flag England 29 Sep 15 2.25pm

Quote dannyh at 29 Sep 2015 1.45pm
However all the flack Lancaster is getting seems a bit unfair.

Not to those of us who predicted that this line-up would fail to beat Wales. Since an awful lot of people saw it coming, the criticism seems entirely reasonable. As I said last week, if you spend four years training, to use your football analogy, to play 4-4-2 but you bottle it three days before the game and ask your players to suddenly play 3-5-1, the criticism that ensues isn't going to be unfair. What's the point of spending 48 months preparing a tactic you're going to abandon the day it actually counts?

Quote dannyh at 29 Sep 2015 1.45pm
In the main Lancaster has been brilliant for England,

In the main, Lancaster has done a very competent job of dragging us out of the post 2011 gutter. But all his work to date has been groundwork for the World Cup and, effectively, for the Wales and Australia games (the two that matter.) And right now, he has a record of Won 0 Lost 1. That's a harsh way of looking at it I know but it's what it boils down to. Remember the way that SCW in 2003 never, ever, took his eyes off the prize and the way he planned to get there? That's why we won the World Cup,

Quote dannyh at 29 Sep 2015 1.45pm
I know the subs he made were "odd" but he must've done it for a reason

All too many coaches these days make a raft of substitutions around the hour mark almost just to remind us how clever they are. If there was any rhyme or reason to the changes on Saturday, it wasn't evident to most people I've spoken to. The real problem wasn't so much the fact of making substitutions, but that he didn't replace like for like. He swapped a quick, sniping 9 for a slow, static one. He swapped a conservative out half for a creative one. He left on the poorer of his midfielders and took off the better one on the day. Thus, he drained all the momentum we had gained up to the hour mark.

Quote dannyh at 29 Sep 2015 1.45pm
if I remember rightly Wales had already started turning the screw before he made the changes.

No, they hadn't. The game changed when Youngs came off. That was the pivotal moment.

Quote dannyh at 29 Sep 2015 1.45pm
As for the Kick at goal that never was to suggest that is Lancasters fault is plain daft, he was miles away in seats, Rob Shaw was on the pitch and it was his choice, at that minute in time it was his choice, he needed to make a comand decision and he f***ed it up.

It IS Lancaster's fault. It was the third time Robshaw had made the same call (and the third time it failed.) Why, after the first two times, did Lancaster not pull Robshaw aside and tell him "in this situation, never, ever again." Although the captain clearly shares responsibility, players are supposed to execute the coaches instructions on the pitch. Clearly, Lancaster had not addressed previous failures of judgment in his preparation. So he takes responsibility for that.

Quote dannyh at 29 Sep 2015 1.45pm
You can prepare the players as best you can, but when they cross the line of chalk you can do no more

Agree. See my point above. They were not properly prepared. Lancaster had had two warnings that Robshaw was inclined to make poor decisions at the key moment of a game, and he had clearly not addressed the issue.

Quote dannyh at 29 Sep 2015 1.45pm
I know there was more to the game and Englands failure than one descion by Rob Shaw

There was. The decision to kick in the first place was immediately exacerbated by an even poorer decision, if that's possible. To throw to 2. That made it vastly easier for the Welsh to bundle the ball into touch. At least if you're going to go for the lineout, throw to 6 or 7 and give yourself a chance to set a platform properly to score. Apparently, Lancaster hadn't coached them in that basic thinking either. Yet England won the World Cup in 2003 precisely because on the key play, they threw to the back of the line.

Quote dannyh at 29 Sep 2015 1.45pm]
Do you really think Lancasters advice with minutes left on the clock, with a kickable penalty, level on points, would be to go for a set peice ?????? I think not

The Captain has to take this one.

Lancaster evidently didn't give any advice. Likely, though, Robshaw would have taken the points. I'm not sure what this proves, other than the captain doesn't trust his kickers. As Faz has alluded to.

Edited by sydtheeagle (29 Sep 2015 2.28pm)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 29 Sep 15 3.03pm

Quote DanH at 29 Sep 2015 1.50pm

Quote dannyh at 29 Sep 2015 1.45pm

All you egg chasers have far more in depth tactical Knowledge than me, I am a football player that occasionally plays rugby, knows the rules, and can have a good game at second row.

However all the flack Lancaster is getting seems a bit unfair.

Look at it from a football view point and you may get what I'm saying, Pardew makes some iffy subs at times (Mutch for Wilf, leaving Jedi out, playing Yannick up top instead of Gayle etc etc. And yet Pards get no s*** what so ever, because in the main he has been brilliant for Palace.

In the main Lancaster has been brilliant for England, I know the subs he made were "odd" but he must've done it for a reason, if I remember rightly Wales had already started turning the screw before he made the changes.

As for the Kick at goal that never was to suggest that is Lancasters fault is plain daft, he was miles away in seats, Rob Shaw was on the pitch and it was his choice, at that minute in time it was his choice, he needed to make a comand decision and he f***ed it up.

He kicks for goal, we maybe get three points but whatever the Welsh have to kick back to us and a draw was a very likely result with that much time left.

You can prepare the players as best you can, but when they cross the line of chalk you can do no more, look at that dick that took the penalty from Gareth Barry and then smashed it at the keeper ?

I know there was more to the game and Englands failure than one descion by Rob Shaw, but that was the catalyst for Wales to win. Do you really think Lancasters advice with minutes left on the clock, with a kickable penalty, level on points, would be to go for a set peice ?????? I think not

The Captain has to take this one.


Blatant euphemism.


 


Pro USA & Israel

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 29 Sep 15 4.28pm

Brian Moore made a good point this morning, most people including him wanted rid of SCW after the 99 world cup. That didn't turn out too bad

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

sydtheeagle Flag England 29 Sep 15 4.50pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 29 Sep 2015 4.28pm

Brian Moore made a good point this morning, most people including him wanted rid of SCW after the 99 world cup. That didn't turn out too bad

There are vast differences between the approach of the two. Woodward was always completely clear-minded. What people disagreed with after 1999 was his strategy. Not his execution. Lancaster now appears not to even have a strategy so any ability to execute is irrelevant. For instance, what's his ideal 10-12-13? You tell me, because I'm blowed if I know? Burrell started pretty much every game for a successful two years and he's not even in the World Cup squad.

As I said earlier, SCW wanted fast, mobile flankers and he stuck with Hilda and Back when many called them into question. Tindall was never flavour of the month but SCW knew the balance he wanted in midfield. By sticking to his vision, dividends were reaped. Repetition has always equalled success in sports. Thus, it's not the fact of our failure against Wales that's problematic. It's the manner of our failure that calls into question Lancaster's tenure.

For me, the most worrying thing is that he appears to be an administrator and organiser, but not a top class strategist or coach. He's a good bloke and he's competent but would you seriously compare him to Gatland, Hansen, Henry, Schmidt, Chieka, Jones, even Cotter? The hell you would. SCW ran every detail of his teams where Lancaster, lacking self-belief, not only defers but clearly defers to the wrong people (Farrell) too. I think it's time to say "thanks" and move on. There are too many world class coaches out there to employ one who isn't.

Edited by sydtheeagle (29 Sep 2015 4.51pm)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 29 Sep 15 9.17pm

Quote dannyh at 29 Sep 2015 1.45pm

All you egg chasers have far more in depth tactical Knowledge than me, I am a football player that occasionally plays rugby, knows the rules, and can have a good game at second row.

However all the flack Lancaster is getting seems a bit unfair.

Look at it from a football view point and you may get what I'm saying, Pardew makes some iffy subs at times (Mutch for Wilf, leaving Jedi out, playing Yannick up top instead of Gayle etc etc. And yet Pards get no s*** what so ever, because in the main he has been brilliant for Palace.

In the main Lancaster has been brilliant for England, I know the subs he made were "odd" but he must've done it for a reason, if I remember rightly Wales had already started turning the screw before he made the changes.

As for the Kick at goal that never was to suggest that is Lancasters fault is plain daft, he was miles away in seats, Rob Shaw was on the pitch and it was his choice, at that minute in time it was his choice, he needed to make a comand decision and he f***ed it up.

He kicks for goal, we maybe get three points but whatever the Welsh have to kick back to us and a draw was a very likely result with that much time left.

You can prepare the players as best you can, but when they cross the line of chalk you can do no more, look at that dick that took the penalty from Gareth Barry and then smashed it at the keeper ?

I know there was more to the game and Englands failure than one descion by Rob Shaw, but that was the catalyst for Wales to win. Do you really think Lancasters advice with minutes left on the clock, with a kickable penalty, level on points, would be to go for a set peice ?????? I think not

The Captain has to take this one.


Its not just this game though that's the thing danny...

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Hoof Hearted 30 Sep 15 11.02am

I think all this doom and gloom is a bit premature.

Let's play the Aussies... and if we get stuffed, let's pile into the Coach, Players, Tactics, Paloma Faith's version of "World In Union" etc etc.

Till then, I for one will be firmly supporting our cause and being optimistic.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 30 Sep 15 11.34am

For those who wondering why Burgess was such a disaster, there's a superb article by the Ireland centre Gordon D'Arcy in the Irish Times, Full article here: [Link] and part of it copied below:

I only started playing centre in 2004. It took until the 2007 World Cup before I felt properly attuned to the nuances of the position and comfortable playing Test matches in the 12 jersey.

Sonny Bill Williams had a daily tutorial from Tana Umaga – one the greatest centres ever – for two years at Toulon before returning to New Zealand and winning his first cap.

It’s simply not possible for him to be ready. And now we have proof.

Burgess lacks the sense of timing, in attack and defence, required to be effective at international level. His naivety embarrassed those around him and severely damaged England’s chances of reaching the quarter-finals.

Stuart Lancaster picked a league convert who doesn’t know how to play inside centre for the biggest match England have played since the 2007 World Cup final. To compound the problem, Brad Barritt was out of position at 13 and exposed accordingly when it mattered most.

Timing is everything at the elite end of centre play. I quickly realised it was my only way of surviving those European or Six Nations games. I wasn’t big enough to dominate tackles so my entry into the line had to be perfect. I was always trying to avoid a collision and attack an inside shoulder.

I think, for now, Burgess can only be effective alongside Bath team-mate George Ford as they have developed some form of understanding before George’s dad, Mike, shifted Burgess into the backrow.

By picking Owen Farrell, Burgess and Barritt, England didn’t come to Twickenham to play rugby. We all knew this. For Jonny May’s try – which I will examine in detail – both centres ran straight as decoys.

Burgess never got to the pace against Wales. He clearly bust a gut but effort and strength were never going to be enough. Barritt was arguably worse and badly exposed for the Gareth Davies try.

By then the Burgess experiment had been abandoned because the England coaching team accepted, long after everyone else, that he had no idea what was happening around him.

This is the flip side of last week’s column; when attacking from centre, you must catch the ball as flat as possible and the best centres always shift direction at that very moment.

Jean De Villiers is (or, sadly, was) the master of this. Ma’a Nonu is absolutely phenomenal.

All Burgess did was run straight in search of collisions with Jamie Roberts (who obliged but really conned him most of the time).

When Burgess played in the NRL he was so effective because everything was pre-ordained. There is no ruck so he timed the run off the scrumhalf and could get up a 10-metre head of steam and thunder into a player of his choosing. In rugby union there are more variables – rucks, pick-and-goes, the advantage rule – so he only gets three or four metres, and one wrong step forces a break in stride that makes him easier to stop.

His skill-set hasn’t transferred to the position he is playing. Again, it takes time.

England didn’t even put him in the back field to counter kicks, like they do Billy Vunipola and Ben Morgan.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

sydtheeagle Flag England 30 Sep 15 12.07pm

Good analysis in the Independent too:

We’re talking in the last instance of Sam Burgess, whose skill set does not begin to meet the demands of the role at international level. Yes, he tackled hard – brutally hard at times. Yes, he carried the ball strongly, if no more productively than a dozen other inside centres in this tournament. But he gives no shape to the midfield attack, appears barely capable of playing the kind of part his opposite number Jamie Roberts performed in the build-up to the brilliant try scored by Gareth Davies after 70 minutes, and cannot kick for love nor money. He tried it twice and reduced the crowd to tears in the process. Tears of misery in the case of the England supporters, tears of laughter in the case of the red-shirted hordes from west of the Severn.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Page 11 of 26 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Rugby world cup 2015