You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Southampton Match Thread
November 16 2026 12.00pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Southampton Match Thread


Page 11 of 13 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
citizensmudge Flag midlands 22 Sep 16 2.00am

Originally posted by RDWEagle

Didn't say that, but yes actually I would there is more than one way to motivate somebody, getting players fired up with some home truths is not always the worst thing to do. And actually they should already be highly motivated; by the huge salary they pick up weekly, putting on the palace shirt and being able to do for a living what most of us would lose a bollock for. But back to my point, I was more getting at that I feel it is completely wrong to single anymore out for undeserving exaggerated compliments and it's insulting to the fans, who I don't care what level or competition it is, deserve better. You talk about motivating players but what does false praise do for anyone, yes he tries hard but should Lee be pleased with that performance? Is that the level he should strive for? Can he expect to be a starter or indeed a prem player at all at that level? By AP calling him terrific you're in tern implying the answer to all the above questions be yes, when that simply isn't an honest assessment. Also on motivating players how does that motivate Wilf for example to give his all every game when Chungy gets praise for an uninspiring performance, when the manager is so openly hard on him.

Edited by RDWEagle (22 Sep 2016 12.50am)

Edited by RDWEagle (22 Sep 2016 12.51am)

What you fail to take into consideration is that everyones needs a different approach when it comes to man management.So many people are banging on about individual performances tonight but we made 7 changes from the weekend so how can the likes of Cabaye and even Fryers be judged against those that played on Saturday in a full strength team.AP picking out a positive rather than burying his head in his hands after a performance like that is exactly what I want to see as its down to the manager to raise the spirits and get everyone up for Sunderland.Start slating individuals or blaming bad luck with injuries and everyone starts feeling sorry for themselves and the spirit we rely on is lost.When you consider the luck we have had since January with key players it is mind boggling.Since the window closed its been Remy a few days after we manage to get the deal done,Souare in a car crash followed 10 days later by Tomkins in his home debut and Dann 3 days after that.Not one manager can legislate for that it makes it nigh on impossible for AP when he is desperately trying to improve the squad and the way we play to ensure we keep moving forward.It would be easy to focus the media on our bad luck in his interviews but the players read the papers and watch Sky Sports too and that feeling sorry for ourselves attitude is the last thing that needs to be in the players heads come Saturday.Im sure people will overlook this kind of thing when they debate AP and how good he is as a manager but he never complained when he was at Mike Ashleys Circus and he has never looked sorry for himself here even when we couldn't buy a win.

Edited by citizensmudge (22 Sep 2016 2.01am)

 

RDWEagle Flag 22 Sep 16 3.05am

Originally posted by citizensmudge

What you fail to take into consideration is that everyones needs a different approach when it comes to man management.So many people are banging on about individual performances tonight but we made 7 changes from the weekend so how can the likes of Cabaye and even Fryers be judged against those that played on Saturday in a full strength team.AP picking out a positive rather than burying his head in his hands after a performance like that is exactly what I want to see as its down to the manager to raise the spirits and get everyone up for Sunderland.Start slating individuals or blaming bad luck with injuries and everyone starts feeling sorry for themselves and the spirit we rely on is lost.When you consider the luck we have had since January with key players it is mind boggling.Since the window closed its been Remy a few days after we manage to get the deal done,Souare in a car crash followed 10 days later by Tomkins in his home debut and Dann 3 days after that.Not one manager can legislate for that it makes it nigh on impossible for AP when he is desperately trying to improve the squad and the way we play to ensure we keep moving forward.It would be easy to focus the media on our bad luck in his interviews but the players read the papers and watch Sky Sports too and that feeling sorry for ourselves attitude is the last thing that needs to be in the players heads come Saturday.Im sure people will overlook this kind of thing when they debate AP and how good he is as a manager but he never complained when he was at Mike Ashleys Circus and he has never looked sorry for himself here even when we couldn't buy a win.

Edited by citizensmudge (22 Sep 2016 2.01am)

I get the different player different approach thing completely I was just trying to demonstrate my point. I am all for picking out the positives, and am usually one of the first to do so, at the end of the day I love palace I don't enjoy criticising them. But there is a difference between picking the positives and falsifying them, would you really agree Lee was 'Terrific'?

Anyway I just want a bit more honesty from AP something along the lines of 'We all know tonight wasn't good enough and we are all hurting because of that, Southampton were good but we flattered them. Nobody was at the level tonight, not the level I set as the manager or the level they hold themselves too as superbly gifted professionals. We ARE and WILL be better than that, we take the pain from tonights defeat and heart from Sundays TERRIFIC win in the league to our next game at Sunderland where we will leave it all on the pitch to get a result that our fans deserve'. I am no speech writer but that to me is a much more honest frank assessment, giving the players a kick up the arse whilst not being too scorning or highlighting individuals. As well as trying to take a relatively positive outlook into the next game at the same time as expressing to the fans it was far from good enough. (That would have got a lot more respect from me, and also includes the correct use of the word terrific.) However I am just one fan with an opinion.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 22 Sep 16 3.25am

But why can we not throw in some youngsters in a game like this? Sako and Mutch, please be decent and leave this club...

 

taldous123 Flag Perth 22 Sep 16 3.58am

Originally posted by RDWEagle

I get the different player different approach thing completely I was just trying to demonstrate my point. I am all for picking out the positives, and am usually one of the first to do so, at the end of the day I love palace I don't enjoy criticising them. But there is a difference between picking the positives and falsifying them, would you really agree Lee was 'Terrific'?

Anyway I just want a bit more honesty from AP something along the lines of 'We all know tonight wasn't good enough and we are all hurting because of that, Southampton were good but we flattered them. Nobody was at the level tonight, not the level I set as the manager or the level they hold themselves too as superbly gifted professionals. We ARE and WILL be better than that, we take the pain from tonights defeat and heart from Sundays TERRIFIC win in the league to our next game at Sunderland where we will leave it all on the pitch to get a result that our fans deserve'. I am no speech writer but that to me is a much more honest frank assessment, giving the players a kick up the arse whilst not being too scorning or highlighting individuals. As well as trying to take a relatively positive outlook into the next game at the same time as expressing to the fans it was far from good enough. (That would have got a lot more respect from me, and also includes the correct use of the word terrific.) However I am just one fan with an opinion.

I totally agree. He also did it a few weeks back with Wickham. Said he thought he was terrific when the general consensus was he was poor! He's not been terrific at all this season! It smacks of desperation at times and it is annoying he thinks the fans are silly and don't know an average/poor performance when we see one because we're not "in the game". It makes him look stupid at times as does his tactics/team selections and substitutes.

 


We're the red and blue army!!

citizensmudge Flag midlands 22 Sep 16 5.00am

Originally posted by RDWEagle

I get the different player different approach thing completely I was just trying to demonstrate my point. I am all for picking out the positives, and am usually one of the first to do so, at the end of the day I love palace I don't enjoy criticising them. But there is a difference between picking the positives and falsifying them, would you really agree Lee was 'Terrific'?

Anyway I just want a bit more honesty from AP something along the lines of 'We all know tonight wasn't good enough and we are all hurting because of that, Southampton were good but we flattered them. Nobody was at the level tonight, not the level I set as the manager or the level they hold themselves too as superbly gifted professionals. We ARE and WILL be better than that, we take the pain from tonights defeat and heart from Sundays TERRIFIC win in the league to our next game at Sunderland where we will leave it all on the pitch to get a result that our fans deserve'. I am no speech writer but that to me is a much more honest frank assessment, giving the players a kick up the arse whilst not being too scorning or highlighting individuals. As well as trying to take a relatively positive outlook into the next game at the same time as expressing to the fans it was far from good enough. (That would have got a lot more respect from me, and also includes the correct use of the word terrific.) However I am just one fan with an opinion.

Your opinion is as important as mine or anyone elses but the real difference is we only see the picture from a distance whereas he is up close and personal.Who knows what he said to the players behind closed doors,who knows what the conversation will be when its him and SP in a quiet room discussing last night and performance levels in terms of the club moving forward.You look at how much these fine margins are worth to any club in our position in the PL and why would any one of us believe that we should be entitled to 100 % honesty? In my opinion he had already made his mind up not to be negative in any way should we lose tonight having put out a team that showed where our priorities lie.Saturday is the game we need to win and negative just would not of helped the cause.

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 22 Sep 16 5.49am

Originally posted by citizensmudge

Your opinion is as important as mine or anyone elses but the real difference is we only see the picture from a distance whereas he is up close and personal.Who knows what he said to the players behind closed doors,who knows what the conversation will be when its him and SP in a quiet room discussing last night and performance levels in terms of the club moving forward.You look at how much these fine margins are worth to any club in our position in the PL and why would any one of us believe that we should be entitled to 100 % honesty? In my opinion he had already made his mind up not to be negative in any way should we lose tonight having put out a team that showed where our priorities lie.Saturday is the game we need to win and negative just would not of helped the cause.

So why take the risk of playing talisman, Dann who will be out of Saturday's game due to injury?

 

citizensmudge Flag midlands 22 Sep 16 6.07am

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

So why take the risk of playing talisman, Dann who will be out of Saturday's game due to injury?

Honestly mate its getting out of hand now.Dann,McArthur or anyone else could train tomorrow and break a leg in 3 places what do you suggest hide the 1st 11 under the stairs and wheel them out on a Saturday only? Maybe AP could have rested him as well maybe Dann asked to play when told he wasn't going to we really don't know the circumstances do we.If Tomkins hadn't of been injured on Saturday then it was guaranteed Dann would have been rested but that's the joys of football at any level I'm afraid.One thing is concrete though no one from the supporters through to the manager and owners would of wanted to see Dann limp off so why turn it into a blame game FFS?

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 22 Sep 16 8.07am

I can't help feeling disappointed because the overall team performance last night was so inept.

In my view, irrespective of other priorities (...and we've yet to see how they pan out) we should have put out our best team at the outset with the aim of winning. We can always take players off and rest them if the result is going our way.

That competition was the easiest way to gain entry to the experience and riches of European football and we didn't turn up.

I also feel sorry for our loyal away fans who attended and sang their hearts out.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Sep 16 8.37am

Originally posted by citizensmudge

Honestly mate its getting out of hand now.Dann,McArthur or anyone else could train tomorrow and break a leg in 3 places what do you suggest hide the 1st 11 under the stairs and wheel them out on a Saturday only? Maybe AP could have rested him as well maybe Dann asked to play when told he wasn't going to we really don't know the circumstances do we.If Tomkins hadn't of been injured on Saturday then it was guaranteed Dann would have been rested but that's the joys of football at any level I'm afraid.One thing is concrete though no one from the supporters through to the manager and owners would of wanted to see Dann limp off so why turn it into a blame game FFS?

The reason, and I'm answering other posters in this sentence but the discussion is a follow up to several, Dann played and got injured and for that matter Delaney played and nearly got injured is that Tomkins is injured and we have have 3 centre halves. This is not a criticism but a fact. We also only have 6 defenders plus fryers so you can answer with that if Kelly or Ward got injured.

I'm sorry but we're paying for not backing up the squad enough already. I didn't expect us to be fully backed up with 2 players for every position, but when it was an obvious concern we paid for inadequate backup in midfield last 2nd half of the season it was also obvious this Summer there might be a problem in defence and also attack. Forwards can cost in the £15 mil bracket so if you don't get what you really want, Remy who is proven but not full primed I understand. Hopefully he'll be ready before Benteke maybe cannot play for what I hope will be very temporary.

But it is obvious, Souare car crash or not, because he could be injured himself so that isn't an excuse, 6 defenders isn't enough, and an unready or ready when he has to play at RB Flamini and makeshift LB in Ledley will both stretch things in a midfield that was a concern to begin with.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (22 Sep 2016 8.46am)

 


COYP

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 22 Sep 16 8.40am

Originally posted by cpj

Don't be so bloody pathetic! Probably our best player. One was a pen and the other a follow-up from outside the box after a good save. You really do not have a clue.

Yes! The troll went for my bait. Come on, you're the only one on this site yet to give her view on Mandanda being a much better goalie than Hennessey. Now that you've popped your head above the parapet, what you got to say about the matter?

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Durban Road Eagle Flag 22 Sep 16 8.44am

As a lot of posters seem to think it wasn't such an important Cup, why not play Speroni? - it would have been a record-breaking 389th appearance in goal for the Eagles - surpassing John Jackson's appearances in goal.
I still wish he had been used in goal a year ago when his injury had healed.
Speroni would have passed a record, as did Dann, making his 100th appearance.
I wonder why Jules stays.


Edited by Durban Road Eagle (22 Sep 2016 8.52am)

 


Kentish Maid, born Beckenham, Kent; lifelong Palace supporter.

Painter Flag Croydon 22 Sep 16 9.05am

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

I can't help feeling disappointed because the overall team performance last night was so inept.

In my view, irrespective of other priorities (...and we've yet to see how they pan out) we should have put out our best team at the outset with the aim of winning. We can always take players off and rest them if the result is going our way.

That competition was the easiest way to gain entry to the experience and riches of European football and we didn't turn up.

I also feel sorry for our loyal away fans who attended and sang their hearts out.

What riches of Europe, I understood there is no European place available in this cup anymore, it's been devalued.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 22 Sep 16 9.06am

that display last night made the first half vs Bournemouth look like a world cup winning 45 mins.

If anything, its shown Pardew just who we dont need anymore in the squad.

Wickham needs to buck his ideas up cos he was lazy at best

Fryers? sit him down in a locked room with campbell please.

Mutch?? dont even know what to say about that.

Sako - Sako Sh1te. looked clumsy at best, Cluelessly lumbering about.

SO sad that after Sundays performance, we have to watch such a spineless and effortless 'display'

For once, if it werent for the much maligned Hennessy, we could have gone in at 1/2 time 4 or 5 down.

Edited by paperhat (22 Sep 2016 9.07am)

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


cpj Flag Kent 22 Sep 16 9.22am

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Yes! The troll went for my bait. Come on, you're the only one on this site yet to give her view on Mandanda being a much better goalie than Hennessey. Now that you've popped your head above the parapet, what you got to say about the matter?

How am I a troll? You're the one who has come on here and made a ridiculous statement to start an argument (again). I've only seen Mandanda once - on Saturday. He didn't have much to do so too early for me to judge his merits. However, he did concede a goal so by your argument he must be rubbish! Most people (including the manager) are saying that Hennessey was one of our two best players last night - but of course that doesn't fit into your bizarre mindset. Did he steal your wife or something?

 

cpj Flag Kent 22 Sep 16 9.27am

Originally posted by thai-eagle

But why can we not throw in some youngsters in a game like this? Sako and Mutch, please be decent and leave this club...

Because all our decent youngsters are out on loan. The only ones who could conceivably have been involved are Dreher, Wynter and Randall Williams. All very well for Pardew to praise Southampton's Academy and how they always have youngsters coming through - perhaps he should try playing ours occasionally.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 22 Sep 16 9.31am

Originally posted by cpj

How am I a troll? You're the one who has come on here and made a ridiculous statement to start an argument (again). I've only (1) seen Mandanda once - on Saturday. He didn't have much to do so too early for me to judge his merits. However, he did concede a goal so by your argument he must be rubbish! Most people (including the manager) are saying that (2) Hennessey was one of our two best players last night - but of course that doesn't fit into your bizarre mindset. Did he steal your wife or something?

1) He didn't have a lot to do - mainly cos he played on sunday

2) He didn't have much competition. I'm pretty sure had I played i'd have been one of our top 2 or 3 players.

You can hang around waiting for Mandanda to make a howler then come on here and bin him off but face facts, Steeeeeeev is miles ahead of the leek muncher.

Edited by paperhat (22 Sep 2016 9.33am)

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


citizensmudge Flag midlands 22 Sep 16 10.10am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The reason, and I'm answering other posters in this sentence but the discussion is a follow up to several, Dann played and got injured and for that matter Delaney played and nearly got injured is that Tomkins is injured and we have have 3 centre halves. This is not a criticism but a fact. We also only have 6 defenders plus fryers so you can answer with that if Kelly or Ward got injured.

I'm sorry but we're paying for not backing up the squad enough already. I didn't expect us to be fully backed up with 2 players for every position, but when it was an obvious concern we paid for inadequate backup in midfield last 2nd half of the season it was also obvious this Summer there might be a problem in defence and also attack. Forwards can cost in the £15 mil bracket so if you don't get what you really want, Remy who is proven but not full primed I understand. Hopefully he'll be ready before Benteke maybe cannot play for what I hope will be very temporary.

But it is obvious, Souare car crash or not, because he could be injured himself so that isn't an excuse, 6 defenders isn't enough, and an unready or ready when he has to play at RB Flamini and makeshift LB in Ledley will both stretch things in a midfield that was a concern to begin with.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (22 Sep 2016 8.46am)

You need to look a bit further than what you think Rudi.We have the same amount of defenders currently as we had in the squad for the second half of last season.

Dann....Delaney....Tomkins....Ward....Souare....Kelly ....Fryers.

That is 2 LB's 2 RB's 3 CB's (with Kelly able to play anywhere across the back)

You then have 10 in midfield,an area of concern as well according to you and out of those you have Ledley who is left footed and Flamini who is right footed both of whom have experience of playing at full back off their respective stronger foot.Take those 2 away and you are still left with Cabaye and McArthur as DM's and they are arguably our strongest pairing anyway.You then obviously have our attacking midfield players and the 5 lads in the squad who would be classed as forwards.Appiah and Cambell are included and perhaps that could be seen as a spot wasted not withstanding the fact that it was scoring goals that let us down last season.

My point is when you look at that squad on paper and the options it gives you at the back and in midfield in my opinion it looks a very strong group of players and one that should comfortably see it through till January.When you consider we have strengthened in the areas we all knew we needed to and left some cash to spend in the mid season window.

 

cpj Flag Kent 22 Sep 16 10.18am

Originally posted by paperhat

1) He didn't have a lot to do - mainly cos he played on sunday

2) He didn't have much competition. I'm pretty sure had I played i'd have been one of our top 2 or 3 players.

You can hang around waiting for Mandanda to make a howler then come on here and bin him off but face facts, Steeeeeeev is miles ahead of the leek muncher.

Edited by paperhat (22 Sep 2016 9.33am)

1. typo - you know what I meant (aren't you clever!).
2. how have I had a go at Mandanda? I've only seen him once so to say I haven't yet formed an opinion is a fair comment. Certainly fairer than your racist comment!

 

citizensmudge Flag midlands 22 Sep 16 10.18am

Originally posted by cpj

Because all our decent youngsters are out on loan. The only ones who could conceivably have been involved are Dreher, Wynter and Randall Williams. All very well for Pardew to praise Southampton's Academy and how they always have youngsters coming through - perhaps he should try playing ours occasionally.

Yeah keep them locked up at Beckenham for the year and just let them out for mickey mouse cup games, that will really help their education.When I read comments like this I just imagine a Mr Magoo type of bloke that used to sit behind me and my old man when I was a kid and all he would ever shout was "Get in to em Palace get in to em" at the top of his voice for the entire 90 minutes.Clueless but he got his moneys worth

 

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 22 Sep 16 10.20am

Right, I was at the game last night and I'll give a breakdown of what I thought were positives and negatives:

Positives
- We're out of the EFL Trophy, which is good given how thin our squad so painfully obviously is.
- Hennessey had a very good game, which is always positive.
- Fan-wise, we were too notch last night; sang most of the game (unlike the s*** Saints fans, who I was very disappointed with), gave some very good banter and turned out in similar numbers as the home fans.

Negatives
- Our fringe players are terrible, and Sako, Mutch and Fryers (and preferably Wickham) need to leave.
- It's horribly obvious that our squad is too thin, and that it's even more infuriating that Boateng etc. have gone on loan.
- Scott Dann is f***ing injured in a f***ing pointless game.

Overall, we might as well have forfeited, despite that, I actually had a good time as our fans actually bothered in creating an atmosphere.

Edited by Dan1994 (22 Sep 2016 10.22am)

 


[Link]

Page 11 of 13 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Southampton Match Thread