You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Benteke to be sold
November 16 2026 10.51am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Benteke to be sold


Page 11 of 12 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Teo15 Flag 15 Jan 17 10.20am

Agree we should try both him and remy upfront! But he's needs to step up and make more effort, he can't just rely on people crossing the ball to him all the time, he should be making things happen on his own for the price we paid for him wouldn't hurt to see a few solo runs in on goal it's not like he's slow.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 15 Jan 17 10.23am

Originally posted by 60 yrs a palace fan

Absolute bollocks.

The man is a class striker.

Its the dross thats around him, not feeding him thats the problem.

Why do they keep lofting the ball up to him when theres no ones around him for the knockdowns.

It wont get any better till we get the delivery to him better.

Benteke and Remy have loads of goals in them if they get the service.

Fact

Totally agree.
If FFS WAS getting this service people would be up in arms.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Glazier#1 Flag 15 Jan 17 10.28am

We can not afford the luxury of having players in the side not pulling their weight. That's my first point. CB is lazy. He should be making life really difficult for defenders when they have the ball. He doesn't. He lopes lazily. No presence.

Secondly, we can not afford the luxury of having a striker whose sole job is to score goals. Modern football will not tolerate this. To be up top on his own, he needs to be available to hit and it shouldn't matter how the ball arrives. It is his role to get it under control in an instant, keep possession and then either turn and go himself or bring others into it. He doesn't

No matter how he receives the ball he just doesn't get it under. We all know what a successful target man looks like. If we think of Drogba, Sparky Mark Hughes of old ,Diego Costa they are/were mobile skillful and able to do whatever they need to bring others into the game or go for goal themselves. It doesn't hold water that he only gets the ball drilled t him 'with snow on it'. The fcat is, even when the ball is on the deck, his control is woefully inadequate.

It is unbelievable how unable CB is to simply control the ball, hold it and link with others.

Ok, just say he does none of all that but gets 20 goals a season. He would need good service from both flanks to achieve that. We are not in a position to offer such service at the moment and so we are left with a striker who looks out of his depth, a massive bulk offering a lightweight threat.

I am astonished that I never saw his shortcomings before we signed him but there again, he wasn't playing regularly for Liverpool.

Now I understand why.

Edited by Glazier#1 (15 Jan 2017 10.30am)

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 15 Jan 17 10.32am

I actually saw an improvement in the side yesterday. We looked comfortable for 70mins until Hennesseys f*** up. Remi looked sharp and I think if he keeps fit will be vital for us

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 15 Jan 17 10.34am

Originally posted by Lyons550

I actually saw an improvement in the side yesterday. We looked comfortable for 70mins until Hennesseys f*** up. Remi looked sharp and I think if he keeps fit will be vital for us

Agreed with you.
We were in no trouble until our keeper did that IMO.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

jeeagles Flag 15 Jan 17 10.36am

He would be a quality striker if he through himself about a bit more. That was evident a few times this season. A guy his size has to be bullying the defence like Glenn Murray used to.

There was a notable difference between the amount of effort Carroll was putting in yesterday, and when Campbell came on against Swansea and when Wickham came on against Man City to name a few.

Unless there is a drastic change soon I think if we get a decent offer in we should sell him and look to replace him with the likes of Carroll or Mitrovic. We need to add a bit of aggression to the side and lazy players bring down the moral of the whole club.

 

TJ Flag Croydon 15 Jan 17 10.36am

I think most Palace fans are in agreement that on his day he is a top striker who isn't being given enough (if anything) by our midfield however he is also lazy and does not work hard enough for a team that's really struggling at the moment. Too much half hearted jogging etc when he should be calling for the ball if we're in possession or pressurising defenders if we're out of it

 

chateauferret Flag 15 Jan 17 10.59am

Originally posted by TJ

I think most Palace fans are in agreement that on his day he is a top striker who isn't being given enough (if anything) by our midfield however he is also lazy and does not work hard enough for a team that's really struggling at the moment. Too much half hearted jogging etc when he should be calling for the ball if we're in possession or pressurising defenders if we're out of it

I thought that about Adebayor but this is worse.

 


============
The Ferret
============

You What Flag se25 15 Jan 17 11.11am

Originally posted by TJ

I think most Palace fans are in agreement that on his day he is a top striker who isn't being given enough (if anything) by our midfield however he is also lazy and does not work hard enough for a team that's really struggling at the moment. Too much half hearted jogging etc when he should be calling for the ball if we're in possession or pressurising defenders if we're out of it

Spot on and for the money he is on that is not good enough.

 

BelfastEagle Flag 15 Jan 17 11.49am

As there now appear to be several interested parties hopefully we can get back what we paid.

PSG would possibly appeal to him ?

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 15 Jan 17 12.03pm

His performances are entirely consistent with someone who doesn't want to be at the club.

And we are not good enough to carry a player that doesn't put in a shift.

If we can line up a replacement and recoup what we spent, let him go.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Rainforest Flag London England 15 Jan 17 12.09pm

Or has he lost the pace he had when he was at Villa ?
Unfortunately, our back 4 also lack pace hence the difficulty for them to track back fast enough to stop a oppo counter attack.

 

Den1923 Flag 15 Jan 17 2.23pm

Originally posted by 60 yrs a palace fan

Absolute bollocks.

The man is a class striker.

Its the dross thats around him, not feeding him thats the problem.

Why do they keep lofting the ball up to him when theres no ones around him for the knockdowns.

It wont get any better till we get the delivery to him better.

Benteke and Remy have loads of goals in them if they get the service.

Fact

Yes,2nd class, no one wanted him Klopp knew hew was lazy, not worth 32mil, another fine example of an AP flop from Klopp!

 

eagle@ tn34 Flag hastings 15 Jan 17 11.32pm

Originally posted by Glazier#1

We can not afford the luxury of having players in the side not pulling their weight. That's my first point. CB is lazy. He should be making life really difficult for defenders when they have the ball. He doesn't. He lopes lazily. No presence.

Secondly, we can not afford the luxury of having a striker whose sole job is to score goals. Modern football will not tolerate this. To be up top on his own, he needs to be available to hit and it shouldn't matter how the ball arrives. It is his role to get it under control in an instant, keep possession and then either turn and go himself or bring others into it. He doesn't

No matter how he receives the ball he just doesn't get it under. We all know what a successful target man looks like. If we think of Drogba, Sparky Mark Hughes of old ,Diego Costa they are/were mobile skillful and able to do whatever they need to bring others into the game or go for goal themselves. It doesn't hold water that he only gets the ball drilled t him 'with snow on it'. The fcat is, even when the ball is on the deck, his control is woefully inadequate.

It is unbelievable how unable CB is to simply control the ball, hold it and link with others.

Ok, just say he does none of all that but gets 20 goals a season. He would need good service from both flanks to achieve that. We are not in a position to offer such service at the moment and so we are left with a striker who looks out of his depth, a massive bulk offering a lightweight threat.

I am astonished that I never saw his shortcomings before we signed him but there again, he wasn't playing regularly for Liverpool.

Now I understand why.

Edited by Glazier#1 (15 Jan 2017 10.30am)


This.
Even the commentators on the radio said benteke needed to get a yellow card to prove that he was actually on the pitch.

 

Holmesdalehorace Flag Christchurch 16 Jan 17 8.49am

I think some of you are mental .... benteke was bought as a focal point and a goal scorer .... both of which he is capable of . Lumping it forward to him aimlessly isn't the answer. I'm hoping if remy starts we can play them both ... remy running the channels etc. Need to lineup 4-4-2 . We will score goals! Our major problem is no presence in the side , pardews biggest mistake was selling jedinak , our captain and soul of club, scotty dann isn't up to that job I'm afraid

 

Den1923 Flag 16 Jan 17 11.43am

Originally posted by Holmesdalehorace

I think some of you are mental .... benteke was bought as a focal point and a goal scorer .... both of which he is capable of . Lumping it forward to him aimlessly isn't the answer. I'm hoping if remy starts we can play them both ... remy running the channels etc. Need to lineup 4-4-2 . We will score goals! Our major problem is no presence in the side , pardews biggest mistake was selling jedinak , our captain and soul of club, scotty dann isn't up to that job I'm afraid

Benteke was bought to feed AP ego, he believed that he would help him get a to six finish. The facts Benteke is not worth 27-32mil we paid for him and to be honest no one else wanted him either at that price, Klopp knew he had very little energy, did not like running or working the defence when he did not have the ball, his floor play was poor, his passing and ability to hold up play poor just not worth the money, his rating are usually 5 or below in the press and he cannot be relied upon to take penalty kicks all in all not a very good striker, sorry but you have to believe it!

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 16 Jan 17 11.51am

Originally posted by bexleydave


I think you make some good points and I'd definitely try Benteke and Remy together. If you've had a look at the video someone posted from when Benteke was at Villa, you will see the sort of service he thrives on. Simple crosses from the wing (and not all at head height) and simple through balls.

In my opinion this 'inverted winger', cutting in business is a load of over-complicated nonsense (and I've heard the arguments about 'overlapping fullbacks'. When we played Bolasie on the left and Zaha on the right (i.e. on the side that matched their footedness), we got better quality crosses in and Souare and Ward used to be able to overlap them as well; we just didn't have the quality of striker to stick the ball in the net. Now we do, but are starving the front-runners of service.

If we go back to good old fashioned no nonsense defending and hitting on the counter, we'll start winning games. We tried to run before we could walk and we just need to get back to basics and doing what we do well.


Agree 100% It was worth try to evolve our style but as soon as we saw it wasn't working we should have reined it back

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

The Royster Flag Peterborough 16 Jan 17 11.57am

What a good idea. We should beg N/castle to let us have Gayle back. But then would Gayle want to play in the Championship having scored so many goals to get N/castle back in prem. I'm struggling to understand why we've waited so long for Remy to get fit to see him on the bench, Wickham always injured. African C O N could be played closed season. As for West Ham result, I get the feeling Sam's met his match here.

 

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 16 Jan 17 11.58am

Originally posted by The Royster

What a good idea. We should beg N/castle to let us have Gayle back. But then would Gayle want to play in the Championship having scored so many goals to get N/castle back in prem. I'm struggling to understand why we've waited so long for Remy to get fit to see him on the bench, Wickham always injured. African C O N could be played closed season. As for West Ham result, I get the feeling Sam's met his match here.

I reckon Gayle would be delighted considering he's found his level.....

Anyway. 4-4 fcking 2

 


@sxp55555

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 16 Jan 17 3.19pm

People digging out Benteke for being Benteke. It's how he plays and maybe right now we need to give him more support up there? How would anyone feel if we went in for Shane Long? To my mind he's exactly what we need up front with Christian and he's a nasty aggressive b****** and we sorely lack those. Just a thought.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Page 11 of 12 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Benteke to be sold