You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ref: Palace v Burnley
November 16 2026 9.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ref: Palace v Burnley


Page 11 of 14 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
PremierPalace Flag 02 May 17 5.51pm

Originally posted by Willo

What should he have done ?
Be rude and ignore him ?
Reading far too much into this.

Anyway, must go out now and deliver some Tory leaflets for the local elections !

He certainly shouldn't be hugging an joining in with bribery mimes

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 May 17 6.16pm

Originally posted by PremierPalace


He certainly shouldn't be hugging an joining in with bribery mimes

Ridiculous.

 

PremierPalace Flag 02 May 17 7.13pm

Originally posted by Willo

Ridiculous.

It was, yes.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 May 17 7.29pm

Originally posted by PremierPalace

It was, yes.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 02 May 17 8.26pm

Originally posted by Willo

He meant the actions, believe me he wasnt agreeing with you

 

chateauferret Flag 02 May 17 8.29pm

Especially when you take into account the disgusting performance he then gave.

These people should not only be whiter than white - they should be seen to be whiter than white. Otherwise accusations can be made which undermine confidence in them, whether they're up to anything or not.

Refs and managers should know the score and should be grown up enough not to think it "rude" to avoid social contact in public immediately before a cup final.

Especially if the referee is bent.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 02 May 17 8.54pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Especially when you take into account the disgusting performance he then gave.

These people should not only be whiter than white - they should be seen to be whiter than white. Otherwise accusations can be made which undermine confidence in them, whether they're up to anything or not.

Refs and managers should know the score and should be grown up enough not to think it "rude" to avoid social contact in public immediately before a cup final.

Especially if the referee is bent.


Ferguson knew EXACTLY what he was doing. With a hug and a joke, he was reinforcing to Clattenberg which team was supposed to win.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 02 May 17 9.27pm

Originally posted by Willo

Ridiculous.

not at all, he was filmed doing it, even you cant deny photographic evidence! And FYI your hero actually admitted making errors in the cup final, something you deny! Who is correct?

 

bodge Flag 02 May 17 9.53pm

Wilf was fouled twice one was a pen the other a red card. We have had some go our way so its evened out to a degee. We do owe Hull one for the Snodgrass dive not the refs fault that one just cheating.

 

PremierPalace Flag 02 May 17 10.36pm

Originally posted by Willo

How can you possibly defend that? An impartial official with such power over any preceding should never been seen beforehand laughing and joking with a high profile member of either party, especially if it involves the miming of putting money into a short pocket, ala bribery. It was deeply unprofessional, and yes, he should have told Ferguson that it was neither the time nor the place. He had a job to do, something that if he had been focussed on he maybe couldn't have done better (learning the advantage rule might have been a start).

It's no secret that you think he is an amazing ref, fair enough that's your opinion and you're entitled to that, but to blindly defend the man seems insane. Surely you can see how unprofessional that is? Sadly it's not a one off though, as we have seen him constantly calling players at big clubs, most notably United by their first names, such as 'Wayne' but in the same game calling less fashionable players (like Ledley, as I can recall one game) "number 28". This cannot possibly be seen as impartial, and smacks of him wanting to cosy up and be friends with the cool kids on the playground.

If a judge were to act in this way, calling one side by a first name or nickname, and was seen doing what Clattenburg did with Ferguson before the cup final, they would be struck off the case straight away, and probably lose their job, depending on the severity. Whilst this is different to referees it shows that impartiality is key. Especially in a game where millions upon millions of pounds are involved.

It's a shame, these referees do not help themselves or their colleagues with these actions, and thus have made people very wary about their trustworthiness.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 May 17 11.13pm

Originally posted by PremierPalace

How can you possibly defend that? An impartial official with such power over any preceding should never been seen beforehand laughing and joking with a high profile member of either party, especially if it involves the miming of putting money into a short pocket, ala bribery. It was deeply unprofessional, and yes, he should have told Ferguson that it was neither the time nor the place. He had a job to do, something that if he had been focussed on he maybe couldn't have done better (learning the advantage rule might have been a start).

It's no secret that you think he is an amazing ref, fair enough that's your opinion and you're entitled to that, but to blindly defend the man seems insane. Surely you can see how unprofessional that is? Sadly it's not a one off though, as we have seen him constantly calling players at big clubs, most notably United by their first names, such as 'Wayne' but in the same game calling less fashionable players (like Ledley, as I can recall one game) "number 28". This cannot possibly be seen as impartial, and smacks of him wanting to cosy up and be friends with the cool kids on the playground.

If a judge were to act in this way, calling one side by a first name or nickname, and was seen doing what Clattenburg did with Ferguson before the cup final, they would be struck off the case straight away, and probably lose their job, depending on the severity. Whilst this is different to referees it shows that impartiality is key. Especially in a game where millions upon millions of pounds are involved.

It's a shame, these referees do not help themselves or their colleagues with these actions, and thus have made people very wary about their trustworthiness.

What a load of old hogwash and rhetorical grandstanding in equal measures.
Certainly chimerical and a rambling farrago of nonsense.
I'm certainly not going to dignify the post by responding to the points raised.
I believe the propogation of absolute tosh is NOT worthy of any considered response.

Edited by Willo (02 May 2017 11.13pm)

 

chateauferret Flag 02 May 17 11.22pm

This, absolutely.

Players like "Wayne" are a big part of the problem too. We have seen situations where it looked like he was changing the referee's mind or "reminding" him of things that weren't true - there was one wasn't there when "Wayne" "reminded" the referee to send a Bournemouth defender off or something and to "forget" Ibrahimovic' part in the incident - constantly getting in the ref's ear like Wormtongue in Theoden's in The Two Towers.

Any referee worth his salt should stop him dead in his tracks and tell him to muzzle it or be booked.

 


============
The Ferret
============

chateauferret Flag 02 May 17 11.38pm

Originally posted by Willo

What a load of old hogwash and rhetorical grandstanding in equal measures.
Certainly chimerical and a rambling farrago of nonsense.
I'm certainly not going to dignify the post by responding to the points raised.
I believe the propogation of absolute tosh is NOT worthy of any considered response.

Edited by Willo (02 May 2017 11.13pm)

FFS, Willo. Premier made a very well constructed, balanced and cogent argument about why Clattenburg's behaviour was entirely inappropriate and how it reasonably looked in the context of his disgusting treatment of the FA Cup Final which he took charge of some minutes afterward.

You know darned well that you haven't the remotest hope of defending his conduct, and his performance he himself subsequently admitted was poor. You also know darned well how Palace fans (real Palace fans that is - not trolls like you) feel about the way we were treated that day yet give no more of a damn about that than a weed fan would.

All you can do is sit there crying "Tosh", "Hogwash" and "nonsense" and throwing your toys around like some great baby who's lost his dummy. It's just noise. You "won't dignify the post by responding" because you can't. That post doesn't need you to dignify it. It's thoroughly dignified as it is. It's also as concrete as anything - clearly, you wouldn't recognise "rhetorical grandstanding" (another two of your favourite words) if it hit you squarely in the chimps. And the only person who's propogating absolute tosh is you, because you haven't a shred of evidence for anything you say, and you know it.

You are out of order, and that's being polite.


Edited by chateauferret (02 May 2017 11.47pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

EagleLee79 Flag Mablethorpe, Lincs 02 May 17 11.40pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

This, absolutely.

Players like "Wayne" are a big part of the problem too. We have seen situations where it looked like he was changing the referee's mind or "reminding" him of things that weren't true - there was one wasn't there when "Wayne" "reminded" the referee to send a Bournemouth defender off or something and to "forget" Ibrahimovic' part in the incident - constantly getting in the ref's ear like Wormtongue in Theoden's in The Two Towers.

Any referee worth his salt should stop him dead in his tracks and tell him to muzzle it or be booked.

Agree with this.

Refs need to stop being so 'pally pally' with players and just be a referee who can do their job properly. Take no s*** from players like Rooney who are constantly moaning in his ear all the time when things arent going his way. Tell him to f*** off and let him do HIS job or book the c***!

 


Add me on Xbox One or PS4 - Eaglelee79

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 May 17 12.25am

Originally posted by chateauferret

FFS, Willo. Premier made a very well constructed, balanced and cogent argument about why Clattenburg's behaviour was entirely inappropriate and how it reasonably looked in the context of his disgusting treatment of the FA Cup Final which he took charge of some minutes afterward.

You know darned well that you haven't the remotest hope of defending his conduct, and his performance he himself subsequently admitted was poor. You also know darned well how Palace fans (real Palace fans that is - not trolls like you) feel about the way we were treated that day yet give no more of a damn about that than a weed fan would.

All you can do is sit there crying "Tosh", "Hogwash" and "nonsense" and throwing your toys around like some great baby who's lost his dummy. It's just noise. You "won't dignify the post by responding" because you can't. That post doesn't need you to dignify it. It's thoroughly dignified as it is. It's also as concrete as anything - clearly, you wouldn't recognise "rhetorical grandstanding" (another two of your favourite words) if it hit you squarely in the chimps. And the only person who's propogating absolute tosh is you, because you haven't a shred of evidence for anything you say, and you know it.

You are out of order, and that's being polite.


Edited by chateauferret (02 May 2017 11.47pm)

NOT "Out of order at all".

I have expressed my honest opinions in my own way and I shall treat some of the risible allegations with the contempt they deserve.

And I have already commented in detail about the incidents in the Final so I really dont need to plough the same "Acres" until the rhetorical soil acquires the texture of sub-standard mince.

You certainly will NOT rile the old "Billy Goat" in me by some of the ludicrous and totally inaccurate allegations which in all honesty have the heady ether of effluvia.Broadbrush, blustery bombastications and risible canards appear to be "Order of the day" as far as you are concerned with high-grade waffle also on your agenda.

At the end of the day I argue my 'Case' free from ad-hominem personal attacks against someone's honesty and integrity which in truth poison the well of debate.

On that note I shall now go to my bed, free in the knowledge that like some on here I have NOT propogated palbable tosh as part of an agenda of personal vilification.

I am sure you will be delighted to be informed that I shall NOT dignify any of your posts with a response as they are as inaccurate as they are risible and one's time can be spent more constructively than by replying to such hogwash.
Any further posts of yours regarding "Yours Truly" shall go unanswered as I have NO desire to place your comments into the 'Spotlight'.Sorry to disappoint you.



Edited by Willo (03 May 2017 12.43am)

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 03 May 17 6.51am

Originally posted by Willo

NOT "Out of order at all".

I have expressed my honest opinions in my own way and I shall treat some of the risible allegations with the contempt they deserve.

And I have already commented in detail about the incidents in the Final so I really dont need to plough the same "Acres" until the rhetorical soil acquires the texture of sub-standard mince.

You certainly will NOT rile the old "Billy Goat" in me by some of the ludicrous and totally inaccurate allegations which in all honesty have the heady ether of effluvia.Broadbrush, blustery bombastications and risible canards appear to be "Order of the day" as far as you are concerned with high-grade waffle also on your agenda.

At the end of the day I argue my 'Case' free from ad-hominem personal attacks against someone's honesty and integrity which in truth poison the well of debate.

On that note I shall now go to my bed, free in the knowledge that like some on here I have NOT propogated palbable tosh as part of an agenda of personal vilification.

I am sure you will be delighted to be informed that I shall NOT dignify any of your posts with a response as they are as inaccurate as they are risible and one's time can be spent more constructively than by replying to such hogwash.
Any further posts of yours regarding "Yours Truly" shall go unanswered as I have NO desire to place your comments into the 'Spotlight'.Sorry to disappoint you.



Edited by Willo (03 May 2017 12.43am)


What a load of bollocks! What happened , did someone give you a thesaurus for your birthday. Are you trying to impress us with your big words?? Well it didnt work, the post is bollocks!

 

chateauferret Flag 03 May 17 7.28am

Originally posted by the silurian


What a load of bollocks! What happened , did someone give you a thesaurus for your birthday. Are you trying to impress us with your big words?? Well it didnt work, the post is bollocks!

I thought I was the one who wasn't allowed to use fancy words.

 


============
The Ferret
============

chateauferret Flag 03 May 17 7.33am

Originally posted by Willo

NOT "Out of order at all".

Blah blah blah blah same old rubbish as before.


Edited by Willo (03 May 2017 12.43am)

Keeps telling us off for "grandstanding" and posting "hogwash" and at the same time posting rants like this one.

Pathetic.

 


============
The Ferret
============

PremierPalace Flag 03 May 17 8.39am

Originally posted by Willo

What a load of old hogwash and rhetorical grandstanding in equal measures.
Certainly chimerical and a rambling farrago of nonsense.
I'm certainly not going to dignify the post by responding to the points raised.
I believe the propogation of absolute tosh is NOT worthy of any considered response.

Edited by Willo (02 May 2017 11.13pm)

Oh Willo, you're so frustrating.

Many in the past have come out and absolutely slated the man, calling him every name under the sun, and whilst some would see that as fair game, I made a point of not using such fallacies, as I knew you would not respond the post. Therefore I find it rather odd that a man of your age and intelligence could not 'dignify' me with an appropriate response. Had I come out and insulted either you or Clattenburg then fine, but I did neither. I just said that a man in a position of power acted unprofessionally, in a high profile event, and was caught in camera doing so. This unfortunately opened him up to criticism, especially when he went on to make mistakes that went in one teams favour (mistakes that he has admitted).

Ironically you always like to bash users and their use of insults instead of valid arguments, yet when one does you instead call 'hogwash' and 'rambling'. As I said before, a man of your intelligence should be able to see that there was no rambling, just a highly thought out point, that I posed to you. Clattenburg acted unprofessionally, as was commented on by many people in the game at the time, and I struggle to see how you can see it a shame anything but that, and unfortunately you still haven't aired this view.

It's a shame Willo, because I genuinely wanted to hear how you could view that as anything other than unprofessional, perhaps we're all missing something, but instead you chose to attack a post that tried to have an actual debate with you (rather than just attacking)... alas you stopped to the level of those you crucify on here.

 

PremierPalace Flag 03 May 17 8.42am

Originally posted by chateauferret

This, absolutely.

Players like "Wayne" are a big part of the problem too. We have seen situations where it looked like he was changing the referee's mind or "reminding" him of things that weren't true - there was one wasn't there when "Wayne" "reminded" the referee to send a Bournemouth defender off or something and to "forget" Ibrahimovic' part in the incident - constantly getting in the ref's ear like Wormtongue in Theoden's in The Two Towers.

Any referee worth his salt should stop him dead in his tracks and tell him to muzzle it or be booked.

This. Yet to see a game where he's playing and isn't in the refs face. Rooney refereed that cup final as much as Clattenburg. Every decision he ran straight over to him gobbling off, and it's worse when they're losing.

He seems to go red/purple and look like a kid on the playground not getting his way and throwing a tantrum - quite amusing really

 

Page 11 of 14 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ref: Palace v Burnley