You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Liverpool Match Thread
November 16 2026 7.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Liverpool Match Thread


Page 11 of 13 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
Elpis Flag In a pub 21 Aug 18 6.03am

Originally posted by SwordFish

I’m sorry but after tonight’s atmospheric performance they really are the club and what it is based on “our famous atmosphere”

Anyone who thinks different is a wally

Not for me .I don't go to see a group of fans jumping up and down nor to see the colourful (very good) displays that have been created . I go to watch the team ,the players ,the match .

The atmosphere could have been better but was not poor and Im sure a goal would have resulted in a rocking Selhurst .


Thought we played well , well enough to get a draw against a team that was in The European cup final last season .Cant be too down with our performance and that we lost to a very soft penalty (ignoring the late breakaway after we had overcommitted ) makes me confident about the season ahead .


 

Dave58 Flag Ipswich 21 Aug 18 6.30am

No shame in losing to a team that will probably finish runners up this year.
A lot of effort was put in by most of the team. A dubious penalty and Townsend hitting the bar, meant it could have been different.
Whilst I admire Roy’s loyalty to Benteke, it is clear he is not up to it. Sorloth looks lightweight. Definitely time for Ayew to be given a chance against Watford.
The league cup match against Swansea will hopefully give some run out time to Mayer.
Wan Bissau’s is pure class. Hennessy looks solid. Some positives.

 

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 21 Aug 18 6.46am

Originally posted by lefty27
I used to think like you until I saw VAR in action in Italy. We are delusional if we think it will level up the playing field. In reality the top 6 will still get the marginal decisions and the rest will be even less likely to get them. It will be a dark day when VAR arrives.

I'd like the world cup edition of VAR please, where decisions improved considerably. I agree that bigger clubs will get more because they're in the penalty area more often with better players.

At least I won't feel as cheated by referees as I do now.

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

Casual Flag Orpington 21 Aug 18 6.56am

Thought first half we matched them. Looked really good, the passing was so fast and everyone wanted the ball. Very good performance against a good side. We will win a lot of games playing like that.
When you think the cost of their keeper (how comfortable is he on the ball ?!) could pretty much pay for the new stand , we did well.

 

The Dolphin Flag 21 Aug 18 8.29am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3361601]

Straight red, three match ban if contested and lost.

One match if we don't contest.

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (20 Aug 2018 11.13pm)

Straight red is three anyway isn't it??

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Aug 18 8.31am

I believe we did enough to get a share of the spoils against a team who many believe will be serious challengers to Man C.Having lost however, it is important that we get get something from the Watford game.

A lot of positives but the usual negative of Benteke.
Admittedly he was against one of the top defenders in the world in Van Dijk but unfortunately it was the same old story with him.

 

The Dolphin Flag 21 Aug 18 8.53am

The calm after the storm.
Milner wipes out Wilf and no free kick.
PVA tackles Milner, Ref waves play on but the Lino calls it and PVA gets booked!!!!!
Penalty - probably just.
Red card - in normal time yes - in slow mo maybe a yellow - maybe.
We did well overall but paid them too much respect in the first half.
Benteke is just not good enough. He has some real park football moments which are just not acceptable at this level I'm afraid. He has to be sold in the next window as he will cost us points this season.
Schlupp and Townsend will have better games.
I want to see Meyer play.
Hacked off this morning for what might have been but then I think - hey - I could be a West Ham fan and then I feel better!!

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 21 Aug 18 8.59am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Straight red is three anyway isn't it??

I know its the Current, but, here ya go . . .

[Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 21 Aug 18 9.00am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Straight red is three anyway isn't it??

3 match ban for violent conduct / dangerous tackle.

One match ban for stopping opponent through on goal.
(although Oliver will probably say Bissaka was running dangerously behind Salah)

 

johnno42000 Flag 21 Aug 18 9.28am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

3 match ban for violent conduct / dangerous tackle.

One match ban for stopping opponent through on goal.
(although Oliver will probably say Bissaka was running dangerously behind Salah)

Probably say he was carrying an Uzi.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

The Dolphin Flag 21 Aug 18 9.34am

Okay.
If it is only one game then we suck it up and give Ward a run out.
We will really notice the difference though!

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 21 Aug 18 9.53am

Originally posted by boo909

No he clipped him with his foot the second time, it was a penalty, 100%. It could have maybe tried a bit harder to stay on his feet but why? If Wilf had done that there'd be no moaning.

From my seat in the Holmesdale and subsequently on TV never a pen. Just because there is contact it doesn't mean it's a foul (football is a contact sport remember). The contact made in that instance wouldn't be enough to send him down and he dived IMO.

Similarly just because a player doesn't go down doesn't mean it isn't a foul, but in this case players were going for the ball and Salah felt a touch and dived rather than try and get a shot away.

Edited by CambridgeEagle (21 Aug 2018 10.04am)

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 21 Aug 18 10.01am

[quote=bright&wright;3361540]

Nah I’d rather have just moved those out of block E, given the HF what they wanted and had an atmosphere, than that sh*t show tonight.

Must have been at a different game to me. Thought it was a good atmosphere myself. Nice not t have that f*****g drum banging all game

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 21 Aug 18 10.05am

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

From my seat in the Holmesdale and subsequently on TV never a pen. Just because there is contact it doesn't mean it's a foul. The contact made in that instance wouldn't be enough to send him down and he dived IMO.

Similarly just because a player doesn't go down doesn't mean it isn't a foul, but in this case players were going for the ball and Salah felt a touch and dived rather than try and get a shot away.

The way i saw it, Sakho stretched for the ball and Salah used the leg to make contact and dive. Very clever way to win a penalty.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Aug 18 10.11am

In terms of the incident with Sakho and Salah, firstly Sakho gets far too tight with the Liverpool player who is very strong and very difficult to shake off the ball.

Salah is always looking to cut in on to his left foot so Sakho would have been better advised to take a step to his right perhaps forcing Salah inside onto his weaker right foot and then Sakho might have been able to get a tackle in with his stronger left foot.Sakho allowed Salah on to Salah's strong foot then Sakho was off balance and stretching legs apart tackling with his weaker right foot and made contact with Salah which resulted in the penalty.

Michael Oliver could not have been better placed to see the incident.Speaking after the game and also over-hearing supporters, the decision split opinion !

Edited by Willo (21 Aug 2018 10.15am)

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 21 Aug 18 10.26am

Originally posted by Willo

In terms of the incident with Sakho and Salah, firstly Sakho gets far too tight with the Liverpool player who is very strong and very difficult to shake off the ball.

Salah is always looking to cut in on to his left foot so Sakho would have been better advised to take a step to his right perhaps forcing Salah inside onto his weaker right foot and then Sakho might have been able to get a tackle in with his stronger left foot.Sakho allowed Salah on to Salah's strong foot then Sakho was off balance and stretching legs apart tackling with his weaker right foot and made contact with Salah which resulted in the penalty.

Michael Oliver could not have been better placed to see the incident.Speaking after the game and also over-hearing supporters, the decision split opinion !

Edited by Willo (21 Aug 2018 10.15am)


Rubbish, you have to get really tight to salah, you can't give him any space. Plus from that distance he's just as good with both feet. Watch the replay, Sakho doesn't kick Salah, Salah falls over sakhos foot, clever play from a clever cheat. As for dividing opinion, from the reaction of the crowd and their chants, I'm not sure too many thought it was a penalty.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Aug 18 10.37am

Originally posted by spartakev2


Rubbish, you have to get really tight to salah, you can't give him any space. Plus from that distance he's just as good with both feet. Watch the replay, Sakho doesn't kick Salah, Salah falls over sakhos foot, clever play from a clever cheat. As for dividing opinion, from the reaction of the crowd and their chants, I'm not sure too many thought it was a penalty.

With respect, I wasn't advocating that Sakho should not have got close to Salah to deny him space but he got so tight that Salah was able to use his strength and roll him.Speaking to a friend a few moments ago, he watched the game on TV and said that Gary Neville felt that Sakho got too tight and he knows a thing or two about defending !

I spoke to some people at half-time and at the end of the game, some thought it was a penalty,some thought they could see why it was given and I over-heard such a contrast of opinions as well.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 21 Aug 18 10.58am

I think Sakho gave Salah the opportunity to take a dive, and minimal contact these days is enough to invite that.

I was just as disappointed with the decision against PVA shortly before that, and the free kick ultimately led to the penalty.

I'm trying hard not to critisise the officials but my perception was the Oliver was itching to give that penalty.


The penalty and the second goal when we were chasing the game aside, we gave a very good Liverpool team a tough game.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 21 Aug 18 11.25am

Good article from Ed Maylon about our prospects this season based on last nights showing

[Link]

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 21 Aug 18 12.13pm

Originally posted by Willo

With respect, I wasn't advocating that Sakho should not have got close to Salah to deny him space but he got so tight that Salah was able to use his strength and roll him.Speaking to a friend a few moments ago, he watched the game on TV and said that Gary Neville felt that Sakho got too tight and he knows a thing or two about defending !

I spoke to some people at half-time and at the end of the game, some thought it was a penalty,some thought they could see why it was given and I over-heard such a contrast of opinions as well.

I don't disagree that there was some contact and from Oliver's angle it may have appeared an obvious impediment of a player with the ball under control, but from my POV it was a poor decision and a clear dive. In fairness we benefited from one against Fulham which could easily have been a penalty.

The red card I think was also questionable given Salah appeared to have lost control of the ball prior to contact so no goalscoring opportunity denied and then went over like an extra in Platoon, however in real time that's hard to call and I thought it was a Red from the Holmesdale (very far away I grant) at the time. I'd hope though that if it were contested a sensible observed would see that the contact didn't actually prevent a goalscoring opportunity and it wasn't dangerous or anything like that and so a yellow rather than a Red.

 

Page 11 of 13 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Liverpool Match Thread