You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Southampton Match Thread
November 16 2026 6.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Southampton Match Thread


Page 11 of 14 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
ItsCPFCforme Flag 30 Jan 19 10.22pm

I would have taken a point beforehand. But the way that game panned out is a shame. Shocking referee and Wilf being a div.

Still, better position in Re: Bottom 3 compared to last game so will look at the positives.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 30 Jan 19 10.23pm

Not looking good for the Fulham game even without Zaha out for that match (only one game ban for 2 yellows?)

Guess if Sako is fit he will replace him on Saturday

The managers faith in Ayew and Schlupp is really depressing - neither are PL calibre players.

Surely 45 mins from Wickham or Benteke was obvious?
To you and me maybe but not the manager who looks increasingly like the old man he is.

 


Man and boy Palace since my first game in 1948 sitting on my dad's shoulders

kev64 Flag Cambs 30 Jan 19 10.23pm

Originally posted by EagleinSF

Wow - what can I say. That was the worst refereeing I've ever seen - and there have been some bad ones.

Did Wilf let himself down - Possibly...

I'm enraged and I was only watching, I didn't get the S**t kicked out of me the whole game. I do know that if I was playing in that match I've have seen red - before getting a card from the ref.

How the F**k did the Saints get away with that? Romeu serially fouling, giving the ref verbal and nothing.

Its easy for us to say that players should calm down but FFS that was out and out assault.

This , the second half if wilf had the ball he was taken out. He was fouled the final time and JWP rippped the piss deliberately to get wilf sent off , you could see him laughing as it happened.

Romeu should of not been on the pitch the amount of times he took players out. Terrible ref display again by Mariner

 

Painter Flag Croydon 30 Jan 19 10.24pm

How Romeus head high rugby tackle on Tomkins wasn't a penalty in Mariners view will be one of life mysteries. Romeu is a thug and spent the evening fouling anything that moved, but got away with it.
Point not a bad result, hope the club fines Zaha for letting the team down with his petulance.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 30 Jan 19 10.25pm

1. We should not have lost that lead. Sat back, invited them on, paid the inevitable price.

2. Wilf has confirmed what we feared - he will never realise his potential because of his mental failings. Tonight really has confirmed that. It's sad.

3. f*** that f***ing ref, and f*** Romeu.

 

eagle@ tn34 Flag hastings 30 Jan 19 10.28pm

Thought PVA shouldnt have turned his back on the player taking the shot for their goal. Once again a rare mistake and we are punished. Makes sats game more interesting now.

COYP

 

davenotamonkey Flag 30 Jan 19 10.29pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


you are making excuses

Zaha is still acting like a child with attitude problem he needs to grow up.

fouls are apart of football and the ones on zaha was dealt with (zaha got sent of because he is an idiot)

this was awful result should of won this same old second half we are poor and again roy with poor tactics refusing subs

Clearly you were watching a different game, because I saw their players foul him persistently in rota, so they didn't draw yellows from the referee for a chain of takedowns (yeah, apart from Romeu's 4 fouls in succession with not a single booking). And for a vast number of those fouls, no free kick was given, including a clear penalty.

No. The fouls were not "dealt with".

They had a clear game-plan today: kick the s*** out of us. Needle the players to provoke a response (look at the s***-eating grin from Ward-Prowse when he knew he'd needled Zaha after fouling him off the ball AND getting away with it again).

t***s.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 30 Jan 19 10.30pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

I've been wayching PL fpotball sonce the PL started and I've seen countless times teams like that assault our players repeatedly and get away with it but I've never seen a match reffed as badly as that.

There is a long list of badly officiated games, normally involving us, just add this one. Nothing will change, not quite as bad a England v Columbia, but close.

 

AERO Flag 30 Jan 19 10.32pm

If we did not sit back in second half and played the same as first half we would have won by a country mile ! Bad tactics . And should have brought wickham or Benteke on to hold ball up .

 

Master Coin Flag 30 Jan 19 10.33pm

Originally posted by AERO

If we did not sit back in second half and played the same as first half we would have won by a country mile ! Bad tactics . And should have brought wickham or Benteke on to hold ball up .

Yep. Roy deciding at HT to park the bus lost us two points. The man is a moron. The sooner he’s gone the better tbh

 

Steve T Flag Cumbria 30 Jan 19 10.33pm

Whatever we say about the referee, and he was truly awful, we cannot escape the fact that we threw away 2 points. Ward Prowse was in acres of space for an age to the build up for their goal . No-one closed him down.

Why Ayew was still on the pitch only Woy will know. But we also missed a hatful once again including that free header from Sakho which missed by a country mile. And someone needs to give Kouyate shooting practice. For a midfielder of his size to never get on the goal sheet is pretty poor.

Hodgson needs to know when to make substitutions. When are either Benteke or Wickham going to start?

 

HellenicEagle Flag Haywards Heath 30 Jan 19 10.34pm

Truly appalling refereeing - some really nasty fouls completely ignored. If players don't get any protection from the referee, its inevitable that at some point someone is going to react. Sure they shouldn't, but if the referee had been doing his job, the whole situation would never have arisen. Mariner should have given himself the red card.

Truly appalling management - every week the Roy manages to turn victory into defeat through poor team selection and a blind refusal to substitute players. Last year I was grateful to Roy. This year I am reaching the point where I am going to have to stop watching matches in order to keep my blood pressure in check. Unfortunately, things are not going to get better, because Roy has shown that he cannot change. We don't need to sign more players; what we need is a new manager who can get the best out of our existing squad.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 30 Jan 19 10.36pm

Having had a few minutes to calm down and leaving Zaha and the ref aside for a moment, got to say that Roy's in game decisions have again cost us points there.

You feel like a stuck record writing the same thing about his substitutions every single week but why on earth was he the only person in the stadium who couldn't see that we needed to bring Wickham or Benteke on? Not only was Ayew totally ineffective but with a big physical centre forward on the pitch their defenders would have had something else to focus on than fouling Zaha.

Roy is a great manager in lots of ways, he has us organised brilliantly and sets us up to defend very well but his teams are utterly predictable and his stubborn refusal to bring on anybody other than Schlupp before the 75th minute is utterly infuriating. Wouldn't be surprised if we lose Meyer in the summer as there's no way he'll be enjoying this.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Casual Flag Orpington 30 Jan 19 10.37pm

If our players are getting hit with tackles and the ref isn’t doing anything , they should fight fire with fire. Get booked for some heavy tackles is fine , getting a second yellow for clapping the ref, seconds after being booked is the actions of a pr*ck.

 

Steve T Flag Cumbria 30 Jan 19 10.37pm

I can almost forgive a player getting sent off for retaliation when he's had poor or no protection from the ref. But to get sent off for mock applause to the ref is ridiculous and he should be fined.

 

merganser Flag 30 Jan 19 10.38pm

Wilf is such a prima donna.

But there is also a failure of management. Roy is far too indulgent of his tantrums.

And what was our skipper doing? He should have intervened and saved Wilf from himself.

Perhaps he will learn a lesson from missing the next match.

We never saw that kind of stupidity from Yannick - or from Andros.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 30 Jan 19 10.39pm

I'm quite angry after that.

The ref was utter s*** and should have sent off one or maybe two Saints players. Instead, Wilf gets himself red carded by acting like the pea brain that he is.

I get his frustration. We all feel it, but he should know better than to clap the ref. Now we face Fulham without him and maybe Tomkins. Truly dumb.

Once again we let a lead slip and inexplicably, Roy brings on Schlupp for Kouyate. Why?

Not good enough all round and that ref should be demoted.

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 30 Jan 19 10.40pm

You can blame the referee all you like. I can’t comment because I didn’t see the match, but the reason we didn’t get three points from that match has to be down to Hodgson’s appalling team selection and his inability to bring on the right substitutes at the right time yet again.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 30 Jan 19 10.42pm

Originally posted by pompeyeagle

You can blame the referee all you like. I can’t comment because I didn’t see the match, but the reason we didn’t get three points from that match has to be down to Hodgson’s appalling team selection and his inability to bring on the right substitutes at the right time yet again.

How do you know if you didn't see it?

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 30 Jan 19 10.44pm

Dire and stupid.

 

Page 11 of 14 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Southampton Match Thread