You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Norwich vs Palace Match Thread
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Norwich vs Palace Match Thread


Page 11 of 14 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 01 Jan 20 10.06pm

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

Good result

Unpopular opinion, Riedewald is better than PVA at left back

So far from what we have seen from Riedewald informs us that he learns and understands what is required of him very quickly, PVA when fit will have to play very consistently from now on ..otherwise.

 

pssguy Flag 01 Jan 20 10.09pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

Kelly stood still watching, playing Cantwell onside.

Edited by Phil’s Barber (01 Jan 2020 5.46pm)


and not as though he was marking anyone. 2 games running

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 01 Jan 20 10.10pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Alan Pardew %W 40
Roy %W 36

out of all their games at palace as manager AP has better ratio.

Only three with ratio worst then Roys based on current Prem run is

Holloway %W 30
Warnock %W 34
Boer %W 20

Any idea what the points per game ratio of those managers is? I'm rubbish at stats, but it might be interesting.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 01 Jan 20 10.12pm

Originally posted by HKOwen

Jairo continues to improve, Brandon was excellent when subbed on, lots of mistakes all round both teams, all officials except the VAR guy had shockers, Moss was dire.

Take the point gratefully, we created almost nothing against worst defence in PL. They could have been out of sight if not for Guaita.

On non football notes, the big screen at Carrow Road is very cool, a huge revolving smart phone.

Home fans not up to much in terms of noise.

They are going down

Not fair to suggest that, they have quite obviously improved ..Spurs fans will testify.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 01 Jan 20 10.13pm

They also beat Man.C at home.

 

Karlosfandango Flag Norfolk 01 Jan 20 10.16pm

I'm just back and I'm not 100% convinced Riedewald could be considered as a left back. He certainly tried but the further forward he got the more panicked his play became. He was pushing forward a lot of the time which meant Sakho had to come across to cover. It was on one of these occasions that he was left exposed and whilst trying to recover pulled something. Sakho looks an utter liability. His knees or hips are gone as he just does't move well unlike Tomkins who is absolute quality.

I didn't think Norwich did very much at all, they had a few moments but nothing that made me think they would get a second. If we had come away losing that match we'd have been very hard done by. As soon as we scored they completely went to pieces but managed to break up play and waste time to save themselves.

There were some very strange refereeing decisions, I think Norwich certainly had the rub of the green in most decisions.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Jan 20 10.20pm

Delighted with the draw.
At Half-time I never thought we would get anything from the game.
Well done!

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 01 Jan 20 10.31pm

Originally posted by Willo

Delighted with the draw.
At Half-time I never thought we would get anything from the game.
Well done!

When was the last time you thought we would?

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 01 Jan 20 10.34pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3497999]

Any idea what the points per game ratio of those managers is? I'm rubbish at stats, but it might be interesting.

Pardew 0.71 at the end of his time with us.

Hodgson 1.37 this season.

Edited by Tickled pink (01 Jan 2020 10.35pm)

 

Rabbit-Tooth Flag London 01 Jan 20 10.38pm

Grateful for the draw. Had the possession but created few chances. But considering the injuries and the number of games played over a short period, the team did well.

It will be interesting what the team, especially the defence, will be on Sunday. We could had 3 maybe 4 youngsters in the side.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 01 Jan 20 10.48pm

Originally posted by Karlosfandango

I'm just back and I'm not 100% convinced Riedewald could be considered as a left back. He certainly tried but the further forward he got the more panicked his play became. He was pushing forward a lot of the time which meant Sakho had to come across to cover. It was on one of these occasions that he was left exposed and whilst trying to recover pulled something. Sakho looks an utter liability. His knees or hips are gone as he just does't move well unlike Tomkins who is absolute quality.

I didn't think Norwich did very much at all, they had a few moments but nothing that made me think they would get a second. If we had come away losing that match we'd have been very hard done by. As soon as we scored they completely went to pieces but managed to break up play and waste time to save themselves.

There were some very strange refereeing decisions, I think Norwich certainly had the rub of the green in most decisions.

They hit the bar it very nearly almost went in, it would have been not unfair if it had. we knocked on their door very loudly but never really stood a chance of getting in until Wickham found a key and it unbelievably fit, we were somewhat fortunate because although we looked comfortable moving towards their goal they looked ridiculously happy breaking us up and deliriously drunk running at our defence.
Point definitely gained.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 01 Jan 20 10.50pm

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

Good result

Unpopular opinion, Riedewald is better than PVA at left back

Watch reidewald and he shows the man outside by being side on.
That's how awb is so good on the right.
On the left is the same principal.
Pva plays front on so can be wrong footed more easily.
I could see reidewald being a diamond in the midfield spraying passes.
Trouble being he thinks quicker than some of our players due to his early training in holland.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 01 Jan 20 10.52pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Pardew 0.71 at the end of his time with us.

Hodgson 1.37 this season.

Edited by Tickled pink (01 Jan 2020 10.35pm)

Thank you. But that is kinda selective. I meant in total. I realise that Pards later stint was carp*, putting it mildly.

*excuse dyslexia

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Mapletree Flag Croydon 01 Jan 20 11.06pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3498010]

Thank you. But that is kinda selective. I meant in total. I realise that Pards later stint was carp*, putting it mildly.

*excuse dyslexia

Almost identical overall

But Roy has had far more draws. Draws are better than they appear as the other team only gets one point. It’s the wrong stat to look at win ratio in isolation. Unless of course your glass is perpetually and irritatingly always half empty.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 01 Jan 20 11.13pm

Originally posted by merganser

I also thought Ridewald was great - tenacious, quick and intelligent. I think he should play full back and keep his place when PVA and JW are fit.

Meyer is alert and clever. Norwich found him a handful, but he lacks defensive bite, Instead of tackling, he just hangs out an ankle. Unless he adds some solidity to his game, he risks getting a broken leg because his challenges are so flaky.

However, he was playing well enough so I was surprised he was subbed so early in the second half.

He lacks strength all over the pitch, given space to move he does well, not given any he struggles ..needs to drink some of what Zaha drank to improve his power.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 01 Jan 20 11.22pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3498010]

Thank you. But that is kinda selective. I meant in total. I realise that Pards later stint was carp*, putting it mildly.

*excuse dyslexia

I'm looking, will post.

 

mattteo Flag 01 Jan 20 11.31pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Watch reidewald and he shows the man outside by being side on.
That's how awb is so good on the right.
On the left is the same principal.
Pva plays front on so can be wrong footed more easily.
I could see reidewald being a diamond in the midfield spraying passes.
Trouble being he thinks quicker than some of our players due to his early training in holland.

You're exagerating wih the diamond in midfield part. The lad has decent passing, all Dutch players do, it's what they learn in their academies. Played 43 matches out of 163 in his career as a defensive midfielder.

He doesn't have any assists or key passes from that position. He's a neat passer of the ball, like holding midfielder ranging from Matic to Fernandinho to Eric Dier to Luka or Kouyate. There are already plenty of these playing in our midfield.

In fact, I think 1 starter should suffice. And besides him should be a Cabaye type, a real threat to the opposing defences. We're already playing Luka and Kouyate or Luka and McCarthy together and it shows that we don't score more than 1 goal per game, very rarely 2 goals.

Riedewald is no Pirlo or Pjanic or Toni Kroos or even Cabaye to make kncredible passes from midfield or to break towards the opposing goal and create superiority (something which Cabaye did in his first years). He's just a central defender who COULD play holding midfielder if the game demands it.

 

mattteo Flag 01 Jan 20 11.42pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

He said PERHAPS cementthe position. Having seen PVAs passing and inability to cut out a cross this season I think JR has every chance of becoming first choice LB

Just asking. I want to know what the common opinion on this thread is.

If 2-3 attacking options are brought in this wonter, then I don't know if Roy can keep all 3 left backs (PVA, Schlupp, Riedewald) in the Premier League 25 men formation. Some players will have to be left out. And having 3 players in 1 position is, frankly, too much. Riedewald has the advantage that he can cover at center back and defensive midfielder too, but these positions seem filled with 4-5 players each as well.

Roy has been using Schlupp fuether up, as an attacking winger, but he's honestly just one sided. In fact, I don't think I've ever seen Schlupp play on the right, as an inverted winger. And you have to at least be able to provide some passes and assists from inverted winger position as well if you want to play in attack. He has scored a couple of goals, but nothing amazing given the playing time he has had.

Schlupp's main problem is that he played galf the matches in his career as left back and half as left midfielder, so we're not sure what he really is, but I'd say he's more a left back because of the above, that an attacking player would need to be able to at least try to play on both sides (Tonlwnsend, Zaha, almost everyone on the Premier League).

But is he better than PVA or Riedewald? Well, Schlupp has the best physique. PVA seems the best for me. He has speed, he is great in attack, it's no wonder Juventus is asking about him and many team would be willing to pay at least 10 million for a 30 year old.

Riesewald might just get the notch ahead of Schlupp given that Schlupp is also out for a while and that he has gotten a run in the first team with good results.

Would you be ok with Schlupp being left out of the 25 men squad if 2-3 other (better) attacking options (strikers, wingers) come this winter?

 

sprites Flag Auckland 01 Jan 20 11.51pm

Originally posted by mattteo

You're exagerating wih the diamond in midfield part. The lad has decent passing, all Dutch players do, it's what they learn in their academies. Played 43 matches out of 163 in his career as a defensive midfielder.

He doesn't have any assists or key passes from that position. He's a neat passer of the ball, like holding midfielder ranging from Matic to Fernandinho to Eric Dier to Luka or Kouyate. There are already plenty of these playing in our midfield.

In fact, I think 1 starter should suffice. And besides him should be a Cabaye type, a real threat to the opposing defences. We're already playing Luka and Kouyate or Luka and McCarthy together and it shows that we don't score more than 1 goal per game, very rarely 2 goals.

Riedewald is no Pirlo or Pjanic or Toni Kroos or even Cabaye to make kncredible passes from midfield or to break towards the opposing goal and create superiority (something which Cabaye did in his first years). He's just a central defender who COULD play holding midfielder if the game demands it.

That's all speculation. You don't really know any more than any of us do. Reidewald played a beautiful long pass in the last cup game. He may very well have those passes you speak of in his arsenal.

 

rawpalace05 Flag Saltdean 02 Jan 20 12.13am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

He lacks strength all over the pitch, given space to move he does well, not given any he struggles ..needs to drink some of what Zaha drank to improve his power.

Its so frustrating, technically very good but is like watching an u12 play amongst men. He also slows down our counters somewhat.

 


1/6/2010.a new era.we made it everyone!!!lets get the ball rolling for another 105 years of proud history.thank you cpfc2010.

palace forever.eeaaaaaaaaaaaaaggglless!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Page 11 of 14 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Norwich vs Palace Match Thread