You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Newcastle Match Thread
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Newcastle Match Thread


Page 11 of 11 << First< 7 8 9 10 11
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Feb 20 11.11pm

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

Just got home from the match (transatlantic flight) .

Really fun time. The crowd was into it early, lots of noise. Lots of singing. Positive atmosphere.

This was the first match in ages where we totally outplayed the other team, and richly deserved 3 points. I thought Newcastle gave us way too much space. They actually reminded me a bit of how we play, in that they struggle to pass or get the ball upfield, but when they got it to St. Maximin, he looked as dangerous as Zaha, and stronger.

I agree with others that we do not miss Luka in our lineup. We've played better in the games he has been out, IMO. Our corners were so much better. And PVA's goal was great.

I thought Ayew was MOTM, but everyone played well. I thought Benteke did a good job of holding the ball up all match long, winning every header, even in windy conditions. But, as usual, he was hopeless in his chances around the net. If we had had Tosun playing, he would have buried 1-2 of the chances Benteke got. Still, I can't blast Benteke, because he played better than usual.

Zaha had 2-3 men blocking him every time he got the ball on the touchline. That seems to be the way every match now. After a while, instead of passing it backwards, he started driving into the middle of the field, which seemed to work well in opening things up.

Aside from his goal, I thought PVA had a good match too. He carried the ball quickly out of the back numerous times.

May I congratulate you on an excellent post.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 24 Feb 20 12.05am

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

Just got home from the match (transatlantic flight) .

Really fun time. The crowd was into it early, lots of noise. Lots of singing. Positive atmosphere.

This was the first match in ages where we totally outplayed the other team, and richly deserved 3 points. I thought Newcastle gave us way too much space. They actually reminded me a bit of how we play, in that they struggle to pass or get the ball upfield, but when they got it to St. Maximin, he looked as dangerous as Zaha, and stronger.

I agree with others that we do not miss Luka in our lineup. We've played better in the games he has been out, IMO. Our corners were so much better. And PVA's goal was great.

I thought Ayew was MOTM, but everyone played well. I thought Benteke did a good job of holding the ball up all match long, winning every header, even in windy conditions. But, as usual, he was hopeless in his chances around the net. If we had had Tosun playing, he would have buried 1-2 of the chances Benteke got. Still, I can't blast Benteke, because he played better than usual.

Zaha had 2-3 men blocking him every time he got the ball on the touchline. That seems to be the way every match now. After a while, instead of passing it backwards, he started driving into the middle of the field, which seemed to work well in opening things up.

Aside from his goal, I thought PVA had a good match too. He carried the ball quickly out of the back numerous times.

Like that one he blasted over the bar...?
Still not convinced he's any better.
Wickham was the answer (imo.)

 

twist Flag Miami, Florida 24 Feb 20 2.29am

Better performance from us, but Newcastle were woeful.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Feb 20 9.26am

Originally posted by sprites

Like that one he blasted over the bar...?
Still not convinced he's any better.
Wickham was the answer (imo.)

Not on the scoresheet in his 4 games for Sheff Wed.

 

george1212 Flag london 24 Feb 20 9.35am

It's been a long season for us Palace fans, not a totally negative one, but the last run of 10 games or so, have been turd.

Yesterday was a comprehensive performance and probably the most deserved 3 points we got all season. We really did deserve to have a few more goals, I think it was only a combination of bad luck and (as usual) somewhat poor finishing in front of goal. That all said, at the so called 'business end' of the season, the 3 points were needed and we got them; job done.

A win against Brighton would be a great way to get a bit closer to safety whilst beating our rivals. But we'll rarely make it simple, so no expectations coming into next Saturday. Even if it's not the result we want, I think we can rest assured that we will probably pick up the points we need to finish the season comfortably mid-table.

Funny how a win can change perspective like that. To be fair it has been woeful recently so I think all of us fans can be forgiven for thinking it wasn't going to change anytime soon.

 

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 24 Feb 20 9.49am

Sky Sports reporter Max Matthews' player ratings:

Crystal Palace: Guaita 7, Ward 6, Dann 6, Cahill 7, Van Aanholt 8, Kouyate 7, McArthur 6, McCarthy 6, Zaha 8, Ayew 8, Benteke 7

!!!!

So only three players scored higher than Benteke.
Dann, Ward and the JMacs were our worst performers!


Oh. My. Days.

 


Spirit of 1974

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 24 Feb 20 4.47pm

Originally posted by bifffabazz

Sky Sports reporter Max Matthews' player ratings:

Crystal Palace: Guaita 7, Ward 6, Dann 6, Cahill 7, Van Aanholt 8, Kouyate 7, McArthur 6, McCarthy 6, Zaha 8, Ayew 8, Benteke 7

!!!!

So only three players scored higher than Benteke.
Dann, Ward and the JMacs were our worst performers!


Oh. My. Days.

Maybe lost points for yellows.

 


Red and Blue Army!

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 24 Feb 20 4.57pm

Originally posted by bifffabazz

Sky Sports reporter Max Matthews' player ratings:

Crystal Palace: Guaita 7, Ward 6, Dann 6, Cahill 7, Van Aanholt 8, Kouyate 7, McArthur 6, McCarthy 6, Zaha 8, Ayew 8, Benteke 7

!!!!

So only three players scored higher than Benteke.
Dann, Ward and the JMacs were our worst performers!


Oh. My. Days.

I have met a few reporters who 'watch' games by sitting in a pub or staying at home and having two to three screens on at the same time so they can file more than one match report. Half the time reports only seem to bear a passing resemblance to what actually happened.

Edited by NickinOX (24 Feb 2020 4.57pm)

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 24 Feb 20 7.09pm

It was a big win,most probably the biggest in the context of the form we were in. Should have won by a greater margin but for their keeper it would have been 3 or 4 nil at half time...

If the Magpies go down their keeper would be worth tapping up, he looks like their best player by a country mile...

 

Page 11 of 11 << First< 7 8 9 10 11

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Newcastle Match Thread