This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by BM
He’s less injured than Joniesta but less talented. Why does everyone rate him? Meyer suffers from the same affliction that happens to some Palace players, the less they play the better they are in the eyes of some fans and cant live up to the expectation.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BM
He’s less injured than Joniesta but less talented. Why does everyone rate him? Really! This is exactly what I meant earlier, Joniesta came through the ranks, so must be more talented than a German International
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Meyer suffers from the same affliction that happens to some Palace players, the less they play the better they are in the eyes of some fans and cant live up to the expectation. Meyer is a good player but has rarely been given a chance and obviously does not fit into the static system that Roy wants to play. Camarasa was superb for a poor Cardiff team but again did not fit into Roy's system. Didn't see anyone say that, but he is a midfield playmaker who can pick a pass and score a goal, are you saying we don't need this?
|
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
Our lack of pace at the back is one of the big reasons we need constant cover in front of them also a big reason why Wilf plays in front of PVA and not Ward. Ward wouldn’t be able to cope without someone tracking back to help him with his lack of pace.Their 2nd and 3rd goals both came from us losing the ball and them quickly attacking and most teams know this is how to beat us. Have you watched Sakho trying to run back, it is almost comical, he is like a budgie in slippers. PVA gets away with so many errors because he has the speed to get back. This lack of pace goes right through our whole squad and in my opinion is one of the big reasons for Roy picking the same type of midfield players. It is also a big factor in why our players are terrified to push forward in numbers, they know they will be destroyed for pace by a decent side. Roy does not stop our players attacking, they stop themselves. Kouyate in my opinion is very poor football player who couldn’t kick snow off a rope but he plays because he can run at pace and all day long. Meyer and Riedewald have also got a major lack of pace which is a major reason why they sit in the bench. Schlupp is technically no where near as good as both of them but he plays an awful lot more. Reason being he is fast and can get around the pitch. I know I defend Roy a lot but there is method to his madness, If we played football every week the most of you want it played with this current squad, we would have been relegated by now. Yes we would have had some nice games to watch but over the course of a year we would have got battered more often than not. Our squad is too old and too slow to play expansive footballing in this division.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ripleyeagle Good post,I thought we played well and deserved a draw.It was a shame Ayew played one of his worse games for us last night as he kept dribbling instead of passing the ball and slowed down our forward play.That said he has been our best player in previous games.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ripleyeagle
Originally posted by ripleyeagle
Good post,I thought we played well and deserved a draw.It was a shame Ayew played one of his worse games for us last night as he kept dribbling instead of passing the ball and slowed down our forward play.That said he has been our best player in previous games. Yes great post from Eddie.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
Our lack of pace at the back is one of the big reasons we need constant cover in front of them also a big reason why Wilf plays in front of PVA and not Ward. Ward wouldn’t be able to cope without someone tracking back to help him with his lack of pace.Their 2nd and 3rd goals both came from us losing the ball and them quickly attacking and most teams know this is how to beat us. Have you watched Sakho trying to run back, it is almost comical, he is like a budgie in slippers. PVA gets away with so many errors because he has the speed to get back. This lack of pace goes right through our whole squad and in my opinion is one of the big reasons for Roy picking the same type of midfield players. It is also a big factor in why our players are terrified to push forward in numbers, they know they will be destroyed for pace by a decent side. Roy does not stop our players attacking, they stop themselves. Kouyate in my opinion is very poor football player who couldn’t kick snow off a rope but he plays because he can run at pace and all day long. Meyer and Riedewald have also got a major lack of pace which is a major reason why they sit in the bench. Schlupp is technically no where near as good as both of them but he plays an awful lot more. Reason being he is fast and can get around the pitch. I know I defend Roy a lot but there is method to his madness, If we played football every week the most of you want it played with this current squad, we would have been relegated by now. Yes we would have had some nice games to watch but over the course of a year we would have got battered more often than not. Our squad is too old and too slow to play expansive footballing in this division. I broadly agree with this viewpoint. I would add that Schlupp provides physicality and being left-footed provides a balance down the left. He has also chipped in with some goals. You mentioned our ageing squad.I believe that in this post-lockdown period with a succession of games in a short period of time, we have to recognise the demands of those in the twilight of their careers.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
Our lack of pace at the back is one of the big reasons we need constant cover in front of them also a big reason why Wilf plays in front of PVA and not Ward. Ward wouldn’t be able to cope without someone tracking back to help him with his lack of pace.Their 2nd and 3rd goals both came from us losing the ball and them quickly attacking and most teams know this is how to beat us. Have you watched Sakho trying to run back, it is almost comical, he is like a budgie in slippers. PVA gets away with so many errors because he has the speed to get back. This lack of pace goes right through our whole squad and in my opinion is one of the big reasons for Roy picking the same type of midfield players. It is also a big factor in why our players are terrified to push forward in numbers, they know they will be destroyed for pace by a decent side. Roy does not stop our players attacking, they stop themselves. Kouyate in my opinion is very poor football player who couldn’t kick snow off a rope but he plays because he can run at pace and all day long. Meyer and Riedewald have also got a major lack of pace which is a major reason why they sit in the bench. Schlupp is technically no where near as good as both of them but he plays an awful lot more. Reason being he is fast and can get around the pitch. I know I defend Roy a lot but there is method to his madness, If we played football every week the most of you want it played with this current squad, we would have been relegated by now. Yes we would have had some nice games to watch but over the course of a year we would have got battered more often than not. Our squad is too old and too slow to play expansive footballing in this division. Completely agree RH is all about players and a system. However. Those players are older and it’s an argument against giving Hodgson money to spend. Otherwise his successor is going to have a team of ageing well paid journeymen and no money to change our style. At the end of the day we are a mid to lower end Premier League team, but our focus should be on scouting, acadamy and longer term RH is a functional manager. Give him 100 million to spend, we will still end up with a team of Schlupps, Ayews, Kouyates etc. That has a place, but the game is evolving and RH with the greatest will isn’t. Every club (and country)he’s ever been at is the same. I suspect RH has benefitted from no crowds, as the receptions at full time wouldn’t have been pleasant......
|
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
Our lack of pace at the back is one of the big reasons we need constant cover in front of them also a big reason why Wilf plays in front of PVA and not Ward. Ward wouldn’t be able to cope without someone tracking back to help him with his lack of pace.Their 2nd and 3rd goals both came from us losing the ball and them quickly attacking and most teams know this is how to beat us. Have you watched Sakho trying to run back, it is almost comical, he is like a budgie in slippers. PVA gets away with so many errors because he has the speed to get back. This lack of pace goes right through our whole squad and in my opinion is one of the big reasons for Roy picking the same type of midfield players. It is also a big factor in why our players are terrified to push forward in numbers, they know they will be destroyed for pace by a decent side. Roy does not stop our players attacking, they stop themselves. Kouyate in my opinion is very poor football player who couldn’t kick snow off a rope but he plays because he can run at pace and all day long. Meyer and Riedewald have also got a major lack of pace which is a major reason why they sit in the bench. Schlupp is technically no where near as good as both of them but he plays an awful lot more. Reason being he is fast and can get around the pitch. I know I defend Roy a lot but there is method to his madness, If we played football every week the most of you want it played with this current squad, we would have been relegated by now. Yes we would have had some nice games to watch but over the course of a year we would have got battered more often than not. Our squad is too old and too slow to play expansive footballing in this division. Finally some sense...
The best footie management game: [Link] |
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
A much better performance and an entertaining game. Very good post. I would add that even though Guaita made two good saves to keep us in it, I feel he should have done better with their second. I've lost count of the number of times since he has been with us that he's been beaten at his near post, and he always seems to go down on his knees. If he'd stayed standing he'd have had a decent chance of keeping out the shot.
|
|
|
Originally posted by robdave2k
Completely agree RH is all about players and a system. However. Those players are older and it’s an argument against giving Hodgson money to spend. Otherwise his successor is going to have a team of ageing well paid journeymen and no money to change our style. At the end of the day we are a mid to lower end Premier League team, but our focus should be on scouting, acadamy and longer term RH is a functional manager. Give him 100 million to spend, we will still end up with a team of Schlupps, Ayews, Kouyates etc. That has a place, but the game is evolving and RH with the greatest will isn’t. Every club (and country)he’s ever been at is the same. I suspect RH has benefitted from no crowds, as the receptions at full time wouldn’t have been pleasant...... In terms of Hodgson's signings at Fulham he did sign quite a few,either permanently, or on Loan, who were near or in their 30s ie Nevland, Litmanen,Dacourt, Kallio, Duff, Greening, Gera and Julian Gray. He did take Fulham to the Europa League final where they lost to Atletico Madrid, and in the EL Fulham did beat Juventus 4-1 at home in the second leg after losing the first leg 3-1.
|
|
|
Originally posted by robdave2k
Completely agree RH is all about players and a system. However. Those players are older and it’s an argument against giving Hodgson money to spend. Otherwise his successor is going to have a team of ageing well paid journeymen and no money to change our style. At the end of the day we are a mid to lower end Premier League team, but our focus should be on scouting, acadamy and longer term RH is a functional manager. Give him 100 million to spend, we will still end up with a team of Schlupps, Ayews, Kouyates etc. That has a place, but the game is evolving and RH with the greatest will isn’t. Every club (and country)he’s ever been at is the same. I suspect RH has benefitted from no crowds, as the receptions at full time wouldn’t have been pleasant...... I don’t disagree with anything you said but Roy was not brought in to develop younger players he was brought in to keep us safe for a few years while the club sorted itself out in the background. It is up to Parish and Dougie to get those younger players in and be ready for the next manager to develop. Roy has no interest in signing 19/20 year olds as he knows he will be gone in a year or so and more than likely this will be his last year in football management. The same goes with developing or moving with the times, he was not brought in to develop or move with the times and why would he change everything he knows. He is 74 not 34. This is just something we are going to have to put up with for another year so a lot of may as well get used to it. Roy will be gone in 12 months and so will most of that squad, the next few transfer windows are critical and it will not be Roy making the signings.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
Roy will be gone in 12 months and so will most of that squad, the next few transfer windows are critical and it will not be Roy making the signings. And I fear that when this happens, because your prediction is very likely, a lot of people that are now complaining will be very sorry of the outcome... Edited by Ian-VI (08 Jul 2020 9.57am)
The best footie management game: [Link] |
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Meyer suffers from the same affliction that happens to some Palace players, the less they play the better they are in the eyes of some fans and cant live up to the expectation. As sweeping generalisations go that is about as good as it gets. Let’s just try and slag off as many fellow fans who might have a different view to you in one sentence oh sage one.
|
|
|
Originally posted by robdave2k
Completely agree RH is all about players and a system. However. Those players are older and it’s an argument against giving Hodgson money to spend. Otherwise his successor is going to have a team of ageing well paid journeymen and no money to change our style. At the end of the day we are a mid to lower end Premier League team, but our focus should be on scouting, acadamy and longer term RH is a functional manager. Give him 100 million to spend, we will still end up with a team of Schlupps, Ayews, Kouyates etc. That has a place, but the game is evolving and RH with the greatest will isn’t. Every club (and country)he’s ever been at is the same. I suspect RH has benefitted from no crowds, as the receptions at full time wouldn’t have been pleasant...... Well the good news is that the club IS focusing on the future with the big investment in the Academy and gaining Cat 1 status. Scouting is something that never stops but success depends on how effective your network is and how it is managed. The constant criticism of Hodgson not giving youth a chance is something of a red herring in my opinion. The fact is, AWB aside, we haven't had a glut of young players pressing for a first team place. Hodgson will be looking at addressing the overall age of the squad this summer I am sure. It's an accepted fact that needs to be done. I don't think it will be too radical more of a gradual rebuild. My concern is that when you are only effectively contracting a manager for a season at a time, it surely hinders medium term planning.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.