You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Manchester City v Palace Match Thread
November 16 2026 5.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Manchester City v Palace Match Thread


Page 11 of 18 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >
EddieMac Flag 17 Jan 21 9.23pm

Originally posted by Mathers

The rose tinted glasses for Guaita need to come off. This season he has been pretty poor and tonight he was pathetic.

3-4 times his passing put us in trouble, he was almost caught in possession and the last two goals were down to him. Pushed the pull into the middle of the box for Stones and should never be beaten on GK side from a free kick.

We were beaten before a ball was kicked with that line up and game plan, however, if you are going to get anything from these games then the GK has to be on form and he simply isn’t.

I am beginning to think the same myself. I know some of his saves have been world class this season but his ball distribution and lack of presence at corners is costing us big time. It will be interesting to see if Roy gives Butland a run.

 

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 17 Jan 21 9.23pm

Originally posted by adelaar

Forget tonight. They are so many levels above us it's untrue.
West Ham and Wolves home next two. Need a win in one of those games and we are fine.
Let's all be realistic, we have a chronic lack of investment and the squad is old. I'm glad Roy said Wilf had a 'knock' we need him for the next two important games. Finishing 13th and above this season is success.
Don't like it? Support someone else.

-.-'

 

BelfastEagle Flag 17 Jan 21 9.24pm

Entirely predictable.

Once we went 1 0 down is was all over.

Didn’t force their keeper to make a single save in whole game.

No cards .....no need for any it wasn’t really a competitive game. Just defence versus attack.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 17 Jan 21 9.24pm

Originally posted by Mathers

The rose tinted glasses for Guaita need to come off. This season he has been pretty poor and tonight he was pathetic.

3-4 times his passing put us in trouble, he was almost caught in possession and the last two goals were down to him. Pushed the pull into the middle of the box for Stones and should never be beaten on GK side from a free kick.

We were beaten before a ball was kicked with that line up and game plan, however, if you are going to get anything from these games then the GK has to be on form and he simply isn’t.

Guaita wasn’t great, but then they were all awful and mainly in the second half as we defended well in the first half. He had no outlet as City pushed up on our defenders putting them under pressure as soon as he gave them a pass. There was also no outlet up front to hit it long. The midfield didn’t help as well. He had no help from any of our players and whoever he gave the ball to that player had no easy pass to make as no one was making space for a pass.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 17 Jan 21 9.25pm

Second half was embarrassing and along with Chelsea our worst performance of the season.

However, I'm not going to have a knee-jerk reaction. Let's face it, we don't have a single player who would get into Citeh's first XI and it's debatable whether any of ours would even get on the Citeh bench!

The next 7 games will define how our season will go, not tonight, so I'll reserve judgment until after the Fulham game.

At least we now have a 9 day break before we face the Spammers.

I think I'll go to bed and read.

 

Tyke Exile Flag Portuguese Cove, Nova Scotia 17 Jan 21 9.25pm

£810 million vs £150 million - what on earth does everyone expect? OK a bit more fight and urgency would be nice but when you try and race your Kia Sportage against a Jaguar XJ and lose you can't blame your Sportage for not being up to the job it was purchased for.

 


Why worry about TODAY when TOMORROW will be even worse.

EddieMac Flag 17 Jan 21 9.26pm

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

Was City that good??

Three direct mistakes by Palaces
McA stupid long cross field pass leads to corner which leads to 1st goal,
Luka pass direct to City player, out corner goal
Corner, we know how that happens from another mistake then Townsend, gone to head being back at City.....
Why keep passing back to keeper which lead to free kick which 4-0.

So how good was actually City?
Cut out 4 mistakes and no goals
Did City create goals no.. they seized of mistakes.

Did Palace try to win a point.... maybe
Can we cut out the mistakes, no not against top teams.
Did we learn anything about Roy and his tactics... SFA

I agree with this. There is no denying Roy’s tactics where unbelievably negative but school boy mistakes cost us which can’t be blamed on Roy. He sent the team out to hopefully nick a point in the last 10 minutes but we gave ourselves no chance.

I am not defending Roy by the way but we have beaten city before by playing those negative tactics,

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 17 Jan 21 9.26pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

I am beginning to think the same myself. I know some of his saves have been world class this season but his ball distribution and lack of presence at corners is costing us big time. It will be interesting to see if Roy gives Butland a run.

I reckon Gordon Banks would struggle to play well behind that lot tonight. Let’s face it, if we really think the problem with this team is the Keeper then there’s no hope for the fans either.

Edited by Helmet46 (17 Jan 2021 9.27pm)

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 17 Jan 21 9.28pm

I

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

I'm deluded? You are the one who wanted to field some of our youth team against a team like Man City FFs. You are the one who wants to destabalise our season by getting rid of the manager who knows more about football than you ever will or any of the posters on here.

Show me where I said field some youth players against City..!!

I know plenty about football thanks, quite obvious you don’t..!!

 

EddieMac Flag 17 Jan 21 9.29pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

I reckon Gordon Banks would struggle to play well behind that lot tonight. Let’s face it, if we really think the problem with this team is the Keeper then there’s no hope for the fans either.

Edited by Helmet46 (17 Jan 2021 9.27pm)

I’m not saying he’s the problem but he’s part of it. He is one of basically every player we have who can’t pass a ball 10 yards,

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 17 Jan 21 9.29pm

Ignore - poster twice.

Edited by doombear (17 Jan 2021 9.31pm)

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 17 Jan 21 9.29pm

Hodgson must have been terrified of a Liverpool repeat.
The grand irony is he sets up to keep the score down but ends up being thrashed anyway. Once we go one down against the likes of Man City and the manner in which we are set up it becomes just a matter of how many; there's no plan b.

I look forward to Hodgson leaving at the end of the season. The club needs a change, some fresh impetus.

 

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 17 Jan 21 9.30pm

We were never going to take anything from that game. Zaha may have had a knock but he was clearly giving Benteke a rest ahead of the next 2 games. We move on to more important games.

Roy has fulfilled the brief given to him and will do again this season. If we spend anything rebuilding in January then Parish is clearly thinking of going with Roy next season. Personally I’d like to see Roy retire at the end of the season. All teams need a fresh approach with a new coach every few years and it’s probably time for us to do that ..... just make sure it’s not another FDB!

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 17 Jan 21 9.31pm

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

Was City that good??

Three direct mistakes by Palaces
McA stupid long cross field pass leads to corner which leads to 1st goal,
Luka pass direct to City player, out corner goal
Corner, we know how that happens from another mistake then Townsend, gone to head being back at City.....
Why keep passing back to keeper which lead to free kick which 4-0.

So how good was actually City?
Cut out 4 mistakes and no goals
Did City create goals no.. they seized of mistakes.

Did Palace try to win a point.... maybe
Can we cut out the mistakes, no not against top teams.
Did we learn anything about Roy and his tactics... SFA

This was the frustrating thing that every goal was the result of a mistake. However the gulf in quality was so large that had those goals not gone in I've no doubt City would have found them somewhere else.

Other than the goal difference taking a beating I'm not too fussed about losing to City as this isn't where our season is decided. However the next 7 games I expect us to be putting in some markedly better performances which will have a huge say in how our season pans out.

Next 7 games: West Ham, Wolves, Newcastle, Leeds, Burnley,Brighton and Fulham.

Edited by samprior (17 Jan 2021 9.31pm)

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 17 Jan 21 9.31pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

I

Show me where I said field some youth players against City..!!

I know plenty about football thanks, quite obvious you don’t..!!

Now guys - don't let's bicker amongst ourselves. Haven't you got a cat to kick?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Jan 21 9.31pm

Tonight was embarrassing but some will conclude that they expected a comprehensive defeat against a top-class team.
We lose the next game,home to W.Ham and the 'Alarm bells' will ring even louder.

 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 17 Jan 21 9.32pm

Originally posted by Tyke Exile

£810 million vs £150 million - what on earth does everyone expect? OK a bit more fight and urgency would be nice but when you try and race your Kia Sportage against a Jaguar XJ and lose you can't blame your Sportage for not being up to the job it was purchased for.

Double what our top earner is on

d7be6656-dad2-4828-8c5a-cc417de52a69.jpg Attachment: d7be6656-dad2-4828-8c5a-cc417de52a69.jpg (89.39Kb)

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 17 Jan 21 9.38pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

I’m not saying he’s the problem but he’s part of it. He is one of basically every player we have who can’t pass a ball 10 yards,

He’s a good keeper but the panic within the team rubs off. It was the same problem Butland had at Stoke.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 17 Jan 21 9.41pm

Souness summed it up well at half time when he was asked what we need to do to play further up the pitch and he answered that he didn’t think this (Palace’s) group of players could.

Let’s be honest, any hope of a performance or result evaporated with Zaha’s absence.

Arguments about whether Roy should have picked Benteke and Ayew also completely futile and sum up where we are although I would argue Ayew works harder, has better touch and scored more goals last season than Benteke has in three years.

City are flying but the biggest disappointment was the nature of the goals conceded from corners IMO.

 

merganser Flag 17 Jan 21 9.41pm

The game came far too soon after the Arsenal match.

I thought our lads all put in a shift against a team of stars.

Mitchell is only youngster, and he did pretty well against Sterling. He’ll have learned a helluva lot.

If it hadn’t been for those two wonder-goals, the scoreline would have been more respectable.

Hats off to Ayew and Townsend for 110 per cent effort, but the same applies to the rest of the team.

 

Page 11 of 18 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Manchester City v Palace Match Thread