You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Everton match thread
November 16 2026 4.13am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace v Everton match thread


Page 11 of 12 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
taylors lovechild Flag 13 Dec 21 8.56am

A thoroughly enjoyable game and glad to see Vieira restored some calm and bravery on the ball (aside from the last 20 minutes). Having two players in the centre of midfield with energy and passing ability seemed to make all the difference. I'm not going to get too carried away as, aside from Demarai Gray, Everton were poor and looked more like they wanted a fight than a game of football. However, I don't think anyone had a bad game and as others have said Hughes and Ayew were great, albeit Gallagher still probably edged it for MOTM.

 

Egor Flag Streatham 13 Dec 21 8.59am

He seemed to be holding his hamstring but did still play on for a good amount of time. He eventually asked Ward to let Viera know there was a problem and went off. We may see Clyne on Wednesday night.

Originally posted by Mathers

Any idea what happened with TM? He didn’t seem injured but completely switched off in the last 20 mins. Thar Gordon break could easily have cost us. So bad that Clyney had to come on a LB.

Think our lack of cover at full back needs to be addressed next month.

 

ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 13 Dec 21 9.04am

A great result and performance from the boys yesterday,especially good to see Will Hughes put in a very good stint on debut.A word of caution though,apart from Spurs I thought the Toffee’s were the worst side we have come up against this season.I know Southampton are on a bad run at the moment but they press well which always seems to give us problems and have been a bogey team for us in the past.We need to keep up the intensity we showed yesterday on Wednesday.
Up the Palace!!

 

Skinnii Flag Sheffield 13 Dec 21 9.56am

Originally posted by Mathers

Any idea what happened with TM? He didn’t seem injured but completely switched off in the last 20 mins. Thar Gordon break could easily have cost us. So bad that Clyney had to come on a LB.

Think our lack of cover at full back needs to be addressed next month.

I do agree we need to address cover at left back but I think the issue with Mitchell is not of his making.

If you watch carefully when we attack we change to a back 3 with Tomkins in the middle, Ward on the right, Guehi on the left. Mitchell pushes high up the left touchline almost as a left sided midfielder. This creates an overload on our left, and prevents defenders from doubling up on Zaha without using a central midfielder (which in turn creates space for one of our midfielders)

When we're defending we revert to an orthodox back four.

However this creates issues for Mitchell.

Firstly he needs to expend a lot of energy pushing forward and then dropping back. This might explain why he looked so tired towards the end of yesterdays game.

Secondly it creates a hole behind him, that should be filled by either Geuhi as the left sided central defender or one of the midfield three dropping in. If our attack breaks down and the opposition breaks quickly in transition (as was the case with Gordon yesterday) they can exploit this space. This is not Mitchell's fault. It's a fault of the tactics. It's a risk I think Vieira is prepared to take because of Guehi's recovery pace.

In the case of the Gordon chance, which came from a quick Everton break after one of our attacks, Mitchell (who looked knackered at this stage) was caught up field, Guehi and Kouyate were sucked into defending Townsend and the ball round the corner exposed the space behind Mitchell. On another day we may have conceded but we didn't so you could say the risk was worth taking.

I think this in game flexibility (defending 4-3-3 and attacking 3-4-3) also explains why Ayew is preferred on the right to Olise.

At the moment Ayew offers far greater protection on the right wing by virtue of his work rate and defensive capabilities when we shift to back a 3 when attacking. Ward does not have the recovery pace of Guehi or attacking potential of Mitchell so we need a player to hold down the whole of the right wing almost on their own - something Ayew did really well yesterday. It will be interesting to see what happens when Ferguson is fit and whether this will allow Vieira to play Olise knowing he has Ferguson sat behind him as cover.

Edited by Skinnii (13 Dec 2021 10.16am)

 


"The object of war is not to die for your country but to make some other b*stard die for theirs" - General Patton

southnorwoodhill Flag 13 Dec 21 10.11am

Originally posted by Skinnii

I do agree we need to address cover at left back but I think the issue with Mitchell is not of his making.

If you watch carefully when we attack we change to a back 3 with Tomkins in the middle, Ward on the right, Guehi on the left. Mitchell pushes high up the left touchline almost as a left sided midfielder. This creates an overload on our left, and prevents defenders from doubling up on Zaha without using a central midfielder (which in turn creates space for one of our midfielders)

When we're defending we revert to an orthodox back four.

However this creates issues for Mitchell.

Firstly he needs to expend a lot of energy pushing forward and then dropping back. This might explain why he looked so tired towards the end of yesterdays game.

Secondly it creates a hole behind him, that should be filled by either Geuhi as the left sided central defender or one of the midfield three dropping in. If our attack breaks down and the opposition breaks quickly in transition (as was the case with Gordon yesterday) they can exploit this space. This is not Mitchell's fault. It's a fault of the tactics. It's a risk I think Vieira is prepared to take because of Guehi's recovery pace.

In the case of the Gordon chance, which came from a quick Everton break after one of our attacks, Mitchell (who looked knackered at this stage) was caught up field, Guehi and Kouyate were sucked into defending Townsend and the ball round the corner exposed the space behind Mitchell. On another day we may have conceded but we didn't so you could say the risk was worth taking.

I think this in game flexibility (defending 4-3-3 and attacking 3-4-3) also explains why Ayew is preferred on the right to Olise.
At the moment Ayew offers far greater protection on the right wing by virtue of his work rate and defensive capabilities when we shift to back 3 when attacking. Ward does not have the recovery pace of Guehi or attacking potential of Mitchell so we need a player to hold down the whole of the right wing almost on their own - something Ayew did really well yesterday. It will be interesting to see what happens when Ferguson is fit and whether this will allow Vieira to play Olise knowing he has Ferguson sat behind him as cover.

Good points. I am reminded of the 3-4-1-2 formation Capello used at Roma when Cafu and Candela would provide width going forward and having the stamina to get back when required. Alas these days Ward isn't quite on the same level as those two and right back is a position we need to invest in.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 13 Dec 21 10.20am

Originally posted by Mathers

Any idea what happened with TM? He didn’t seem injured but completely switched off in the last 20 mins. Thar Gordon break could easily have cost us. So bad that Clyney had to come on a LB.

Think our lack of cover at full back needs to be addressed next month.

It does yes, Wardy exposed again a number of times yesterday and some slack defending nearly cost us (twice), particularly the second half chance. At least Mitchell offers us something going forward. Ward was not involved once getting forward and it was ALL Ayew down our right hand side.

On that note, Jordan was again absolutely superb, he roasted Godfrey time after time and was involved in so much of our good work. He retained the ball well, set up Connor for the first goal and work tirelessly for the team.

Wilf needs resting. Yes he still shows the odd bit of class but in general terms he is just not on it at the moment. Yet again he walked off without so much as a smile yesterday or ANY acknowledgement to the crowd whatsoever.

He is that underwhelming that people keep saying he must be playing with an injury?! I’m not sure he is and these comments have been circulating for TWO seasons now. Time to give somebody else an opportunity and give Dazet a bit of a break.

Edited by Phil’s Barber (13 Dec 2021 10.24am)

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 13 Dec 21 10.28am

Originally posted by Skinnii

I do agree we need to address cover at left back but I think the issue with Mitchell is not of his making.

If you watch carefully when we attack we change to a back 3 with Tomkins in the middle, Ward on the right, Guehi on the left. Mitchell pushes high up the left touchline almost as a left sided midfielder. This creates an overload on our left, and prevents defenders from doubling up on Zaha without using a central midfielder (which in turn creates space for one of our midfielders)

When we're defending we revert to an orthodox back four.

However this creates issues for Mitchell.

Firstly he needs to expend a lot of energy pushing forward and then dropping back. This might explain why he looked so tired towards the end of yesterdays game.

Secondly it creates a hole behind him, that should be filled by either Geuhi as the left sided central defender or one of the midfield three dropping in. If our attack breaks down and the opposition breaks quickly in transition (as was the case with Gordon yesterday) they can exploit this space. This is not Mitchell's fault. It's a fault of the tactics. It's a risk I think Vieira is prepared to take because of Guehi's recovery pace.

In the case of the Gordon chance, which came from a quick Everton break after one of our attacks, Mitchell (who looked knackered at this stage) was caught up field, Guehi and Kouyate were sucked into defending Townsend and the ball round the corner exposed the space behind Mitchell. On another day we may have conceded but we didn't so you could say the risk was worth taking.

I think this in game flexibility (defending 4-3-3 and attacking 3-4-3) also explains why Ayew is preferred on the right to Olise.

At the moment Ayew offers far greater protection on the right wing by virtue of his work rate and defensive capabilities when we shift to back a 3 when attacking. Ward does not have the recovery pace of Guehi or attacking potential of Mitchell so we need a player to hold down the whole of the right wing almost on their own - something Ayew did really well yesterday. It will be interesting to see what happens when Ferguson is fit and whether this will allow Vieira to play Olise knowing he has Ferguson sat behind him as cover.

Edited by Skinnii (13 Dec 2021 10.16am)

Tactical decision are based upon the players you have available to you and their strengths and weaknesses, so I think you're right in your assessment.

Mitchell yesterday seemed to really struggle in the last 20 minutes, but it seems this was possibly down to him continuing playing while having an injury.

Looking to the future, I question whether Olise will be deployed wide right as I thought he played more centrally. And whether Ferguson comes good remains to be seen.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 13 Dec 21 11.18am

Good post Skinnii.

 

Mathers Flag 13 Dec 21 11.22am

All fair points. The imbalance of the full backs is becoming a concern. No doubt Wardy has stepped up this season but his lack of pace is costing us goals (yesterday he got very lucky he didn’t gift equaliser) and means we simply do not attack from wide right as he hasn’t got the legs to overlap the winger.

TM needs a rest or possibly injured. Only other left footer we have is Schlupp but serious question marks over his defensive capabilities.

Need to spend some serious cash on full backs soon as it’s a position we’ve neglected in recent years and relied on the academy.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 13 Dec 21 11.41am

Originally posted by sprites

Here’s a question: does Andersen get back in the team? We’ve looked more solid defensively with Tonks I think.

100% yes.

JT looked better yesterday, but IMO that is all down to having a ball player at DCM who always made himself available.

To be fair to him, as long as we have the midfield right. I'm now less worried about him coming into the team than I was before last night.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 13 Dec 21 11.45am

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

I think we do miss Anderson’s range of passing. He can ping a cross field ball to the wide men that Tomkins can’t. But isn’t it great we have options and not scraping the barrel.
Hope Tyrick is ok for Wednesday


Not so much yesterday IMO as Hughes played some good accurate passes that got us moving quickly.

Also as MOTD2 showed in their analysis, Gallagher and Ayew worked together extremely well in getting the ball into good forward positions.

Once again, sadly, Wilf was the weak link up front for much of the game.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 13 Dec 21 12.22pm

When you think we had Andersonl, Jimmy Mac , Ferguson all out. Then Olise Eze on the bench. Rak Saki turnin up every game in the U23, Wilf playing well but not at his best, brilliant academy, top manager, best fans, just proud to be Palace and Then if we could just get Connor for another season please Chelsea.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 13 Dec 21 12.33pm

1 win and Anderson isn't good enough to get back in the squad, Hughes, Tompkins and ayew are the best thing since sliced bread.

Cant wait to lose against Southampton and for the pva is tactically inept, ayew shouldn't play again and we need Anderson and mccarthur back ASAP post's to start again.

 

YT Flag Oxford 13 Dec 21 12.59pm

Originally posted by rikz

1 win and Anderson isn't good enough to get back in the squad, Hughes, Tompkins and ayew are the best thing since sliced bread.

Cant wait to lose against Southampton and for the pva is tactically inept, ayew shouldn't play again and we need Anderson and mccarthur back ASAP post's to start again.

I can wait!

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 13 Dec 21 1.38pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Maybe start Eze or Olise instead of Wilf. He is very sensitive at the moment. Ten men would not help.

Totally agree. I don't know what's going on with Zaha at the moment but it's just a matter of time before he gets himself sent off the way he's carrying on.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 13 Dec 21 1.43pm

Originally posted by rikz

1 win and Anderson isn't good enough to get back in the squad, Hughes, Tompkins and ayew are the best thing since sliced bread.

Cant wait to lose against Southampton and for the pva is tactically inept, ayew shouldn't play again and we need Anderson and mccarthur back ASAP post's to start again.

It’s very strange, one week we are in a relegation battle, the next we are challenging for a European spot.
All because a win over a dysfunctional Everton, after a run of 3 defeats. Just shows how fickle fans are, one week Ayew should never be in the team, next he is nearly MOM, if it wasn’t for Gallagher.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 13 Dec 21 3.16pm

Originally posted by rikz

1 win and Anderson isn't good enough to get back in the squad, Hughes, Tompkins and ayew are the best thing since sliced bread.

Cant wait to lose against Southampton and for the pva is tactically inept, ayew shouldn't play again and we need Anderson and mccarthur back ASAP post's to start again.

If he is tactically inept, lucky he left in the summer then

 

becky Flag over the moon 13 Dec 21 3.44pm

Originally posted by pompeyeagle

Totally agree. I don't know what's going on with Zaha at the moment but it's just a matter of time before he gets himself sent off the way he's carrying on.

As I said earlier on in this thread, I wonder if he's being affected by suddenly seeming to loose his 'top dog' status.

He was the biggest fish in the Palace pond; the one man we couldn't play without, first name on the team sheet every week and the darling of the crowd when he picked up the ball and took it round three players. His ambition was a top 5 club and European football, and quite rightly so at the time.

Now, suddenly at 29 as his sun is definitely heading into the West, no big club has come in for him, he's certainly slower (by his standards) and less agile of late and suddenly his pond is full of hungry, younger players, taking their chances and taking the glory, together with a new manager who isn't building a one-man team around him.


It must, for a player like Wilf, be very hard to take mentally with the frustration of unfulfilled ambition.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Oddball2021 Flag Adelaide 13 Dec 21 4.34pm

I like Wilf up front as a cameo main striker. He's not as good on the wings anymore it seems to me, but deadly as a striker if he gets a sniff and that forces oppositions to put their best defenders on him which provides gaps elsewhere. Viera is doing a great job making Palace a SQUAD team that relies less and less on individuals. It's awesome to think that Wilf can be dropped without a revolt from the fans. My major take from the Everton match is Will Hughes. I saw him at training some weeks ago and thought he looked below standard. I'm happy to see that it must have been a temporary thing as he was brilliant against Everton. I believe that our run of three losses was largely due to the role Macarthur played in linking and mopping up in midfield and developing attacks. Milo or Kouyate cannot do that as well or as fast, and TBH I was expecting more losses, because the ball wasn't getting to our more dynamic frontline players, whose quietness became apparent and were wrongly getting blamed. The Everton match from the first minute Hughes was helping to regularly bring these players into attacking action - Everton hardly touched the balI - saw it as a critical part of our system, and was hoping that Jairo or Hughes or whoever would do that role. SO my big positive of the Everton match was Hughes. Also, good to see Tomkins doing a job that he can now slot into whenever Anderson or Guehi are out. The squad is starting to look awesome. Also Clyne did a half decent job at RB last week. CPFC looking good. I like Viera!

 

george1212 Flag london 13 Dec 21 4.49pm

I think the other good news (and I am sure has already been covered) is that Hughes had a good debut for us. Our central midfield seemed problematic but all of a sudden, and with Jimmy Mac coming back soon-ish, we actually look a bit more decent in the middle.

And boy, that win was a relief after four games without one.

Fingers crossed for Wednesday evening.

 

Page 11 of 12 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Everton match thread