You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mateta ?
November 16 2026 4.17am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Mateta ?


Page 11 of 12 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
dreamwaverider Flag London 01 Feb 22 12.07am

Very happy. Adds another angle to our squad.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 01 Feb 22 2.18am

Originally posted by rikz

Don't think edouard, benteke and mateta are a bad choice of strikers for us but would rather edouard played through the middle with zaha and olise either side.

I agree, that's probably the best front three we have. Although I can see the temptation to play Ayew for the tougher games.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 01 Feb 22 6.05am

Seems more willing to come for the ball and try to find space that Ben who wants it to him. He's improved a lot since pat took the helm. Just maybe we have a rough diamond who is slowly being polished. Time will tell.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 01 Feb 22 6.23am

It makes perfect sense to play Ayew against the top 6 clubs and Olise for the others. As Olise matures and his defensive work improves then eventually the role will become his alone.

Mateta is getting better. Wasn’t keen with what I saw initially but he has definitely improved and it appears PV likes him so that’s good enough for me.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 01 Feb 22 7.20am

In today's money £9m seems like a good bit of business for a player who's shown glimpses of what he could offer. The one thing I'll say about him is that he has that Bolasie madness about him, in that you're not really sure what he's going to do. He comes across as a good character so I really hope for him and us that this works out. With the signing of Plange as well it seems the club have decided to go for potential, which for a club our size seems a sensible route if we get it right.

 

ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 01 Feb 22 8.52am

Strange how he wasn’t played or on the bench very often after scoring that goal against Brighton.The rumour being PV didn’t rate him and suddenly since Christmas he has featured and suddenly is wanted.Was it a grand plan to play it cool to sign him cheaply?

 

PatrickA Flag London 01 Feb 22 9.37am

I watched him in the pre-season games and wasn’t impressed.
His timing was off, he couldn’t head the ball straight and had difficulty controlling the ball.
However, I have seen a recent improvement and can see why some see him as a better current option than Benteke.
He takes up good positions in the penalty area, looks to run in behind defences and looks like he could cause defenders problems with his awkward style.
When everybody is fit perhaps not an automatic starter , but certainly an option.

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 01 Feb 22 11.21am

At a reduced fee, it's a good deal. Still not fully convinced by him but the past few weeks have been better. In the build up to the Brighton game, Neville/Carragher were saying that any striker signed into the Premier League for <£20m is a complete gamble which makes us getting one we know the ability of at ~£9m quite sensible.

I think the best part of the deal is it gives us a lot of freedom in the summer. Without this deal, we'd be left with Edouard plus Benteke with 1 year on his contract (are we counting Ayew?) as recognised strikers which has us vulnerable and needing to buy, possibly spending silly money.

Now, we can see if we get Nketiah, see if a bid comes in for Benteke, or if it suits us, do absolutely nothing and exit the summer with the same 3 (JP, Edouard, Benteke) we started with and spend the money on a central midfielder.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 01 Feb 22 12.41pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

At a reduced fee, it's a good deal. Still not fully convinced by him but the past few weeks have been better. In the build up to the Brighton game, Neville/Carragher were saying that any striker signed into the Premier League for <£20m is a complete gamble which makes us getting one we know the ability of at ~£9m quite sensible.

I think the best part of the deal is it gives us a lot of freedom in the summer. Without this deal, we'd be left with Edouard plus Benteke with 1 year on his contract (are we counting Ayew?) as recognised strikers which has us vulnerable and needing to buy, possibly spending silly money.

Now, we can see if we get Nketiah, see if a bid comes in for Benteke, or if it suits us, do absolutely nothing and exit the summer with the same 3 (JP, Edouard, Benteke) we started with and spend the money on a central midfielder.


It will be interesting to see what Nketiah and his agent will look for when his contract runs out. Hopefully, we avoided a dud with him. I see us sticking with the 3 strikers we've got. Can't see Benteke going anywhere given his comfortable existence in London. I wouldn't exclude Ayew as an option up front (assuming his contract is extended) and let's not forget that Zaha has been quite effective when pressed into a central striker role.

I hope we'll keep any funds we have for strengthening midfield and defence.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 01 Feb 22 12.50pm

Sometimes I think we underestimate the time it takes for some players to adjust to living in a new country, speaking a different language, playing with new team mates and in the toughest league in the world. I'm certainly guilty of that in retrospect.

The fee we have paid for Mateta is a more realistic one. He's certainly made progress under PV - I'm sure French language has helped there - and maybe the security of a permanent deal will help him settle further.

I'm still not convinced by him, but I'll be delighted to be proven wrong.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Far away fan Flag On the border of jungle 01 Feb 22 1.17pm

Happy he has signed, there is a decent player there, Roy's system wasn't correct for him.

 

Omph Flag Liverpool 01 Feb 22 2.18pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Sometimes I think we underestimate the time it takes for some players to adjust to living in a new country, speaking a different language, playing with new team mates and in the toughest league in the world. I'm certainly guilty of that in retrospect.

The fee we have paid for Mateta is a more realistic one. He's certainly made progress under PV - I'm sure French language has helped there - and maybe the security of a permanent deal will help him settle further.

I'm still not convinced by him, but I'll be delighted to be proven wrong.

Pretty sure French is one of the languages Roy is fluent in and Wilf, Kouyate and Tekkers are all French speakers. But with you on the acclimatisation point. Back in the day it was customary to wait a while for new signings to settle.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 01 Feb 22 2.47pm

Well done Mateta.

And many 'drapeau de coin' (corner flags) as you can eat.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 01 Feb 22 3.31pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Sometimes I think we underestimate the time it takes for some players to adjust to living in a new country, speaking a different language, playing with new team mates and in the toughest league in the world. I'm certainly guilty of that in retrospect.

The fee we have paid for Mateta is a more realistic one. He's certainly made progress under PV - I'm sure French language has helped there - and maybe the security of a permanent deal will help him settle further.

I'm still not convinced by him, but I'll be delighted to be proven wrong.

For me, pretty much exactly what Neillo has said. I would only add that I have a lot of respect for Mateta the individual. In what must have been a pretty horrible last twelve months, by and large, he's kept his head down, hasn't complained, has clearly worked hard on his game, been a positive figure, and earned the chance to play that he's had recently. That he appears to have taken that chance with both hands is very much to his credit.

Whether, as Neillo says, Mateta turns out to be the real thing is something only time will tell but in an age of self-centred footballing prima donnas, Mateta's application and humility in the face of adversity has been a breath of fresh air and I have nothing but respect for the way he's earned his opportunity. I'd love to see him thrive and build on the past month. Whatever else, the lad has character.


Edited by sydtheeagle (01 Feb 2022 3.32pm)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Robk Flag 01 Feb 22 5.20pm

Pleased he’s signed...will improve even more and hopefully score more goals.....

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 01 Feb 22 7.07pm

I have to say I find this signing, if not baffling, then at least difficult to understand.

Mainz letting him go when they were in a relegation dogfight, and on such advantageous terms to us, was an alarm bell to begin with. He's been here for a year, and failed to convince either of his managers that he was good enough to be first choice, notwithstanding his inclusion in the team in the last couple of weeks. Hodgson and Vieira play very different football, yet by and large neither found much use for Mateta.

Freedman and Parish can't have been blown away by Mateta either, or they wouldn't have extended Bentekes contract, bought Edouard and tried repeatedly to get Nketiah. Quite what has changed the minds of the manager, DoF and chairman now is unclear. I appreciate that we might have got him for a lesser fee than was originally agreed, but that itself speaks volumes for how he's played.

Mostly though I'm confused about this signing because of what I've seen on the pitch. He's slow, clumsy and laboured.

Hopefully he'll prove me entirely wrong with bells on!

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 01 Feb 22 7.15pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

I have to say I find this signing, if not baffling, then at least difficult to understand.

Mainz letting him go when they were in a relegation dogfight, and on such advantageous terms to us, was an alarm bell to begin with. He's been here for a year, and failed to convince either of his managers that he was good enough to be first choice, notwithstanding his inclusion in the team in the last couple of weeks. Hodgson and Vieira play very different football, yet by and large neither found much use for Mateta.

Freedman and Parish can't have been blown away by Mateta either, or they wouldn't have extended Bentekes contract, bought Edouard and tried repeatedly to get Nketiah. Quite what has changed the minds of the manager, DoF and chairman now is unclear. I appreciate that we might have got him for a lesser fee than was originally agreed, but that itself speaks volumes for how he's played.

Mostly though I'm confused about this signing because of what I've seen on the pitch. He's slow, clumsy and laboured.

Hopefully he'll prove me entirely wrong with bells on!

Agree. Can’t help thinking they thought we’d better do more in the window than just the lad from Derby for £1m & this was an easy win.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 01 Feb 22 9.41pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

I have to say I find this signing, if not baffling, then at least difficult to understand.

Mainz letting him go when they were in a relegation dogfight, and on such advantageous terms to us, was an alarm bell to begin with. He's been here for a year, and failed to convince either of his managers that he was good enough to be first choice, notwithstanding his inclusion in the team in the last couple of weeks. Hodgson and Vieira play very different football, yet by and large neither found much use for Mateta.

Freedman and Parish can't have been blown away by Mateta either, or they wouldn't have extended Bentekes contract, bought Edouard and tried repeatedly to get Nketiah. Quite what has changed the minds of the manager, DoF and chairman now is unclear. I appreciate that we might have got him for a lesser fee than was originally agreed, but that itself speaks volumes for how he's played.

Mostly though I'm confused about this signing because of what I've seen on the pitch. He's slow, clumsy and laboured.

Hopefully he'll prove me entirely wrong with bells on!

Agree entirely. But $9 is probably about right for 3rd choice striker in today's market. I also hope he proves us wrong.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 Feb 22 9.49pm

Originally posted by sprites

Agree entirely. But is probably about right for 3rd choice striker in today's market. I also hope he proves us wrong.

I think 9 dollars is the bargain of the century

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 01 Feb 22 10.25pm

At least we seem to be following a plan now. Young potential. Two more this window.
Just hope Mateta keeps improving.

 

Page 11 of 12 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mateta ?