You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > CPFC V Stoke Match Thread
November 16 2026 3.59am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

CPFC V Stoke Match Thread


Page 11 of 15 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >
Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 02 Mar 22 4.29am

Originally posted by 55 years a fan

The only thing to say tonight is we got through.

Is it me or are we getting worse as the season goes on ?

I thought the team were playing for Comic Relief!!! Looked very lack lustre as indeed they did last Saturday. They won't get through the next round playing like that.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 02 Mar 22 5.11am

We are in the hat for the quarterfinals, that is all that matters, really. But what a horrible, horrible Palace effort. Zaha did his best to get a Stoke assist, Ayew (no comments) and how come Edouardo is regarded below Mateta?
Great game from our left-back kid, Jairo proved he is wasted on the bench and Schlupp is no more than a passenger. Hope our luck in the draws continues, sod we avoid the big guns in the next round.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 02 Mar 22 6.24am

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

I thought the team were playing for Comic Relief!!! Looked very lack lustre as indeed they did last Saturday. They won't get through the next round playing like that.

Correct we won’t, but I’m sure we all said that in 1990 when we scraped passed Rochdale and Cambridge. Low and behold, we raised our game and beat the mighty Liverpool.

It’s the FA Cup, we’re in the quarter finals, one game from Wembley, anything can happen now.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 02 Mar 22 8.09am

This isn't the league, performances mean absolutely nothing and it is entirely just the result. The weather was horrible and we should just be glad we're through. Having said all that...

...Mateta has the worst first touch since I can't remember when and I'm starting to think perhaps he won't be here next season. I keep hoping that he might have that unexpected quality that Bolasie always had, but you would hope at this level a player would know how to trap and hold a ball. Did the club just agree to the reduced fee out of desperation as they couldn't get a better option? Bentenke is in semi-retirement but Edouard must be watching on thinking "What have I done wrong?"

Tayo was about the only bright spot. Naive at times, but so much energy and has a great left foot. He hit a couple of great direct balls that landed right on Mateta's head. Jairo always comes across as a good guy so I'm glad he got the winner. A great opportunity to play Eze in his preferred central role last night with the way we set up, but again he's left on the bench. I think Vieira has done a great job, but I just don't understand why he is still not getting game time, unless he isn't fully fit.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Mar 22 8.11am

The objective of course was to be in the hat for the next round and this was achieved but the performance against a Championship team left a great deal to be desired.

Anyone not knowing the teams would have difficulty in knowing which was the PL team.
A far from convincing display,no fluidity going forward,did not move the ball fast enough particularly in the 1st half and played a number of sideways and backwards passes.
The defending once again was abject on occasions and the goal we conceded was very poor with the goalscorer left in acres of space.

Through to the next round but a disappointing performance.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 02 Mar 22 8.14am

Last nights game was as much about Stoke playing well as us playing badly. They had nothing to lose they got stuck in and played far more expansively than you would expect for a team in 15th in the championship. Look at Boro’s result last night. We won that’s all you have to do in a cup tie.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 02 Mar 22 8.24am

Originally posted by Willo

The objective of course was to be in the hat for the next round and this was achieved but the performance against a Championship team left a great deal to be desired.

Anyone not knowing the teams would have difficulty in knowing which was the PL team.
A far from convincing display,no fluidity going forward,did not move the ball fast enough particularly in the 1st half and played a number of sideways and backwards passes.
The defending once again was abject on occasions and the goal we conceded was very poor with the goalscorer left in acres of space.

Through to the next round but a disappointing performance.

It was almost as bad as Spurs.

 

WJK1960 Flag 02 Mar 22 8.43am

Clearly the weather conditions were not good, but there were several things wrong last night.

The formation did not look right, particularly on our left hand side. Was Zaha playing left wing or off Mateta ? It wasn't clear to me and the support given to Adaramola in terms of having an out ball was often limited.

It does seem to me that we are trying to move towards a more fluid style of football being less reliant on a target man. I assume that is the main reason Mateta is being given a decent run, and that in general Benteke is not playing. There was some evidence of this against Watford. But the team needs the players to do this. One of Gallaghers many qualities is that he is always trying to get on the front foot when getting the ball, looking to pass forward or running off the ball into space off Olise or Ayew. But when he is not playing we revert to sideways and backward passing that we saw yesterday and are then reliant on either a great pass from the centre backs or a bit of individual play from Olise or Zaha to free up some space. If that doesn't happen we become very sterile. Yesterday the players weren't able or willing to make the runs into space so we started playing target man football upto Mateta and this is just not his strength.
Hopefully we can make these changes but it does worry me that when Gallagher goes we wont have the personnel to play this more fluid football.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 02 Mar 22 8.47am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

The weather was horrible and we should just be glad we're through.

I remember Clinton Morrison on commentary a few years ago saying that he loved playing in those sort of conditions as the big defenders would be slipping and sliding all over the place

 

ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 02 Mar 22 9.00am

Apart from our two centre backs,Conor Gallagher and Michael Olise the remainder who played last night are only championship standard.

 

The Dolphin Flag 02 Mar 22 9.07am

It was a poor game played by two out of form sides in dreadful conditions.
The aim of the game was to win and we did and are in the next round which is great.
More worrying to me is that we didn't look like there was a game plan and if there was then the players didn't follow it.
PV was going beserk - for him - on the sidelines for the whole of the first half so something wasn't right.
We need to step up on Saturday to have even the remote chance of a draw.
We have a bench that we would have died for in years gone by but the performances on the field are not so good currently - stale and without invention.
On a high note I though that the new full back - Adaramola - looked very sharp and intelligent and with confidence will be a very good player indeed.

 

The Dolphin Flag 02 Mar 22 9.11am

Mateta has the worst first touch since I can't remember when

Did you never see Adi Akinbiyi ??

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Mar 22 9.14am

Originally posted by ripleyeagle

Apart from our two centre backs,Conor Gallagher and Michael Olise the remainder who played last night are only championship standard.

As I have stated before,I am not convinced with Anderson at all.Ball-playing central defender but is greatly wanting in the actual art of defending.I was not impressed with him at Fulham last season.
In general, our defending is woeful.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 02 Mar 22 9.24am

The other day I questioned whether this group of players had it in them to ' win ugly '. Got my answer last night !

The starting eleven was interesting and maybe gave us an insight as to where Olise could end up playing as he progresses. However we didn't look a cohesive unit against a determined, well organised opponent.

I thought Tayo did well at left back, especially as it appeared that Wilf was in a strop right from the start, and rarely helped him out when he needed an outlet. If he keeps developing he can provide real competition for Mitchell.

The enigmas that is Benteke showed better touched in his 5 minute cameo than Mateta did in the previous 85/90.

Bottom line - we're through despite a below par performance

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Fatherken Flag 02 Mar 22 9.27am

that was the worst game I have seen in many a year .
I should have known it would be bad from the start .
Could only get a seat in the old stand , horrible weather , a lack of signage going in entrance 11/12 to block E and stewards not knowing how to get there either . Some s**t light show before the game [ what was that all about ? ]
After all that , a team that seemed that they did not want to be there .
But at least we are into the next round .

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Mar 22 9.28am

Originally posted by NEILLO

The other day I questioned whether this group of players had it in them to ' win ugly '. Got my answer last night !

The starting eleven was interesting and maybe gave us an insight as to where Olise could end up playing as he progresses. However we didn't look a cohesive unit against a determined, well organised opponent.

I thought Tayo did well at left back, especially as it appeared that Wilf was in a strop right from the start, and rarely helped him out when he needed an outlet. If he keeps developing he can provide real competition for Mitchell.

The enigmas that is Benteke showed better touched in his 5 minute cameo than Mateta did in the previous 85/90.

Bottom line - we're through despite a below par performance

I never expected a rout, in actual fact I predicted 1-0 but I did expect us to more dominant against a Stoke side with 1 win in their previous 8 league games.
There was nothing between the teams and our defensive woes continued.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 02 Mar 22 9.40am

Originally posted by Willo

I never expected a rout, in actual fact I predicted 1-0 but I did expect us to more dominant against a Stoke side with 1 win in their previous 8 league games.
There was nothing between the teams and our defensive woes continued.

We've played far better than that this season - and lost.

I'm sure PV will have made his thoughts clear on the level of performance.

But in Cup football it's all about the result.

As for our defence, Clyne had a bad one last night. It's clear that we need a new right back this summer. Tayo I thought was a 6/10. Given more help on the night, he could have had a better game. He's certainly one to push on.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

PatrickA Flag London 02 Mar 22 9.45am


You could be accused of hyperbole in referring to our ‘defensive woes.’
We have a -1 goal difference which is better than it has been for some time and we have never been in danger of taking an absolute trashing.
Mitchell and Guehi are enjoying fine seasons and, prior to Christmas, Ward had looked very solid.
I understand that you have a problem with Anderson and accept he is not a Dann nor a Cahill.
While he is not a dominant old school defender he is critical to the way Vieira wants to play and he is an adept passer of the ball from the back.
There will be a mistakes made , but the key question is whether the benefits outweigh the detriments?
Insofar that our defensive record is comparatively good and that we are attempting to play constructively I would argue that the answer to that is yes.


Originally posted by Willo

I never expected a rout, in actual fact I predicted 1-0 but I did expect us to more dominant against a Stoke side with 1 win in their previous 8 league games.
There was nothing between the teams and our defensive woes continued.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 02 Mar 22 9.46am

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

Really. I thought Clyne’s passing was awful tonight. He could see the forward pass he should be playing but didn’t have the ability to play it. That said the rest weren’t much better.

I agree. I think we are all blinded by fond memories of Clyne. He looks ever more out of depth than Ward when getting forward and his passing is awful.

 

The Dolphin Flag 02 Mar 22 9.50am

I guess that sometimes we need to look at it from the Players point of view.
Their objective was to win the game - and they did.
Would they have preferred to play better and win more easily - I am sure that they would.
I suspect that a lot of used to play at one level or another and frankly those horrible games when you won ugly were great games to play in.
Maybe it is different at the professional level but nonetheless, while I have been critical of last nights performance, we did do what was asked of us.

 

Page 11 of 15 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > CPFC V Stoke Match Thread