This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by footythoughts
You implied that it's not been taken seriously, is deemed 'acceptable', and that no action will be taken. I'm saying that it's received national media attention, has not been deemed acceptable and is being investigated by the club and police with a view of taking action. "It is virtually guaranteed that nothing will happen to the Newcastle fans, whereas someone will probably try and destroy the Palace fan’s life over this. " It's not virtually guarenteed at all, and the idea that 'someone will probably try and destroy the Palace fan’s life over this' is massively OTT. He'll be watching games on telly for a while due to thinking the price of a ticket includes being racist to those he's going to see. It doesn't.
Certainly it would, though you're basically just throwing any get out going now. None of which seem to consider anyone aside from the individual engaging in this behaviour to begin with. Maybe he has tourettes too and it's one of his tics? Or maybe he doesn't.. We can only get so far fetched in excusing behaviour. Edited by footythoughts (12 May 2023 2.20pm) I’m not excusing anyone’s behaviour I am saying how utterly irrelevant it is in the grand scheme of things and how much attention something like this gets compared to the violence, rape and murders that occur on a daily basis sometimes without a mention in the press. The world has become skewed in its priorities.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
This is a powerful lesson… A high school class is learning about the Salem Witch Trials. Their teacher told them they were going to play a game. "I'm going to come around and whisper to each of you whether you're a witch or a regular person. Your goal is to build the largest group possible that does NOT have a witch in it. At the end, any group found to include a witch gets a failing grade." The teens dove into grilling each other. One fairly large group formed, but most of the students broke into small, exclusive groups, turning away anyone they thought gave off even a hint of guilt. "Okay," the teacher said. "You've got your groups. Time to find out which ones fail. All witches, please raise your hands." No one raised a hand. The kids were confused and told the teacher he'd messed up the game. "Did I?” He asked. “Was anyone in Salem an actual witch? Or did everyone just believe what they'd been told?" And that is how you show kids how easy it is to divide a Community. Shunning, scapegoating, placing blame and dividing will each destroy far more than they will protect. Don’t allow fear to cloud your decisions. Use your own discernment. Trust your heart…and your gut. The best teachers will show you where to look, but they won’t tell you what to see. ~Unknown This is how I see Britain bashing itself to pieces over racism at the moment. You see, I consider you to be one of the people who are more interested in trying to prove people are racist than trying to fix any issues. It’s almost a case of joyous indignation when you find something or someone you can get your teeth into. There is so much else wrong in this world that I really haven’t got the time or the energy to worry about the odd fella pulling faces but I’m not defending him and believe me neither is his father. It's notable that it wasn't until the accusations started against the powerful that the Salem witch trials came to a rapid end. Edited by Stirlingsays (12 May 2023 2.37pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| footythoughts |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
I’m not excusing anyone’s behaviour I am saying how utterly irrelevant it is in the grand scheme of things and how much attention something like this gets compared to the violence, rape and murders that occur on a daily basis sometimes without a mention in the press. The world has become skewed in its priorities. As are most things. Sending a message that this is unacceptable at a game is a worthwhile one in comparison to doing nothing and inadvertantly encouraging it. We could argue that football itself takes up a massively disproportionate amount of media attention, but here we are with it being massively popular and so within that setting there are rules to be adhered to.
|
|
| footythoughts |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Beanyboysmd
The English Premiership is arguably one of the most watched leagues in the world. The money made from international TV rights is now a majority of the Premierships income. We can try to crowbar "Nanny state" or "Thin end of the wedge" or whatever meaningless phrase into the conversation but it all boils down to one thing... The whole world is watching, can you not do your allegedly hilarious "Ching-chong Chinaman" routine in front of the rest of the world? You are making us look like t***s. Well summed up. There are definitely arguments to be made about level of punishment, but it's not behaviour that's welcome at the game and a message making that clear is to be expected as not doing so is an encouragement.
|
|
|
Originally posted by footythoughts
Well summed up. There are definitely arguments to be made about level of punishment, but it's not behaviour that's welcome at the game and a message making that clear is to be expected as not doing so is an encouragement. I know that posts that start with "What about......" are a bit tedious. All the same, what about other aspects of football crowd behaviour that aren't welcome at games? As we all know, "fans" routinely wave a finger, make w**nking gestures and V signs, sing "your support is f*cking sh*t", and so on. Even though they are blatantly infringing against the ground regulations in full view of stewards, police, TV cameras, manager, directors and journalists, not a soul says a word about it. I accept what an earlier poster said, namely, that racist gestures and chants are different in that they insult a whole tribe or human type (I can't think of another word for race), but the chasm between the shrug of the shoulders for one class of offensive behaviour and a near-emotional breakdown for another smacks to me slightly of hypocrisy.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Beanyboysmd
The English Premiership is arguably one of the most watched leagues in the world. The money made from international TV rights is now a majority of the Premierships income. We can try to crowbar "Nanny state" or "Thin end of the wedge" or whatever meaningless phrase into the conversation but it all boils down to one thing... The whole world is watching, can you not do your allegedly hilarious "Ching-chong Chinaman" routine in front of the rest of the world? You are making us look like t***s. Spot on
|
|
| footythoughts |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by JRW2
I know that posts that start with "What about......" are a bit tedious. All the same, what about other aspects of football crowd behaviour that aren't welcome at games? As we all know, "fans" routinely wave a finger, make w**nking gestures and V signs, sing "your support is f*cking sh*t", and so on. Even though they are blatantly infringing against the ground regulations in full view of stewards, police, TV cameras, manager, directors and journalists, not a soul says a word about it. I accept what an earlier poster said, namely, that racist gestures and chants are different in that they insult a whole tribe or human type (I can't think of another word for race), but the chasm between the shrug of the shoulders for one class of offensive behaviour and a near-emotional breakdown for another smacks to me slightly of hypocrisy. A fair point. It's likely as much about what's workable and how targetted it is. Racially abusing a player. whether it's the conduct of this tosser, or someone thinking monkey noises or bananas thrown on a pitch is a laugh, crosses a line with most I would say, whereas calling someone a w***er is a bit of a meaningless equal opportunity insult. It was captured on camera (and possibly even seen by Son at the time), and I would say that behaving like this towards an Asian in other settings is hardly decent behaviour. The club had little choice. I get what you mean about what is allowed to go on and what isn't, but I'm pretty sure Palace don't want to be seen as the club where this conduct is encouraged through lack of action. The bloke got the kind of response you'd expect when racially targetting a sportsman before a global audience. Consequence for crap behaviour is a good learning opportunity.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
Surprised this thread is so long. Guy makes a gesture that is clearly targeting Son for his race. Gets caught on camera. League has been very clear it'll be zero tolerance on racist gestures and racist gestures have led to bans for a long time now - there are plenty of examples. Club has publicly said they'll ban the guy. Any other outcome would be newsworthy - the above is exactly the expected result, isn't it? It can be cross compared to situation X or time Y or any number of things but none of it is really relevant - the league has been abundantly clear that it won't tolerate it and anyone that's got enough points to get a ticket to Tottenham away cannot possibly claim to not be aware of the league's expectations of behaviour relevant to racial gestures. True, although tickets do change hands of course. Edited by YT (12 May 2023 4.59pm)
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
| footythoughts |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
Surprised this thread is so long. Guy makes a gesture that is clearly targeting Son for his race. Gets caught on camera. League has been very clear it'll be zero tolerance on racist gestures and racist gestures have led to bans for a long time now - there are plenty of examples. Club has publicly said they'll ban the guy. Any other outcome would be newsworthy - the above is exactly the expected result, isn't it? Indeed. In the public sphere with some there's perfectly valid comment about the level of punishment that should be dished out, and in more disingenuous quarters it's as much about being scared that there is consequence for the type of conduct that they may well align with or their ego is based in (feeling 'better' than this group or that) and wanting to be able to live that fantasy out with impunity. As you say, any other outcome than a ban of some length wouldn't make much sense and would be a bad reflection on the club. He let the club down and was suitably sent packing. Edited by footythoughts (12 May 2023 5.28pm)
|
|
|
When you're not to be outdone by any accusations of racism in South East London - [Link]
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Beanyboysmd
The English Premiership is arguably one of the most watched leagues in the world. The money made from international TV rights is now a majority of the Premierships income. We can try to crowbar "Nanny state" or "Thin end of the wedge" or whatever meaningless phrase into the conversation but it all boils down to one thing... The whole world is watching, can you not do your allegedly hilarious "Ching-chong Chinaman" routine in front of the rest of the world? You are making us look like t***s. You have unintentionally hit the nail on the head. Our standards are now governed by commercial interests. You see it every day. You might think that is a force for good, but I say it is simple a force for the self interest of business. Sadly it isn't yours if you are White ,male, heterosexual and don't own a multi national. The potential global market consists of only 10% Whites and advertisements are generally aimed at Women and minorities. Those are the ones who wish to feel empowered and therefore are the easiest meat. You might think that our new puritanical world is a step towards utopia but look under the surface and something ugly lurks.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
You have unintentionally hit the nail on the head. Our standards are now governed by commercial interests. You see it every day. You might think that is a force for good, but I say it is simple a force for the self interest of business. Sadly it isn't yours if you are White ,male, heterosexual and don't own a multi national. The potential global market consists of only 10% Whites and advertisements are generally aimed at Women and minorities. Those are the ones who wish to feel empowered and therefore are the easiest meat. You might think that our new puritanical world is a step towards utopia but look under the surface and something ugly lurks. Literally all that's being asked is not to make racist gestures. There are plenty of avenues still available to abuse people, that won't lead to a stadium ban, if you require.
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
| footythoughts |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
Literally all that's being asked is not to make racist gestures. There are plenty of avenues still available to abuse people, that won't lead to a stadium ban, if you require.
I'd say Hrolf certainly has a point regarding commercial interests, but it's worth considering that there can be both local and global aspects to that. Locally I wouldn't automatically assume that the majority of fans are happy with this man's behaviour - we're hardly in cross section territory here. Ultimately, nobody with any sense wants bellends like this popping up every time we're playing doing racially abusive faces as way of reflecting the clubs and its values. We're better than that. He should slink off for a while and learn some basic values and common decency.
|
|
|
Let's all have a discussion on whether we should punish someone for what they said.
|
|
|
Thank god there’s a football match on today
|
|
|
Originally posted by Davepalace707
Thank god there’s a football match on today Mods - ban him for life for blasphemy.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
| footythoughts |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
It’s just an observation but son does actually look different to the average indigenous white westerner. Doesn’t need showing granted but Is that racist to state what I see ? While I'm sure your thought comes from a good place, in the Son incident it was done in an angry, aggressive and deameaning manner with the purpose of causing offense and getting a reaction (which it did), that's abundantly clear from the footage. That's not how you behave towards someone and doesn't leave much room for a get out. It clearly wasn't meant as a joke or sincere and sober examination of physical difference. We've had ever get out going stated at someone was who is clearly just a bit of a d!ck either when drunk, or in general. The most conjured up has to be 'what if he has special needs'. Of course, many special needs people 'look different' also. We could angrily mock them too in a rage while at the special Olympics perhaps and see what the response is; I doubt a positive one in that scenario either. We should ask ourselves why we're so desperate to make excuses for this person. From 'personas' mashing the report button, it's clearly not a 'freedom of speech' or 'truth' issue. To a barrage of 'what ifs' with little basis in reality at the guys conduct. Ultimately, if a person angrily racially abuses someone to their face, and does so in front of numerous cameras in front of a worldwide TV audience there is likely going to be a consequence for that. If the guy can't operate in the real world, he'd best watch at home until he can rather than damage the image of the club.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.