You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Aston Villa vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread
November 16 2026 3.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Aston Villa vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread


Page 11 of 13 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
dreamwaverider Flag London 17 Sep 23 3.07pm

Originally posted by monkey

Only he’ll know for sure, but can you imagine the wrath of the home crowd if he had changed his decision? I do think it was more of an ego thing though, ‘I’m right and I’m not changing my mind’ it’s got to be that because no one is surely that stupid to still think that was a penalty after looking at it again

My take is that Richards touched the ball but barely. The ref was definitely trying to prove he was right and so chose the option that Richards didn't touch it. Where are these heat ray thingies you get in the cricket? Or can football not afford the technology??!!

Edited by dreamwaverider (17 Sep 2023 3.07pm)

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 17 Sep 23 3.08pm

Originally posted by monkey

Only he’ll know for sure, but can you imagine the wrath of the home crowd if he had changed his decision? I do think it was more of an ego thing though, ‘I’m right and I’m not changing my mind’ it’s got to be that because no one is surely that stupid to still think that was a penalty after looking at it again

Darren England is . . .

As for the 'wrath' of the home crowd, i think he is that arrogant, it wouldn't of bothered him. We've had it at Selhurst, ref never blinked an eyelid.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 Sep 23 4.22pm

Originally posted by Robk

Unfortunately Darren England isn’t one of the better Referees... Oliver or Taylor wouldn’t have given it....

Anyone know who was on VAR? Suspect neither of these two

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 17 Sep 23 4.29pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Anyone know who was on VAR? Suspect neither of these two

VAR: Robert Jones. Assistant VAR: Ian Hussin.
The fourth official, appropriately enough, was Steve Martin.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 17 Sep 23 4.35pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

In the last 11 games England has reffed Villa he has awarded them 7 penalties. Palace have never won when he has been in charge. Just saying.

hes another clattenberg!

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 17 Sep 23 4.38pm

The ref is of course always under pressure from the crowd, and you could feel it piling on top of him, but that should not affect VAR, or does it?

The commentators, including at the game, 'why is this necessary?'
'it's a stonewall penalty' etc.etc.

'It's an obvious penalty' - Dion Dublin and others, all wrong.

I feel for the players after all that effort, they did not deserve to lose to a clearly wrong decision.

VAR should have gone to specsavers, judgements no better than referees, do we want games to be 105 minutes long after all this cobblers I don't think so.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 17 Sep 23 4.38pm

Originally posted by IMMER PALACE

You normally come up with an interesting or thought provoking post - but this is pony.

Football, for a club our size, with the constraints we operate in is ultra competitive. There is an average of less than 3 goals scored per game. The idea that Palace should be so much better than the better funded opposition away from home that we can easily overcome terrible decisions like that is delusional.

The ref done us. Short and simple. Mistake or ego or bent.

bent ! becomes more and more obvious every week.....VAR is just a tool to help useless bent referees get the decisions they want
...ie big clubs to win!

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 17 Sep 23 5.05pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

What are the exact rules on penalties?
If the defender touches the ball before the man, and I mean slightly, is that still a penalty if the attacker then trips over the defender? Maybe touching the ball very slightly doesn't count as touching it. It didn't yesterday.

Secondly what is the rule on attackers entering the penalty area
Edited by dreamwaverider (17 Sep 2023 1.08pm)

The rules are the same as they have always been ,If in the opinion of the referee a foul is committed its a penalty

Whats changed is the protocols (I posted a link on page 12) which sees VAR interfering with that decision .

I think VAR have overstepped the mark with encroachment , they now say unless the player encroaching has in THEIR opinion an effect on the outcome of the kick they will let it go .

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 17 Sep 23 5.20pm

Don't worry about the penalty decision. The problem is that Palace don't match the ambition of Villa. They had strength in depth on the bench, we have very little.

Wilf left, Olise injured, and Ayew went off. Our response is to bring on Mateta, put Schlupp wide right and leave Rak-Sakhi on the bench. The Brazilian wonder kid has not even appeared yet.

Joel got rinsed again at right back. We have needed a replacement since AWB left, but we spent £20m on a reserve keeper instead.

Yes we will stay up - Luton and Sheff U are very poor. Will we finish higher than 12th place - almost certainly not.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 17 Sep 23 5.31pm

Originally posted by Gribbo

Don't worry about the penalty decision. The problem is that Palace don't match the ambition of Villa. They had strength in depth on the bench, we have very little.

Wilf left, Olise injured, and Ayew went off. Our response is to bring on Mateta, put Schlupp wide right and leave Rak-Sakhi on the bench. The Brazilian wonder kid has not even appeared yet.

Joel got rinsed again at right back. We have needed a replacement since AWB left, but we spent £20m on a reserve keeper instead.

Yes we will stay up - Luton and Sheff U are very poor. Will we finish higher than 12th place - almost certainly not.

Erm we’re not exactly in the same league as them financially. It might have escaped your notice but they’re a slightly bigger club than us in every way. I think their ambitions might be a little higher than us. Former league winners, European champions with a ground capacity of 43,000 and all that

Edited by monkey (17 Sep 2023 5.31pm)

 

Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 17 Sep 23 5.39pm

Originally posted by monkey

Erm we’re not exactly in the same league as them financially. It might have escaped your notice but they’re a slightly bigger club than us in every way. I think their ambitions might be a little higher than us. Former league winners, European champions with a ground capacity of 43,000 and all that

Edited by monkey (17 Sep 2023 5.31pm)

Well, they had all those things going for them when we beat them 3-1 at Selhurst last season.

 

Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 17 Sep 23 5.45pm

Regarding Silurian's post....

There's a lot to be said for this, you old dinosaur! Given that matches that start at 3 p.m. on a Saturday are just entering injury time when the classified results used to be read out by James Alexander Gordon (I'm an old dinosaur too), there's an obvious advantage to clubs with the biggest squads, i.e. nine quality subs as opposed to five of those just making up the numbers. Yet another way to favour the clubs who already have the most going for them.

Edited by Elwissthebest (17 Sep 2023 5.47pm)

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 17 Sep 23 6.23pm

Don't know why folk are complaining about VAR. VAR correctly told the ref to take another look at the penalty presumably because they thought the decision was wrong or at worst questionable.

As I understand it the ref has the final say, and that is why the ref is shown the replay.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 Sep 23 6.36pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

The ref is of course always under pressure from the crowd, and you could feel it piling on top of him, but that should not affect VAR, or does it?

The commentators, including at the game, 'why is this necessary?'
'it's a stonewall penalty' etc.etc.

'It's an obvious penalty' - Dion Dublin and others, all wrong.

I feel for the players after all that effort, they did not deserve to lose to a clearly wrong decision.

VAR should have gone to specsavers, judgements no better than referees, do we want games to be 105 minutes long after all this cobblers I don't think so.

I agree with most of this except VAR going to spec savers. I believe VAR thought decision was wrong. Unfortunately England is an arrogant t*** and is superior to those in VAR. Until we adopt the RU approach football is f***ed

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 Sep 23 6.39pm

Originally posted by the silurian

hes another clattenberg!

Yep I was at Spurs last season, another appalling ref display

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 17 Sep 23 6.48pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

Don't know why folk are complaining about VAR. VAR correctly told the ref to take another look at the penalty presumably because they thought the decision was wrong or at worst questionable.

As I understand it the ref has the final say, and that is why the ref is shown the replay.

I would cut the ref out the VAR decision making.
He has enough on his plate already.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 17 Sep 23 6.54pm

Ahamada developing well just not sure about Rak Saki.
To be fair, neither get much pitch time.

 

Charles Flag Forest Hill 18 Sep 23 12.01pm

As Villa survived more and more chances for us to score a second goal, you kind of knew they'd stage a storming finish. Whether that would have denied us a point with better refereeing is debatable. If we'd got the draw I think we were good for then that would have been a very creditable result away from home to one of last season's stronger sides considering we started with three of the favourite stating 11 injured, saw Ayew limp off after 25 minutes and Andersen looked to be carrying a knock (no long diagonal balls at all, plus he wasn't at his best).

 

Goalpost1 Flag Worcester Park 18 Sep 23 12.44pm

Taking off my Palace hat for a moment. When I saw the penalty incident in real time you can see why it was given but looking at it on replays CR gets a lot of the ball. I think it is a very harsh call.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 18 Sep 23 1.22pm

Ref Watch on Sky this morning dealt with the issue most efficiently by ignoring it altogether. They briefly discussed whether Diaby should have got a penalty but no mention of anything else. Presumably even Dermot Gallagher couldn't defend the ref on this one.

 

Page 11 of 13 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Aston Villa vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread