You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 22 2026 3.51am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

ukip (LOCKED)


Page 110 of 187 < 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 >
Stirlingsays Flag 18 Feb 15 1.34pm

Quote The Sash at 18 Feb 2015 1.22pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 1.05pm

So I deserve UKIP because some people are racist? Hmm.


UKIP are a result of the Labour and the middle class left abandonment and sneering at the white working class 'white van man' character they created.

With such a despicable Tory government doing what good Tory governments are supposed to do, Labour should be hovering up all of their votes with ease in places like Rochester et al, but they aren't because Labour and the left cared little for them or their votes under Blair.

The left ignored them, denigrated them and instead of dealing with them as a demographic instead created a grotesque caricature of them as ignorant, shaven headed, little Englander racists, which in some cases maybe true, most cases not - there can be no whingeing now they are getting their own back and Labour are being bitten on the arse surely ???

Edited by The Sash (18 Feb 2015 1.23pm)

Well put....Nail is hit precisely on its head.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Feb 15 1.36pm

Quote The Sash at 18 Feb 2015 1.33pm

Quote Willo at 18 Feb 2015 1.31pm

Quote The Sash at 18 Feb 2015 1.22pm

With such a despicable Tory government doing what good Tory governments are supposed to do,

All I will say is :

If you get me on my political "Soapbox" the "No Standing" shall pale into insignificance.Best I keep well out of this debate.

Edited by Willo (18 Feb 2015 1.31pm)


Do you stand or sit on your soap box ?

LOL !


 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 18 Feb 15 1.36pm

Quote The Sash at 18 Feb 2015 1.22pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 1.05pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 12.49pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 11.32am

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 11.09am

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 11.07am

I've decided.

Go on then!


I think you'd have been saying the same sort of thing about the influx of blacks and Irish back in the day.


See there you go.....Nick....Don't complain about UKIP because mate, you totally deserve it.


So I deserve UKIP because some people are racist? Hmm.


UKIP are a result of the Labour and the middle class left abandonment and sneering at the white working class 'white van man' character they created (esp in the South)

With such a despicable Tory government doing what good despicable Tory governments are supposed to do, Labour should be hoovering up all of their votes with ease in places like Rochester , but they aren't because Labour and the left cared little for them or their votes under Blair and UKIP have filled the void.

The left ignored them, denigrated them and instead of dealing with them as a demographic instead created a grotesque caricature of them as ignorant, shaven headed, little Englander racists, which in some cases maybe true, most cases not - there can be no whingeing now they are getting their own back and Labour are being bitten on the arse surely ???

Edited by The Sash (18 Feb 2015 1.32pm)

Whilst I agree with your assessment, I myself don't support Labour anymore (even though I think they are the lesser evil of the 2 big parties), I struggle to see how a party full of ex (failed) Tories and the odd labourite thrown in can claim to represent the working class.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 18 Feb 15 1.41pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 1.36pm

Quote The Sash at 18 Feb 2015 1.22pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 1.05pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 12.49pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 11.32am

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 11.09am

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 11.07am

I've decided.

Go on then!


I think you'd have been saying the same sort of thing about the influx of blacks and Irish back in the day.


See there you go.....Nick....Don't complain about UKIP because mate, you totally deserve it.


So I deserve UKIP because some people are racist? Hmm.


UKIP are a result of the Labour and the middle class left abandonment and sneering at the white working class 'white van man' character they created (esp in the South)

With such a despicable Tory government doing what good despicable Tory governments are supposed to do, Labour should be hoovering up all of their votes with ease in places like Rochester , but they aren't because Labour and the left cared little for them or their votes under Blair and UKIP have filled the void.

The left ignored them, denigrated them and instead of dealing with them as a demographic instead created a grotesque caricature of them as ignorant, shaven headed, little Englander racists, which in some cases maybe true, most cases not - there can be no whingeing now they are getting their own back and Labour are being bitten on the arse surely ???

Edited by The Sash (18 Feb 2015 1.32pm)

Whilst I agree with your assessment, I myself don't support Labour anymore (even though I think they are the lesser evil of the 2 big parties), I struggle to see how a party full of ex (failed) Tories and the odd labourite thrown in can claim to represent the working class.


They don't, in the same way the chattering middle classes who man todays Labour party don't, difference is they don't sneer, they claim to listen, they picture themselves in the pub as Mr / Mrs 'Everyman' and hit the right triggers in terms of their concerns.

Ultimately the wishes of the electorate, in all mainstream parties, comes well down the list of their priorities in reality, but if you can tell them what they want to hear over a pint of good old British Bitter without spilling over your shirt then it means votes.


Edited by The Sash (18 Feb 2015 2.09pm)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Feb 15 1.45pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 1.36pm

Whilst I agree with your assessment, I myself don't support Labour anymore (even though I think they are the lesser evil of the 2 big parties), I struggle to see how a party full of ex (failed) Tories and the odd labourite thrown in can claim to represent the working class.

Question: what are the working class most concerned about?

Answer: housing, jobs and the cost of living (the latter being the same for most of us).

UKIP's policy of reducing immigration would directly address the first two of these three.....I don't know by how much but there would certainly be some sort of release of pressure.

What practical policies are any of the main parties offering on these areas......Answer, feck all other than warm words.....If you don't touch Eastern European immigration you aren't doing anything.

There is the basic attraction for the working classes.


Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Feb 2015 1.47pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 18 Feb 15 2.00pm

Exactly, the voters will go with whoever is promising to sort what ever is gripping thier sh1t the tightest, and most areas where UKIP are making massive strides are areas where eastern Europeans have just been dumped and (through no fault of thier own) are turning the place in to a s*** hole.

I watched the Romanians are coming last night, awful how people haveto live in a very poor country, absolutley terrible, but being homless here in the UK seems to be a better prospect than being homeless in Romania, and that may well be the case.

However why should someone who has saved and paid for his house etc etc have the value demolished because a half way house for romanian gypsies has been built at the end of their road.

The bigger picture, which is that the addition of smaller poorer countries to the EU puts strain on the more wealthier countries and that is all fair and above board (some would say) however when it starts effecting peoples homes and where they live something has to change, or the people will vote for whoever is saying they will change it.

I'm no politician but surely making it less appealing for Romaninas to rock up here with their hand out has to be the only rational starting point, and no matter how dumb ass the rest of UKIPS policies may be, thier stance on immigration and the EU will win them bucket loads of seats in areas that are effected directly by mass immigration from eastern Europe, and those areas are increasing day by day.

I would not be surprised at all if within a few years they are the main challengers to the Torys, Labour are the very epitomy of a joke Party, even thier leader looks like a muppet (bert off of Seasame Street).

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Feb 15 2.33pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 1.45pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 1.36pm

Whilst I agree with your assessment, I myself don't support Labour anymore (even though I think they are the lesser evil of the 2 big parties), I struggle to see how a party full of ex (failed) Tories and the odd labourite thrown in can claim to represent the working class.

Question: what are the working class most concerned about?

Answer: housing, jobs and the cost of living (the latter being the same for most of us).

UKIP's policy of reducing immigration would directly address the first two of these three.....I don't know by how much but there would certainly be some sort of release of pressure.

What practical policies are any of the main parties offering on these areas......Answer, feck all other than warm words.....If you don't touch Eastern European immigration you aren't doing anything.

There is the basic attraction for the working classes.


Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Feb 2015 1.47pm)

I'm not so sure that reducing working migrants will result in jobs being taken up, simply because migrant labour tends to proliferate in areas of higher employment, where as longer term unemployment tends towards areas of very low employment.

It should, in theory, push up wages as well, given that companys deprived of cheap migrant labour will either have to employ locally or offshore aspects of their businesses (dependent on viability).

The housing issue, I can imagine that a lot of home owners who rent property might be hit quite hard if you remove a significant portion of the renting population (migrant workers).

Really the solution need to be relocation from areas of high unemployment, into those areas in which employment is fulfilled by migrant labour.

The cost of living could go either way, prices could fall with less demand, or they could rise if companies shift work overseas to host nations.

Also you may find repercussions for British citizens working abroad arguably being 'forced to return', if the UK was excluded from the free movement and working.

The question would be, who are UKIP more interested in long term. Remember that its only really more recently that the idea of 'working migrants' has been a big thing of theirs and it could, I would say is, much more something they use to boost their core agenda which is EU membership.

I could quite easily see UKIP leaving the EU, controlling migration that good for business - less so.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Feb 15 2.42pm

Quote The Sash at 18 Feb 2015 1.22pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 1.05pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 12.49pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 11.32am

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 11.09am

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 11.07am

I've decided.

Go on then!


I think you'd have been saying the same sort of thing about the influx of blacks and Irish back in the day.


See there you go.....Nick....Don't complain about UKIP because mate, you totally deserve it.


So I deserve UKIP because some people are racist? Hmm.


UKIP are a result of the Labour and the middle class left abandonment and sneering at the white working class 'white van man' character they created (esp in the South)

With such a despicable Tory government doing what good despicable Tory governments are supposed to do, Labour should be hoovering up all of their votes with ease in places like Rochester , but they aren't because Labour and the left cared little for them or their votes under Blair and UKIP have filled the void.

The left ignored them, denigrated them and instead of dealing with them as a demographic instead created a grotesque caricature of them as ignorant, shaven headed, little Englander racists, which in some cases maybe true, most cases not - there can be no whingeing now they are getting their own back and Labour are being bitten on the arse surely ???

Edited by The Sash (18 Feb 2015 1.32pm)

The left never abandoned them, they betrayed the working classes through the initial work of Kinnock, then Smith and finally Blair in the production of New Labour, a right of center political party that was essentially 'friend of business', claiming the lie of a 'third way', in reality they were more right wing than Ted Heaths Conservative government, and relied on a spin of being 'the party of the people'.

The rise of both UKIP and the Greens, has its basis in the betrayal of Labour of the working classes - Not just 'white', but all working class people.

Throwing a few bones to civil rights groups doesn't make you left wing. The poverty experienced by working class ethnic groups became greater under new labour, as they utilsied and exploited them for their corporate masters.

Those areas 'which eastern Europeans' have made into 's**t holes', aren't because of the migrants, its down the failure of local authorties and councils to fulfill their obligations, instead money was clawed back to pay for tax cuts and popularist policys aimed at winning elections.

Labour betrayed the working classes.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Feb 15 2.59pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Feb 2015 2.33pm


I'm not so sure that reducing working migrants will result in jobs being taken up, simply because migrant labour tends to proliferate in areas of higher employment, where as longer term unemployment tends towards areas of very low employment.

It should, in theory, push up wages as well, given that companys deprived of cheap migrant labour will either have to employ locally or offshore aspects of their businesses (dependent on viability).

The housing issue, I can imagine that a lot of home owners who rent property might be hit quite hard if you remove a significant portion of the renting population (migrant workers).

Really the solution need to be relocation from areas of high unemployment, into those areas in which employment is fulfilled by migrant labour.

The cost of living could go either way, prices could fall with less demand, or they could rise if companies shift work overseas to host nations.

Also you may find repercussions for British citizens working abroad arguably being 'forced to return', if the UK was excluded from the free movement and working.

The question would be, who are UKIP more interested in long term. Remember that its only really more recently that the idea of 'working migrants' has been a big thing of theirs and it could, I would say is, much more something they use to boost their core agenda which is EU membership.

I could quite easily see UKIP leaving the EU, controlling migration that good for business - less so.



Of course it's a reduction in immigration not a stopping of it.....With control of the numbers, in theory we can more readily control numbers for the labour market. A system of work permits instead of this ridiculous equality with British workers which devalues their birthright.

A reduction in competing for jobs for youth in high immigrant areas will only benefit them.

I could go on to speculate but that's what it is...speculation.....I for one am prepared to find out.

Still, I will speculate to the extent of remembering the situation where I live before we had mass EU immigration into Wisbech.....I remember having less of a housing problem, better wages and more social cohesion....At least here.


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Feb 15 3.12pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Feb 2015 2.42pm

The left never abandoned them, they betrayed the working classes through the initial work of Kinnock, then Smith and finally Blair in the production of New Labour, a right of center political party that was essentially 'friend of business', claiming the lie of a 'third way', in reality they were more right wing than Ted Heaths Conservative government, and relied on a spin of being 'the party of the people'.

The rise of both UKIP and the Greens, has its basis in the betrayal of Labour of the working classes - Not just 'white', but all working class people.

Throwing a few bones to civil rights groups doesn't make you left wing. The poverty experienced by working class ethnic groups became greater under new labour, as they utilsied and exploited them for their corporate masters.

Those areas 'which eastern Europeans' have made into 's**t holes', aren't because of the migrants, its down the failure of local authorties and councils to fulfill their obligations, instead money was clawed back to pay for tax cuts and popularist policys aimed at winning elections.

Labour betrayed the working classes.



I think that's a fair amount of truth in that.

Immigrants by themselves aren't to blame...But an undirected distribution into the workforce is...The affects on housing and infrastructure make life their undoubtedly less pleasant for those unable to move....A mass ghettoisation of immigrants into areas that previously didn't have them can't be portrayed as something everyone should feel positive about....More competition for jobs and housing.

As for blaming various layers of government....Is it really realistic to expect them to be able to build the housing and infrastructure at the levels required to match the intake.

No it isn't really...So really it's about signing up for 'free movement' and not negotiating properly on transition controls that has really kicked the least able to adapt right squarely in the balls.....So yeah Labour and certain parts of the right (not elements of the old left) well and truly screwed the weakest of the British working classes...(Sure some of them are feckless but they are our feckless youth...Plus many just want a fair chance).....Instead governmental decisions designed for the business world effectively pulled up the ladder on them.

Still many on the left still support Labour's behaviour and support 'free movement' because they think that this is a racism argument and will jerk that knee if there is any discussion of the practical affects of immigration.

But they certainly made friends in the business world.

Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Feb 2015 3.14pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 18 Feb 15 4.38pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Feb 2015 2.42pm

Quote The Sash at 18 Feb 2015 1.22pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 1.05pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 12.49pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 11.32am

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 11.09am

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 11.07am

I've decided.

Go on then!


I think you'd have been saying the same sort of thing about the influx of blacks and Irish back in the day.


See there you go.....Nick....Don't complain about UKIP because mate, you totally deserve it.


So I deserve UKIP because some people are racist? Hmm.


UKIP are a result of the Labour and the middle class left abandonment and sneering at the white working class 'white van man' character they created (esp in the South)

With such a despicable Tory government doing what good despicable Tory governments are supposed to do, Labour should be hoovering up all of their votes with ease in places like Rochester , but they aren't because Labour and the left cared little for them or their votes under Blair and UKIP have filled the void.

The left ignored them, denigrated them and instead of dealing with them as a demographic instead created a grotesque caricature of them as ignorant, shaven headed, little Englander racists, which in some cases maybe true, most cases not - there can be no whingeing now they are getting their own back and Labour are being bitten on the arse surely ???

Edited by The Sash (18 Feb 2015 1.32pm)

The left never abandoned them, they betrayed the working classes through the initial work of Kinnock, then Smith and finally Blair in the production of New Labour, a right of center political party that was essentially 'friend of business', claiming the lie of a 'third way', in reality they were more right wing than Ted Heaths Conservative government, and relied on a spin of being 'the party of the people'.

The rise of both UKIP and the Greens, has its basis in the betrayal of Labour of the working classes - Not just 'white', but all working class people.

Throwing a few bones to civil rights groups doesn't make you left wing. The poverty experienced by working class ethnic groups became greater under new labour, as they utilsied and exploited them for their corporate masters.

Those areas 'which eastern Europeans' have made into 's**t holes', aren't because of the migrants, its down the failure of local authorties and councils to fulfill their obligations, instead money was clawed back to pay for tax cuts and popularist policys aimed at winning elections.

Labour betrayed the working classes.


Call it betrayal, call it abandonment ultimately it amounts to the same thing.


 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

matt_himself Flag Matataland 18 Feb 15 6.29pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Feb 2015 2.42pm

Quote The Sash at 18 Feb 2015 1.22pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 1.05pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 12.49pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 11.32am

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 11.09am

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 11.07am

I've decided.

Go on then!


I think you'd have been saying the same sort of thing about the influx of blacks and Irish back in the day.


See there you go.....Nick....Don't complain about UKIP because mate, you totally deserve it.


So I deserve UKIP because some people are racist? Hmm.


UKIP are a result of the Labour and the middle class left abandonment and sneering at the white working class 'white van man' character they created (esp in the South)

With such a despicable Tory government doing what good despicable Tory governments are supposed to do, Labour should be hoovering up all of their votes with ease in places like Rochester , but they aren't because Labour and the left cared little for them or their votes under Blair and UKIP have filled the void.

The left ignored them, denigrated them and instead of dealing with them as a demographic instead created a grotesque caricature of them as ignorant, shaven headed, little Englander racists, which in some cases maybe true, most cases not - there can be no whingeing now they are getting their own back and Labour are being bitten on the arse surely ???

Edited by The Sash (18 Feb 2015 1.32pm)

The left never abandoned them, they betrayed the working classes through the initial work of Kinnock, then Smith and finally Blair in the production of New Labour, a right of center political party that was essentially 'friend of business', claiming the lie of a 'third way', in reality they were more right wing than Ted Heaths Conservative government, and relied on a spin of being 'the party of the people'.

The rise of both UKIP and the Greens, has its basis in the betrayal of Labour of the working classes - Not just 'white', but all working class people.

Throwing a few bones to civil rights groups doesn't make you left wing. The poverty experienced by working class ethnic groups became greater under new labour, as they utilsied and exploited them for their corporate masters.

Those areas 'which eastern Europeans' have made into 's**t holes', aren't because of the migrants, its down the failure of local authorties and councils to fulfill their obligations, instead money was clawed back to pay for tax cuts and popularist policys aimed at winning elections.

Labour betrayed the working classes.



The Unions and Labours left f***ed themselves in the seventies by bringing British manufacturing and heavy industry to a grinding halt through their greed, laziness and envy.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

elgrande Flag bedford 18 Feb 15 6.31pm

Quote The Sash at 18 Feb 2015 1.22pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 1.05pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 12.49pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 11.32am

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 11.09am

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 11.07am

I've decided.

Go on then!


I think you'd have been saying the same sort of thing about the influx of blacks and Irish back in the day.


See there you go.....Nick....Don't complain about UKIP because mate, you totally deserve it.


So I deserve UKIP because some people are racist? Hmm.


UKIP are a result of the Labour and the middle class left abandonment and sneering at the white working class 'white van man' character they created (esp in the South)

With such a despicable Tory government doing what good despicable Tory governments are supposed to do, Labour should be hoovering up all of their votes with ease in places like Rochester , but they aren't because Labour and the left cared little for them or their votes under Blair and UKIP have filled the void.

The left ignored them, denigrated them and instead of dealing with them as a demographic instead created a grotesque caricature of them as ignorant, shaven headed, little Englander racists, which in some cases maybe true, most cases not - there can be no whingeing now they are getting their own back and Labour are being bitten on the arse surely ???

Edited by The Sash (18 Feb 2015 1.32pm)

Very nicely put Sash.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

legaleagle Flag 18 Feb 15 10.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 11.04am

I was referring to our earlier debate in this thread not your last couple of posts, where you make some good points.

If I remember correctly earlier in the thread you said of me: 'I do get the feeling your actual deep down key issue is your dislike of immigrants because of "non-English" ethnicity '

I said that's basically calling me a racist to which you have continually insisted it wasn't and you insist that being averse to different ethnicity isn't the same as racism.....I'm happy for others to judge whether that's warm words or not.

I think it's fair to refer to that when partly connecting the rise and popularity of UKIP to the accusations and finger pointing that some on the left have promoted for decades.

However I didn't and don't intend to reengage in another round of 'you said this, no I didn't' posts.

Others can decide.


Edited by Stirling says (18 Feb 2015 11.04am)


Noted and understood that your comments last night weren't actually responding to the post of mine made immediately before your response and included by you as the only prior post above your response,as opposed to much earlier posts you say you were in fact responding to and had already previously responded to,I think.

I agree people can make up their own minds and if some think you have hit the nail on the head or scored a TKO, well,everyone is entitled to their opinion.Others may or may not form a different opinion.

But the issue itself (as opposed to anything relating to you and me) has IMO an inherent "TKO" of its own.If an individual asserts they have concerns about EU immigrants settling here,because amongst other things, of cultural differences from people living in England/the UK , and where the majority of such immigrants are caucasians (using the common UK understanding of the term) of the same "race" as both the majority of the population already living in England/The UK and the individual in question, it is hard to see how such concerns could possibly amount to racism since "race" wouldn't enter into the equation,as opposed to ethnicity (culture/history etc) which plainly would.

But,if other posters disagree and think an allegation of racism is even possible to imply(or be inferred) from use of the term "ethnicity" in criticising a person expressing concerns relating to cultural differences of immigrants who are generally of the same "race" as that person,that's entirely a matter for them.

You and I disagree about UKIP, its merits and whether it is part of the solution or part of the problem,but regardless of that,I trust you would agree that not every criticism of a UKIP supporter's views on immigration and cultural differences can be legitimately and automatically responded to by suggesting the critic is alleging racism (though I am sure you would accept there have been worrying instances of some UKIP supporters and politicians expressing views that might reasonably be termed racist). There are,IMO, plenty of other reasons for criticising UKIP, but that's another matter for another post or poster

But,I agree Stirling,enough between you and me about who said what. Otherwise,we may both have a legitimate technical knock out against us on grounds of boredom

Edited by legaleagle (18 Feb 2015 11.10pm)

 

legaleagle Flag 18 Feb 15 11.23pm

THE UKIP parliamentary candidate who thinks the dragon on the Welsh flag is a satanic symbol finally bites the dust...after the Deputy Chairman of UKIP, (seemingly completely unaware her party had lined him up to be one of their selected candidates in place of a local member) had described him as being "bonkers".

[Link]

 

OldFella Flag London 19 Feb 15 1.06am

Quote legaleagle at 18 Feb 2015 10.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 11.04am

I was referring to our earlier debate in this thread not your last couple of posts, where you make some good points.

If I remember correctly earlier in the thread you said of me: 'I do get the feeling your actual deep down key issue is your dislike of immigrants because of "non-English" ethnicity '

I said that's basically calling me a racist to which you have continually insisted it wasn't and you insist that being averse to different ethnicity isn't the same as racism.....I'm happy for others to judge whether that's warm words or not.

I think it's fair to refer to that when partly connecting the rise and popularity of UKIP to the accusations and finger pointing that some on the left have promoted for decades.

However I didn't and don't intend to reengage in another round of 'you said this, no I didn't' posts.

Others can decide.


Edited by Stirling says (18 Feb 2015 11.04am)


Noted and understood that your comments last night weren't actually responding to the post of mine made immediately before your response and included by you as the only prior post above your response,as opposed to much earlier posts you say you were in fact responding to and had already previously responded to,I think.

I agree people can make up their own minds and if some think you have hit the nail on the head or scored a TKO, well,everyone is entitled to their opinion.Others may or may not form a different opinion.

But the issue itself (as opposed to anything relating to you and me) has IMO an inherent "TKO" of its own.If an individual asserts they have concerns about EU immigrants settling here,because amongst other things, of cultural differences from people living in England/the UK , and where the majority of such immigrants are caucasians (using the common UK understanding of the term) of the same "race" as both the majority of the population already living in England/The UK and the individual in question, it is hard to see how such concerns could possibly amount to racism since "race" wouldn't enter into the equation,as opposed to ethnicity (culture/history etc) which plainly would.

But,if other posters disagree and think an allegation of racism is even possible to imply(or be inferred) from use of the term "ethnicity" in criticising a person expressing concerns relating to cultural differences of immigrants who are generally of the same "race" as that person,that's entirely a matter for them.

You and I disagree about UKIP, its merits and whether it is part of the solution or part of the problem,but regardless of that,I trust you would agree that not every criticism of a UKIP supporter's views on immigration and cultural differences can be legitimately and automatically responded to by suggesting the critic is alleging racism (though I am sure you would accept there have been worrying instances of some UKIP supporters and politicians expressing views that might reasonably be termed racist). There are,IMO, plenty of other reasons for criticising UKIP, but that's another matter for another post or poster

But,I agree Stirling,enough between you and me about who said what. Otherwise,we may both have a legitimate technical knock out against us on grounds of boredom

small]Edited by legaleagle (18 Feb 2015 11.10pm)

You personally already have. What a complete lot of self-aggrandising waffle you post on this site. Do you take half hourly selfies also?


 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

legaleagle Flag 19 Feb 15 8.57am

Many thanks OldFella for your kind words and in a funny sort of way for giving substance to one of my points so much more effectively than I could have

Always nice to see a poster actually engage with the argument rather than resort to ignoring the point but slagging off the poster instead stance that some (but clearly not you) adopt on here.

You are quite right:Compared to your consistently amazing,modest and stimulating top-level contributions on here which I unfailingly find myself in awe of,I am but an utter minnow unworthy to exist alongside a true giant such as yourself

I hope you feel better soon.


Edited by legaleagle (19 Feb 2015 9.54am)

 

crystal balls Flag The Garden of Earthly Delights 19 Feb 15 9.50am

Quote The Sash at 18 Feb 2015 4.38pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Feb 2015 2.42pm

Quote The Sash at 18 Feb 2015 1.22pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 1.05pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 12.49pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 11.32am

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 11.09am

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 11.07am

I've decided.

Go on then!


I think you'd have been saying the same sort of thing about the influx of blacks and Irish back in the day.


See there you go.....Nick....Don't complain about UKIP because mate, you totally deserve it.


So I deserve UKIP because some people are racist? Hmm.


UKIP are a result of the Labour and the middle class left abandonment and sneering at the white working class 'white van man' character they created (esp in the South)

With such a despicable Tory government doing what good despicable Tory governments are supposed to do, Labour should be hoovering up all of their votes with ease in places like Rochester , but they aren't because Labour and the left cared little for them or their votes under Blair and UKIP have filled the void.

The left ignored them, denigrated them and instead of dealing with them as a demographic instead created a grotesque caricature of them as ignorant, shaven headed, little Englander racists, which in some cases maybe true, most cases not - there can be no whingeing now they are getting their own back and Labour are being bitten on the arse surely ???

Edited by The Sash (18 Feb 2015 1.32pm)

The left never abandoned them, they betrayed the working classes through the initial work of Kinnock, then Smith and finally Blair in the production of New Labour, a right of center political party that was essentially 'friend of business', claiming the lie of a 'third way', in reality they were more right wing than Ted Heaths Conservative government, and relied on a spin of being 'the party of the people'.

The rise of both UKIP and the Greens, has its basis in the betrayal of Labour of the working classes - Not just 'white', but all working class people.

Throwing a few bones to civil rights groups doesn't make you left wing. The poverty experienced by working class ethnic groups became greater under new labour, as they utilsied and exploited them for their corporate masters.

Those areas 'which eastern Europeans' have made into 's**t holes', aren't because of the migrants, its down the failure of local authorties and councils to fulfill their obligations, instead money was clawed back to pay for tax cuts and popularist policys aimed at winning elections.

Labour betrayed the working classes.


Call it betrayal, call it abandonment ultimately it amounts to the same thing.


I don't think new Labour abandoned working class voters so much as the "white van man" abandoned Labour, if they ever voted for them in the first place. In reality, a lot of working class people always voted Tory, the Alf Garnets of this world.

The Tory working class rejoiced under Maggie, but have now abandoned the Tories as they perceive the current lot to be posh boys who have no appeal to them, and Farage has fashioned his image as a pint and a fag bloke who blames all failings on the EU and immigrants. This plays well to some (around 15%), and reinforces perceptions of nostalgia for a time that never really existed, but doesn't stand up to close scrutiny.

 


I used to be immortal

Hoof Hearted 19 Feb 15 10.25am

Quote legaleagle at 18 Feb 2015 10.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 11.04am

I was referring to our earlier debate in this thread not your last couple of posts, where you make some good points.

If I remember correctly earlier in the thread you said of me: 'I do get the feeling your actual deep down key issue is your dislike of immigrants because of "non-English" ethnicity '

I said that's basically calling me a racist to which you have continually insisted it wasn't and you insist that being averse to different ethnicity isn't the same as racism.....I'm happy for others to judge whether that's warm words or not.

I think it's fair to refer to that when partly connecting the rise and popularity of UKIP to the accusations and finger pointing that some on the left have promoted for decades.

However I didn't and don't intend to reengage in another round of 'you said this, no I didn't' posts.

Others can decide.


Edited by Stirling says (18 Feb 2015 11.04am)


Noted and understood that your comments last night weren't actually responding to the post of mine made immediately before your response and included by you as the only prior post above your response,as opposed to much earlier posts you say you were in fact responding to and had already previously responded to,I think.

I agree people can make up their own minds and if some think you have hit the nail on the head or scored a TKO, well,everyone is entitled to their opinion.Others may or may not form a different opinion.

But the issue itself (as opposed to anything relating to you and me) has IMO an inherent "TKO" of its own.If an individual asserts they have concerns about EU immigrants settling here,because amongst other things, of cultural differences from people living in England/the UK , and where the majority of such immigrants are caucasians (using the common UK understanding of the term) of the same "race" as both the majority of the population already living in England/The UK and the individual in question, it is hard to see how such concerns could possibly amount to racism since "race" wouldn't enter into the equation,as opposed to ethnicity (culture/history etc) which plainly would.

But,if other posters disagree and think an allegation of racism is even possible to imply(or be inferred) from use of the term "ethnicity" in criticising a person expressing concerns relating to cultural differences of immigrants who are generally of the same "race" as that person,that's entirely a matter for them.

You and I disagree about UKIP, its merits and whether it is part of the solution or part of the problem,but regardless of that,I trust you would agree that not every criticism of a UKIP supporter's views on immigration and cultural differences can be legitimately and automatically responded to by suggesting the critic is alleging racism (though I am sure you would accept there have been worrying instances of some UKIP supporters and politicians expressing views that might reasonably be termed racist). There are,IMO, plenty of other reasons for criticising UKIP, but that's another matter for another post or poster

But,I agree Stirling,enough between you and me about who said what. Otherwise,we may both have a legitimate technical knock out against us on grounds of boredom

Edited by legaleagle (18 Feb 2015 11.10pm)

legal...... I just awarded a TKO to Stirling for a laugh really.

You make some good points.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 19 Feb 15 10.35am

Quote crystal balls at 19 Feb 2015 9.50am

Quote The Sash at 18 Feb 2015 4.38pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Feb 2015 2.42pm

Quote The Sash at 18 Feb 2015 1.22pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 1.05pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 12.49pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 11.32am

Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Feb 2015 11.09am

Quote nickgusset at 18 Feb 2015 11.07am

I've decided.

Go on then!


I think you'd have been saying the same sort of thing about the influx of blacks and Irish back in the day.


See there you go.....Nick....Don't complain about UKIP because mate, you totally deserve it.


So I deserve UKIP because some people are racist? Hmm.


UKIP are a result of the Labour and the middle class left abandonment and sneering at the white working class 'white van man' character they created (esp in the South)

With such a despicable Tory government doing what good despicable Tory governments are supposed to do, Labour should be hoovering up all of their votes with ease in places like Rochester , but they aren't because Labour and the left cared little for them or their votes under Blair and UKIP have filled the void.

The left ignored them, denigrated them and instead of dealing with them as a demographic instead created a grotesque caricature of them as ignorant, shaven headed, little Englander racists, which in some cases maybe true, most cases not - there can be no whingeing now they are getting their own back and Labour are being bitten on the arse surely ???

Edited by The Sash (18 Feb 2015 1.32pm)

The left never abandoned them, they betrayed the working classes through the initial work of Kinnock, then Smith and finally Blair in the production of New Labour, a right of center political party that was essentially 'friend of business', claiming the lie of a 'third way', in reality they were more right wing than Ted Heaths Conservative government, and relied on a spin of being 'the party of the people'.

The rise of both UKIP and the Greens, has its basis in the betrayal of Labour of the working classes - Not just 'white', but all working class people.

Throwing a few bones to civil rights groups doesn't make you left wing. The poverty experienced by working class ethnic groups became greater under new labour, as they utilsied and exploited them for their corporate masters.

Those areas 'which eastern Europeans' have made into 's**t holes', aren't because of the migrants, its down the failure of local authorties and councils to fulfill their obligations, instead money was clawed back to pay for tax cuts and popularist policys aimed at winning elections.

Labour betrayed the working classes.


Call it betrayal, call it abandonment ultimately it amounts to the same thing.


I don't think new Labour abandoned working class voters so much as the "white van man" abandoned Labour, if they ever voted for them in the first place. In reality, a lot of working class people always voted Tory, the Alf Garnets of this world.

The Tory working class rejoiced under Maggie, but have now abandoned the Tories as they perceive the current lot to be posh boys who have no appeal to them, and Farage has fashioned his image as a pint and a fag bloke who blames all failings on the EU and immigrants. This plays well to some (around 15%), and reinforces perceptions of nostalgia for a time that never really existed, but doesn't stand up to close scrutiny.


Sure they did. Its just confirming the clichéd caricature I mentioned in the first post of these little Alf Garnett / Old man Steptoe types which is the strategy that's been employed rather than actually taking their concerns on immigration seriously.

If there were hordes of Eastern European politicians waiting at Sangatte or flying in from Lodz, willing to sit in the Commons for twice the time and half the money instead of them being plumbers they might have understood where these people are coming from on immigration.

In reality they are Labour voters by class, Tory by experience and tend to be the people who win or lose you general elections. As Labour / Tories are now finding out as they seem to be the most fertile ground for UKIP

Unlike those in the enclaves of the likes of Henley in the blue corner or Sunderland in the Red, where you can, by shaving a monkey, sticking the right coloured rosette guarantees victory they will flip flop between parties dependant on how good / sh*t their personal circumstances have been under the current regime.

Edited by The Sash (19 Feb 2015 10.39am)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Page 110 of 187 < 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic