This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| NJ CLOCKTOWER |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
In the vitriolic defence of Israel’s response to the attack by Hamas in this thread one crucial thing stands out. Netanyahu! His desire to remain in power and his need to continue to have the support of the hard line traditionalists and settlers is central to what is happening. No one defends Hamas or what it did. Nor does anyone believe that Israel doesn’t have the right to defend itself, or respond. That’s not to say that the Palestinian people themselves don’t have legitimate reasons to feel mistreated, or not to criticise Zionism. All of which is extremely complicated and outside the current situation. The style of Israel’s response and its disregard for the lives of the innocent is indefensible. No matter what the provocation, objective or behaviour of its adversary. That would not be happening but for Netanyahu. Who is not very popular in Israel itself, let alone elsewhere. With the USA losing patience I sense change on the horizon and hopefully a reduction in civilian casualties following a more nuanced strategy in trying to eliminate Hamas. It is evident from your statement that you believe Benjamin Netanyahu's desire to maintain power and appease hardline factions within Israel plays a central role in the current situation between Israel and Hamas. I have to agree with you on that basis. You acknowledge Israel's right to defend itself but criticize the style of Israel's response and its disregard for innocent lives. Maybe, you could explain how Israel should have responded? Both sides have legitimate grievances and concerns that contribute to the ongoing tensions. A nuanced approach is necessary to address these issues effectively and minimize civilian casualties. You suggest that with the United States possibly losing patience, there may be a change on the horizon, leading to a more nuanced strategy in dealing with Hamas. I would like to know what that strategy might be... Some potential steps towards a resolution could include: 1. Renewed Dialogue: Encouraging direct negotiations between Israeli and Hamas leaders is crucial for building trust and finding common ground. 2. Two-State Solution: Many previous international agreements and proposals have supported the establishment of two states – Israel and Palestine – living side by side in peace and security. 3. Addressing Security Concerns: Any solution must address the legitimate security concerns of both Israelis and Palestinians. Robust security cooperation, including intelligence sharing and joint patrols, can help foster trust and minimize violence. 4. Economic Development and Assistance: Promoting economic development in the Palestinian territories can contribute to stability and improve living conditions. International support, investment, and aid can help create jobs, enhance infrastructure, and improve access to basic services, providing a foundation for a more prosperous future. 5. Human Rights and Humanitarian Concerns: Protecting the human rights of all individuals involved, including the rights of Palestinians living in the occupied territories, is crucial. International bodies and organizations should monitor the situation, investigate alleged violations, and provide necessary humanitarian assistance. 6. Education and People-to-People Initiatives: Promoting joint educational programs, cultural exchanges, and grassroots initiatives can help foster mutual understanding and tolerance between Israeli and Palestinian societies. Encouraging dialogue and opportunities for interaction can help bridge divides and build lasting trust. Ultimately, a sustainable solution must ensure the security, dignity, and self-determination of both Israelis and Palestinians.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Perhaps I should have made it plain that I meant no one here defends Hamas, although in the context of the remarks think that ought to be obvious. Nevertheless, I also doubt the reliability of this “survey”! Whenever such things are quoted the first thing I do is check the source to determine whether it can be trusted. Any organisation which has Douglas Murray as an employee raises questions and any “survey” should therefore be treated with a large dose of salt. You would need to see the questions asked, the size of the sample and the profiles of the respondents to make any kind of judgement on the validity. For instance, if you asked the average British citizen whether they have any sympathy for the people living under the control of Hamas they would probably say yes. That though isn’t the same as having sympathy for Hamas. The Henry Jackson Society is a right wing pressure group masquerading as a think tank. Its funding is obscure but there is more than a whiff of substantial Jewish support and the danger of its output being propaganda rather than information. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (10 Apr 2024 11.33pm) Of course you reject any report, source or poll that disagrees with your views, while accepting anything that does agree, however crackpot those sources are - you are as constant as the northern star.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NJ CLOCKTOWER
It is evident from your statement that you believe Benjamin Netanyahu's desire to maintain power and appease hardline factions within Israel plays a central role in the current situation between Israel and Hamas. I have to agree with you on that basis. You acknowledge Israel's right to defend itself but criticize the style of Israel's response and its disregard for innocent lives. Maybe, you could explain how Israel should have responded? Both sides have legitimate grievances and concerns that contribute to the ongoing tensions. A nuanced approach is necessary to address these issues effectively and minimize civilian casualties. You suggest that with the United States possibly losing patience, there may be a change on the horizon, leading to a more nuanced strategy in dealing with Hamas. I would like to know what that strategy might be... Some potential steps towards a resolution could include: 1. Renewed Dialogue: Encouraging direct negotiations between Israeli and Hamas leaders is crucial for building trust and finding common ground. 2. Two-State Solution: Many previous international agreements and proposals have supported the establishment of two states – Israel and Palestine – living side by side in peace and security. 3. Addressing Security Concerns: Any solution must address the legitimate security concerns of both Israelis and Palestinians. Robust security cooperation, including intelligence sharing and joint patrols, can help foster trust and minimize violence. 4. Economic Development and Assistance: Promoting economic development in the Palestinian territories can contribute to stability and improve living conditions. International support, investment, and aid can help create jobs, enhance infrastructure, and improve access to basic services, providing a foundation for a more prosperous future. 5. Human Rights and Humanitarian Concerns: Protecting the human rights of all individuals involved, including the rights of Palestinians living in the occupied territories, is crucial. International bodies and organizations should monitor the situation, investigate alleged violations, and provide necessary humanitarian assistance. 6. Education and People-to-People Initiatives: Promoting joint educational programs, cultural exchanges, and grassroots initiatives can help foster mutual understanding and tolerance between Israeli and Palestinian societies. Encouraging dialogue and opportunities for interaction can help bridge divides and build lasting trust. Ultimately, a sustainable solution must ensure the security, dignity, and self-determination of both Israelis and Palestinians. I am neither a military strategist nor a diplomat with answers to an intractable problem as old as time. It just seems obvious that taking the approach that Israel under Netanyahu has is ultimately going to make things worse than a more nuanced, forensic and carefully thought out one. Losing the support of almost the entire developed world, including your major ally, is self defeating. Israel clearly has great intelligence sources which could be put to better use. The real problem here is Iran. Hamas being a proxy. Replacing Hamas with a non aligned authority should possibly be the aim. I was in Israel only a few weeks prior to the Hamas action and know that the relationship between ordinary Israelis, whether Jewish or Arab, is often perfectly ok. The possibility of peaceful coexistence exists at ground level. It’s the extremists that are the problem. So the idea of cultural exchanges is good, and does already exist. Rather than turn Gaza into a refugee camp with its cities rubble, I would develop it, flood it with kindness and western comforts. Show the people love in return for hatred. It takes time and is almost certainly too late for these generations. So there is a lot of agreement between us but the immediate issue is to stop escalation and pull Iran back from retaliation and Israel back from further provocation. Then to allow aid in, try to find a way to halt the war temporarily, then semi permanently, Israel to replace Netanyahu, the UN to send in peacekeepers, the Arab States to fund reconstruction, Iran to be forced by internal dissent to concentrate on itself thus reducing the power of Hamas and making its replacement easier. Impractical dreams? Probably, but better these dreams than the current nightmare.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Of course you reject any report, source or poll that disagrees with your views, while accepting anything that does agree, however crackpot those sources are - you are as constant as the northern star. I don’t though reject the report. I don’t trust it, because of its source. If it came from a reliable, trusted, independent polling company with a reputation for objectivity and sound methodology then it could be. When it originates from a source which undeniably has an agenda, it cannot be. That applies whoever is the source and whatever their bias may be. So much more information is required on the sampling and the questioning before any kind of reliable information can be deduced from it. Any newspaper or other media outlet using it without questioning its validity must also have questions to answer about their own objectivity.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
| NJ CLOCKTOWER |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I am neither a military strategist nor a diplomat with answers to an intractable problem as old as time. It just seems obvious that taking the approach that Israel under Netanyahu has is ultimately going to make things worse than a more nuanced, forensic and carefully thought out one. Losing the support of almost the entire developed world, including your major ally, is self defeating. Israel clearly has great intelligence sources which could be put to better use. The real problem here is Iran. Hamas being a proxy. Replacing Hamas with a non aligned authority should possibly be the aim. I was in Israel only a few weeks prior to the Hamas action and know that the relationship between ordinary Israelis, whether Jewish or Arab, is often perfectly ok. The possibility of peaceful coexistence exists at ground level. It’s the extremists that are the problem. So the idea of cultural exchanges is good, and does already exist. Rather than turn Gaza into a refugee camp with its cities rubble, I would develop it, flood it with kindness and western comforts. Show the people love in return for hatred. It takes time and is almost certainly too late for these generations. So there is a lot of agreement between us but the immediate issue is to stop escalation and pull Iran back from retaliation and Israel back from further provocation. Then to allow aid in, try to find a way to halt the war temporarily, then semi permanently, Israel to replace Netanyahu, the UN to send in peacekeepers, the Arab States to fund reconstruction, Iran to be forced by internal dissent to concentrate on itself thus reducing the power of Hamas and making its replacement easier. Impractical dreams? Probably, but better these dreams than the current nightmare. First of all I have to point out that, I am not Israeli nor Jewish. Your statement presents a thoughtful and comprehensive perspective on the Israel-Palestine conflict, you highlight the complexities involved and offer a vision for potential resolution.The world or allies have been professionally manipulated by Hamas.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Of course you reject any report, source or poll that disagrees with your views, while accepting anything that does agree, however crackpot those sources are - you are as constant as the northern star. I'm with Wizzy on this. Utterly skewered question probably got the results they wanted. Old trick. Muslims know Hamas committed the atrocities as Hamas have not only owned it but filmed and posted it. There will be keyboard warriors claiming it was all some Jewish conspiracy, but not 40+%.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
I'm with Wizzy on this. Utterly skewered question probably got the results they wanted. Old trick. Muslims know Hamas committed the atrocities as Hamas have not only owned it but filmed and posted it. There will be keyboard warriors claiming it was all some Jewish conspiracy, but not 40+%. Wisbech said: "No one defends Hamas or what it did. Nor does anyone believe that Israel doesn’t have the right to defend itself, or respond." Thousands of Muslims march through London practically every week, many of them defend Hamas, many of them believe that Israel does not have a right to exist or defend itself. Just look at their placards, just listen to their chants.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Wisbech said: "No one defends Hamas or what it did. Nor does anyone believe that Israel doesn’t have the right to defend itself, or respond." Thousands of Muslims march through London practically every week, many of them defend Hamas, many of them believe that Israel does not have a right to exist or defend itself. Just look at their placards, just listen to their chants. Oh yes indeed, but I was only responding to the point you made when you said: "...a recent survey found that only one in four British Muslims believe that Hamas committed murder and rape in Israel on October 7th..." They pretty much all know full well they did it, but a pollster asks the question in a clever way and a certain % will give a certain answer that suggests otherwise. The broader point is that the protest has morphed. Initially, there was limited support. However, tell a Muslim that 30,000+ of their non-combatant brothers and sisters - mainly children - have been killed you can't expect there to be no reaction. Trouble is, this isn't Chechnya. This is Israel. This has conjured up the ancient conflict between these 2 religions. Protestors now see beyond Oct 7 and focus on the Islamic dead, on Al-Aqsa, on the occupation of one of their holiest places, of Western complicity and so on. Israel's disproportionate reaction has brought their conflict to us.
|
|
|
Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (11 Apr 2024 12.35pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
In the vitriolic defence of Israel’s response to the attack by Hamas in this thread one crucial thing stands out. Netanyahu! His desire to remain in power and his need to continue to have the support of the hard line traditionalists and settlers is central to what is happening. No one defends Hamas or what it did. Nor does anyone believe that Israel doesn’t have the right to defend itself, or respond. That’s not to say that the Palestinian people themselves don’t have legitimate reasons to feel mistreated, or not to criticise Zionism. All of which is extremely complicated and outside the current situation. The style of Israel’s response and its disregard for the lives of the innocent is indefensible. No matter what the provocation, objective or behaviour of its adversary. That would not be happening but for Netanyahu. Who is not very popular in Israel itself, let alone elsewhere. With the USA losing patience I sense change on the horizon and hopefully a reduction in civilian casualties following a more nuanced strategy in trying to eliminate Hamas. Well said.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Oh yes indeed, but I was only responding to the point you made when you said: "...a recent survey found that only one in four British Muslims believe that Hamas committed murder and rape in Israel on October 7th..." They pretty much all know full well they did it, but a pollster asks the question in a clever way and a certain % will give a certain answer that suggests otherwise. The broader point is that the protest has morphed. Initially, there was limited support. However, tell a Muslim that 30,000+ of their non-combatant brothers and sisters - mainly children - have been killed you can't expect there to be no reaction. Trouble is, this isn't Chechnya. This is Israel. This has conjured up the ancient conflict between these 2 religions. Protestors now see beyond Oct 7 and focus on the Islamic dead, on Al-Aqsa, on the occupation of one of their holiest places, of Western complicity and so on. Israel's disproportionate reaction has brought their conflict to us. The brother and sister bulls*** is my question. Just because they are Muslim. Most of the Palestinians would cut the throat of western Muslims for a meal. As a poster on here states regularly. Colour is skin deep. Clearly not when it’s Muslims protesting the deaths of Muslims but when it’s Muslims commuting crimes against kids it fits.
|
|
|
but Originally posted by georgenorman
Of course you reject any report, source or poll that disagrees with your views, while accepting anything that does agree, however crackpot those sources are - you are as constant as the northern star. But nowhere near as bright , SWIDT
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Oh yes indeed, but I was only responding to the point you made when you said: "...a recent survey found that only one in four British Muslims believe that Hamas committed murder and rape in Israel on October 7th..." They pretty much all know full well they did it, but a pollster asks the question in a clever way and a certain % will give a certain answer that suggests otherwise. The broader point is that the protest has morphed. Initially, there was limited support. However, tell a Muslim that 30,000+ of their non-combatant brothers and sisters - mainly children - have been killed you can't expect there to be no reaction. Trouble is, this isn't Chechnya. This is Israel. This has conjured up the ancient conflict between these 2 religions. Protestors now see beyond Oct 7 and focus on the Islamic dead, on Al-Aqsa, on the occupation of one of their holiest places, of Western complicity and so on. Israel's disproportionate reaction has brought their conflict to us. The question was not asked 'in a clever way'. Two statements were presented and the respondent was asked "for each of the following pairs of statements, choose which statement comes closest to your view." For the particular report item that you quote the pair of statements were: The 30,000+ figure of non-combatant deaths that you quote is of course a Hamas supplied figure, but you don't seem to have any problem accepting it. Edited by georgenorman (11 Apr 2024 1.19pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
The question was not asked 'in a clever way'. Two statements were presented and the respondent was asked "for each of the following pairs of statements, choose which statement comes closest to your view." For the particular report item that you quote the pair of statements were: The 30,000+ figure of non-combatant deaths that you quote is of course a Hamas supplied figure, but you don't seem to have any problem accepting it. Edited by georgenorman (11 Apr 2024 1.19pm) Genuine question; based on all the photos/videos and information we do have access to, do you really believe the civilian death toll is going to be significantly less than what Hamas are suggesting? What's a figure you'd be comfortable agreeing to at this stage as a likely civilian death toll?
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Genuine question; based on all the photos/videos and information we do have access to, do you really believe the civilian death toll is going to be significantly less than what Hamas are suggesting? What's a figure you'd be comfortable agreeing to at this stage as a likely civilian death toll? Do you really believe that Hamas supplied information is reliable? I'm not comfortable with any civilian death toll. Edited by georgenorman (11 Apr 2024 2.13pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Do you really believe that Hamas supplied information is reliable? I'm not comfortable with any civilian death toll. Edited by georgenorman (11 Apr 2024 2.13pm) In general, no I don’t. Now I’ve answered your question maybe you could answer mine: do you believe that the civilian death toll is going to be significantly less than what Hamas have suggested?
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
In general, no I don’t. Now I’ve answered your question maybe you could answer mine: do you believe that the civilian death toll is going to be significantly less than what Hamas have suggested? Yes.
|
|
|
Unless something changes soon the civilian death toll is likely to be way higher than any current propaganda anywhere.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
Unless something changes soon the civilian death toll is likely to be way higher than any current propaganda anywhere. That’s certainly my take as well.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.