Quote The Sash at 20 Feb 2015 8.36am
Quote crystal balls at 20 Feb 2015 8.14am
Quote The Sash at 19 Feb 2015 10.35am
Labour betrayed the working classes.
Call it betrayal, call it abandonment ultimately it amounts to the same thing.
I don't think new Labour abandoned working class voters so much as the "white van man" abandoned Labour, if they ever voted for them in the first place. In reality, a lot of working class people always voted Tory, the Alf Garnets of this world.
The Tory working class rejoiced under Maggie, but have now abandoned the Tories as they perceive the current lot to be posh boys who have no appeal to them, and Farage has fashioned his image as a pint and a fag bloke who blames all failings on the EU and immigrants. This plays well to some (around 15%), and reinforces perceptions of nostalgia for a time that never really existed, but doesn't stand up to close scrutiny.
Sure they did. Its just confirming the clichéd caricature I mentioned in the first post of these little Alf Garnett / Old man Steptoe types which is the strategy that's been employed rather than actually taking their concerns on immigration seriously.
If there were hordes of Eastern European politicians waiting at Sangatte or flying in from Lodz, willing to sit in the Commons for twice the time and half the money instead of them being plumbers they might have understood where these people are coming from on immigration.
In reality they are Labour voters by class, Tory by experience and tend to be the people who win or lose you general elections. As Labour / Tories are now finding out as they seem to be the most fertile ground for UKIP
Unlike those in the enclaves of the likes of Henley in the blue corner or Sunderland in the Red, where you can, by shaving a monkey, sticking the right coloured rosette guarantees victory they will flip flop between parties dependant on how good / sh*t their personal circumstances have been under the current regime.
Edited by The Sash (19 Feb 2015 10.39am)
I agree with all of your very well made points; except one. Labour (and the Tories) only need to get roughly 40% of the vote in 40% of constituencies to gain a majority. Therefore both parties have no need to go chasing votes that they would only gain by appealing to "white van man" types when by doing so, they could well alienate some or all of the floating voters (and disaffected Liberals) whose support will determine the outcome of the election.
Why should Labour pander to (for example)those Chelsea supporters who abused that guy on the train in Paris the other evening? I imagine that they're probably not going to vote but, if they did, which party do you think would gain their support?
UKIP support in the polls is falling, other issues are more important. Debate Europe and immigration by all means, but views (as evidenced on this forum) are entrenched and unlikely to be changed by debate. It'll soon be time to vote and we shall see in the outcome how well UKIP do.
The election, in my opinion, will be decided by which party gains most support from disaffected Liberals, those are the real floating voters.
-------------------------------------------------------
Again an absolute cliché of the white working class as racist, narrow minded little Englanders, (and just to remind you so far the only identifiable Chelsea supporter has been an upper middle class public schoolboy from Millfield) that are too stupid and indolent to vote.
The paragraph in bold, neatly demonstrating why these normally natural Labour voters no longer are. Labour hasn't 'pandered' to them for years, in fact its ignored them, why start now ?
Like I said its far easier for the left to paint this voting demographic as racist and insular and discount them than actually try and win them back or take their legitimate concerns seriously, its far better to sneer down their middle class, right-on, Islingtonian noses at the ageing Bedford rascal and flag of St George in the front garden in Chatham.
As for the election, I don't support any party, don't vote so actually don't care. I long ago disengaged from the process so who votes for what and where has absolutely no meaning, however Liberals will now either not vote or go to Labour. Cleggs grasping for power and jumping into bed with the polar opposite of Liberalism has seen to them as a serious political threat for years.
Edited by The Sash (20 Feb 2015 8.39am)
Again, good points, (though if the perpetrator is a public schoolboy I don't know if he is necessarily a "natural" Labour supporter :-))
I just don't think that all traditional working class voters (whatever that means today) will support Labour, no matter what the politicians say in their speaches. Chasing those votes doesn't make much sense in the context of the election if by doing so they alienate those who might well vote for them.
I gave up voting for what the Westminster parties say or do, but will vote in May, and my choice will be based on what my local constituency candidates offer, which I have come to the conclusion is a far better way of choosing. Experience has shown that anything else can only lead to disappointment and disillusion!
I used to be immortal
|