This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| Tom-the-eagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote legaleagle at 22 Feb 2015 1.05pm
Interesting reactions to Kermit's post/link. It seems there is a UKIP politician (not voter) whose distaste for black people is such she wouldn't sit next to one at a meal.Presumably none of the pro-UKIP posters on here would vote for her if she stood as a candidate in their council elections. If anyone on here wants to defend her sentiments as being no kind of any problem in a politician of any party,then fair enough and I wait with bated breath to hear why and how. But,a reaction of just suggesting Kermit is inferring every UKIP voter must be like her (which would be nonsense) is something he plainly wasn't saying in his post and does seem to be a stock response of some about any concerns expressed about why some people with questionable views might be attracted to UKIP. Similarly,the suggestion that her seemingly abhorrent racism equates to suggesting all labour/tory voters must condone child abuse or tax avoidance is plain silly,as plain silly as suggesting all UKIP voters are racist,which is precisely what Kermit didn't suggest. Of course its valid to query a politician who advocates fighting tax avoidance if they themselves engage in it and there have been plenty of psts on here dong just that.Politicians are hypocrites,what's new? But,that hardly equates to a politician refusing to eat with a black person,or does in some people's eyes?Her behaviour /views isn't hypocrisy but something far more insidious. We avoid tax, almost all of us, in some way when we can.Has anyone on here never stayed 5 minutes over at a parking meter and not paid extra,thus avoiding a parking tax imposed by a local authority? Smokers/drinkers never brought in more duty free cigs or booze than the duty-free limit? Would that be the same as any of us being racists? Would that mean none of us could oppose multi-nationals avoiding tax through clever schemes thought up by expensive accountants? Plainly, loads of people intending to vote for UKIP are not motivated by racism or an antipathy to other cultures or even by an antipathy to immigration,but it seems some may be motivated in part by the first. The question of why UKIP appeals to such people is interesting and valid. Edited by legaleagle (22 Feb 2015 1.10pm) UKIP do focus on the EU, its UKIP knockers like yourself who are so desperate to change the focus on to general immigration. Or what about conservative Bob Allen, did he join the Tory’s because he was racist?
"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit |
|
| legaleagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Tom-the-eagle at 22 Feb 2015 1.29pm
Quote legaleagle at 22 Feb 2015 1.05pm
Interesting reactions to Kermit's post/link. It seems there is a UKIP politician (not voter) whose distaste for black people is such she wouldn't sit next to one at a meal.Presumably none of the pro-UKIP posters on here would vote for her if she stood as a candidate in their council elections. If anyone on here wants to defend her sentiments as being no kind of any problem in a politician of any party,then fair enough and I wait with bated breath to hear why and how. But,a reaction of just suggesting Kermit is inferring every UKIP voter must be like her (which would be nonsense) is something he plainly wasn't saying in his post and does seem to be a stock response of some about any concerns expressed about why some people with questionable views might be attracted to UKIP. Similarly,the suggestion that her seemingly abhorrent racism equates to suggesting all labour/tory voters must condone child abuse or tax avoidance is plain silly,as plain silly as suggesting all UKIP voters are racist,which is precisely what Kermit didn't suggest. Of course its valid to query a politician who advocates fighting tax avoidance if they themselves engage in it and there have been plenty of psts on here dong just that.Politicians are hypocrites,what's new? But,that hardly equates to a politician refusing to eat with a black person,or does in some people's eyes?Her behaviour /views isn't hypocrisy but something far more insidious. We avoid tax, almost all of us, in some way when we can.Has anyone on here never stayed 5 minutes over at a parking meter and not paid extra,thus avoiding a parking tax imposed by a local authority? Smokers/drinkers never brought in more duty free cigs or booze than the duty-free limit? Would that be the same as any of us being racists? Would that mean none of us could oppose multi-nationals avoiding tax through clever schemes thought up by expensive accountants? Plainly, loads of people intending to vote for UKIP are not motivated by racism or an antipathy to other cultures or even by an antipathy to immigration,but it seems some may be motivated in part by the first. The question of why UKIP appeals to such people is interesting and valid. Edited by legaleagle (22 Feb 2015 1.10pm) UKIP do focus on the EU, its UKIP knockers like yourself who are so desperate to change the focus on to general immigration. Or what about conservative Bob Allen, did he join the Tory’s because he was racist?
I am not intending personally to vote for UKIP, which will not surprise you. I haven't yet made my mind up where my vote will go.I trust you don't suggest that invalidates me having an opinion about the points I wrote about, any more than if a person is going to vote for UKIP,it would invalidates them having an opinion about,say,the Tories or Labour? The person you refer to as having idiotic views was an elected politician of the party in question.Of course there are many other issues to focus on (personally,I'd like to see some morefocus on senior UKIP politicians/adviser's views about the NHS),but none of that makes it illegitimate to have some concern (which I trust you share) about the number (ie not just one or two) of current UKIP politicians/advisers who seem to hold some pretty inappropriate views.If you have no such concern,that's your entitlement. I personally,without apology, distinguish between people saying "something silly" and overt racism (and indeed overt racism in 2014/15). Of course,representatives of all parties have said inappropriate things in the past.However,I think it legitimate to focus on the coming election rather than past ones, and it would be just as legitimate for you to post about anything you felt was inappropriate said by a politician/adviser of any party recently,particularly if it did equate to something as highly inappropriate as racism.
|
|
| legaleagle |
|
|---|---|
|
. Edited by legaleagle (22 Feb 2015 7.25pm)
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
"Use your words..."
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.