This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
UK jets now actively protecting Israel, what suckers. Netanyahu expertly sucks in the west to his eternal war, it can never possibly be won, the Middle East is 95% Islamic. I suspected our involvement from the start, there have been Israel military flights detected here and increased flights to Tel Aviv from Cyprus, and of course against the Houthis largely unsuccessfully. I just hope that we are not on the ground in any way. I am watching little Palestinian children queueing to have their identities tattooed on them, so if they do not make it through the night they will be able to be identified. That is what we are now complicit in.
Have you ever noticed that tyrannical regimes seem to be a little short on moral concerns? Get a grip.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
A very interesting question. The Left have been clearly anti Israel.
I'm not quite sure why you think that these things just happen for no reason. That is extremely naive. So kill them outside the consulate and not on Iranian soil. And if you can't get em another way. Naive? A state attacking diplomatic soil crosses the rubicon. That is rogue state stuff.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
Iran fires missiles and drones at Israel, which is being labelled "a major escalation" by Israeli military. Is there anybody on here that can educate me re the attack in Damascus; I believe it was the consulate building that was bombed, not the Embassy. Just wondering if there is a legal difference re diplomatic immunity etc. in that the consulate building may not be offered the same legal protection. I’m not saying that the bombing was right; just whether there is a loophole for the bombing.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
No one wants an escalation, but no response to this attack will only embolden Iran and anyone else who fancies attacking a Western ally. I'm not sure that restraint will actually lead to a better outcome. War is nonetheless unpredictable. What is predictable is that at some stage there will be a major conflict in the Middle East, and we had better be ready to act to protect our interests. Are you sure about that? Putin might, as it would divert attention from Ukraine and tie up the Americans. Most of the world doesn’t including, I expect, Iran as it’s not in their interests. Their strategy of proxy wars has worked pretty well for them and they know a full on all out confrontation would destroy them for sure, even if they don’t care about the other consequences. It’s not though in Israel’s ultimate interests either, as the risks are too high. There is no reason a major conflict in the Middle East is inevitable. Possible certainly but not inevitable. So whilst being prepared is sensible there’s no sense in deciding to get your retaliation in first. Diplomacy can work when it aligns with desired outcomes.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
So kill them outside the consulate and not on Iranian soil. And if you can't get em another way. Naive? A state attacking diplomatic soil crosses the rubicon. That is rogue state stuff. I heard that they were in a building next door to the consulate, if that helps your diplomatic sensibilities. If you want to complain, then consider the stupidity of attacking the Israeli mainland in supposed retaliation.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Are you sure about that? Putin might, as it would divert attention from Ukraine and tie up the Americans. Most of the world doesn’t including, I expect, Iran as it’s not in their interests. Their strategy of proxy wars has worked pretty well for them and they know a full on all out confrontation would destroy them for sure, even if they don’t care about the other consequences. It’s not though in Israel’s ultimate interests either, as the risks are too high. There is no reason a major conflict in the Middle East is inevitable. Possible certainly but not inevitable. So whilst being prepared is sensible there’s no sense in deciding to get your retaliation in first. Diplomacy can work when it aligns with desired outcomes. It is certainly true that a number of scenarios could unfold, including attacks by different countries in different regions at the same time, designed to spread allied forces thinner. If I were a military strategist for the West, I would have considered all possibilities and the current capability to respond.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I heard that they were in a building next door to the consulate, if that helps your diplomatic sensibilities. If you want to complain, then consider the stupidity of attacking the Israeli mainland in supposed retaliation. If that is so then I withdraw but if not then you are underestimating the difficult position Israel have put us in. Otherwise it is a very thick red line that only terrorists cross (Beat Liverpool though)
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
If that is so then I withdraw but if not then you are underestimating the difficult position Israel have put us in. Otherwise it is a very thick red line that only terrorists cross (Beat Liverpool though) Terrorists don't play by rules, and when confronting them, there is little room for fair play if you want to prevail. Iran sponsor terrorism globally. The idea that they are the victims in this is laughable.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Iran informed neighbours 3 days ago of their plan. They then tell the west. The west are ready to shoot down the bombs. Iran looks ok in its fans eyes as they have done something. It’s done I reckon ! Quite possible. It is amusing that Iran wanted to retaliate when their buddies have been attacking Israeli interests for ages, but these are the games we play.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Terrorists don't play by rules, and when confronting them, there is little room for fair play if you want to prevail. Iran sponsor terrorism globally. The idea that they are the victims in this is laughable. Possibly but not an idea I articulated.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Possibly but not an idea I articulated. No, but I'm putting it into context. Iran are the scourge of the world. The USA probably tolerate them because it's less trouble than a major conflict. Problem is, they are close to producing enough material for a nuclear missile. It might be that neutralising Iran could be the only option in the not too distant future.
|
|
| NJ CLOCKTOWER |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Stating the obvious doesn’t generally solve problems. Diplomacy is only part of the way forward. The realisation that the attack has totally failed to find targets will be a lesson well learned. That should mean that diplomacy has a more fertile ground to grow in. The first thing to try to achieve is calm and the resumption of a war of words as weapons, not drones and missiles. Then let the quiet diplomacy start. I listened to an American expert last night who made a lot of sense. He pointed out that constantly positioning Iran as a pariah and never rewarding them means they have nothing to lose. He was effectively recommending adopting a risk and reward strategy with them. Perhaps that’s what, in time, we will see.
Your mention of incentives for countries like Iran suggests that you may believe in the power of positive reinforcement.
I suggests that a combination of approaches, including military response if necessary, is needed to adequately address and resolve aggressive actions. Relying solely on diplomacy in complex scenarios involving aggression and conflict, is only one option. a more comprehensive approach, encompassing a range of strategies and considering underlying motivations, grievances, and incentives, is necessary for effectively resolving such issues.
|
|
| NJ CLOCKTOWER |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
UK jets now actively protecting Israel, what suckers. Netanyahu expertly sucks in the west to his eternal war, it can never possibly be won, the Middle East is 95% Islamic. I suspected our involvement from the start, there have been Israel military flights detected here and increased flights to Tel Aviv from Cyprus, and of course against the Houthis largely unsuccessfully. I just hope that we are not on the ground in any way. I am watching little Palestinian children queueing to have their identities tattooed on them, so if they do not make it through the night they will be able to be identified. That is what we are now complicit in.
May I ask you your age. I only ask because the only two posts I have seen from you was one telling me to hang off a clock like Harold Lloyd, and now I've just read your childish dribble above are you old enough to even be on this site?
|
|
|
Originally posted by NJ CLOCKTOWER
May I ask you your age. I only ask because the only two posts I have seen from you was one telling me to hang off a clock like Harold Lloyd, and now I've just read your childish dribble above are you old enough to even be on this site? I hardly ever agree with Steeleye, he is our resident lefty however he is a long term poster and entitled to his views. He is also a useful source of information on youth and academy games and regularly updates the rest of us. You have only been on this site for a couple of months and only seem to post on this thread. This is a football website and whilst I welcome all you might want to post a bit more on the football as Steeleye does. Enjoy your day.
One more point |
|
| NJ CLOCKTOWER |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I hardly ever agree with Steeleye, he is our resident lefty however he is a long term poster and entitled to his views. He is also a useful source of information on youth and academy games and regularly updates the rest of us. You have only been on this site for a couple of months and only seem to post on this thread. This is a football website and whilst I welcome all you might want to post a bit more on the football as Steeleye does. Enjoy your day. It sounds like there's some diversity of opinion on the site, which can be healthy for discussions. Steeleye you say contributes valuable insights beyond just his political views, which is appreciated. And sure, I'll try to engage more broadly in football discussions going forward. Thanks for the reminder!
|
|
|
Originally posted by NJ CLOCKTOWER
Your mention of incentives for countries like Iran suggests that you may believe in the power of positive reinforcement.
I suggests that a combination of approaches, including military response if necessary, is needed to adequately address and resolve aggressive actions. Relying solely on diplomacy in complex scenarios involving aggression and conflict, is only one option. a more comprehensive approach, encompassing a range of strategies and considering underlying motivations, grievances, and incentives, is necessary for effectively resolving such issues. My post was actually reporting what I had heard an American recommending. It was late on Friday evening as the attack was underway and regrettably I cannot recall his name but he clearly knew his stuff. From memory he was the Director of something like the “American and Arabia Institute” and had previously served in US administrations. So not my ideas. I suspect he was better informed than anyone here. Cynically dismissing foreign leaders as children is not his view. He believes the Iranians have been very clever with their strategy and are not fools. He also believes they are pragmatic and will respond to positive suggestions without needing to compromise their principles. He was very critical of past US policy. Not of the need to offer help to defend Israel but in the lack of subtlety in dealing with Iran. Any kind of military response by Israel would be calamitous, in my opinion. It is unnecessary. They made all the response needed on Friday night. Like someone facing a bully and avoiding all their blows by being quicker of thought and action, all that results is the bully running out of energy and ideas. There’s no need to punch the bully now. They know their aggression doesn’t work. Now’s the time to start talking.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
My post was actually reporting what I had heard an American recommending. It was late on Friday evening as the attack was underway and regrettably I cannot recall his name but he clearly knew his stuff. From memory he was the Director of something like the “American and Arabia Institute” and had previously served in US administrations. So not my ideas. I suspect he was better informed than anyone here. Cynically dismissing foreign leaders as children is not his view. He believes the Iranians have been very clever with their strategy and are not fools. He also believes they are pragmatic and will respond to positive suggestions without needing to compromise their principles. He was very critical of past US policy. Not of the need to offer help to defend Israel but in the lack of subtlety in dealing with Iran. Any kind of military response by Israel would be calamitous, in my opinion. It is unnecessary. They made all the response needed on Friday night. Like someone facing a bully and avoiding all their blows by being quicker of thought and action, all that results is the bully running out of energy and ideas. There’s no need to punch the bully now. They know their aggression doesn’t work. Now’s the time to start talking. How comfortable are you with Iran making the bomb? Are we perhaps caught between a rock and a hard place?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.