Frickin Saweet South Cronx 19 Aug 19 12.24pm |
|
|
lovely lad though, acknowledging that Palace have been very good to him, and not wanting to 'leave like a thief'.
|
A89M Streatham 19 Aug 19 1.23pm |
|
|
His hold up play is poor, bullied far too often against all types of defenders – it’s very rare he comes out with the ball in a battle. When he does receive the ball to feet, he looks to give it away as quickly as possible which suggests a confidence issue. He’s not good enough for our style of play, Wilf drives into the box and Benteke hasn’t got the know how to delay his run or wait for a cut back.
I do believe he’d score more goals if we set up to his strengths as Allardyce has stated on TalkSport i.e cross the ball more often, beat the first man in set pieces (Luka was awful yesterday) but it’s not good enough that a 32 million player on 100k + a week can only score with his head, what are his other strengths?
|
Lanzo-Ad Lanzarote 19 Aug 19 3.01pm |
|
|
All the games that we scored 3 or more goals in the league last season, 6 games, only once we played a "target man", its not rocket science, we play much better with a mobile striker, Bats was ideal, but Benteke is clueless in this role, we dont and never will play to Benteke's strength, because or "best" forward players, Wilf and Andros don't like playing there, Ayew although not great is our best option by far.
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn
|
Bexley Eagle Bexley Kent 19 Aug 19 3.23pm |
|
|
Even the law of averages must say he should score more than 1 goal a season playing as a striker. Hopefully we are still in the Prem next summer when is wages are freed up, to get someone in who does know where the back of the net is.
|
MikeCrete Crete 19 Aug 19 3.30pm |
|
Originally posted by Frickin Saweet
lovely lad though, acknowledging that Palace have been very good to him, and not wanting to 'leave like a thief'.
That's exactly what he is doing; stealing wages & someone else's place in the team.
|
DenTyler Sidcup 19 Aug 19 4.01pm |
|
|
How about we try something radical…
Andros on the left and wilf on the right. Tekkers in the middle. Both wingers with enough skill and pace to either take on there man/men or god forbid, put a first time cross in. This would also hopefully help ward out as fingers crossed the defender and midfielder on his side would be keeping more of an eye on our biggest threat making our right back issues since AWB left a bit less of a problem.
Watch how many goals Man City score from a simple tap in because there wide players get crosses/first time passes into the danger areas. You can literally see the forward players queuing up. If tekkers still can’t put away the chances then give Wickham or Ayew or any of the youth strikers a go but, please Roy, play our wide players as wingers and show some attacking initiative.
We have plenty of options with defensive midfielders, so let them do there job and let wilf and andros supply the ammunition. The way we look at the moment we have nothing to lose by giving this a go.
Also, I’ve read a few posts about Luka on here, about not looking good etc. Same was said last season about him and look how much we needed him. Ended up being one of the players of the season. Think he is just a slow starter at the start of a season.
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 19 Aug 19 4.33pm |
|
|
Yes I think delivering service to Benteke as much as possible (and fvck the 250 Zaha step overs in dribbles to the near post before losing it every match) is possibly Roy’s only chance of saving his and our skin. He should’ve been adding this into the mix anyway. We can still pass the ball around, just now and then not wait for the oppo to get everyone behind th ball every time we have it, which actually meant EIGHT players defending or confronting our ONE player with the ball in the box seeing as we had SIX fvcking players around the centre circle marking TWO Sheff Utd players.
Unless we get a loan striker in then this is our only option to add to some of the good stuff in 2 x one minute spells v Everton and nothing to mention v Sheff Utd.
I know we start slowly and Zaha needs to clear his head, but those were long term players yesterday and last season’s v Everton and although I’m not surprised as I predicted 0-1 points after 4 games, it’s still unacceptable.
COYP
|
palace chick South Croydon 19 Aug 19 4.45pm |
|
Originally posted by DenTyler
How about we try something radical…
Andros on the left and wilf on the right. Tekkers in the middle. Both wingers with enough skill and pace to either take on there man/men or god forbid, put a first time cross in. This would also hopefully help ward out as fingers crossed the defender and midfielder on his side would be keeping more of an eye on our biggest threat making our right back issues since AWB left a bit less of a problem.
Watch how many goals Man City score from a simple tap in because there wide players get crosses/first time passes into the danger areas. You can literally see the forward players queuing up. If tekkers still can’t put away the chances then give Wickham or Ayew or any of the youth strikers a go but, please Roy, play our wide players as wingers and show some attacking initiative.
We have plenty of options with defensive midfielders, so let them do there job and let wilf and andros supply the ammunition. The way we look at the moment we have nothing to lose by giving this a go.
Also, I’ve read a few posts about Luka on here, about not looking good etc. Same was said last season about him and look how much we needed him. Ended up being one of the players of the season. Think he is just a slow starter at the start of a season.
Think you will find that Man City have 11 world stars on the pitch plus they get midfielders into the box. We have just Benteke who sometimes gets into the box because of the way he’s told to play with no service whatsoever. He won’t score goals the way we (Hodgson) uses him. I can’t tell anymore if he is any good or not? Wickham would also have the same problems. If anything we saw the other week that Ayew and Benteke got more of the ball. That may have helped because our back four didn’t play so deep as they did for the whole match yesterday for which Hodgson/Lexington never changed the tactics throughout - unbelievably :-(
|
DenTyler Sidcup 19 Aug 19 4.53pm |
|
|
That was my point. We can’t change players now until January, we have nothing to lose (can’t possibly worse than yesterday) and everything to gain.
Tekkers confidence is shot to sh*t and no amount of money can buy that. It’s no use moaning about how much the fella earns, just need to find away to get him scoring (which Big Sam did).get the ball in nice and quick. The bloke has played and scored for his country, was wanted by all the big boys when he was at villa, it’s all about confidence I’m sure a couple of scruffy goals will get him going.
For the record, I’m not a big fan of Tekkers, but while he is wearing the red and blue I’d rather see the team set up to try and get him firing again.
Honestly, the way we set up, shearer, Owen and Henry would struggle.
|
DenTyler Sidcup 19 Aug 19 4.56pm |
|
Originally posted by palace chick
Think you will find that Man City have 11 world stars on the pitch plus they get midfielders into the box. We have just Benteke who sometimes gets into the box because of the way he’s told to play with no service whatsoever. He won’t score goals the way we (Hodgson) uses him. I can’t tell anymore if he is any good or not? Wickham would also have the same problems. If anything we saw the other week that Ayew and Benteke got more of the ball. That may have helped because our back four didn’t play so deep as they did for the whole match yesterday for which Hodgson/Lexington never changed the tactics throughout - unbelievably :-(
I agree, the management has no plan B. And your right of course about Man City, but the principal is the same from champions league to Sunday league, decent amount of crosses and balls into the box will equal more goals. Man City just do it incredibly well.
|
kev64 Cambs 19 Aug 19 5.00pm |
|
|
Its seems that we blame the service to Tekkers for him not scoring, but with the same service Batashui came in and did the job perfectly well in the same position.
At the end of the day Wilf need to play on the left and Roy needs to stop expecting Tekkers to score when he is sat up front on his own with 5 defenders around him.
It hasnt worked for 2 years so why is going to work now ?.
|
DenTyler Sidcup 19 Aug 19 5.07pm |
|
Originally posted by kev64
Its seems that we blame the service to Tekkers for him not scoring, but with the same service Batashui came in and did the job perfectly well in the same position.
At the end of the day Wilf need to play on the left and Roy needs to stop expecting Tekkers to score when he is sat up front on his own with 5 defenders around him.
It hasnt worked for 2 years so why is going to work now ?.
I’ve watched every premier league game we have played under Roy and I don’t think we have played with a natural right footer on the right and left on the left ever. The way we played with bats worked the way we are set up now but he’s not here and tekkers is. The point I was trying to make is that we are where we are with the players we have, does it not make sense to try something else? I’ve been a fan for as long as I can remember (since the days of cannon and Sansom etc) but I don’t want to watch this dross for much longer. It’s bloody depressing, I can honestly say that Sunday was the worst I’ve seen us play in a long time.
|
grumpymort US/Thailand/UK 19 Aug 19 7.52pm |
|
Originally posted by kev64
Its seems that we blame the service to Tekkers for him not scoring, but with the same service Batashui came in and did the job perfectly well in the same position.
At the end of the day Wilf need to play on the left and Roy needs to stop expecting Tekkers to score when he is sat up front on his own with 5 defenders around him.
It hasnt worked for 2 years so why is going to work now ?.
It is the service at fault and comparing him to Bat is silly they play different type of game.
The current tactics are not fit for Benteke and with him having such low confidence as well that wont help.
Roy needs to change things otherwise no point playing Benteke.
The other thing which is annoying is Roy has him coming back all the time defending as well and when he gets in oppositions box Zaha every time slows things up having to take players on with the over the top tricks rather then whip in quick balls
when Big Sam was in charge he stopped this it was all balls go forward and quick direct balls thats why we started seeing Benteke scoring again.
Not all is awful slow play and players messing about with the ball always coming inside then wondering why their is no space or losing the ball.
(VPN) - [Link] (Alt VPN) - [Link]
|
dreamwaverider London 19 Aug 19 10.22pm |
|
|
Small and super quick seems to be the name of today’s game in attack. Big 6’4” lanky players are no longer cutting it.
|
ambrose7 Croydon 19 Aug 19 10.43pm |
|
|
Benteke did sod all yesterday, as did others.
However, the number of times where we were on an 'attack' (we had the ball in their half) and Benteke was the only person in the Sheff Utd box, with 4/5 defenders around him, was incredible.
Which one of our midfielders is looking to make a run into the box and take a defender's attention?
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration 2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough 1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds 7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.
|
pssguy 19 Aug 19 11.38pm |
|
Originally posted by kev64
Its seems that we blame the service to Tekkers for him not scoring, but with the same service Batashui came in and did the job perfectly well in the same position.
At the end of the day Wilf need to play on the left and Roy needs to stop expecting Tekkers to score when he is sat up front on his own with 5 defenders around him.
It hasnt worked for 2 years so why is going to work now ?.
Exactly. eight goals in our final 2 games of last season with Benteke not playing a minute
|
HKOwen Hong Kong 20 Aug 19 1.57am |
|
|
Yes, exactly this.
There is a recent shift on various threads with Banteke's lack of goals being due to lack of service.
He has become lazy, hardly breaks into a jog and more importantly misses sitters when the chances come.
There was an actual stat of sitters missed %age and he was top.
If does make you wonder why Roy plays him though
Team that beat Bournemouth all available last week apart from AWB and BATS, and we failed to get either a RB or a striker in the window.
Presumably Sheff Utd will batter Bournemouth
Originally posted by pssguy
Exactly. eight goals in our final 2 games of last season with Benteke not playing a minute
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.
|
dreamwaverider London 20 Aug 19 4.12am |
|
|
I don’t buy it that it’s the other players fault. Maybe I would if he hadn’t scored for say 5 games and he was jumping up and down about the tactics but this is a STRIKER who has scored 3 goals in 2 seasons in a mid table team. If our board continue to ignore our need for an out and out goal scorer effectively forcing our manager to play him due to lack of anyone else then the inevitable will catch up with us. RH is himself a very quiet mannered man who like Benteke would appear to be keeping his head down to protect his salary but eventually all this hiding is going to bite us big time. Truth is, our chairman, manager and centre forward are all 3 past their sell by dates. Our DoF is either hopeless or not being allowed to perform which is no excuse. If SP doesn’t accept this situation and sell because he is so in love with the club/himself and the position of power/fame it gives him then I fear we will stagnate or worse from here on.
|
southnorwoodhill 20 Aug 19 8.31am |
|
|
I agree about getting the ball in early. At least then we could see if Benteke is capable of getting on the end of a cross. Problem is neither Zaha or Townsend are particularly good at putting in an accurate threatening cross.
|
Palace in the Blood 20 Aug 19 2.05pm |
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
I don’t buy it that it’s the other players fault. Maybe I would if he hadn’t scored for say 5 games and he was jumping up and down about the tactics but this is a STRIKER who has scored 3 goals in 2 seasons in a mid table team. If our board continue to ignore our need for an out and out goal scorer effectively forcing our manager to play him due to lack of anyone else then the inevitable will catch up with us. RH is himself a very quiet mannered man who like Benteke would appear to be keeping his head down to protect his salary but eventually all this hiding is going to bite us big time. Truth is, our chairman, manager and centre forward are all 3 past their sell by dates. Our DoF is either hopeless or not being allowed to perform which is no excuse. If SP doesn’t accept this situation and sell because he is so in love with the club/himself and the position of power/fame it gives him then I fear we will stagnate or worse from here on. When did we last have a striker who scored lots of goals? Strikers have come to us on permanent or on loan and generally they have not been a success with us but scored after they left Solorth for a current example. Benteke scored when we played to his strengths, and Murray all those years ago in championship. If we are to play a striker whose main strength is in the air then we need to play to that strength. I agree that he has lost confidence but the only way he will get it back is to start scoring. Ayew in my view is not a target man but better playing off a tall striker. Wickham has over his careeer played both sort of roles. Zaha for all his strengths is not a world class striker but he is a world class winger.
I would to see us play Zaha and Townsend as wingers supplying a front 2 of Wickham/Benteke as the target man with Meyer/ Camarasa as the number 10. I would put Mcarthy,and Luka in Midfield. Due to injuries our back 4 will probably change little however I can see Cahill replacing Dann when fit
|