You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?
November 22 2026 6.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?


Page 116 of 280 < 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 >
W12 26 Apr 22 4.31pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

It's just a matter of time until they try the ID cards again.....Then pushing to get rid of physical cash so that they can control your finances completely as well.

The western social control systems are all a matter of time.


I'm fairly close to this pit of vipers by the way by way of what I do for a living so can see elements of this happening up close.


Edited by W12 (26 Apr 2022 4.31pm)

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 26 Apr 22 4.45pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Sure, but also a hell of a lot of Irish Catholics have settled all over the world.

There has been Russians in what is now called Ukraine for centuries, they were there when it was just a part of the Ottoman empire, and then part of Russia and so on. Ukraine is a relatively new country but its ethnic make up has remained relatively static for far longer.

True, I wasn't giving any particular value judgement on it, nor a particular timeframe.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Apr 2022 9.11am)

 


Red and Blue Army!

cryrst Flag The garden of England 26 Apr 22 4.46pm

Originally posted by W12

I'm fairly close to this pit of vipers by the way by way of what I do for a living so can see elements of this happening up close.


Edited by W12 (26 Apr 2022 4.31pm)

So you are part of the problem that you so dislike.!

 

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Apr 22 4.47pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Please provide a link to such independent journalism

Hindsight is a wonderful thing. We are all excellent politicians with it.

Clearly, the right thing to do here would have been to hand the Russian government the keys to Ukraine and - by extension - Moldova. Nobody would have minded and it would all have worked out jolly well, as it has in Donbas in recent years.

I recommend this book

Decentralization, Regional Diversity, and Conflict: The Case of Ukraine

As that was not done, what would be your approach from here on?

Edited by Mapletree (26 Apr 2022 12.03pm)

To be fair there are plenty of high level strategists who were arguing for different approaches to the Ukraine for many years. Their pre war lectures are not hard to find.

At what point does the accusation of hindsight become an excuse for poor policy choices?

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Apr 22 4.56pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

True, I wasn't giving any particular value judgement on it, nor a particular timeframe.

The Irish are so intermixed with the British that distinctions are purely cultural at this point....mind you the practical differences between the cultures are more imagined than anything else.

In that sense it's very similar to the Ukrainians and Russians..... It's a war between slavs who are all pretty much the same.

I'm not arguing for full human universalism....because that's basically the commie's position. But this war is essentially self harming and at the end of it I think most will come to view it that way.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Apr 2022 4.57pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 26 Apr 22 5.01pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

The Irish are so intermixed with the British that distinctions are purely cultural at this point....mind you the practical differences between the cultures are more imagined than anything else.

In that sense it's very similar to the Ukrainians and Russians..... It's a war between slavs who are all pretty much the same.

I'm not arguing for full human universalism....because that's basically the commie's position. But this war is essentially self harming and at the end of it I think most will come to view it that way.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Apr 2022 4.57pm)

I can understand what you mean, yet, all I can see is that Ukrainians who were not particularly radical now hate Russia. They're not going to give up. It's not a winnable war.
I'm in daily contact with Russians and Ukrainians and none seem particularly happy with what's happening - for differing reasons.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 26 Apr 22 5.04pm

Originally posted by W12

I'm fairly close to this pit of vipers by the way by way of what I do for a living so can see elements of this happening up close.

Edited by W12 (26 Apr 2022 4.31pm)

What as Putin's boyfriend you mean?

 

W12 26 Apr 22 5.18pm

Originally posted by cryrst

So you are part of the problem that you so dislike.!

How did you make that assumption?

 

W12 26 Apr 22 5.18pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

What as Putin's boyfriend you mean?

Mongo like candy.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 26 Apr 22 5.31pm

Originally posted by W12

How did you make that assumption?

You help the system you despise

 

W12 26 Apr 22 5.36pm

Originally posted by cryrst

You help the system you despise

No I don't

 

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Apr 22 5.55pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I can understand what you mean, yet, all I can see is that Ukrainians who were not particularly radical now hate Russia. They're not going to give up. It's not a winnable war.
I'm in daily contact with Russians and Ukrainians and none seem particularly happy with what's happening - for differing reasons.

While I'm critical of my own side's general policy towards Russia since the Berlin wall came down....something I view as recklessly counter productive this doesn't translate into thinking an invasion was the correct Russian response.

Whole books could be written on alternative tactics that essentially result in protecting your own people in borderlands and no doubt those books on alternative approaches will be written.....there's also the Nato encroachment aspect, western interference and the coup and all the rest of it but I'll leave that be.

I agree, that polarisation means that come the peace deal the Russian call for the demilitarisation of Ukraine isn't realistic....though a demilitarised zone around its areas is.

When we think of 'winning', that would mean different things to different people depending upon the take.....there is no doubt that whatever the outcome both sides will claim victories because no set of elites are Turkeys voting for Christmas.....though personally I think most of our elites are practically oven ready.

What will be the end result? I think Russia will gain territory that won't be given back. The cost of gaining it though makes it a hard sell even internally. However, as they control the media they will decide most people's opinions....the same as here.

In the longer light of day I think the view will prevail that soft power would have been the better approach to their policy aims.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Apr 2022 6.02pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 26 Apr 22 6.09pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

While I'm critical of my own side's general policy towards Russia since the Berlin wall came down....something I view as recklessly counter productive this doesn't translate into thinking an invasion was the correct Russian response.

Whole books could be written on alternative tactics that essentially result in protecting your own people in borderlands and no doubt those books on alternative approaches will be written.....there's also the Nato encroachment aspect, western interference and the coup and all the rest of it but I'll leave that be.

I agree, that polarisation means that come the peace deal the Russian call for the demilitarisation of Ukraine isn't realistic....though a demilitarised zone around its areas is.

When we think of 'winning', that would mean different things to different people depending upon the take.....there is no doubt that whatever the outcome both sides will claim victories because no set of elites are Turkeys voting for Christmas.....though personally I think most of our elites are practically oven ready.

What will be the end result? I think Russia will gain territory that won't be given back. The cost of gaining it though makes it a hard sell even internally. However, as they control the media they will decide most people's opinions....the same as here.

In the longer light of day I think the view will prevail that soft power would have been the better approach to their policy aims.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Apr 2022 6.02pm)

It's a decent observation. Just in a practical sense, to overcome a country like Ukraine would take probably 4 or 5 times the forces Russia is committing. Conventional military thinking is that you need 2.5-3 times the forces when attacking defending forces. By my reckoning, requiring maybe more than 700,000 troops. Just can't see it happening.
But I can imagine a deal over Donbas or/and Crimea. While Ukraine has the upper hand, no deal will be done, however. You can't blame them for that if they think they will win. It's just hard reality.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Grumbles 26 Apr 22 6.19pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

It's a decent observation. Just in a practical sense, to overcome a country like Ukraine would take probably 4 or 5 times the forces Russia is committing. Conventional military thinking is that you need 2.5-3 times the forces when attacking defending forces. By my reckoning, requiring maybe more than 700,000 troops. Just can't see it happening.

3 to 1 in open ground up to 10 to 1 in urban environments.

The policy of appeasement has not worked so yes a tougher line should have been taken on Russia. Question being should, NATO or the Allies really have "encroached" in '45 or '90."

 

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Apr 22 6.24pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

It's a decent observation. Just in a practical sense, to overcome a country like Ukraine would take probably 4 or 5 times the forces Russia is committing. Conventional military thinking is that you need 2.5-3 times the forces when attacking defending forces. By my reckoning, requiring maybe more than 700,000 troops. Just can't see it happening.
But I can imagine a deal over Donbas or/and Crimea. While Ukraine has the upper hand, no deal will be done, however. You can't blame them for that if they think they will win. It's just hard reality.

That would be true if the areas you are defending were hostile. I think Russia keeping its gains mostly restricted to high Russian populated areas reduces those difficulties.

Most pro Ukrainians in the Donbas for example will long since have moved out since 2014.

I can't see a win for Ukraine here.....that's Ukraine personally.....I realise that the west are more than willing to sacrifice the entire Ukrainian male population and not care how gang pressed some of them were.

Nato could 'win' a long economically damaging war where we are all eating beans...or it could end in us getting fried.

Personally I argue for the least damage solutions, but I'm still waiting for that view to emerge within the elites outside of Orban.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 26 Apr 22 6.30pm

Originally posted by Grumbles

3 to 1 in open ground up to 10 to 1 in urban environments.

The policy of appeasement has not worked so yes a tougher line should have been taken on Russia. Question being should, NATO or the Allies really have "encroached" in '45 or '90."

I was joking about Patton in 45 before - but look what happened to him. That's a conspiracy theory that has been brushed under the carpet some time ago. He was all for driving straight on. However, my personal opinion is that Russian forces were strong in 45 and would have won (nukes notwithstanding). Today, it genuinely looks like, militarily, Russia are not the threat people thought (nukes notwithstanding).

 


Red and Blue Army!

Grumbles 26 Apr 22 6.42pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Nato could 'win' a long economically damaging war where we are all eating beans...or it could end in us getting fried.

But would mean Western countries seeing the strategic weaknesses of globalisation?

Or are the likes of Musk now too big for countries to control?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Apr 22 6.45pm

Originally posted by Grumbles

But would mean Western countries seeing the strategic weaknesses of globalisation?

Or are the likes of Musk now too big for countries to control?

Two good questions.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 26 Apr 22 7.02pm

Originally posted by Grumbles

But would mean Western countries seeing the strategic weaknesses of globalisation?

Or are the likes of Musk now too big for countries to control?

For question one: I don't see mass mobilisation like the first or second world war being possible now in western countries.

As for elites and the super rich. They usually simply get richer somehow, although a lot of countries could get rid of whoever they please - on the quiet if they have to.

 


Red and Blue Army!

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 26 Apr 22 7.03pm

Let Putin over-commit, he is desperate to finish this by May 9th when Russia remembers the 'Great Patriotic War'.

He could even lose the Donbass, and it is all his own fault.

France and Germany now supplying weapons.

Why give Putin a thing after what he has done.


 

Page 116 of 280 < 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?