You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 7 2026 8.47pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Brexit Thread (LOCKED)


Page 1163 of 1552 < 1159 1160 1161 1162 1163 1164 1165 1166 1167 >
Spiderman Flag Horsham 29 Jul 19 10.57pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I suspect Parliament would have something to say about that.

Please explain what they could do about it? Vote of no confidence? Bring it on, as Labour have gone, I suspect some of the Tory Brexit busters will either be de-selected or lose their seats (those whose constituents voted to leave).
I can forsee the Brexit party targeting seats in, mainly Labour constituencies, where they voted to leave but the MP has tried to derail Brexit eg Yvette Cooper with the Tories probably not even contesting them

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 30 Jul 19 5.40pm

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

Insulting?, it's taking the positive out of a slave having the power to rise against their owner's. Its not a literal comparison.

Darling how was your day "I've been working like a slave all day"
Anyone ever heard of that or a similar term?
I bet they wernt offended then!!!

It's a pretty s*** metaphor really. For starters slaves had no say in the matter. If anything it makes her look even more stupid.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Matov Flag 31 Jul 19 12.04am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Not really getting Boris's position on Brexit since he announced that there would be no early GE.

If that's the case why all the apparent certainty that we are leaving on 31th October when the MP stats don't add up?

Does he have a dirty tricks plan that no one is aware of? Can he just time it out without the remainers in Parliament refusing to accept a 'no deal'.

Is he expecting the EU to just not extend the deadline if he refuses to ask for one? Because I can see them calling that bluff and extending it anyway......Maybe he can refuse the extension without Parliament's approval.


Edited by Stirlingsays (29 Jul 2019 1.39pm)

Decided to stick my toe back into the political waters now that the mud has cleared a little.

For me the key to understanding it all is the Dominic Cummings/Gove partnership in essentially taking control of the No Deal preparations. One hell of a combination and sending a crystal clear message. This is a s*** or bust, in less than 100 days, piece of political theatre.

Johnson is a student of history. And knows that his entire political legacy rests on one single date. October 31st, 2019.

If we are still in the EU come November 1st he will be remembered as a failure. Nothing else matters to him now.

He has effectively burnt all the Remain bridges. His insistence on not sitting down to talk to the EU until it drops the backstop means he is gambling everything on it either backing down or else Parliament forces him, and it will require Conservative rebels to effectively collapse their own Government, to fight an election on a simple No Deal narrative.

And that is winnable. Lose all the rebels, replace them with people willing to do what their manifesto promises and do a deal with the Brexit Party. And Johnson strolls an October election. 30-40 seat majority. Maybe even stand aside in certain seats for Brexit candidates. With a Labour Party torn to bits as the Lib-Dems effectively cripple them. No way they will combine because Labours northern MP's will be up in arms. A suicide pact for Labour.

My own prediction is that Corbyn will bottle calling a vote of no confidence and that Johnson might get us out on October 31st on the back of Labour rebels abstaining on votes designed to stop at it.

In terms of the EU, I suspect they will not blink until at least the middle of September but Brexit will be decided by the end of that month.

Also interesting noises from Ireland. A hard-border destroys them. 85% of their exports have to cross it compared to less than half of 1% of ours. That reality is starting to hit home.

I was wary of Johnson. Still am. But the makeup of his cabinet along with that Cummings/Gove combination has caused me to concede that perhaps, and it is a huge perhaps, he might actually deliver on what he has said he would.

Halloween is Johnsons date with destiny. No other way of looking at it. Might be worth stocking up on the fireworks early because it could be a wonderful night!

But if November 1st dawns with that s***ty flag not having one less star, Brexit is over. A truly historic few weeks await us.

Edited by Matov (31 Jul 2019 12.09am)

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Stirlingsays Flag 31 Jul 19 12.17am

Originally posted by Matov

Decided to stick my toe back into the political waters now that the mud has cleared a little.

For me the key to understanding it all is the Dominic Cummings/Gove partnership in essentially taking control of the No Deal preparations. One hell of a combination and sending a crystal clear message. This is a s*** or bust, in less than 100 days, piece of political theatre.

Johnson is a student of history. And knows that his entire political legacy rests on one single date. October 31st, 2019.

If we are still in the EU come November 1st he will be remembered as a failure. Nothing else matters to him now.

He has effectively burnt all the Remain bridges. His insistence on not sitting down to talk to the EU until it drops the backstop means he is gambling everything on it either backing down or else Parliament forces him, and it will require Conservative rebels to effectively collapse their own Government, to fight an election on a simple No Deal narrative.

And that is winnable. Lose all the rebels, replace them with people willing to do what their manifesto promises and do a deal with the Brexit Party. And Johnson strolls an October election. 30-40 seat majority. Maybe even stand aside in certain seats for Brexit candidates. With a Labour Party torn to bits as the Lib-Dems effectively cripple them. No way they will combine because Labours northern MP's will be up in arms. A suicide pact for Labour.

My own prediction is that Corbyn will bottle calling a vote of no confidence and that Johnson might get us out on October 31st on the back of Labour rebels abstaining on votes designed to stop at it.

In terms of the EU, I suspect they will not blink until at least the middle of September but Brexit will be decided by the end of that month.

Also interesting noises from Ireland. A hard-border destroys them. 85% of their exports have to cross it compared to less than half of 1% of ours. That reality is starting to hit home.

I was wary of Johnson. Still am. But the makeup of his cabinet along with that Cummings/Gove combination has caused me to concede that perhaps, and it is a huge perhaps, he might actually deliver on what he has said he would.

Halloween is Johnsons date with destiny. No other way of looking at it. Might be worth stocking up on the fireworks early because it could be a wonderful night!

But if November 1st dawns with that s***ty flag not having one less star, Brexit is over. A truly historic few weeks await us.

Edited by Matov (31 Jul 2019 12.09am)

Yep good post, however Johnson has denied an early election but perhaps that's just an early chess move to quieten debate on it at this stage.

I agree, I think he wins an election, especially one fought on Brexit with him out front and centre making a pact with Farage.

At the moment he appears to be going for the 'time out' option.....I'm skeptical about it working but hopeful if that's the choice.

As for Johnson himself, yep I agree. While my vote is with Johnson as a election winner I very much view him as the best of a poor bunch.

He doesn't seem to believe in much and comes across as the typical neo liberal GDP Tory.....though hopefully with a much higher commitment to free speech and at least we should get him ditching all the ridiculous feminism BS that May infected the party with.

Edited by Stirlingsays (31 Jul 2019 12.19am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Matov Flag 31 Jul 19 1.00am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

As for Johnson himself, yep I agree. While my vote is with Johnson as a election winner I very much view him as the best of a poor bunch.

He doesn't seem to believe in much and comes across as the typical neo liberal GDP Tory.....though hopefully with a much higher commitment to free speech and at least we should get him ditching all the ridiculous feminism BS that May infected the party with.

Edited by Stirlingsays (31 Jul 2019 12.19am)

Not much in that to disagree with although I suspect that he set his sights on number 10 early and was willing to do anything to get there. Meaning he desires a legacy. And that he might just succeed.

Plus he has a teflon quality. By rights and all modern parameters he should not have been in with a sniff of making it but he did so.

Reserving judgement at the moment. October 31st really is the key date here and I suspect he knows it. What has impressed me is how he has hit the ground running on Brexit. No smoke and mirrors and effectively setting out his stall straight away with no room for backing out.

And I know I bang on about it but that Cummings/Grove axis is the key for me. Raab as foreign secretary as well. Bridges and boats are well and truly burnt and this is a fight to the political death for him. And he must know it. Failure to leave by October 31st and none of it matters anymore as the Brexit Party effectively kill the Tories off for decades to come.

September is now the key. Lot of hot air between now and the first week but then it gets real.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Sir James Hird Flag Mount Martha 31 Jul 19 3.39am

Viewing Brexit from the outside(thank goodness!).
I would guess Germany, France and maybe Netherlands are the only viable countries in the common market and thus supporting the basket cases of Italy, Greece,Spain etc...... Would this be correct?
Is this why the members of the European Union are playing hardball with the UK?
I would suggest that Boris's approach is the right one.
However there is probably so much s--t going on behind the scenes none of us know what is going on anyway.
Maybe its time The UK or England if the other members of the United Kingdom dont want in to stay stuff the lot of yer. Go it alone. We did it before.
"And did those feet in ancient times.....etc"

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 31 Jul 19 6.24am

Originally posted by Matov


Reserving judgement at the moment. October 31st really is the key date here and I suspect he knows it. What has impressed me is how he has hit the ground running on Brexit. No smoke and mirrors and effectively setting out his stall straight away with no room for backing out.

What a refreshing comment at a time when so many others have already made their minds up that we are doomed, based on absolutely nothing but their existing prejudice.

My only complaint at the moment is that I'd like to see less photo opportunities of our Prime Minister holding chickens as it really isn't necessary

 

dannyboy1978 Flag 31 Jul 19 7.01am

BBC team scare mongers in full swing.
[Link]
They have had 3 years to do this and choose now!

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 31 Jul 19 7.23am

Originally posted by Sir James Hird

Viewing Brexit from the outside(thank goodness!).
I would guess Germany, France and maybe Netherlands are the only viable countries in the common market and thus supporting the basket cases of Italy, Greece,Spain etc...... Would this be correct?
Is this why the members of the European Union are playing hardball with the UK?
I would suggest that Boris's approach is the right one.
However there is probably so much s--t going on behind the scenes none of us know what is going on anyway.
Maybe its time The UK or England if the other members of the United Kingdom dont want in to stay stuff the lot of yer. Go it alone. We did it before.
"And did those feet in ancient times.....etc"

Good point. I think the EU will not miss us but they will miss our money. The concern for them is that if we "get away with it" others may follow.

Moving onto to Johnson's strategy I think he has it about right. There is no point in holding discussions with the EU unless they take the backstop off the table. The EU's strategy is quite clear delay and prevarication, this suits the Remainers as they hope the tide will tun in their favour and it never happens.

Johnson has now called the EU's bluff and they have a big decision to make. Compromise on the backstop or risk a hard Brexit with them seen as the guilty party. They could go "all in" and hope that parliament rejects a hard Brexit and that Johnson then loses a general election. However this is high risk as I think Johnson may get the votes.

Parliament has rejected a hard Brexit before however this was only by one vote and at a time when it was thought a better deal was available. Faced with a binary choice some MPs will have a tough call.

The Remainers don't enter the equation as they will always vote against it whatever the deal or no deal. Some MP's can be persuaded to switch sides because they face the prospect of facing a rampant Brexit party at the GE. Boris may also pressurise the local party to deselect an MP in favour of a Brexiteer.

If Johnson can show that the EU are the bad guys and are unwillingly to negotiate I think he will get just enough votes to pass a no deal Brexit but it will be tight.

For now he needs to increase the Tory vote in the opinion polls. The more likely a Tory win at the next GE the more likely that the EU will realise that a deal is the best solution for them as Corbyn will not be the next PM.

 


One more point

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 31 Jul 19 8.28am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Please explain what they could do about it? Vote of no confidence? Bring it on, as Labour have gone, I suspect some of the Tory Brexit busters will either be de-selected or lose their seats (those whose constituents voted to leave).
I can forsee the Brexit party targeting seats in, mainly Labour constituencies, where they voted to leave but the MP has tried to derail Brexit eg Yvette Cooper with the Tories probably not even contesting them

Only if there is a GE. I don't think the Tories will risk one as it could cause them a complete break up. If a vote of no confidence succeeds then there would be a new coalition government rather than a GE as a consequence.

Assuming there is no GE then the current Parliament will find a way to stop no deal. Some have argued that there are legal challenges being prepared which would likely rule it out as impossible but certainly tie it up in the Courts for years.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 31 Jul 19 8.32am

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

BBC team scare mongers in full swing.
[Link]
They have had 3 years to do this and choose now!

Explain what is "scare mongering" about publishing a factual article about a vital issue dominating the national news?

Don't we have a right to understand the impact?

Do you prefer that we be kept in the blissful ignorance of promises, wishes and hopes?

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 31 Jul 19 8.40am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Only if there is a GE. I don't think the Tories will risk one as it could cause them a complete break up. If a vote of no confidence succeeds then there would be a new coalition government rather than a GE as a consequence.

Assuming there is no GE then the current Parliament will find a way to stop no deal. Some have argued that there are legal challenges being prepared which would likely rule it out as impossible but certainly tie it up in the Courts for years.

I don't see that happening and I am not sure that Corbyn wants that either? For a coalition to succeed it would need the DUP to break with the Tories, they would still need some Tory rebels to defect to one of the other parties. Those Tories who defect would never be forgiven by Tory voters for letting in a Corbyn government and would be ousted at the next GE in 3 years.

A more likely scenario is there are not enough votes for a no deal Brexit and not enough votes for a new coalition government.

Corbyn is 70 he knows if he is ever going to be PM it is now or never. His popularity is diminishing and whilst a coalition government would give him what he wants I don't see he will be able to gather enough votes. His best chance is to fight a GE this year as a Remain party which would see the Lib Dems lose the votes they hoovered up from Labour.

Anyway all speculation no one really knows.

 


One more point

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 31 Jul 19 9.20am

Originally posted by Badger11

I don't see that happening and I am not sure that Corbyn wants that either? For a coalition to succeed it would need the DUP to break with the Tories, they would still need some Tory rebels to defect to one of the other parties. Those Tories who defect would never be forgiven by Tory voters for letting in a Corbyn government and would be ousted at the next GE in 3 years.

A more likely scenario is there are not enough votes for a no deal Brexit and not enough votes for a new coalition government.

Corbyn is 70 he knows if he is ever going to be PM it is now or never. His popularity is diminishing and whilst a coalition government would give him what he wants I don't see he will be able to gather enough votes. His best chance is to fight a GE this year as a Remain party which would see the Lib Dems lose the votes they hoovered up from Labour.

Anyway all speculation no one really knows.

I agree no-one knows. Certainly not Bogus Johnson.

I don't think the DUP will break with the Tories but I do believe that there is likely to be a significant group of Tories who will put country before party at this time if a no deal outcome is the alternative.

I think there is a growing mood within Labour that they need to replace Corbyn if they are to secure power so don't be surprised if something happens in the coming few weeks to achieve that in time.

But I am only speculating too.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Stirlingsays Flag 31 Jul 19 10.03am

Corbyn is going nowhere, not until after a general election anyway. The Labour party benches are filled with his supporters, as is his right.

When Corbyn loses as I expect him to then the fallout and aftermath in the Labour ranks will be fascinating to watch.

I still find it hard to envisage Labour going back to a kind of Blairism though....still, all will be revealed.

Edited by Stirlingsays (31 Jul 2019 10.04am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Midlands Eagle Flag 31 Jul 19 10.12am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Explain what is "scare mongering" about publishing a factual article about a vital issue dominating the national news?

Don't we have a right to understand the impact?

The article was deliberately written to appeal to people like yourself who are so close minded that they aren't interested in any other viewpoint apart from their own.

Everyone has the right to understand the impact of a no deal Brexit but reading biased articles like that one won't help at all

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 31 Jul 19 10.21am

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

BBC team scare mongers in full swing.
[Link]
They have had 3 years to do this and choose now!

No one was talking about no deal 3 years ago; it was all project fear and we were going to agree the easiest trade deal in history...

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 31 Jul 19 10.22am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

The article was deliberately written to appeal to people like yourself who are so close minded that they aren't interested in any other viewpoint apart from their own.

Everyone has the right to understand the impact of a no deal Brexit but reading biased articles like that one won't help at all

This has been the problem with the whole Brexit affair.
There is virtually no unbiased information and no previous experience to draw on.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 31 Jul 19 10.23am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

The article was deliberately written to appeal to people like yourself who are so close minded that they aren't interested in any other viewpoint apart from their own.

Everyone has the right to understand the impact of a no deal Brexit but reading biased articles like that one won't help at all

Which parts of the article specifically did you find biased?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 31 Jul 19 10.31am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow


Which parts of the article specifically did you find biased?

Primarily the fact that it's all doom and gloom and painting a picture of the worst possible scenario which is typical BBC

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 31 Jul 19 10.50am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Primarily the fact that it's all doom and gloom and painting a picture of the worst possible scenario which is typical BBC

But it isn't is it?

It's full of government statements about what to expect and how to prepare. It doesn't offer opinion.

Any picture it paints is an objective one. As such this is more like a photograph than a piece of abstract art which needs interpretation and can be seen by different people in different ways.

These are facts, not opinions and people need to start being honest about them and not trying to bury them under a "project fear" label and hope they will just disappear.

Be honest. If you are prepared to put up with the disruption and cost this will all result in, because you believe we will be better off eventually, than say so.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Page 1163 of 1552 < 1159 1160 1161 1162 1163 1164 1165 1166 1167 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic