You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread
November 20 2026 12.50pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Benteke thread


Page 118 of 166 < 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 >
Fatherken Flag 22 Aug 19 10.37am

The last two seasons one he had an operation after the second game instead of in the closed season , clubs fault not his . It takes time to get fit after any operation . Second the management have not played to his strength's , he does more work than people on here want to see , there view is he is on the pitch just to score goals that's it . He has had chances and missed so do lots of forwards with better supply to them .
There seem to me that there are a lot of glory hunters [ saying they will give up there season tickets if he is still here next season ] not true Palace supporters . Before anyone asks I have been going to Selhurst through thick and thin for 60 years .

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Aug 19 10.45am

Originally posted by Fatherken

The last two seasons one he had an operation after the second game instead of in the closed season , clubs fault not his . It takes time to get fit after any operation . Second the management have not played to his strength's , he does more work than people on here want to see , there view is he is on the pitch just to score goals that's it . He has had chances and missed so do lots of forwards with better supply to them .
There seem to me that there are a lot of glory hunters [ saying they will give up there season tickets if he is still here next season ] not true Palace supporters . Before anyone asks I have been going to Selhurst through thick and thin for 60 years .

What makes me laugh is the cuppingbof his ears after he finally scores a goal, then he doesn’t score another one. I know we haven’t played to his strengths but he has had some chances, missed them all, never made basic moves to areas the ball comes across and instead hides behind as many defenders as possible.

I’m not supporting a w@nker like that next season. The penalty demand was a complete insult to the club. Use him this season’s and get rid.

 


COYP

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 22 Aug 19 11.12am

Benteke would have been long gone but for two things.

Firstly his wages. I can't see a queue of clubs willing to match his contract with Palace. Only maybe the Chinese.

Secondly his transfer fee. Palace aren't going to get anywhere near what he cost to bring in.

Result ; stuck with him and no option but to play him as we failed to bring in another striker.

You can make all the excuses for him that you like - injuries, lack of service etc., but he seems to coast through games when he does play and gets paid a fortune for doing so.
I always have that hope that he will rediscover the Benteke of old, but that hope has almost diminished to nothing.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 22 Aug 19 12.12pm

Agree with this, unless Roy going to play two wingers no point having him starting.

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

What makes me laugh is the cuppingbof his ears after he finally scores a goal, then he doesn’t score another one. I know we haven’t played to his strengths but he has had some chances, missed them all, never made basic moves to areas the ball comes across and instead hides behind as many defenders as possible.

I’m not supporting a w@nker like that next season. The penalty demand was a complete insult to the club. Use him this season’s and get rid.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Legal_Eagle11 Flag Essex 22 Aug 19 1.57pm

Benteke being offered a contract? Until when?!

Please just let him go and we can save his obscene wages.

Those suggesting it’s to make sure we can sell him, that assumes a club will want to buy him.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 22 Aug 19 2.05pm

Originally posted by Legal_Eagle11

Benteke being offered a contract? Until when?!

Please just let him go and we can save his obscene wages.

Those suggesting it’s to make sure we can sell him, that assumes a club will want to buy him.

He is negotiating an increase in his wages, otherwise he will go for free and we get no chance of getting any of the fee paid.

The bizarre world of football.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 22 Aug 19 2.24pm

Originally posted by Painter

He is negotiating an increase in his wages, otherwise he will go for free and we get no chance of getting any of the fee paid.

The bizarre world of football.

He wants what? An INCREASE in his wages OMFG. IF, he gets a new contract, it should be on lower wages, as he has failed to do what he's paid for.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Aug 19 2.39pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

He wants what? An INCREASE in his wages OMFG. IF, he gets a new contract, it should be on lower wages, as he has failed to do what he's paid for.

Too right. No one is going to pay him 100k a week. We should half his wages and put more bonuses in. A goal bonus of 200k a goal will do, we wouldn't have to pay a penny all season.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Ian-VI Flag Vicenza 22 Aug 19 2.55pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Benteke would have been long gone but for two things.

Firstly his wages. I can't see a queue of clubs willing to match his contract with Palace. Only maybe the Chinese.

Secondly his transfer fee. Palace aren't going to get anywhere near what he cost to bring in.

Result ; stuck with him and no option but to play him as we failed to bring in another striker.

You can make all the excuses for him that you like - injuries, lack of service etc., but he seems to coast through games when he does play and gets paid a fortune for doing so.
I always have that hope that he will rediscover the Benteke of old, but that hope has almost diminished to nothing.

Too true.
And I strongly hope that the club won't be so silly to renew his contract to avoid losing him for free.
No one will ever buy him at any sum, so we'd better cut the losses and let him go for free.
Renewing his contract and therefore be unable to sign a decent striker for another 2-3 years would be criminal.

 


The best footie management game: [Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 22 Aug 19 6.50pm

Some right drama queens in here.

Benteke new contract start move you get his basic wage down but offer bonuses to take it to the same or just above what he currently is on.

You dont let a guy you paid 35m for just walk for free especially when you have no other strikers.

The contract doesn't mean he will be staying it just means Palace will get some money for him if they sell.

If this guy was used correctly i could see him scoring 10-12 a season no problem again.

A lot people stating he doesn't do much well you are not watching the full games then maybe it's the camera feeds not showing much of him to you but he is clearly doing a lot of what Roy is asking for just look at a lot of defending he does every corner/freekick he does try to get in the box gets no service so no wonder he then doesn't really put effort in to try again.

Why Roy wont allow direct balls or quick crossing is strange Wilf and Andros can do them it was proven when Big Sam was in charge they may not like it.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 22 Aug 19 6.52pm

Unbelievable that we've not only given Wickham a new contract but are now doing the same to Benteke. At this point I feel like we're either being trolled or it's all a big social experiment. Keira Knightley has got more up front than we've had over the last couple of seasons.

Genuine question, can you name another club with a worse track record with strikers than us? With about 4 exceptions we have signed stinker after stinker for about 20 years now.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

chris123 Flag hove actually 22 Aug 19 6.58pm

I struggle to see the logic in this, it's not as though he's been a form player for us who's going through a bad patch. Benteke has been poor for two years.

 

MikeCrete Flag Crete 23 Aug 19 9.06am

Originally posted by Fatherken

The last two seasons one he had an operation after the second game instead of in the closed season , clubs fault not his . It takes time to get fit after any operation . Second the management have not played to his strength's , he does more work than people on here want to see , there view is he is on the pitch just to score goals that's it . He has had chances and missed so do lots of forwards with better supply to them .
There seem to me that there are a lot of glory hunters [ saying they will give up there season tickets if he is still here next season ] not true Palace supporters . Before anyone asks I have been going to Selhurst through thick and thin for 60 years .


I have over 50 years supporting Palace, so am not in any way glory hunter. I want to be entertained & really do object to someone who disrespected the club & earns £130K a week starting week after week. It seems the only way to really get my point across to the powers that be is to stop going to matches & spending so much money doing do. It really is too much if we resign Benteke.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Aug 19 9.23am

Originally posted by grumpymort

Some right drama queens in here.

Benteke new contract start move you get his basic wage down but offer bonuses to take it to the same or just above what he currently is on.

You dont let a guy you paid 35m for just walk for free especially when you have no other strikers.

The contract doesn't mean he will be staying it just means Palace will get some money for him if they sell.

If this guy was used correctly i could see him scoring 10-12 a season no problem again.

A lot people stating he doesn't do much well you are not watching the full games then maybe it's the camera feeds not showing much of him to you but he is clearly doing a lot of what Roy is asking for just look at a lot of defending he does every corner/freekick he does try to get in the box gets no service so no wonder he then doesn't really put effort in to try again.

Why Roy wont allow direct balls or quick crossing is strange Wilf and Andros can do them it was proven when Big Sam was in charge they may not like it.

1. Proof cpfc is being run by bean counters without a care, including for us, and not football people.

2. Nobody is going to pay money for him.

3. He’s a fvcking forward paid to score goals. Defending corners is an extra. And where’s the cvnt when we break anyway? Behind 9 players that’s where.

‘He does try to get in the box.’ What, like all those balls through the corridor of uncertainty and he’s hiding or actually nowhere to be seen you mean! Dozens of these he could’ve picked up the 10-12 goals per season, instead it’s ONE per season.

4. I agree on the high ball eventually coming in too late though. Sometimes I get the feeling this is the Zaha and Townsend club. Townsend prefers the right and Zaha the left. These 2 should be ordered to change round for 30-40% of the match at least, preferably longer if it’s working.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Aug 19 9.27am

Originally posted by MikeCrete


I have over 50 years supporting Palace, so am not in any way glory hunter. I want to be entertained & really do object to someone who disrespected the club & earns £130K a week starting week after week. It seems the only way to really get my point across to the powers that be is to stop going to matches & spending so much money doing do. It really is too much if we resign Benteke.

We should get a statement or vote or something sent to Parish of thousands of us who will cancel our season tickets if they take us further down this road. It might be the only way seeing ad Roy will accept it, even though if you read his comment of ‘its up to the owners and DOF. I’m happy to work with Benteke’ it suggests otherwise.

We’re becoming a joke now.

 


COYP

JohnB Flag 23 Aug 19 9.30am

If you watch the press conference with Roy yesterday, he is asked is he happy that Benteke is being offered a new contract. He gave the most diplomatic response ever which loosely translated to, I can't believe he's being offered a new contract, what kind of buffoons am I working for?

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 23 Aug 19 9.36am

Well I'm sure he won't be at the club if we are playing in the Championship next season which with everything going on (or not going on) at the club seems an increasingly likely scenario.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Aug 19 9.38am

Originally posted by JohnB

If you watch the press conference with Roy yesterday, he is asked is he happy that Benteke is being offered a new contract. He gave the most diplomatic response ever which loosely translated to, I can't believe he's being offered a new contract, what kind of buffoons am I working for?

Yep, the Americans and Parish will only react to revenue loss. If we accept it they’ll do it. The only way to get through to them is show them the financial and commercial loss it’ll cost.

 


COYP

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 23 Aug 19 9.40am

Benteke could end up being our saviour. His goals may help us avoid relegation to League One next season.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Aug 19 9.48am

It’s so stupid. We’ll end up paying him the money we’re hoping to get it someone is stupid enough to pay for him, which they won’t be.

Also telling that Benteke is considering the extension. Is nobody interested and therefore no big free agent signing on fee? I wonder why.

This is so stupid I can’t understand it and will probably do me a favour in giving Selhurst a miss. I’ll come back after relegation, hopefully no Benteke, Parish running football or anything, or the Americans, in whichever order or combination.

I accept the full football and Benteke here until contract expiry, but not extending it. We’re being insulted and taken for granted here and should make a stand because it’s going too far and more than likely will get worse.

 


COYP

Page 118 of 166 < 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread