This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Never. What I would like is a solution for now not hand wringing about how we got here. How novel. Well, solutions don't appear to be on the table, it appears that the taste for blood is the neo liberal vogue. Johnson, Truss and Wallace have almost convinced me that it must be May, as they are nuts in May already. I find the rhetoric insane. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Apr 2022 2.08am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
How novel. Well, solutions don't appear to be on the table, it appears that the taste for blood is the neo liberal vogue. Johnson, Truss and Wallace have almost convinced me that it must be May, as they are nuts in May already. I find the rhetoric insane. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Apr 2022 2.08am) You seem to have overlooked that Russia is the invader with a stated aim to move on to Moldova. If a sovereign state asks for help against an invader do we ignore that? An imperialist invader that has been poisoning people on our shores and has a history of being indiscriminate about killing civilians, most notably in Syria.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You are entitled to your opinions. Personally I believe that only lip service is being applied to peace and men lives are needlessly being thrown away in the south and east. They are outgunned and it's a mincer. To me it appears that Nato want to seriously militarise Ukraine once Russia have taken the east and southern areas but not in time to fight them there.....but to stand off. This means that eastern and southern army of about 50,000 are lost. I'm not someone who thinks its ok to throw away tens of thousands of troops holding an impossible line. I pray most are taken prisoner and returned rather than lost once encirclement is finiahed. Ukraine will have to negotiate in a position where they have already lost the territory that Russia wants and thrown away the bulk of their experienced troops on an impossible task. The Ukraine and its government are the State department's pawns. Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Apr 2022 11.37pm) I don't think that anyone thinks It's ok to throw away tens of thousands of troops holding an impossible line! I certainly haven't heard anyone propose such a strategy! Neither have I heard anything from the Ukrainians which suggest they are "the State Department's pawns". Quite the reverse. It's them which is pushing the west for more support. So they must believe there is a solid point to defending their territory in the way they are. I have heard military experts, which none of us here are, suggest that the degradation of Russian forces is much worse than they anticipated and that the supply of advanced anti-tank and anti-air weapons will accelerate that. The conclusion being that defeat in the east is not the forgone conclusion you assume it is. It looks pretty hopeless to me too, but as a non-expert I defer to those who are. Of course, those who are experts at everything don't do that.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
You seem to have overlooked that Russia is the invader with a stated aim to move on to Moldova. If a sovereign state asks for help against an invader do we ignore that? An imperialist invader that has been poisoning people on our shores and has a history of being indiscriminate about killing civilians, most notably in Syria. Stated aim? What is your evidence for saying it's a 'stated aim', a news report about comments from a general? Does that count as a 'stated' aim now? How about all the other comments from generals that aren't reported on? How about what Putin has actually said? Do you take them seriously as well or do you ignore the bits the MSM don't report on? You could only say I've overlooked the fact Russia's invaded if you hadn't actually read my posts where I've pointed that out and also made the point that other options regarding Ukraine were available. I've never supported this war.....whether it's Nato/West's policy towards Russia since the Berlin wall or Putin's invasion. I've no support for the way Putin treats his opponents nor the way he runs Russia. I look more towards Orban as I've previously said.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I don't think that anyone thinks It's ok to throw away tens of thousands of troops holding an impossible line! I certainly haven't heard anyone propose such a strategy! That's my view of what's going to happen, the Ukraine's troops currently in the Donbas are going to be encircled and effectively thrown away. That's what it looks like to me and we will see if I'm right or not. Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Neither have I heard anything from the Ukrainians which suggest they are "the State Department's pawns". Quite the reverse. It's them which is pushing the west for more support. Without Nato's weapons this would be over already. If you don't think that makes them Nato's pawns then I think that's just because you prefer different language. When a peace deal is desired, it will be more Nato's than the Ukraine's decision in my view. Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
So they must believe there is a solid point to defending their territory in the way they are. I have heard military experts, which none of us here are, suggest that the degradation of Russian forces is much worse than they anticipated and that the supply of advanced anti-tank and anti-air weapons will accelerate that. The conclusion being that defeat in the east is not the forgone conclusion you assume it is. It looks pretty hopeless to me too, but as a non-expert I defer to those who are. Of course, those who are experts at everything don't do that. I would never object to warriors defending their country. However, I do object to conscripts being forced into service against their will.....men pushed to the front against their will. I've heard that has happened here. As for the predictions for how this goes, we will see. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Apr 2022 12.49pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by W12
You buying this? Not sure if you wanted an answer but if you did then no.
Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course). |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Stated aim? What is your evidence for saying it's a 'stated aim', a news report about comments from a general? Does that count as a 'stated' aim now? How about all the other comments from generals that aren't reported on? How about what Putin has actually said? Do you take them seriously as well or do you ignore the bits the MSM don't report on? You could only say I've overlooked the fact Russia's invaded if you hadn't actually read my posts where I've pointed that out and also made the point that other options regarding Ukraine were available. I've never supported this war.....whether it's Nato/West's policy towards Russia since the Berlin wall or Putin's invasion. I've no support for the way Putin treats his opponents nor the way he runs Russia. I look more towards Orban as I've previously said. No Russian general would talk out of line, those words were planted by the leadership. Even if not, I see no sign of Rustam Minnekayev being sanctioned for what he said so The Kremlin must concur with its deputy commander of The Central Military District
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
No Russian general would talk out of line, those words were planted by the leadership. Even if not, I see no sign of Rustam Minnekayev being sanctioned for what he said so The Kremlin must concur with its deputy commander of The Central Military District For someone who professes to know something about logic I find your paragraph somewhat reaching. Ok, lets look at what you say here. Firstly, the premise that all statements from underlings are planted by the leadership is a nice line in conspiracy but it's unlikely and also unknowable...maybe some are, maybe not. Secondly, how would you know whether he's been sanctioned or internally criticised or not? You don't. So your conclusion that the Kermlin 'must concur' is a conclusion built upon soft foundation......no granite shoreline for you. Putin has made stated aims, but instead you are guilty of cherry picking what you wish from a general.....like I've said, lots of generals, lots of statements but for you it's all been put on a plate. Personally, from my reading of Russia's best interests. I don't see Russia wishing to engage in a long war with multiple fronts. That appears to be something more that Nato would like. We shall see syrup.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
That's my view of what's going to happen, the Ukraine's troops currently in the Donbas are going to be encircled and effectively thrown away. That's what it looks like to me and we will see if I'm right or not. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Apr 2022 12.49pm) You posted it as though it was an incontrovertible fact, whilst it's obviously just your view! It's probably mine too, given the way things look, but those with greater knowledge than me seem to disagree. I hope they are right. Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Without Nato's weapons this would be over already. If you don't think that makes them Nato's pawns then I think that's just because you prefer different language. When a peace deal is desired, it will be more Nato's than the Ukraine's decision in my view.. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Apr 2022 12.49pm) But they aren't "Nato's weapons" are they? They are weapons donated by countries that are Nato members. It's a very important distinction which Russia tries to obscure at every opportunity to convince people like you that Nato is an aggressor, with a dog in this fight. It isn't. Providing military assistance to Ukraine in these circumstances is the moral responsibility of western nations, but they have been ultra-careful not to involve Nato. Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I would never object to warriors defending their country. However, I do object to conscripts being forced into service against their will.....men pushed to the front against their will. I've heard that has happened here. As for the predictions for how this goes, we will see. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Apr 2022 12.49pm) Certainly, all men under 60 were conscripted and I expect some, who have the appropriate experience, are being used at the front. That is a matter for the Ukrainians, who seem to have maintained a high degree of resolve and morale. We will indeed see how it goes. I have heard predictions that Putin wants the May parades to be celebrating his great "victory", so maybe that will provide the window of opportunity for a settlement.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
You posted it as though it was an incontrovertible fact, whilst it's obviously just your view! It's probably mine too, given the way things look, but those with greater knowledge than me seem to disagree. I hope they are right. How can something that hasn't happened yet be stated as a fact? It's my view from what I've seen from less emotive sources. Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
But they aren't "Nato's weapons" are they? They are weapons donated by countries that are Nato members. It's a very important distinction which Russia tries to obscure at every opportunity to convince people like you that Nato is an aggressor, with a dog in this fight. It isn't. Providing military assistance to Ukraine in these circumstances is the moral responsibility of western nations, but they have been ultra-careful not to involve Nato. A distinction without a difference. Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Certainly, all men under 60 were conscripted and I expect some, who have the appropriate experience, are being used at the front. That is a matter for the Ukrainians, who seem to have maintained a high degree of resolve and morale. We will indeed see how it goes. I have heard predictions that Putin wants the May parades to be celebrating his great "victory", so maybe that will provide the window of opportunity for a settlement. If people have to be conscripted then it's a bit dubious to say they have high resolve and morale.....otherwise they wouldn't need conscription. I'm not of the view that you force people to fight....on certain fronts it's a practical maim or death sentence. Sure it's a 'matter for the Ukrainians', however when you force people to fight against their will and they die doing it.....some might find issues with that. I'm not sure that Putin's aims will be finished by those victory parades, however I don't see the Russians wanting a long war....I see Nato wanting that. What scares me is what happens once Putin wants to stop but Nato/Ukraine don't.....That's when the scary escalation could happen and I'm obviously selfishly keen that sense prevails. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Apr 2022 3.50pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by W12
You buying this? How much does she charge for a 'quickie'? The wife's visiting family in Truro for the week.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
How can something that hasn't happened yet be stated as a fact? It's my view from what I've seen from less emotive sources. You are being pedantic. You know exactly what was meant. You stated it as though it was a forgone conclusion, and that no other outcome is possible, whereas, for the reasons I have given, that's untrue. Originally posted by Stirlingsays
A distinction without a difference. It's a very big difference, but it's exactly what Putin wants you to think and seems to be the fundamental reason for your muddled thinking on all of this. Once again we are witnessing the way Russian botnets target the impressionable right, primarily in the USA, which then gets fed into the minds of people who watch their basement video pontifications. Originally posted by Stirlingsays
If people have to be conscripted then it's a bit dubious to say they have high resolve and morale.....otherwise they wouldn't need conscription. I'm not of the view that you force people to fight....on certain fronts it's a practical maim or death sentence. Sure it's a 'matter for the Ukrainians', however when you force people to fight against their will and they die doing it.....some might find issues with that. I'm not sure that Putin's aims will be finished by those victory parades, however I don't see the Russians wanting a long war....I see Nato wanting that. What scares me is what happens once Putin wants to stop but Nato/Ukraine don't.....That's when the scary escalation could happen and I'm obviously selfishly keen that sense prevails. I saw many very reluctantly saying goodbye to their wives and family, but nevertheless accepting that they had to play their part. The whole country has shown resolve, which is something Putin did not expect. As Putin's aims remain a mystery, who knows when they will be satisfied. If ever. Degrading his forces to the point where he looks for a way out which can be sold as a victory in Russia seems the least worse option to me. When Putin decides to stop, it will be Ukraine who decides whether the terms are acceptable. Nato will not be involved. Pressure might be applied by some countries, but not by Nato. Escalation will certainly be avoided at any reasonable cost. It won't be sought.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Dnipro seems to be key. Russian forces are making slow progress in encircling a large part of Donbas, this in turn will cut off supply routes to the majority of Ukraine's professional & battle hardened army. Since Russian forces decided to move the offensive entirely into the south east, they have made their lives much easier in defending their ground units (particularly tanks) Logistics whilst still poor are infinitely better than what they were & I saw a while back the Russians had built fuel lines that run into Russian occupied Donbas. you can see the slow encirclement for yourself here If/once they have secured this, momentum will shift towards Dnipro & finally onto Odesa. Providing the West continues to equip & train Ukrainian soldiers time is on Ukrainian side & for them to win they simply need to hold the Russians where they are, Russia will simply run out of decent equipment before the Ukrainians will. Moldova/Transnistria It comes as absolutely no surprise to me Russia wants to take a chunk of Moldova for itself, I posted over a month ago that Lukashenko had announced plans for Ukraine to be broken into 4 puppet states & for Russia to invade Moldova. The unrest were now seeing in Moldova is at the command of Russia to spread to war to different areas making it harder for the west to manage. For example see this [Tweet Link]
Always fire your rpg's at government buidings in broad daylight whilst under surveillance and remember to always leave your evidence behind, absolute f***ing noobs but this seems to be Russian operatives in a nutshell during this war. This leads me onto something quite funny & sadly mostly missed due to the twitter news.
The mountains are calling & I must go. |
|
|
Apparently Russia foiled an assassination attempt on some public TV figure, a Ukrainian man was arrested carrying a Swastika, photo of Hitler and a load of other crap, the funniest thing however was he was carrying 3 copies of the Sims video game... Clearly the Russian operative in charge of this false flag had read the instructions & followed them to a T except he should have placed 3 sim cards in stash & not he above. See here [Tweet Link]
The Russians actually broadcast this bollocks to its own population Edited by Ouzo Dan (27 Apr 2022 8.15pm)
The mountains are calling & I must go. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ouzo Dan
Apparently Russia foiled an assassination attempt on some public TV figure, a Ukrainian man was arrested carrying a Swastika, photo of Hitler and a load of other crap, the funniest thing however was he was carrying 3 copies of the Sims video game... Clearly the Russian operative in charge of this false flag had read the instructions & followed them to a T except he should have placed 3 sim cards in stash & not he above. See here [Tweet Link]
The Russians actually broadcast this bollocks to its own population Edited by Ouzo Dan (27 Apr 2022 8.15pm) I heard his grandfather served in the 99 luftballoons division
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Ouzo Dan
Dnipro seems to be key. Russian forces are making slow progress in encircling a large part of Donbas, this in turn will cut off supply routes to the majority of Ukraine's professional & battle hardened army. Since Russian forces decided to move the offensive entirely into the south east, they have made their lives much easier in defending their ground units (particularly tanks) Logistics whilst still poor are infinitely better than what they were & I saw a while back the Russians had built fuel lines that run into Russian occupied Donbas. you can see the slow encirclement for yourself here If/once they have secured this, momentum will shift towards Dnipro & finally onto Odesa. Providing the West continues to equip & train Ukrainian soldiers time is on Ukrainian side & for them to win they simply need to hold the Russians where they are, Russia will simply run out of decent equipment before the Ukrainians will. Moldova/Transnistria It comes as absolutely no surprise to me Russia wants to take a chunk of Moldova for itself, I posted over a month ago that Lukashenko had announced plans for Ukraine to be broken into 4 puppet states & for Russia to invade Moldova. The unrest were now seeing in Moldova is at the command of Russia to spread to war to different areas making it harder for the west to manage. For example see this [Tweet Link]
Always fire your rpg's at government buidings in broad daylight whilst under surveillance and remember to always leave your evidence behind, absolute f***ing noobs but this seems to be Russian operatives in a nutshell during this war. This leads me onto something quite funny & sadly mostly missed due to the twitter news. Very insightful and meaningful contributions. Thanks for the considered, balanced take.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I heard his grandfather served in the 99 luftballoons division
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Ouzo Dan
Apparently Russia foiled an assassination attempt on some public TV figure, a Ukrainian man was arrested carrying a Swastika, photo of Hitler and a load of other crap, the funniest thing however was he was carrying 3 copies of the Sims video game... Clearly the Russian operative in charge of this false flag had read the instructions & followed them to a T except he should have placed 3 sim cards in stash & not he above. See here [Tweet Link]
The Russians actually broadcast this bollocks to its own population Edited by Ouzo Dan (27 Apr 2022 8.15pm) Hilarious and as inept as the rest of this Russia operation and propaganda campaign has been.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.