You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread
November 20 2026 12.50pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Benteke thread


Page 119 of 166 < 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 >
ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 23 Aug 19 10.10am

I have never seen such strong feelings about renewing a player's contract in my time of supporting Palace.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 23 Aug 19 10.19am

at my optimistic best this means we get a sell-on fee when he leaves at the end of the season, at my pessimistic worst we're stuck with this fella for the next few years.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Aug 19 10.20am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I have never seen such strong feelings about renewing a player's contract in my time of supporting Palace.

He hasn’t been considered as a player. More an asset (that’s a joke), or figure on a spreadsheet.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Aug 19 10.25am

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

at my optimistic best this means we get a sell-on fee when he leaves at the end of the season, at my pessimistic worst we're stuck with this fella for the next few years.

Yep. But if he’s likely to leave at the end of the season, he should refuse to extend. But why has there been no interest this summer?

It’s nonsensical, if you look at it considering the football.

If someone does buy him after another year it’ll cover his wages for that year so what’s the point of this.

Just fvck off. This’ll becit for me. I’ll come back when something promising in a change at cpfc happens. Fvck this.

 


COYP

MikeCrete Flag Crete 23 Aug 19 11.05am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

We should get a statement or vote or something sent to Parish of thousands of us who will cancel our season tickets if they take us further down this road. It might be the only way seeing ad Roy will accept it, even though if you read his comment of ‘its up to the owners and DOF. I’m happy to work with Benteke’ it suggests otherwise.

We’re becoming a joke now.

Think are right Rudi, statement of intent to Parish.
s it is we will be lucky to stay up so is going to buy the season tickets then?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Aug 19 11.16am

Originally posted by MikeCrete

Think are right Rudi, statement of intent to Parish.
s it is we will be lucky to stay up so is going to buy the season tickets then?

If we are irrelevant, which is how I’m reading this sh1t now, then they won’t miss my season ticket money. I’ll be a mug to pay it when I can watch at home or fall asleep while it’s on or watch the Dallas cheerleader trials instead. That’s if we stay up and are on streams.

Things or challenges will only get harder when Zaha leaves and we want to add to them? Jokers.

 


COYP

A89M Flag Streatham 23 Aug 19 12.09pm

Playing devils advocate here but we don't play to Benteke's strengths, which I think is quite clear to all and the only reason I can see that being because of is Wilf - Everything goes through Wilf, where he likes to drive into the box and cut the ball back or commit defenders, which doesn't suit Bentekes one dimensional game at all, which is - 'stand at the back post and hope it lands on my head'.

With the above in mind, are we re-signing Benteke for when Wilf goes and we have to revise how we play? Maybe we'll start playing towards our strikers strengths rather than relying on one man?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Aug 19 12.17pm

Originally posted by A89M

Playing devils advocate here but we don't play to Benteke's strengths, which I think is quite clear to all and the only reason I can see that being because of is Wilf - Everything goes through Wilf, where he likes to drive into the box and cut the ball back or commit defenders, which doesn't suit Bentekes one dimensional game at all, which is - 'stand at the back post and hope it lands on my head'.

With the above in mind, are we re-signing Benteke for when Wilf goes and we have to revise how we play? Maybe we'll start playing towards our strikers strengths rather than relying on one man?

It’s a good point. But Roy doesn’t play that way either. Parish hired FDB one year after Benteke to not play the direct football Benteke is suited to.

What do you think Parish will do? Seek out the direct football manager that either doesn’t exist or has been promoted with a large kitty and no interest in us. It’s so muddled it’s fvcking embarrassing how we’re now being run.

And people claim Parish learns from his mistakes? It would be funny if it wasn’t so painful and damaging. He doesn’t plan or learn, only wants acquiescent people around him who will usually be inexperienced.

Fvcking he’ll i was almost looking forward to 20/21 season after this struggle. Not now.

 


COYP

A89M Flag Streatham 23 Aug 19 1.02pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

It’s a good point. But Roy doesn’t play that way either. Parish hired FDB one year after Benteke to not play the direct football Benteke is suited to.

What do you think Parish will do? Seek out the direct football manager that either doesn’t exist or has been promoted with a large kitty and no interest in us. It’s so muddled it’s fvcking embarrassing how we’re now being run.

And people claim Parish learns from his mistakes? It would be funny if it wasn’t so painful and damaging. He doesn’t plan or learn, only wants acquiescent people around him who will usually be inexperienced.

Fvcking he’ll i was almost looking forward to 20/21 season after this struggle. Not now.

You're right, Roy doesn't play this way and Parish doesn't seem to like the style either.

IF we stay up, will Roy be here after this season when Wilf leaves? If he doesn't and we have to resort back to direct football to gain stability after Wilfs departure, Benteke would be the ideal striker to have but again, you're right, we have used all the stable British managers who play this way.

It's very hard to see SP's vision..

 

EddieMac Flag 23 Aug 19 1.48pm

A lot of you spend your days crying on here about the clubs finances and how much we waste on wages but you are willing to let 15-20 million walk out the door for free.

Contradicting yourselves !!

If Benteke does not sign a new deal he leaves for free. If he does sign a new deal on same wages then an asset is protected. It may cost us 5 million or so over a year but then he gets sold for say 15 million which is 10 mill profit.

It is a no brainer.

 

Palace_love_affair Flag SE London 23 Aug 19 1.52pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

A lot of you spend your days crying on here about the clubs finances and how much we waste on wages but you are willing to let 15-20 million walk out the door for free.

Contradicting yourselves !!

If Benteke does not sign a new deal he leaves for free. If he does sign a new deal on same wages then an asset is protected. It may cost us 5 million or so over a year but then he gets sold for say 15 million which is 10 mill profit.

It is a no brainer.

Which mug are we expecting to part with 15m for a striker with 4 goals in his last 51 apps?


 


"We're the Holmesdale, We're the Holmesdale, We're the Holmesdale over here!!"

EddieMac Flag 23 Aug 19 2.03pm

Originally posted by Palace_love_affair

Which mug are we expecting to part with 15m for a striker with 4 goals in his last 51 apps?


Sheffield United paid 20 or so million for Ollie McBurnie. I rest my case.

 

RyWa Flag Beckenham 23 Aug 19 2.09pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Sheffield United paid 20 or so million for Ollie McBurnie. I rest my case.

McBurnie scored 24 goals last season.
He also looked very good when he came on against us.

 

Den1923 Flag 23 Aug 19 2.18pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

A lot of you spend your days crying on here about the clubs finances and how much we waste on wages but you are willing to let 15-20 million walk out the door for free.

Contradicting yourselves !!

If Benteke does not sign a new deal he leaves for free. If he does sign a new deal on same wages then an asset is protected. It may cost us 5 million or so over a year but then he gets sold for say 15 million which is 10 mill profit.

It is a no brainer.

nobody in their right mind would pay that a striker who can't score, has no floor skills, can't take penalties and does not know how to work defenders off the ball!

 

JohnB Flag 23 Aug 19 2.18pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

A lot of you spend your days crying on here about the clubs finances and how much we waste on wages but you are willing to let 15-20 million walk out the door for free.

Contradicting yourselves !!

If Benteke does not sign a new deal he leaves for free. If he does sign a new deal on same wages then an asset is protected. It may cost us 5 million or so over a year but then he gets sold for say 15 million which is 10 mill profit.

It is a no brainer.

So why would Benteke suddenly have a change of heart and join another club after signing a new contract with us, when he has already turned down offers from other clubs in the last year? If no club goes in for him and we sign him on a new contract, we're lumbered with him.

If your argument is that because he could get a big signing on fee and large wages for going on a free, why would he then sign a contract with us that are not on better terms than he's currently on?

Literally none of renewing his contract makes any sense.

Losing him on a free may mean we don't recoup any kind of fee, but we also then have over £100k a week off the wage bill which could be used to bring in a loan signing like Batshuayi rather than continue with a player that just isn't working.

 

EddieMac Flag 23 Aug 19 2.32pm

Originally posted by JohnB

So why would Benteke suddenly have a change of heart and join another club after signing a new contract with us, when he has already turned down offers from other clubs in the last year? If no club goes in for him and we sign him on a new contract, we're lumbered with him.

If your argument is that because he could get a big signing on fee and large wages for going on a free, why would he then sign a contract with us that are not on better terms than he's currently on?

Literally none of renewing his contract makes any sense.

Losing him on a free may mean we don't recoup any kind of fee, but we also then have over £100k a week off the wage bill which could be used to bring in a loan signing like Batshuayi rather than continue with a player that just isn't working.

If he is signing a new contract it is because he wants to stay at Palace as there are always buyers and takers for premier league players. You may not think he is worth anything but believe me in todays market even with his recent goal scoring record he is still worth a lot of money.

He doesnt have to have a change of heart, players get sold all the time even though they really dont want to move. So in a years time if the club decise they want him gone then he will be gone. Players generally do not want to stay at clubs where they are not wanted. (Benteke at Liverpool)

It makes perfect sense to get him tied down to a new deal.

Your saying get 100k off the wage bill but are letting 15-20 million walk out the door. The maths dont add up.

 

EddieMac Flag 23 Aug 19 2.33pm

Originally posted by RyWa

McBurnie scored 24 goals last season.
He also looked very good when he came on against us.


Lets see how he does in the Premier league

 

kev64 Flag Cambs 23 Aug 19 2.44pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

A lot of you spend your days crying on here about the clubs finances and how much we waste on wages but you are willing to let 15-20 million walk out the door for free.

Contradicting yourselves !!

If Benteke does not sign a new deal he leaves for free. If he does sign a new deal on same wages then an asset is protected. It may cost us 5 million or so over a year but then he gets sold for say 15 million which is 10 mill profit.

It is a no brainer.

its a no brainer, nobody will sign a striker on 130k a week for 15m that does not score goals. Tekkers really doesn't care he's a multi millionaire is fing useless at what he does and will get a huge sign on fee again from us and 4 mill a year for walking a round a football pitch and going to the gym.

If we resign him, my St next year wont be renewed and im off to watch Cambridge play until sense prevails in se25

 

lefty27 Flag ipswich 23 Aug 19 2.46pm

Don’t think he can be criticised for not closing down defenders. The way we play under Roy we don’t press the ball from the front. I expect he’s under instructions not to, also neither did Zaha last week, they were both passengers.
I would be very disappointed if he leaves on a free after all we have invested in him, IF he scores a few goals there will be for sure a team willing to buy him, especially one which plays direct and has wingers that cross the ball.

 

RyWa Flag Beckenham 23 Aug 19 2.48pm

Originally posted by EddieMac


Lets see how he does in the Premier league

Cant do any worse than Benteke, only needs to score twice this season to have a better season than Benteke has for the last 2 seasons.
Id have taken McBurnie over Benteke every day of the week.

 

Page 119 of 166 < 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread