This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Totally incorrect. Feel free to prove that’s the case, though. That would require you to be objective so I have a feeling we could be waiting a while. There are some posted by others on this thread that go against what you would view as the current ‘narrative’. There are plenty that support further research into the question re cancer you are asking. There are plenty that have challenging hypotheses. If they were all following the narrative they’d firstly not be published as you say, and secondly if they were they’d say ‘no casual link, nothing to see here’. But they don’t. Your dogmatic view is yours to hold but don’t cry about it or try to hide behind accusations of personal attack when you post nonsense and are called out for it accordingly. Maybe follow your own advice and ‘leave it there’ if this is all triggering you so much? I did earlier in the thread.
|
|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
I did earlier in the thread. I'm afraid you didn't. You're saying that all research reports, effectively ever, are useless. That's a pretty bold claim. I'm not sure you understand what 'proof' actually means in this context.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
I'm afraid you didn't. You're saying that all research reports, effectively ever, are useless. That's a pretty bold claim. I'm not sure you understand what 'proof' actually means in this context. Go back and read the thread then
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
So yet another of the Campbell videos on excess deaths is referenced here with its use of official statistics and heavy hints of a cover up by the main stream media and governments. What it fails to do is state 2 very obvious facts. Firstly that the pandemic has had, and continues to have, serious implications for health services across the world. Treatments have been delayed and diagnostic tests missed alongside any direct effect from the virus itself. Secondly that there is no uniformity in data collection so whilst some country’s data can be relied on and reasonable comparisons made that’s not true everywhere. This isn’t featuring as a story in the MSM because there is no new story. It’s just part of the pandemic which has been, and continues to receive, coverage. We knew the NHS would suffer in its ability to deliver care. That’s why we took the extreme measures we did and why we rushed through the vaccination programme. This excess death statistics are simply ongoing evidence of that. Nothing else. There is nothing to see here other than a charlatan hinting at a conspiracy theory in order to keep the pounds rolling in. Those that fall for this nonsense lay themselves open to having their judgements questioned on everything else. Why is it a charlatan act to report figures?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It isn’t and it wasn’t suggested it was. What was is that the guy reporting the figures is a charlatan and that the inferences that are unsaid, but still obviously meant to be understood by his intended audience that something other than Covid itself is responsible (vaccines anyone) confirm that yet again. Something other than Covid is involved.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
That link explains things very well. Thanks for finding it. It has never been suggested this is down to Covid itself, but due to the impact of Covid on our health services. Services that were already at a crisis point. What the situation would have been without Covid can only be guessed but we may still have seen higher mortality than in the previous years. Covid has just made things worse and is continuing to do so, with all the backlogs that now exist. I am pleased to see the specific denial of any contribution from the vaccines, which are what the conspiracy theorists want you to believe are responsible. I'm not blaming vaccines. I'm blaming lockdowns which, in addition to missed diagnoses, created the very backlogs they were intended to avoid.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
I'm not blaming vaccines. I'm blaming lockdowns which, in addition to missed diagnoses, created the very backlogs they were intended to avoid. We've been here before. No one argues that the measures taken produced these consequences. What is argued that any other strategy would have necessarily produced a better outcome. There are very good reasons for believing the opposite and that if we had not locked down our situation, undoubtedly bad, would have been very much worse. Looking back and objectively trying to learn the lessons is why we are having a thorough, unemotional enquiry. Just stating that the lockdowns were responsible is stating the obvious. Others though do want to blame the vaccines, usually those opposed to them from the start, those who distrust anything official or scientific or those who encourage such attitudes by spreading misinformation in order to enrich themselves.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
We've been here before. No one argues that the measures taken produced these consequences. What is argued that any other strategy would have necessarily produced a better outcome. There are very good reasons for believing the opposite and that if we had not locked down our situation, undoubtedly bad, would have been very much worse. Looking back and objectively trying to learn the lessons is why we are having a thorough, unemotional enquiry. Just stating that the lockdowns were responsible is stating the obvious. Others though do want to blame the vaccines, usually those opposed to them from the start, those who distrust anything official or scientific or those who encourage such attitudes by spreading misinformation in order to enrich themselves. There was cause to lockdown the most vulnerable but the damage caused to businesses and education as well as less definable harm to mental health, etc, makes complete lockdown a very difficult position to defend and, to me, represents a dangerous precedent.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
There was cause to lockdown the most vulnerable but the damage caused to businesses and education as well as less definable harm to mental health, etc, makes complete lockdown a very difficult position to defend and, to me, represents a dangerous precedent. I don’t find it difficult to defend at all. We know it has had consequences and we knew it would when they were introduced. We don’t know what the consequences would have been if we didn’t lockdown. It’s only theory. Comparisons with other countries are only valid if the circumstances are similar, and there aren’t any. If you drive into a brick wall at speed you know there will be a mess and possibly casualties. If the alternative is going over a cliff edge with no knowledge of what lies below you will probably opt to drive into the wall. We made the best decision we could with the knowledge we had at the time. Whether we would do exactly the same again with the knowledge we have now and with that which the enquiry reveals, is altogether a different matter. No precedent has been set. Pandemics are infrequent events. Lessons will be learned and better preparations made.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I don’t find it difficult to defend at all. We know it has had consequences and we knew it would when they were introduced. We don’t know what the consequences would have been if we didn’t lockdown. It’s only theory. Comparisons with other countries are only valid if the circumstances are similar, and there aren’t any. If you drive into a brick wall at speed you know there will be a mess and possibly casualties. If the alternative is going over a cliff edge with no knowledge of what lies below you will probably opt to drive into the wall. We made the best decision we could with the knowledge we had at the time. Whether we would do exactly the same again with the knowledge we have now and with that which the enquiry reveals, is altogether a different matter. No precedent has been set. Pandemics are infrequent events. Lessons will be learned and better preparations made. Another definition of driving over a cliff is closing down society and the economy with no knowledge of the potential damage in the hope that a vaccine that has never been developed before will appear.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Another definition of driving over a cliff is closing down society and the economy with no knowledge of the potential damage in the hope that a vaccine that has never been developed before will appear. Not to my mind it isn’t. We knew there would be consequences, some of which were unquantifiable but others for which some estimates were possible. The judgement seems to have been that unpleasant although they would be that they were survivable and, on balance, presented a least bad option than risking any of the alternatives. I say we but the truth is that none of us carried the responsibilities involved. Looking at things from the outside and thinking you know better is easy. Actually doing things is hard. I have no time at all for Johnson and the government he led. I thought it one of the worst in my lifetime but at least he acted responsibly over the way the pandemic strategy was developed, even if he failed to follow that strategy himself. Your remark about the vaccines is not correct. Although the mNRA vaccines had not been used on humans and was relatively new technology there was a great deal of confidence that it could and would deliver answers provided it was fully resourced. The way this was done was a terrific tribute to the way the world can cooperate in a crisis and a beacon of hope for our future. I expect movies to be made about it in time as there are stories to be told that will inspire future generations. WEF and globalisation conspiracy theorists ought to hang their heads in shame.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Not to my mind it isn’t. We knew there would be consequences, some of which were unquantifiable but others for which some estimates were possible. The judgement seems to have been that unpleasant although they would be that they were survivable and, on balance, presented a least bad option than risking any of the alternatives. I say we but the truth is that none of us carried the responsibilities involved. Looking at things from the outside and thinking you know better is easy. Actually doing things is hard. I have no time at all for Johnson and the government he led. I thought it one of the worst in my lifetime but at least he acted responsibly over the way the pandemic strategy was developed, even if he failed to follow that strategy himself. Your remark about the vaccines is not correct. Although the mNRA vaccines had not been used on humans and was relatively new technology there was a great deal of confidence that it could and would deliver answers provided it was fully resourced. The way this was done was a terrific tribute to the way the world can cooperate in a crisis and a beacon of hope for our future. I expect movies to be made about it in time as there are stories to be told that will inspire future generations. WEF and globalisation conspiracy theorists ought to hang their heads in shame. It was still a huge gamble that an effective vaccine would be developed within a reasonable timeframe.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
It was still a huge gamble that an effective vaccine would be developed within a reasonable timeframe. I don’t think there was any gamble involved. The industry was sure it would work. The issue was the scale needed and that demanded commitment and very hard work. That several separate efforts were made further improved the chances. Who do you think paid the highest price? The young perhaps, who have the time to rebuild and recover? There will always been inequality of impact whatever you do. The selfish were those who could have been vaccinated but chose not to, thus putting themselves and others at greater risk and loading potential additional strain upon our health services. The excess deaths we are now seeing would have been lessened if the selfish had joined in the national effort. They of course will deny it and hide behind their fig leaf excuse of personal freedom.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I don’t think there was any gamble involved. The industry was sure it would work. The issue was the scale needed and that demanded commitment and very hard work. That several separate efforts were made further improved the chances. Who do you think paid the highest price? The young perhaps, who have the time to rebuild and recover? There will always been inequality of impact whatever you do. The selfish were those who could have been vaccinated but chose not to, thus putting themselves and others at greater risk and loading potential additional strain upon our health services. The excess deaths we are now seeing would have been lessened if the selfish had joined in the national effort. They of course will deny it and hide behind their fig leaf excuse of personal freedom. The medical experts were also confident that hundreds of thousands would die. We don't know what would have happened without lockdown but we also don't know what would have happened if the vaccine hadn't been effective;lockdown until one was developed?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
The medical experts were also confident that hundreds of thousands would die. We don't know what would have happened without lockdown but we also don't know what would have happened if the vaccine hadn't been effective;lockdown until one was developed? It depends on what you mean about medical experts thinking hundreds of thousands would die. Across the world? Directly or indirectly? No one knew. There were those who tried to estimate possible worst case scenarios that were then picked up and used as scare stories. No one could either be 100% sure of anything but there was a real confidence that the vaccine development would work and so the resources were provided to ensure that when it did we were ready to move quickly. It did and we did. Judgements had to be made. They can always be considered incorrect and could be subsequently proved incorrect but they still need to be made. They were, and we are where we are. I am glad we did. One of my granddaughters fits your highest price category. She got supported in many ways and although very isolated for long periods has come out the other side ok. She managed to feed herself and her young family, kept her home warm and her children’s education going. She missed her friends but the internet kept them together better than might have been expected. Then they celebrated when it relaxed.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.