Quote silvertop at 07 Jul 2014 11.55am
Quote matt_himself at 06 Jul 2014 10.26pm
Quote Kermit8 at 06 Jul 2014 10.14pm
Quote matt_himself at 06 Jul 2014 10.04pm
Quote Bert the Head at 06 Jul 2014 9.56pm
Quote matt_himself at 06 Jul 2014 9.35pm
Quote nickgusset at 06 Jul 2014 9.26pm
Quote matt_himself at 06 Jul 2014 9.22pm
Quote nickgusset at 06 Jul 2014 9.07pm
Quote matt_himself at 06 Jul 2014 8.03pm
So this latest episode was started by the peace loving and gentle Palestinians kidnapping and murdering three Israeli teens which the perpetrators knew would draw a response from the IDF and the more militant parts of Israeli society.
Quite how some people can defend these people is beyond me.
Who is defending them?
These people:
[Link]
Didn't see anything about defending the kidnapping and murdering of Israeli teenagers there. Can you show us where that bit is.
I was talking about defending the Palestinian cause. In general. The Palestinians have proved time and time again hat they are unable to act in a civilised manner, for example the unprovoked murdering of three teenagers making their way home. The murders have not been condemned by the Palestinian leadership or for that matter by he Palestine Campaign.
Keep trying to twist my words Gusset.
One more thing, as you didn't know the difference between deficit and debt reduction, would you like some pointers on the history of the Israel/Palestine situation?
"unprovoked" stealing people’s homes and massacring them and then continuing to build new settlements on stolen land would provoke a far less patience response from the US and Britain if it happened to them than we expect of the Palestinians.
"unable to act in a civilised manner" running over people with bulldozers and burning a teenager alive hardly places Israel in a good light in terms of being all that civilized
For all the talk of Palestinians denying the state of Israel - which is not true in any case - Israel doesn't accept a Palestinian state.
What did the three Israeli teens do to he Palestinians that warranted their kidnap and murder?
The Palestinians provoked this latest situation. Make no mistake.
What? All of them?
I would have thought those poor teenagers were murdered by a handful, don't you?
You should be more mindful of what you write. It comes across as inflammatory and I know a reasonable chap like yourself would not like that to be the case, would you?
Who killed the teenagers? It was Palestinians. What constitutes Palestinians is a small community, is a tight community and is one where Hamas and Fatah have direct control over much of its population. Whomever killed these teens were either directly in one of the many 'resistance' groups' representing Palestinians or were not too far removed from them. The perpetrators would have to be congenital idiots not to know or foretell the consequences of their actions.
As for the second part, thank you for your condescending comments. However, isn't the point of a message to allow an exchange of thoughts? Or as they don't fit with your very narrow World view, they shouldn't be voiced at all? Is that what you are saying?
Matt, I am sorry to jump in on a good old ding-dong between you and our Caledonian friend, but this could rank as one of the siliest and most ill-informed posts I have read on this subject. That would include press releases by the Israeli Defence Force and opinions from the American Christian Right.
There are about 10 million Palestinians. About half live within Israel, mostly crammed into the West Bank and Gaza Strip. The other 5 million or so live in squalid settlement camps in neighbouring Arab countries, pretty much as second class citizens. Let us say that these are probably not places that most of them would like to live, many having been dispossessed of their homes by force by Israelis with many relatives being murdered in the process and within the lifetime of many.
So, which of those Palestinians do you think deserve to be bombed? The ones who committed the atrocity or just a reasonable selection of them? Israel prides itself as being an island of democracy in an otherwise oppressive region and to a large extent that is true - in the way they treat their own people. The way they deal with [admittedly] terrorist acts from Palestinians is very much in keeping with the worst acts of their Arab neighbours. I see no distinction. It is simply insupportable.
I genuinely do not follow you on this.
I said that the Palestinians know who did this. I maintain they could find out within hours, such is the control they have over their people. It is a similar situation to Belfast in the seventies. The resistance groups run the place. They could root out the perpetrators and hand them over if they wanted. I maintain that he perpetrators knew what they were doing, which was to stoke up tensions.
Then you go on to say who I want bombed. This is completely out of context with my post. I don't want any civilian population bombed and I haven't advocated this anywhere.
I fail to understand your comment that this is the 'silliest post' on the subject. You have not countered my comments, you have created arguments of your own from nowhere. I am happy to debate this subject but your position needs to cogent, which I don't believe it is.
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02
|