You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine
November 22 2026 2.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Israel / Palestine


Page 12 of 80 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >
Stirlingsays Flag 07 Jul 14 2.30pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Jul 2014 11.37pm

Realistically any solution will need to see the situation, economically, in the Palestine Authority improved to undermine the support and appeal provided by Hamas. Fatah itself is probably a spent force, that was largely held together by Arafat, and a generation of PLO leaders who were not 'Islamist' inspired.

As it stands, neither side are actually interested in peace, as the 'continual' cycle of conflict suit their agendas, and neither side can actually win.



The only win would be for the other not to exist. As that's not likely to happen Israel certainly seem to have most of the cards.

The day the Palestinians in Gaza voted in Hamas was the day they f*cked themselves up for a long time. I threw up my hands that day.

Israel can deal with the extremist approcach far more easierly than any other.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ghosteagle Flag 07 Jul 14 2.45pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 07 Jul 2014 2.30pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Jul 2014 11.37pm

Realistically any solution will need to see the situation, economically, in the Palestine Authority improved to undermine the support and appeal provided by Hamas. Fatah itself is probably a spent force, that was largely held together by Arafat, and a generation of PLO leaders who were not 'Islamist' inspired.

As it stands, neither side are actually interested in peace, as the 'continual' cycle of conflict suit their agendas, and neither side can actually win.



The only win would be for the other not to exist. As that's not likely to happen Israel certainly seem to have most of the cards.

The day the Palestinians in Gaza voted in Hamas was the day they f*cked themselves up for a long time. I threw up my hands that day.

Israel can deal with the extremist approcach far more easierly than any other.

I think the rise of Hamas in popularity among Palestinians is testament to the oppression that they have suffered at the hands of Israel. Israel has never had any intention of allowing a Palestinian state, and given the violence that they have inflicted upon a poor and impoverished people while stealing their land it can come as no surprise that the people have come to believe that their only hope lies in people also prepared to use violence. What would make a difference is if the international community would hold Israel to account for its actions.


 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 07 Jul 14 4.32pm

Quote silvertop at 07 Jul 2014 11.55am

Quote matt_himself at 06 Jul 2014 10.26pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Jul 2014 10.14pm

Quote matt_himself at 06 Jul 2014 10.04pm

Quote Bert the Head at 06 Jul 2014 9.56pm

Quote matt_himself at 06 Jul 2014 9.35pm

Quote nickgusset at 06 Jul 2014 9.26pm

Quote matt_himself at 06 Jul 2014 9.22pm

Quote nickgusset at 06 Jul 2014 9.07pm

Quote matt_himself at 06 Jul 2014 8.03pm

So this latest episode was started by the peace loving and gentle Palestinians kidnapping and murdering three Israeli teens which the perpetrators knew would draw a response from the IDF and the more militant parts of Israeli society.

Quite how some people can defend these people is beyond me.

Who is defending them?

These people:

[Link]


Didn't see anything about defending the kidnapping and murdering of Israeli teenagers there.
Can you show us where that bit is.


I was talking about defending the Palestinian cause. In general. The Palestinians have proved time and time again hat they are unable to act in a civilised manner, for example the unprovoked murdering of three teenagers making their way home. The murders have not been condemned by the Palestinian leadership or for that matter by he Palestine Campaign.

Keep trying to twist my words Gusset.

One more thing, as you didn't know the difference between deficit and debt reduction, would you like some pointers on the history of the Israel/Palestine situation?

"unprovoked" stealing people’s homes and massacring them and then continuing to build new settlements on stolen land would provoke a far less patience response from the US and Britain if it happened to them than we expect of the Palestinians.

"unable to act in a civilised manner" running over people with bulldozers and burning a teenager alive hardly places Israel in a good light in terms of being all that civilized

For all the talk of Palestinians denying the state of Israel - which is not true in any case - Israel doesn't accept a Palestinian state.


What did the three Israeli teens do to he Palestinians that warranted their kidnap and murder?

The Palestinians provoked this latest situation. Make no mistake.


What? All of them?

I would have thought those poor teenagers were murdered by a handful, don't you?

You should be more mindful of what you write. It comes across as inflammatory and I know a reasonable chap like yourself would not like that to be the case, would you?


Who killed the teenagers? It was Palestinians. What constitutes Palestinians is a small community, is a tight community and is one where Hamas and Fatah have direct control over much of its population. Whomever killed these teens were either directly in one of the many 'resistance' groups' representing Palestinians or were not too far removed from them. The perpetrators would have to be congenital idiots not to know or foretell the consequences of their actions.

As for the second part, thank you for your condescending comments. However, isn't the point of a message to allow an exchange of thoughts? Or as they don't fit with your very narrow World view, they shouldn't be voiced at all? Is that what you are saying?


Matt, I am sorry to jump in on a good old ding-dong between you and our Caledonian friend, but this could rank as one of the siliest and most ill-informed posts I have read on this subject. That would include press releases by the Israeli Defence Force and opinions from the American Christian Right.

There are about 10 million Palestinians. About half live within Israel, mostly crammed into the West Bank and Gaza Strip. The other 5 million or so live in squalid settlement camps in neighbouring Arab countries, pretty much as second class citizens. Let us say that these are probably not places that most of them would like to live, many having been dispossessed of their homes by force by Israelis with many relatives being murdered in the process and within the lifetime of many.

So, which of those Palestinians do you think deserve to be bombed? The ones who committed the atrocity or just a reasonable selection of them? Israel prides itself as being an island of democracy in an otherwise oppressive region and to a large extent that is true - in the way they treat their own people. The way they deal with [admittedly] terrorist acts from Palestinians is very much in keeping with the worst acts of their Arab neighbours. I see no distinction. It is simply insupportable.

I genuinely do not follow you on this.

I said that the Palestinians know who did this. I maintain they could find out within hours, such is the control they have over their people. It is a similar situation to Belfast in the seventies. The resistance groups run the place. They could root out the perpetrators and hand them over if they wanted. I maintain that he perpetrators knew what they were doing, which was to stoke up tensions.

Then you go on to say who I want bombed. This is completely out of context with my post. I don't want any civilian population bombed and I haven't advocated this anywhere.

I fail to understand your comment that this is the 'silliest post' on the subject. You have not countered my comments, you have created arguments of your own from nowhere. I am happy to debate this subject but your position needs to cogent, which I don't believe it is.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

matt_himself Flag Matataland 07 Jul 14 4.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 10.34am

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 8.24am

The Israelis have arrested a number of suspects in relation to the horrific death of the Palestinian teenager:

[Link]

Now, will the Palestinians to do the right thing and identify the murderers of the Israeli teens?

I was under the impression that Hamas had denied responsibility?


Doing the right thing, in my opinion, is being the murderers to justice, meaning that the Palestinian Authority co-operates with the Israelis to do this.

I have not blamed Hamas. I have blamed Palestinians for the deaths of the three teenagers.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

ghosteagle Flag 07 Jul 14 4.57pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 4.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 10.34am

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 8.24am

The Israelis have arrested a number of suspects in relation to the horrific death of the Palestinian teenager:

[Link]

Now, will the Palestinians to do the right thing and identify the murderers of the Israeli teens?

I was under the impression that Hamas had denied responsibility?


Doing the right thing, in my opinion, is being the murderers to justice, meaning that the Palestinian Authority co-operates with the Israelis to do this.

I have not blamed Hamas. I have blamed Palestinians for the deaths of the three teenagers.

I accept that, if possible, the Palestininan Authority should try and aprehend the perpetrators but expecting them to work with the Israelis is short-sighted. Expecting them to work with the very same people who are bombing their homes and oppressing them is highly unlikely.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Jul 14 5.13pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 4.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 10.34am

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 8.24am

The Israelis have arrested a number of suspects in relation to the horrific death of the Palestinian teenager:

[Link]

Now, will the Palestinians to do the right thing and identify the murderers of the Israeli teens?

I was under the impression that Hamas had denied responsibility?


Doing the right thing, in my opinion, is being the murderers to justice, meaning that the Palestinian Authority co-operates with the Israelis to do this.

I have not blamed Hamas. I have blamed Palestinians for the deaths of the three teenagers.

Marwan Kawasmeh and Amar Abu-Isa, are the two individuals that the ISA (Israeli Security Authority) claim were responsible. Both the ISA and PA agree that they went missing the night of the abduction, and are at large. The PA has foiled 43 kidknapping plans against Israeli's (mostly IDF) since 2013 and the ISA around 60.

The ISA and PA work surprisingly closely to prevent kidknapping's. But the problem maybe that people see Hamas as a single group, rather than a series of interrelated factions and groups with a similar ideological basis.

Suspicion has also fallen on Salifist group within the Al-Qassam Brigades that was exiled from Hamas (in Hebron) for extremism maybe responsible. In recent years both the Palestinian Authority and ISA have had problems with the Al-Qassam Brigades, particularly in the West Bank where Hamas has a much lower degree of influence.

The Al-Qassam Brigades whilst a part of Hammas, operate independently of the Councils (Political Wing) and Welfare (Charitable wing).


Edited by jamiemartin721 (07 Jul 2014 5.18pm)

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

matt_himself Flag Matataland 07 Jul 14 5.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 4.57pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 4.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 10.34am

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 8.24am

The Israelis have arrested a number of suspects in relation to the horrific death of the Palestinian teenager:

[Link]

Now, will the Palestinians to do the right thing and identify the murderers of the Israeli teens?

I was under the impression that Hamas had denied responsibility?


Doing the right thing, in my opinion, is being the murderers to justice, meaning that the Palestinian Authority co-operates with the Israelis to do this.

I have not blamed Hamas. I have blamed Palestinians for the deaths of the three teenagers.

I accept that, if possible, the Palestininan Authority should try and aprehend the perpetrators but expecting them to work with the Israelis is short-sighted. Expecting them to work with the very same people who are bombing their homes and oppressing them is highly unlikely.


But surely an action like this, bringing the murderers of three innocent teenagers to justice in the Palestinian Authority's interest.

Should it be that Hamas was not responsible, it puts distance between the PA and the killers, plus it shows that the PA can act in a mature and dignified manner.

It would also give the Israelis no grounds for carrying out attacks.

It appears a win win. Why not do it if, as the PA has said, that it is not involved nor sanctioned the killings?

Edited by matt_himself (07 Jul 2014 5.37pm)

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

matt_himself Flag Matataland 07 Jul 14 5.39pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 5.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 4.57pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 4.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 10.34am

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 8.24am

The Israelis have arrested a number of suspects in relation to the horrific death of the Palestinian teenager:

[Link]

Now, will the Palestinians to do the right thing and identify the murderers of the Israeli teens?

I was under the impression that Hamas had denied responsibility?


Doing the right thing, in my opinion, is being the murderers to justice, meaning that the Palestinian Authority co-operates with the Israelis to do this.

I have not blamed Hamas. I have blamed Palestinians for the deaths of the three teenagers.

I accept that, if possible, the Palestininan Authority should try and aprehend the perpetrators but expecting them to work with the Israelis is short-sighted. Expecting them to work with the very same people who are bombing their homes and oppressing them is highly unlikely.


But surely an action like this, bringing the murderers of three innocent teenagers to justice in the Palestinian Authority's interest.

Should it be that Hamas was not responsible, it puts distance between the PA, Hamas and the killers, plus it shows that the PA can act in a mature and dignified manner.

It would also give the Israelis no grounds for carrying out attacks.

It appears a win win. Why not do it if, as the PA has said, that it is not involved nor sanctioned the killings?


 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

ghosteagle Flag 07 Jul 14 6.00pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 5.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 4.57pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 4.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 10.34am

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 8.24am

The Israelis have arrested a number of suspects in relation to the horrific death of the Palestinian teenager:

[Link]

Now, will the Palestinians to do the right thing and identify the murderers of the Israeli teens?

I was under the impression that Hamas had denied responsibility?


Doing the right thing, in my opinion, is being the murderers to justice, meaning that the Palestinian Authority co-operates with the Israelis to do this.

I have not blamed Hamas. I have blamed Palestinians for the deaths of the three teenagers.

I accept that, if possible, the Palestininan Authority should try and aprehend the perpetrators but expecting them to work with the Israelis is short-sighted. Expecting them to work with the very same people who are bombing their homes and oppressing them is highly unlikely.


But surely an action like this, bringing the murderers of three innocent teenagers to justice in the Palestinian Authority's interest.

Should it be that Hamas was not responsible, it puts distance between the PA and the killers, plus it shows that the PA can act in a mature and dignified manner.

It would also give the Israelis no grounds for carrying out attacks.

It appears a win win. Why not do it if, as the PA has said, that it is not involved nor sanctioned the killings?

Edited by matt_himself (07 Jul 2014 5.37pm)

Because working directly with the Israelis would be anathema to most Palestinians and would weaken support for the PA itself from within. It is also difficult to believe that any Palestinian that was handed over to the Israeli authorities would receive a fair trial or be treated in a humane way. I also fail to see how it would stop the Israeli attacks, they have never needed a reason to attack Gaza and the West Bank before and had already signaled their intention for collective punishment of the Palestinian people before collecting any evidence. Far from showing that the PA could act in a dignified manner it would demonstrate to the majority of Palestinians that the PA was being dictated to by the Israelis and could not stand up to them.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 07 Jul 14 7.43pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 5.39pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 5.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 4.57pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 4.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 10.34am

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 8.24am

The Israelis have arrested a number of suspects in relation to the horrific death of the Palestinian teenager:

[Link]

Now, will the Palestinians to do the right thing and identify the murderers of the Israeli teens?

I was under the impression that Hamas had denied responsibility?


Doing the right thing, in my opinion, is being the murderers to justice, meaning that the Palestinian Authority co-operates with the Israelis to do this.

I have not blamed Hamas. I have blamed Palestinians for the deaths of the three teenagers.

I accept that, if possible, the Palestininan Authority should try and aprehend the perpetrators but expecting them to work with the Israelis is short-sighted. Expecting them to work with the very same people who are bombing their homes and oppressing them is highly unlikely.


But surely an action like this, bringing the murderers of three innocent teenagers to justice in the Palestinian Authority's interest.

Should it be that Hamas was not responsible, it puts distance between the PA, Hamas and the killers, plus it shows that the PA can act in a mature and dignified manner.

It would also give the Israelis no grounds for carrying out attacks.

It appears a win win. Why not do it if, as the PA has said, that it is not involved nor sanctioned the killings?



I don't think it's that simple.
Oh if only those people living under an oppressive, maybe even apartheid cloud could be more civilised and just let those awfully nice people settle on there land, take their children in the night or ban the media whilst atrocities take place without making such an awful fuss then the Israel/Palestine problem would be over . Then we could all sit down together and have a nice cuppa.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 07 Jul 14 8.05pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 2.45pm

I think the rise of Hamas in popularity among Palestinians is testament to the oppression that they have suffered at the hands of Israel. Israel has never had any intention of allowing a Palestinian state, and given the violence that they have inflicted upon a poor and impoverished people while stealing their land it can come as no surprise that the people have come to believe that their only hope lies in people also prepared to use violence. What would make a difference is if the international community would hold Israel to account for its actions.



I'd agree to a certain extent that the rise of Hamas is due to oppression and fear. It's the same reason Israelis have been voting in the right into government....It's a basic human reaction.

However, oppression and fear are hardly new in this situation and what also saw the rise of Hamas was the failure of Fatah on corruption and the forever dire economy.....Of course all they did in reality was vote to make reality worse for themselves.

You say that Israel has never had any intention of allowing a Palestinian state. I think that's factually wrong actually. The 2000 Camp David Summit came very close to a two state solution with Jerusalem a shared capital......Clinton is pretty clear on how close this came....It wasn't Israel who pulled the plug but Arafat.

If that agreement had been signed both sides would have been fighting a civil war with extremists.....Arafat no doubt was far less confident of prevailing.

Israel is a democracy that contains many people who aren't anti two state at all. I think it's over emotional of you to characterize Israel as a purely negative entity.

Hamas however is against democracy (no elections since they took Gaza), anti western and committed to the deaths of all Jews. From my perspective you should be far harsher on them and more balanced on Israel.

Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Jul 2014 8.05pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

matt_himself Flag Matataland 07 Jul 14 8.05pm

Quote nickgusset at 07 Jul 2014 7.43pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 5.39pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 5.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 4.57pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 4.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 10.34am

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 8.24am

The Israelis have arrested a number of suspects in relation to the horrific death of the Palestinian teenager:

[Link]

Now, will the Palestinians to do the right thing and identify the murderers of the Israeli teens?

I was under the impression that Hamas had denied responsibility?


Doing the right thing, in my opinion, is being the murderers to justice, meaning that the Palestinian Authority co-operates with the Israelis to do this.

I have not blamed Hamas. I have blamed Palestinians for the deaths of the three teenagers.

I accept that, if possible, the Palestininan Authority should try and aprehend the perpetrators but expecting them to work with the Israelis is short-sighted. Expecting them to work with the very same people who are bombing their homes and oppressing them is highly unlikely.


But surely an action like this, bringing the murderers of three innocent teenagers to justice in the Palestinian Authority's interest.

Should it be that Hamas was not responsible, it puts distance between the PA, Hamas and the killers, plus it shows that the PA can act in a mature and dignified manner.

It would also give the Israelis no grounds for carrying out attacks.

It appears a win win. Why not do it if, as the PA has said, that it is not involved nor sanctioned the killings?



I don't think it's that simple.
Oh if only those people living under an oppressive, maybe even apartheid cloud could be more civilised and just let those awfully nice people settle on there land, take their children in the night or ban the media whilst atrocities take place without making such an awful fuss then the Israel/Palestine problem would be over . Then we could all sit down together and have a nice cuppa.


Have you ever heard of Mahatma Gandi? He was a bald chap and Indian freedom fighter.

He used different tactics to murder to achieve his aims and was successful.

My point being, sometimes, in order to progress a situation which is never ending circle of death, maybe it is time to consider different tactics.

In my mind, this situation is an excellent opportunity for the Palestinians to change the game and work with the Israelis to capture these murderers. They would have the moral high ground in the situation.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

matt_himself Flag Matataland 07 Jul 14 8.06pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 6.00pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 5.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 4.57pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 4.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 10.34am

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 8.24am

The Israelis have arrested a number of suspects in relation to the horrific death of the Palestinian teenager:

[Link]

Now, will the Palestinians to do the right thing and identify the murderers of the Israeli teens?

I was under the impression that Hamas had denied responsibility?


Doing the right thing, in my opinion, is being the murderers to justice, meaning that the Palestinian Authority co-operates with the Israelis to do this.

I have not blamed Hamas. I have blamed Palestinians for the deaths of the three teenagers.

I accept that, if possible, the Palestininan Authority should try and aprehend the perpetrators but expecting them to work with the Israelis is short-sighted. Expecting them to work with the very same people who are bombing their homes and oppressing them is highly unlikely.


But surely an action like this, bringing the murderers of three innocent teenagers to justice in the Palestinian Authority's interest.

Should it be that Hamas was not responsible, it puts distance between the PA and the killers, plus it shows that the PA can act in a mature and dignified manner.

It would also give the Israelis no grounds for carrying out attacks.

It appears a win win. Why not do it if, as the PA has said, that it is not involved nor sanctioned the killings?

Edited by matt_himself (07 Jul 2014 5.37pm)

Because working directly with the Israelis would be anathema to most Palestinians and would weaken support for the PA itself from within. It is also difficult to believe that any Palestinian that was handed over to the Israeli authorities would receive a fair trial or be treated in a humane way. I also fail to see how it would stop the Israeli attacks, they have never needed a reason to attack Gaza and the West Bank before and had already signaled their intention for collective punishment of the Palestinian people before collecting any evidence. Far from showing that the PA could act in a dignified manner it would demonstrate to the majority of Palestinians that the PA was being dictated to by the Israelis and could not stand up to them.

It appears we have different perspectives but I respect your views.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 07 Jul 14 8.36pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 8.05pm

Quote nickgusset at 07 Jul 2014 7.43pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 5.39pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 5.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 4.57pm

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 4.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 10.34am

Quote matt_himself at 07 Jul 2014 8.24am

The Israelis have arrested a number of suspects in relation to the horrific death of the Palestinian teenager:

[Link]

Now, will the Palestinians to do the right thing and identify the murderers of the Israeli teens?

I was under the impression that Hamas had denied responsibility?


Doing the right thing, in my opinion, is being the murderers to justice, meaning that the Palestinian Authority co-operates with the Israelis to do this.

I have not blamed Hamas. I have blamed Palestinians for the deaths of the three teenagers.

I accept that, if possible, the Palestininan Authority should try and aprehend the perpetrators but expecting them to work with the Israelis is short-sighted. Expecting them to work with the very same people who are bombing their homes and oppressing them is highly unlikely.


But surely an action like this, bringing the murderers of three innocent teenagers to justice in the Palestinian Authority's interest.

Should it be that Hamas was not responsible, it puts distance between the PA, Hamas and the killers, plus it shows that the PA can act in a mature and dignified manner.

It would also give the Israelis no grounds for carrying out attacks.

It appears a win win. Why not do it if, as the PA has said, that it is not involved nor sanctioned the killings?



I don't think it's that simple.
Oh if only those people living under an oppressive, maybe even apartheid cloud could be more civilised and just let those awfully nice people settle on there land, take their children in the night or ban the media whilst atrocities take place without making such an awful fuss then the Israel/Palestine problem would be over . Then we could all sit down together and have a nice cuppa.


Have you ever heard of Mahatma Gandi? He was a bald chap and Indian freedom fighter.

He used different tactics to murder to achieve his aims and was successful.

My point being, sometimes, in order to progress a situation which is never ending circle of death, maybe it is time to consider different tactics.

In my mind, this situation is an excellent opportunity for the Palestinians to change the game and work with the Israelis to capture these murderers. They would have the moral high ground in the situation.


It would be good if conciliatory talks were held. But until Israelis stop occupying Palestinian territories and the Palestinians stop launching crude missiles, it ain't going to happen.
Why, I ask, aren't others doing more to act as impartial concilliatories? (sic)

 

ghosteagle Flag 08 Jul 14 11.35am

Quote Stirlingsays at 07 Jul 2014 8.05pm

Quote ghosteagle at 07 Jul 2014 2.45pm

I think the rise of Hamas in popularity among Palestinians is testament to the oppression that they have suffered at the hands of Israel. Israel has never had any intention of allowing a Palestinian state, and given the violence that they have inflicted upon a poor and impoverished people while stealing their land it can come as no surprise that the people have come to believe that their only hope lies in people also prepared to use violence. What would make a difference is if the international community would hold Israel to account for its actions.



I'd agree to a certain extent that the rise of Hamas is due to oppression and fear. It's the same reason Israelis have been voting in the right into government....It's a basic human reaction.

However, oppression and fear are hardly new in this situation and what also saw the rise of Hamas was the failure of Fatah on corruption and the forever dire economy.....Of course all they did in reality was vote to make reality worse for themselves.

You say that Israel has never had any intention of allowing a Palestinian state. I think that's factually wrong actually. The 2000 Camp David Summit came very close to a two state solution with Jerusalem a shared capital......Clinton is pretty clear on how close this came....It wasn't Israel who pulled the plug but Arafat.

If that agreement had been signed both sides would have been fighting a civil war with extremists.....Arafat no doubt was far less confident of prevailing.

Israel is a democracy that contains many people who aren't anti two state at all. I think it's over emotional of you to characterize Israel as a purely negative entity.

Hamas however is against democracy (no elections since they took Gaza), anti western and committed to the deaths of all Jews. From my perspective you should be far harsher on them and more balanced on Israel.

Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Jul 2014 8.05pm)

A common misunderstanding of the Camp David Accords and the reason for the summits failure. The deal presented would have left the Palestinian state split into three cantons with the vast majority of the water sources held within the borders of Israel. Such an agreement would have offered neither economic viability nor the minimal requirements for a politically independent state. Clinton, the supposed 'mediator', allied himself with the Israelis and tried to force Arafat to accept an agreement which the Israelis knew from the outset would be unacceptable to the majority of Palestinians. Clinton was more concerned with posterity then any real concern for the plight of Palestine.
I would also have to disagree that Israel is a democracy. While the people can vote, Israeli Muslims are second class citizens with no political representation and are sidelined in housing, education and employment.
Of course, Hamas is no friend of democracy but a people under daily attack from an aggressive, invading army are hardly likely to worry about the niceties of political processes.


 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 08 Jul 14 1.15pm

Quote Kingvagabond at 06 Jul 2014 9.03pm

Quote matt_himself at 06 Jul 2014 8.03pm

So this latest episode was started by the peace loving and gentle Palestinians kidnapping and murdering three Israeli teens which the perpetrators knew would draw a response from the IDF and the more militant parts of Israeli society.

Quite how some people can defend these people is beyond me.

I'm not really sure either side can be defended Matt. After the war ourselves and the Yanks decided to make an idiotic move and helped force a Jewish state in Israel. The irony is that prior to this Jews and Muslims had been living in relative harmony. We caused what has been 60+ years of hatred and war. As it is the Israelis pay for settlers to move to the Palestinian part of the West Bank, the Palestinians murder these 'invaders' the Israelis then use their American funded arsenal of weapons to smash the Palestinians. In turn the Palestinians fire rockets at border towns. The Palestinians murder Israeli teens and blow up busses, the Israelis assassinate political figures and use airstrikes to kill innocents. Unfortunately that is the Middle East situation. Both sides are filled with both innocents and horrible butchering people.

Stirling, personally I get what you are saying but each day there is no conflict is another day diplomatic means can be sought.

The roots of this go back a lot longer than 60 years KV...

Balfour, the British mandate to support a Zionist state and carve the region up, the appointment of a Jewish MP, Samuel to administer the region and find a 'solution' (which was surprisingly Jew biased to such an extent it was embarrassing), the British support and boosting of teh self serving and self proclaimed leader Al Husieni to represent the whole of Palestine before betraying him and sending him into the arms of Adolf - all of that

Its not the only reason for what happens today but the seeds of the hatred in the region fall squarely on the shoulders of the British upper political classes in the early 20th century


Edited by The Sash (08 Jul 2014 1.16pm)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Stirlingsays Flag 08 Jul 14 5.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 08 Jul 2014 11.35am

A common misunderstanding of the Camp David Accords and the reason for the summits failure. The deal presented would have left the Palestinian state split into three cantons with the vast majority of the water sources held within the borders of Israel. Such an agreement would have offered neither economic viability nor the minimal requirements for a politically independent state. Clinton, the supposed 'mediator', allied himself with the Israelis and tried to force Arafat to accept an agreement which the Israelis knew from the outset would be unacceptable to the majority of Palestinians. Clinton was more concerned with posterity then any real concern for the plight of Palestine.
I would also have to disagree that Israel is a democracy. While the people can vote, Israeli Muslims are second class citizens with no political representation and are sidelined in housing, education and employment.
Of course, Hamas is no friend of democracy but a people under daily attack from an aggressive, invading army are hardly likely to worry about the niceties of political processes.


Interesting.....Can I have evidence for your first two points.....The camp David information would be most interesting.

As of your excuse for Hamas that things are all too aggressive with Israel for an election.....That's complete rot and you shouldn't offer it forward..

Hamas have to take their side of the blame for the situation in Gaza. Even if what you say were true there are numerous occasions even in recent history where countries have held elections under duress......I don't remember the election that Hamas won being a particularly peaceful time either.

Anti democratic
Anti western
Anti semitic
Anti peace

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ghosteagle Flag 08 Jul 14 5.53pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Jul 2014 5.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 08 Jul 2014 11.35am

A common misunderstanding of the Camp David Accords and the reason for the summits failure. The deal presented would have left the Palestinian state split into three cantons with the vast majority of the water sources held within the borders of Israel. Such an agreement would have offered neither economic viability nor the minimal requirements for a politically independent state. Clinton, the supposed 'mediator', allied himself with the Israelis and tried to force Arafat to accept an agreement which the Israelis knew from the outset would be unacceptable to the majority of Palestinians. Clinton was more concerned with posterity then any real concern for the plight of Palestine.
I would also have to disagree that Israel is a democracy. While the people can vote, Israeli Muslims are second class citizens with no political representation and are sidelined in housing, education and employment.
Of course, Hamas is no friend of democracy but a people under daily attack from an aggressive, invading army are hardly likely to worry about the niceties of political processes.


Interesting.....Can I have evidence for your first two points.....The camp David information would be most interesting.

As of your excuse for Hamas that things are all too aggressive with Israel for an election.....That's complete rot and you shouldn't offer it forward..

Hamas have to take their side of the blame for the situation in Gaza. Even if what you say were true there are numerous occasions even in recent history where countries have held elections under duress......I don't remember the election that Hamas won being a particularly peaceful time either.

Anti democratic
Anti western
Anti semitic
Anti peace

The evidence is all over the internet and I’m sure you could find it with a little investigating. It's all common knowledge among commentators taking an objective view.
Yes, Hamas could set up an election in theory but my point is not that they cannot physically do so but that the constant Israeli attack means that they have a ready made excuse why they are not permitting elections which the Palestinian people will buy. Also, it must be noted that Hamas won an election, they did not simply take power, which means that in the eyes of the people they are a legitimate part of government.
It is certainly true that elections are often held under duress. Those would be the elections such as the one in Syria or in the east of Ukraine which the West then complains are tainted.
The four anti's, that I assume you are labelling Hamas with, are all true, although i think they would argue that 'no peace' is in fact 'no surrender' and the 'anti western' is born out of the wests indifference to the plight of Palestine. Israel could easily be labelled with anti-democratic and anti-peace. It is also anti-Arab, the fact that the two sides have become so diametrically opposed over the years is clearly something that goes back generations......

 

Stirlingsays Flag 08 Jul 14 6.05pm

Quote ghosteagle at 08 Jul 2014 5.53pm

The evidence is all over the internet and I’m sure you could find it with a little investigating. It's all common knowledge among commentators taking an objective view.
Yes, Hamas could set up an election in theory but my point is not that they cannot physically do so but that the constant Israeli attack means that they have a ready made excuse why they are not permitting elections which the Palestinian people will buy. Also, it must be noted that Hamas won an election, they did not simply take power, which means that in the eyes of the people they are a legitimate part of government.
It is certainly true that elections are often held under duress. Those would be the elections such as the one in Syria or in the east of Ukraine which the West then complains are tainted.
The four anti's, that I assume you are labelling Hamas with, are all true, although i think they would argue that 'no peace' is in fact 'no surrender' and the 'anti western' is born out of the wests indifference to the plight of Palestine. Israel could easily be labelled with anti-democratic and anti-peace. It is also anti-Arab, the fact that the two sides have become so diametrically opposed over the years is clearly something that goes back generations......


You make these statements and claim they are objective yet provide no way for me to check their truth or validity......Why do I have to do the searching when it's you who make the claim?

You ask me to believe that Clinton is lying over the Camp David situation.....Mmmmmm. I ask the question why are you so willing to believe that Clinton is lying and instead believe..Whoever you got this information from?.....Both sides are capable of lying....We need evidence.

I seek objectivity on this.

Israel isn't anti Arab....Well not as far as I'm aware. Many Arabs live and importantly choose to live and work within its borders.

I know they have concerns about being out breed by Israeli Arabs but I haven't seen evidence of prosecution of Arabs in Israel.....It's a country with a justice system which should prevent that.

Again I'm willing to change my opinion if there are objective sources to prove otherwise.

Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Jul 2014 6.06pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ghosteagle Flag 08 Jul 14 6.18pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Jul 2014 6.05pm

Quote ghosteagle at 08 Jul 2014 5.53pm

The evidence is all over the internet and I’m sure you could find it with a little investigating. It's all common knowledge among commentators taking an objective view.
Yes, Hamas could set up an election in theory but my point is not that they cannot physically do so but that the constant Israeli attack means that they have a ready made excuse why they are not permitting elections which the Palestinian people will buy. Also, it must be noted that Hamas won an election, they did not simply take power, which means that in the eyes of the people they are a legitimate part of government.
It is certainly true that elections are often held under duress. Those would be the elections such as the one in Syria or in the east of Ukraine which the West then complains are tainted.
The four anti's, that I assume you are labelling Hamas with, are all true, although i think they would argue that 'no peace' is in fact 'no surrender' and the 'anti western' is born out of the wests indifference to the plight of Palestine. Israel could easily be labelled with anti-democratic and anti-peace. It is also anti-Arab, the fact that the two sides have become so diametrically opposed over the years is clearly something that goes back generations......


You make these statements and claim they are objective yet provide no way for me to check their truth or validity......Why do I have to do the searching when it's you who make the claim?

You ask me to believe that Clinton is lying over the Camp David situation.....Mmmmmm. I ask the question why are you so willing to believe that Clinton is lying and not...Whoever you got this information from?

I seek objectivity on this.

Israel isn't anti Arab....Well not as far as I'm aware. Many Arabs live and importantly choose to live and work within its borders.

I know they have concerns about being out breed by Israeli Arabs but I haven't seen evidence of prosecution of Arabs in Israel.....It's a country with a justice system which should prevent that.

Again I'm willing to change my opinion if there are objective sources to prove otherwise.

As I said, all the information you seek can be found easily on the internet with a simple search. Although I enjoy a intellectual discussion on this most complex of issues I’m not going to spend my time providing sources for everything I say, I would hope that if you are interested in the things I’m showing you that it would lead you to do further investigations.
I don't understand your suspicions over the claim that Clinton has lied about his part in this, he was an American president and has a long history of lying about just about anything and everything.
I accept that many Arabs have to work and live in Israel for economic reasons, but this doesn't exclude Israel from being a racist society where any non-Jews are excluded from the political process and Arabs are regularly persecuted by the justice system. The justice system, far from preventing such injustice, is set up to perpetuate the discrimination.

 

Page 12 of 80 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine