Quote twist at 15 Jul 2015 9.08pm
Quote kenbarr at 14 Jul 2015 11.01pm
Quote twist at 14 Jul 2015 9.09pm
Stop with calling the confederate flag racist. Do your research. Its not even the official flag of the confederate states. Its the West Virginia battle flag. It was incorporated into later Confederate flags, but not alone.
The ONLY reason its considered racist is because the KKK picked it up in the 50's and used it as their flag. Oh, the confederacy supported slavery therefore they were racist ? Hello, Britain was big into slavery at one point, as was most of Europe. It was not until 1833 that Britain abolished slavery, and even then they allowed the East India trading company to continue it for another 10 years.
If the KKK picked up the union jack tomorrow and started calling it their official flag, does that mean we are all racists Brits for flying the Jack ?
What about the Swastika ? For thousands of years was a symbol of auspiciousness, yet taken up by the Nazi's and now its an evil symbol ?
I dont believe states should be flying the flag on their property, but i do believe in the rights of citizens to fly it.
The swastika is an ancient religious symbol that appears in a great many cultures, including First Nations/Native American. The symbol used by the Nazis is a mirror image of the swastika and is called in German the hakenkreutz, or hooked cross. It is not the traditional swastika and should not be confused with it. There was a small town in Colorado named Swastika Falls that some groups wanted to have renamed, The residents quite rightly pointed out that the name had nothing to do with Nazis and Nazism b ut dated back to the First Nations people who originally lived there. As far as racism in the United States, I and others have freely acknowledged this, If you take a look back at my posts I refer to racism as the original sin of the United States. The fact that we Americans have as a nation become sensitive to racist symbols such as the Confederate war flag and the Washington NFL team's offensive nickname should be viewed as progress towards as a more sensitive and caring society. I lived through the 1960s and they were definitely not the nostalgic era they are being made out to be. There were many rough times as we struggled with how we as a nation dealt with each other, never mind the world at large.
The Nazi version is not a mirror image, turned 45 degrees maybe, but not mirror image.
As to becoming more sensitive, we are now over sensitive, wanting to at least appear as PC as we can possibly be. Just ask Sir Tim Hunt, how oversensitive we have become.
I'll take your point as a quibble depending on which version of the hakenkreutz you are talking about, the angled versus the block. It is supposed to represent the letters NS, for "National Socialiste" Deutsche Arbeiters Partei. See Shirer, "The Rise and Fall of The Third Reich" Simon and Schuster 1960.
As far as sensitivity is concerned, the histories of the US & UK countries are quite different when it comes to racism. The United States has a rather violent history in this area, with everything from a policy of manifest destiny forcing indigenous people from their lands and the forced appropriation of land from other peoples and nations to enslavement, government sanctioned murders and terrorism inflicted upon a group of people for no other reason but their appearance. This nation's history is abysmal in this area and needs to be dealt with in a civilized and sensitive manner. Maybe you haven't experienced this but both my ancestors in Germany and my family in the US have. We have seen law enforcement inflict violence on people peaceably assembling for the purpose of petitioning their government for redress of grievances, a Constitutionally guaranteed right. I have personally seen the despair and desolation of the reservation and segregated communities where separate is definitely unequal and in many cases suffering violent discrimination.
This is my last post on this thread. I have said all I am going to say. Unlike a different post, which is far less important in the general scheme of things, I will click the unsubscribe button. The issues being discussed here are very personal to me and I wish to maintain my good standing and decorum on HOL.
Divorced...And LOVING it! VJRAM Rev. CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach Trevor Francis, International PRAT
|