You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > isis
November 22 2026 2.13am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

isis


Page 12 of 51 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Aug 14 9.07am

Quote redandblue4life at 22 Aug 2014 8.52am

It's time we acted we should be there helping destroy these evil basterds killing innocent women and children every day ! Get into them and f*** em up I say !

i am inclined to agree, politically though i can't see it happening. It would likely cost the conservatives the next election, and without US troop numbers its high risk, ISIS will switch to guerrilla warfare tactics and militarily we lack sufficent troops to pacify the area sufficiently to prevent them operating. Reliance on the Iraqi army to do that is questionable. Probably the best. The insurgent groups in that area will be happy to just hit targets and rack up casulties untill its politically untenable to stay there.

the best we can do is provide assistance to the Iraqi military provide air support and special ops support

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Aug 14 9.16am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 22 Aug 2014 8.47am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 21 Aug 2014 6.33pm

Quote legaleagle at 20 Aug 2014 7.52pm

Quote ASCPFC at 20 Aug 2014 5.09pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 20 Aug 2014 4.57pm

Quote ASCPFC at 20 Aug 2014 4.46pm

I'm surprised by all the calls to wipe them out. I would ask exactly who would you wipe out? People in these situations, when confronted by a force with overwhelming firepower, simply fade away and are driven underground. They begin using guerilla tactics and organising and funding themselves as an Islamic terrorist organisation. Before you know it the problem has spread worldwide to every city/airport/train station/school/university - you get the picture.
My suggestion would be to combine a hard response with a deal of some kind. Maybe there could be some legitimate Muslim state run by ISIS where people could go and choose to live under Sharia law etc. if they so wished? Part of the deal could be to hand over anyone proven guilty of atrocities to be tried under international law at the Hague, or some such thing; rather than renditioning. The hard part would be getting them to talk which is why I would first assemble a huge force so they would know we mean business.


using your logic though a huge force would be pointless as we wouldnt be able to do anything anyway.

Where would you put this state? What country should give up their teritory to house these animals? Maybe somewhere with international jurisdiction like the Antartic?

Yes a lot of these people would melt away but as with Pol Pot (to a degree), once the fear of them is removed, the people will rise against anyone who tries to disappear.

You cannot be rational with these people. That is why we are always destined to lose unless we do something more drastic.


Not really, a huge force would be necessary to get them to the negotiating table. Why else would they bother? They are pretty much doing what they want at present bar the odd air-strike. As for where would the state be, the obvious answer is more-or-less where it is already. I don't really like the idea of some radical Islamic state but if so many people seem to be attracted to it then who are we to stop them? Inevitably there will just be an escalation of the conflict until some solution is found.
The doing something more drastic would be something akin to the US in Vietnam, the UN in Korea or everyone in Afghanistan. It would pretty likely never end and cause perhaps millions of casualties. This is not a conventonal force like the Iraqi army in Desert Storm. These are committed, well funded and highly manouverable forces who can quite easily disappear when needed. Dare I say it, I really wouldn't like to see the outcome of a massive US intervention. I say protect the borders of what they already have so they can't expand, step up airstrikes and pressure and then see what the diplomats can come up with when the heat dies down a bit.


Edited by ASCPFC (20 Aug 2014 5.10pm)

The major difference with Vietnam,Afghanistan,Korea etc is that they were essentially national liberation movements.Here,the underlying ideology is not nationalist but a multinational religious one.So,whether any binding "deal"could be cut (if one gets over whether that's a good idea or not) is,in my view,unlikely. The mere fact of "diplomatic" semi-recognition would give the underlying ideology incredible legitimacy (and support) all over the place...

In terms of "sealing off" the territory they already have,do we just,as a part,leave any shia, christians,apostates still located there etc to their grisly fate?

ISIS are more or less a 'national liberation movement', albeit one about the establishment of a Muslim Caliphate, their focus is primarily on the region of the Sunni North of Iraq and Eastern Syria.
Which is a real problem, because they have a long term goal and achievable strategy, where as Al-Queda were purely 'terrorists' striking at the West, ISIS could quite conceivably establish themselves. They're also a lot more attractive to jyhadists for that reason - as they're representing something real to fight for.

Their successes are also appealing to a number of less Islamic militants, such as Baathists and more nationalist insurgents in that Iraqi region, as they have a realistic hope of success. Especially with the prospect of Shia militants

Those insurgents are fairly well established, know the area very well.



I am sorry Jamie but that is a load of bollocks. They want more than an islamic state. That is just the start, anyone who believes differently quite frankly is living in cloud cuckoo land. If they are allowed to establish a calihate it will be little more than an extremely large terrorist camp. Think Afghanistan x 100

ISIS aren't really a terrorist group, not primarily. They use terror certainly and the tactics, but they are focused on real world gains and establishing territory and holding it. As such theyre much more a threat to the area, and much more attractive to radicalised young Muslims than al-qaeda and its spectacle driven suicide attacks ever were. Isis are a real threat in that they're also successful. That. Means they're attracting recruits and sponsors.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Ouzo Dan Flag Behind you 22 Aug 14 9.36am

The IS have eyes on Turkey, they wont stop until everyone obeys their version of Islam.

Thank f*** Saddam actually did as he was told and disposed of those chemical weapons.
Can you imagine if IS had some of that at its disposal?

Edited by Ouzo Dan (22 Aug 2014 9.39am)

 


The mountains are calling & I must go.

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 22 Aug 14 10.13am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Aug 2014 9.16am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 22 Aug 2014 8.47am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 21 Aug 2014 6.33pm

Quote legaleagle at 20 Aug 2014 7.52pm

Quote ASCPFC at 20 Aug 2014 5.09pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 20 Aug 2014 4.57pm

Quote ASCPFC at 20 Aug 2014 4.46pm

I'm surprised by all the calls to wipe them out. I would ask exactly who would you wipe out? People in these situations, when confronted by a force with overwhelming firepower, simply fade away and are driven underground. They begin using guerilla tactics and organising and funding themselves as an Islamic terrorist organisation. Before you know it the problem has spread worldwide to every city/airport/train station/school/university - you get the picture.
My suggestion would be to combine a hard response with a deal of some kind. Maybe there could be some legitimate Muslim state run by ISIS where people could go and choose to live under Sharia law etc. if they so wished? Part of the deal could be to hand over anyone proven guilty of atrocities to be tried under international law at the Hague, or some such thing; rather than renditioning. The hard part would be getting them to talk which is why I would first assemble a huge force so they would know we mean business.


using your logic though a huge force would be pointless as we wouldnt be able to do anything anyway.

Where would you put this state? What country should give up their teritory to house these animals? Maybe somewhere with international jurisdiction like the Antartic?

Yes a lot of these people would melt away but as with Pol Pot (to a degree), once the fear of them is removed, the people will rise against anyone who tries to disappear.

You cannot be rational with these people. That is why we are always destined to lose unless we do something more drastic.


Not really, a huge force would be necessary to get them to the negotiating table. Why else would they bother? They are pretty much doing what they want at present bar the odd air-strike. As for where would the state be, the obvious answer is more-or-less where it is already. I don't really like the idea of some radical Islamic state but if so many people seem to be attracted to it then who are we to stop them? Inevitably there will just be an escalation of the conflict until some solution is found.
The doing something more drastic would be something akin to the US in Vietnam, the UN in Korea or everyone in Afghanistan. It would pretty likely never end and cause perhaps millions of casualties. This is not a conventonal force like the Iraqi army in Desert Storm. These are committed, well funded and highly manouverable forces who can quite easily disappear when needed. Dare I say it, I really wouldn't like to see the outcome of a massive US intervention. I say protect the borders of what they already have so they can't expand, step up airstrikes and pressure and then see what the diplomats can come up with when the heat dies down a bit.


Edited by ASCPFC (20 Aug 2014 5.10pm)

The major difference with Vietnam,Afghanistan,Korea etc is that they were essentially national liberation movements.Here,the underlying ideology is not nationalist but a multinational religious one.So,whether any binding "deal"could be cut (if one gets over whether that's a good idea or not) is,in my view,unlikely. The mere fact of "diplomatic" semi-recognition would give the underlying ideology incredible legitimacy (and support) all over the place...

In terms of "sealing off" the territory they already have,do we just,as a part,leave any shia, christians,apostates still located there etc to their grisly fate?

ISIS are more or less a 'national liberation movement', albeit one about the establishment of a Muslim Caliphate, their focus is primarily on the region of the Sunni North of Iraq and Eastern Syria.
Which is a real problem, because they have a long term goal and achievable strategy, where as Al-Queda were purely 'terrorists' striking at the West, ISIS could quite conceivably establish themselves. They're also a lot more attractive to jyhadists for that reason - as they're representing something real to fight for.

Their successes are also appealing to a number of less Islamic militants, such as Baathists and more nationalist insurgents in that Iraqi region, as they have a realistic hope of success. Especially with the prospect of Shia militants

Those insurgents are fairly well established, know the area very well.



I am sorry Jamie but that is a load of bollocks. They want more than an islamic state. That is just the start, anyone who believes differently quite frankly is living in cloud cuckoo land. If they are allowed to establish a calihate it will be little more than an extremely large terrorist camp. Think Afghanistan x 100

ISIS aren't really a terrorist group, not primarily. They use terror certainly and the tactics, but they are focused on real world gains and establishing territory and holding it. As such theyre much more a threat to the area, and much more attractive to radicalised young Muslims than al-qaeda and its spectacle driven suicide attacks ever were. Isis are a real threat in that they're also successful. That. Means they're attracting recruits and sponsors.


That's only their short term goal. Their long term aim is much more far reaching. Power & religious extremism is a dangerous cocktail.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Aug 14 10.15am

Quote Ouzo Dan at 22 Aug 2014 9.36am

The IS have eyes on Turkey, they wont stop until everyone obeys their version of Islam.

Thank f*** Saddam actually did as he was told and disposed of those chemical weapons.
Can you imagine if IS had some of that at its disposal?

Edited by Ouzo Dan (22 Aug 2014 9.39am)

indeed, though if he had remained in power i doubt Isis would exist. Iraq would have acted to prevent Syrian rebel supply from Iraq, as that part of Iraq was his powerbase. The Sunni Iraq insurgency was piviotal in the Syrian rebel forces logistics

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Ouzo Dan Flag Behind you 22 Aug 14 2.50pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Aug 2014 10.15am

Quote Ouzo Dan at 22 Aug 2014 9.36am

The IS have eyes on Turkey, they wont stop until everyone obeys their version of Islam.

Thank f*** Saddam actually did as he was told and disposed of those chemical weapons.
Can you imagine if IS had some of that at its disposal?

Edited by Ouzo Dan (22 Aug 2014 9.39am)

indeed, though if he had remained in power i doubt Isis would exist. Iraq would have acted to prevent Syrian rebel supply from Iraq, as that part of Iraq was his powerbase. The Sunni Iraq insurgency was piviotal in the Syrian rebel forces logistics

Agreed Jamie, The power vacuum that has been left by George's coalition of the willing is what is responsible for all this mess.

It doesnt help that we are arming IS in Syria yet bombing them in Iraq....

 


The mountains are calling & I must go.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Aug 14 3.33pm

Quote Ouzo Dan at 22 Aug 2014 2.50pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Aug 2014 10.15am

Quote Ouzo Dan at 22 Aug 2014 9.36am

The IS have eyes on Turkey, they wont stop until everyone obeys their version of Islam.

Thank f*** Saddam actually did as he was told and disposed of those chemical weapons.
Can you imagine if IS had some of that at its disposal?

Edited by Ouzo Dan (22 Aug 2014 9.39am)

indeed, though if he had remained in power i doubt Isis would exist. Iraq would have acted to prevent Syrian rebel supply from Iraq, as that part of Iraq was his powerbase. The Sunni Iraq insurgency was piviotal in the Syrian rebel forces logistics

Agreed Jamie, The power vacuum that has been left by George's coalition of the willing is what is responsible for all this mess.

It doesnt help that we are arming IS in Syria yet bombing them in Iraq....

That does help our arms sales though - in several ways.

 


Red and Blue Army!

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Aug 14 6.28pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 22 Aug 2014 10.13am

That's only their short term goal. Their long term aim is much more far reaching. Power & religious extremism is a dangerous cocktail.

It'll take them a good ten years to secure, of course they're likely to then look at the rest of Iraq. I can't see them going for Turkey and provoking NATO, but Kuwait, Jordon etc would probably be next (although if they went for the rest of Iraqi, Iran would be dragged into it). Saudi, are probably too powerful for ISIS (and ideologically on similar pages) and I doubt they have the capacity to take on Iran.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Aug 14 6.29pm

Quote ASCPFC at 22 Aug 2014 3.33pm

Quote Ouzo Dan at 22 Aug 2014 2.50pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Aug 2014 10.15am

Quote Ouzo Dan at 22 Aug 2014 9.36am

The IS have eyes on Turkey, they wont stop until everyone obeys their version of Islam.

Thank f*** Saddam actually did as he was told and disposed of those chemical weapons.
Can you imagine if IS had some of that at its disposal?

Edited by Ouzo Dan (22 Aug 2014 9.39am)

indeed, though if he had remained in power i doubt Isis would exist. Iraq would have acted to prevent Syrian rebel supply from Iraq, as that part of Iraq was his powerbase. The Sunni Iraq insurgency was piviotal in the Syrian rebel forces logistics

Agreed Jamie, The power vacuum that has been left by George's coalition of the willing is what is responsible for all this mess.

It doesnt help that we are arming IS in Syria yet bombing them in Iraq....

That does help our arms sales though - in several ways.

Technically we're arming Rebel groups in Syria involved in the main uprising, rather than ISIS. I don't doubt some of the weapons end up in ISIS hands though, probably in exchange for fuel.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 22 Aug 14 8.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Aug 2014 6.28pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 22 Aug 2014 10.13am

That's only their short term goal. Their long term aim is much more far reaching. Power & religious extremism is a dangerous cocktail.

It'll take them a good ten years to secure, of course they're likely to then look at the rest of Iraq. I can't see them going for Turkey and provoking NATO, but Kuwait, Jordon etc would probably be next (although if they went for the rest of Iraqi, Iran would be dragged into it). Saudi, are probably too powerful for ISIS (and ideologically on similar pages) and I doubt they have the capacity to take on Iran.


It doesn't have to be secure, certainly not in the same context as a country. Sme on here already saying that we should let them set up a state. Almost immediately they would look at expanding their reach. I wouldn't be surprised that instead of moving south as expected they moved west or at least a feint towards Israel to get the west and the rest if the Muslim world involved.

They are no mugs

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Aug 14 8.31pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 22 Aug 2014 8.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Aug 2014 6.28pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 22 Aug 2014 10.13am

That's only their short term goal. Their long term aim is much more far reaching. Power & religious extremism is a dangerous cocktail.

It'll take them a good ten years to secure, of course they're likely to then look at the rest of Iraq. I can't see them going for Turkey and provoking NATO, but Kuwait, Jordon etc would probably be next (although if they went for the rest of Iraqi, Iran would be dragged into it). Saudi, are probably too powerful for ISIS (and ideologically on similar pages) and I doubt they have the capacity to take on Iran.


It doesn't have to be secure, certainly not in the same context as a country. Sme on here already saying that we should let them set up a state. Almost immediately they would look at expanding their reach. I wouldn't be surprised that instead of moving south as expected they moved west or at least a feint towards Israel to get the west and the rest if the Muslim world involved.

They are no mugs

If they are no mugs then it is doubtful they would attack Isreal. Been tried by a combination of just about all of the arab neighbouring states with much larger armies than Isreal had - and probably about 100 times greater force than ISIS has - yet failed miserably, lasting only a few days.
People seem to think the whole Muslim world is behind ISIS but it really is only a faction of Islam that is involved and there are at least two other maijor factions in Islamic religion and a lot of minor ones.
It's a bit like Christianity where we have Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox. Even within all of those there are hundreds of different sects etc. ISIS is basically for one particualr group of Muslims. It's a bit like the religious wars of the 16th century - where Roman Catholic Spain tried to eliminate good old Protestant blightly and all that jazz.

Edited by ASCPFC (22 Aug 2014 8.32pm)

 


Red and Blue Army!

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 22 Aug 14 8.37pm

Quote ASCPFC at 22 Aug 2014 8.31pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 22 Aug 2014 8.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Aug 2014 6.28pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 22 Aug 2014 10.13am

That's only their short term goal. Their long term aim is much more far reaching. Power & religious extremism is a dangerous cocktail.

It'll take them a good ten years to secure, of course they're likely to then look at the rest of Iraq. I can't see them going for Turkey and provoking NATO, but Kuwait, Jordon etc would probably be next (although if they went for the rest of Iraqi, Iran would be dragged into it). Saudi, are probably too powerful for ISIS (and ideologically on similar pages) and I doubt they have the capacity to take on Iran.


It doesn't have to be secure, certainly not in the same context as a country. Sme on here already saying that we should let them set up a state. Almost immediately they would look at expanding their reach. I wouldn't be surprised that instead of moving south as expected they moved west or at least a feint towards Israel to get the west and the rest if the Muslim world involved.

They are no mugs

If they are no mugs then it is doubtful they would attack Isreal. Been tried by a combination of just about all of the arab neighbouring states with much larger armies than Isreal had - and probably about 100 times greater force than ISIS has - yet failed miserably, lasting only a few days.
People seem to think the whole Muslim world is behind ISIS but it really is only a faction of Islam that is involved and there are at least two other maijor factions in Islamic religion and a lot of minor ones.
It's a bit like Christianity where we have Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox. Even within all of those there are hundreds of different sects etc. ISIS is basically for one particualr group of Muslims. It's a bit like the religious wars of the 16th century - where Roman Catholic Spain tried to eliminate good old Protestant blightly and all that jazz.

Edited by ASCPFC (22 Aug 2014 8.32pm)


I don't think for one moment that the Muslim world is behind them. In fact it's quite the opposite, however by involving Israel by attack or threat, Hamas will feel emboldened and the whole thing will escalate.

I am not saying that they WILL do that but it is feasible. We should be looking at destroying their strongholds which are primarily in Syria and will weaken them significantly and allow Syrian soldiers & rebels as well as Iraqi and Kurdish troops to fight on the ground.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Aug 14 8.45pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 22 Aug 2014 8.37pm

Quote ASCPFC at 22 Aug 2014 8.31pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 22 Aug 2014 8.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Aug 2014 6.28pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 22 Aug 2014 10.13am

That's only their short term goal. Their long term aim is much more far reaching. Power & religious extremism is a dangerous cocktail.

It'll take them a good ten years to secure, of course they're likely to then look at the rest of Iraq. I can't see them going for Turkey and provoking NATO, but Kuwait, Jordon etc would probably be next (although if they went for the rest of Iraqi, Iran would be dragged into it). Saudi, are probably too powerful for ISIS (and ideologically on similar pages) and I doubt they have the capacity to take on Iran.


It doesn't have to be secure, certainly not in the same context as a country. Sme on here already saying that we should let them set up a state. Almost immediately they would look at expanding their reach. I wouldn't be surprised that instead of moving south as expected they moved west or at least a feint towards Israel to get the west and the rest if the Muslim world involved.

They are no mugs

If they are no mugs then it is doubtful they would attack Isreal. Been tried by a combination of just about all of the arab neighbouring states with much larger armies than Isreal had - and probably about 100 times greater force than ISIS has - yet failed miserably, lasting only a few days.
People seem to think the whole Muslim world is behind ISIS but it really is only a faction of Islam that is involved and there are at least two other maijor factions in Islamic religion and a lot of minor ones.
It's a bit like Christianity where we have Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox. Even within all of those there are hundreds of different sects etc. ISIS is basically for one particualr group of Muslims. It's a bit like the religious wars of the 16th century - where Roman Catholic Spain tried to eliminate good old Protestant blightly and all that jazz.

Edited by ASCPFC (22 Aug 2014 8.32pm)


I don't think for one moment that the Muslim world is behind them. In fact it's quite the opposite, however by involving Israel by attack or threat, Hamas will feel emboldened and the whole thing will escalate.

I am not saying that they WILL do that but it is feasible. We should be looking at destroying their strongholds which are primarily in Syria and will weaken them significantly and allow Syrian soldiers & rebels as well as Iraqi and Kurdish troops to fight on the ground.

I'm really not sure on the religion and politics of HAMAS but I do get the feeling that they are not of the same background as ISIS at all. I could be entirely wrong though, just a feeling. HAMAS are only really anti-Isreal due to a perceived wrong, they are not Islamic extremists looking to carve out a new territory - they want their old one back. As far as I'm aware their main policy and raison d'etre is resistance to Isreali and perceived western policy towards the West Bank and Palestine - not a resistance movement against everything that the whole west stands for.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Stirlingsays Flag 22 Aug 14 9.10pm

Quote ASCPFC at 22 Aug 2014 8.45pm

I'm really not sure on the religion and politics of HAMAS but I do get the feeling that they are not of the same background as ISIS at all. I could be entirely wrong though, just a feeling. HAMAS are only really anti-Isreal due to a perceived wrong, they are not Islamic extremists looking to carve out a new territory - they want their old one back. As far as I'm aware their main policy and raison d'etre is resistance to Isreali and perceived western policy towards the West Bank and Palestine - not a resistance movement against everything that the whole west stands for.


This reminds me of the romantic idea Americans use to have of the IRA.

Checking out what Hamas are about isn't too hard....Read what human rights organizations say about them.....What journalists who have reported from Gaza say about them......Read their charter.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 22 Aug 14 10.01pm

Quote ASCPFC at 22 Aug 2014 8.45pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 22 Aug 2014 8.37pm

Quote ASCPFC at 22 Aug 2014 8.31pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 22 Aug 2014 8.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Aug 2014 6.28pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 22 Aug 2014 10.13am

That's only their short term goal. Their long term aim is much more far reaching. Power & religious extremism is a dangerous cocktail.

It'll take them a good ten years to secure, of course they're likely to then look at the rest of Iraq. I can't see them going for Turkey and provoking NATO, but Kuwait, Jordon etc would probably be next (although if they went for the rest of Iraqi, Iran would be dragged into it). Saudi, are probably too powerful for ISIS (and ideologically on similar pages) and I doubt they have the capacity to take on Iran.


It doesn't have to be secure, certainly not in the same context as a country. Sme on here already saying that we should let them set up a state. Almost immediately they would look at expanding their reach. I wouldn't be surprised that instead of moving south as expected they moved west or at least a feint towards Israel to get the west and the rest if the Muslim world involved.

They are no mugs

If they are no mugs then it is doubtful they would attack Isreal. Been tried by a combination of just about all of the arab neighbouring states with much larger armies than Isreal had - and probably about 100 times greater force than ISIS has - yet failed miserably, lasting only a few days.
People seem to think the whole Muslim world is behind ISIS but it really is only a faction of Islam that is involved and there are at least two other maijor factions in Islamic religion and a lot of minor ones.
It's a bit like Christianity where we have Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox. Even within all of those there are hundreds of different sects etc. ISIS is basically for one particualr group of Muslims. It's a bit like the religious wars of the 16th century - where Roman Catholic Spain tried to eliminate good old Protestant blightly and all that jazz.

Edited by ASCPFC (22 Aug 2014 8.32pm)


I don't think for one moment that the Muslim world is behind them. In fact it's quite the opposite, however by involving Israel by attack or threat, Hamas will feel emboldened and the whole thing will escalate.

I am not saying that they WILL do that but it is feasible. We should be looking at destroying their strongholds which are primarily in Syria and will weaken them significantly and allow Syrian soldiers & rebels as well as Iraqi and Kurdish troops to fight on the ground.

I'm really not sure on the religion and politics of HAMAS but I do get the feeling that they are not of the same background as ISIS at all. I could be entirely wrong though, just a feeling. HAMAS are only really anti-Isreal due to a perceived wrong, they are not Islamic extremists looking to carve out a new territory - they want their old one back. As far as I'm aware their main policy and raison d'etre is resistance to Isreali and perceived western policy towards the West Bank and Palestine - not a resistance movement against everything that the whole west stands for.

HAMAS' charter makes it very clear that their vision is of an Islamic society governed by sharia law.

Fathi Hammad, HAMAS Interior Minister, November 2013: "We anticipate further victories, in which we shall liberate our land, Allah willing. We shall liberate our Al-Aqsa Mosque, and our cities and villages, as a prelude to the establishment of the future Islamic Caliphate"

However, it is true that their roots are different to those of ISIS.HAMAS come directly out of the Muslim Brotherhood (who include the people kicked out of power in Egypt last year) whereas ISIS come out of the Saudi-based Wahhabi/Salafist strand of Sunni Islam.

One possible explanation for HAMAS' desire to up the stakes with Israel recently is to cement their popularity, which had been sagging, in Gaza (and increase it in the West Bank)in the face of a small (but growing) emerging challenge from disaffected ex members now more aligned with ISIS


For more re the concept of a "Caliphate":

[Link]


Edited by legaleagle (22 Aug 2014 10.09pm)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 23 Aug 14 10.02pm

[Link]

Hmmm...

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 23 Aug 14 11.40pm

Quote nickgusset at 23 Aug 2014 10.02pm

[Link]

Hmmm...


An absolute basket case!!

 


Pro USA & Israel

Stirlingsays Flag 24 Aug 14 3.49am

Quote nickgusset at 23 Aug 2014 10.02pm

[Link]

Hmmm...


Nick.....The websites you refer to show a rather worrying trend......In terms of opinion validation there will always be websites that will reflect the views we feel.....People tend to find what they go looking for mate....It doesn't make it correct of course.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 24 Aug 14 7.30am

"The Axis of Evil" - All supposedly the main terrorist three in the US war on terror.

Iran, Iraq and North Korea. Except they weren't really, were they?

US officials still too cowardly to out the real problem guys - Saudi. Would rather lie and castigate others than present reality.


That guy in Nick's link may be a nutcase but he has hit more than one nail on the head.

Edited by Kermit8 (24 Aug 2014 7.34am)

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 24 Aug 14 1.12pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 22 Aug 2014 9.10pm

Quote ASCPFC at 22 Aug 2014 8.45pm

I'm really not sure on the religion and politics of HAMAS but I do get the feeling that they are not of the same background as ISIS at all. I could be entirely wrong though, just a feeling. HAMAS are only really anti-Isreal due to a perceived wrong, they are not Islamic extremists looking to carve out a new territory - they want their old one back. As far as I'm aware their main policy and raison d'etre is resistance to Isreali and perceived western policy towards the West Bank and Palestine - not a resistance movement against everything that the whole west stands for.


This reminds me of the romantic idea Americans use to have of the IRA.

Checking out what Hamas are about isn't too hard....Read what human rights organizations say about them.....What journalists who have reported from Gaza say about them......Read their charter.


The original IRA didn't want much more than NI to be part of the Republic. I don't agree with anything they did but they wouldn't have carried on terror attaks if they had achieved their objective. They weren't looking for the whole world to be a Catholic state or anything like that. They probably would have stock-piled their arms just in case and as is the case today, the more radical element would go into organised crime. Really here, you have backed up my points quite well - I don't beleive HAMAS would be doing anything if there was a deal done with them that gave them the sovereign territory they want. HAMAS have not hijacked planes, or attacked the olympics or anything other than attacked Isreal - who they see as occupying their territory - but now they are the bad guys whilst the PLO are seemigly alright. If it wasn't so serious it would be funny. You are going to come back at me with their charter but what kind of charter do you expect them to have? A nice cuddly one which thanks the West for all it's help - or perhaps a recognition of a state that has never recognised any of their rights? Perhaps they would tone down the Muslim stuff but that may make them seem weak to people who are at their wits end with even the most basic parts of everyday life. Their charter aims for the very best and most radical they could hope for, just like the IRA if they were treated differently they may well feel like negotiation was a good option. You are unlikely to negotiate, however, if you know you will be kdnapped or murdered if you turn up to talks in person.

Edited by ASCPFC (24 Aug 2014 1.17pm)

 


Red and Blue Army!

Page 12 of 51 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > isis