You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Leader's debates
November 22 2026 2.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Leader's debates


Page 12 of 13 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 20 Apr 15 4.41pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 20 Apr 2015 3.51pm

Since then the BBC have admitted that people with leftwing views/opinions made up 67% of the audience... so Farage was right to highlight it... it was pretty obviously a leftwing bias though.


Got a link to that Hoofy?

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 20 Apr 15 4.46pm

Apparently our Nige had 2 bottles of gin confiscated on the way into the central methodist hall before the debate last week.

[Link]

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 20 Apr 15 4.46pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 20 Apr 2015 3.51pm

Quote OknotOK at 20 Apr 2015 1.40pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 2.24pm

Fair point. The audience should (if it *should* be anything at all) a reasonable reflection of society. The BBC is doing its job if it just randomly selects from the applicants. What they tend to do is pick a mixture. Often it's the mad lefties who are just louder than the rest (empty vessels make the most noise).

Same applies to the questions they select. I'm often a bit suspicious about the questions they choose (I'm basing all my comments on 'Any Questions' because sometimes they seem deliberately chosen to appeal to lefties. But they're just the ones I notice. The ones which appeal to right-wingers I probably just think are sensible!

I agree that audiences for these sort of things should in principle be balanced or selected randomly. But in this instance I actually think any real anger over the audience selection is a bit unnecessary as this debate will primarily have helped shape the view points of left-wing voters, so the questions and audience being primarily left wing (which does appear to have been the case), seems much less important.

I actually don't know what the selection criteria was on the questions though - there could have been a bias.

Then "lefties" could argue it was just levelling up the fairly obvious bias shown in the Sky debates - especially by the rather fawning Kay Burley.

Will be interesting to see if the final "debate" on QT is framed with a similar audience and slant of questioning.


On the night Dimbleby insisted that the audience selection was fair and had been carefully selected by an independent polling company.

Since then the BBC have admitted that people with leftwing views/opinions made up 67% of the audience... so Farage was right to highlight it... it was pretty obviously a leftwing bias though.

Actually the BBC admitted that "left-wing" made up 102 of 200 audience members, so 51%. And even then that is if you include the Lib Dems - who position themselves deliberately as central - as left wing. 58 were Tory or UKIP supporters. The rest were undecided.

The actual makeup was:
-5 Labour
-5 Tory
-4 Lib Dem
-3 UKIP
-2 SNP
-2 Green
-1 Plaid

So 10 would be "left wing" (45% of decided voters, 36% of the total audience), 4 would be centre ground, 8 would be right wing (36% of the decided voters, 29% of total audience). And the rest of the audience were undecided.

And ITV has confirmed it used the same distribution as well. So clearly the BBC didn't select its audience any differently to the other debates.

Which leads me back to the idea that it is all "the right" getting in a fluster about something because they performed badly.

What could have given a bigger left wing bias would have been the panel - which was predominantly left wing.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

imbored Flag UK 20 Apr 15 5.03pm

Quote OknotOK at 20 Apr 2015 4.46pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 20 Apr 2015 3.51pm

Quote OknotOK at 20 Apr 2015 1.40pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 2.24pm

Fair point. The audience should (if it *should* be anything at all) a reasonable reflection of society. The BBC is doing its job if it just randomly selects from the applicants. What they tend to do is pick a mixture. Often it's the mad lefties who are just louder than the rest (empty vessels make the most noise).

Same applies to the questions they select. I'm often a bit suspicious about the questions they choose (I'm basing all my comments on 'Any Questions' because sometimes they seem deliberately chosen to appeal to lefties. But they're just the ones I notice. The ones which appeal to right-wingers I probably just think are sensible!

I agree that audiences for these sort of things should in principle be balanced or selected randomly. But in this instance I actually think any real anger over the audience selection is a bit unnecessary as this debate will primarily have helped shape the view points of left-wing voters, so the questions and audience being primarily left wing (which does appear to have been the case), seems much less important.

I actually don't know what the selection criteria was on the questions though - there could have been a bias.

Then "lefties" could argue it was just levelling up the fairly obvious bias shown in the Sky debates - especially by the rather fawning Kay Burley.

Will be interesting to see if the final "debate" on QT is framed with a similar audience and slant of questioning.


On the night Dimbleby insisted that the audience selection was fair and had been carefully selected by an independent polling company.

Since then the BBC have admitted that people with leftwing views/opinions made up 67% of the audience... so Farage was right to highlight it... it was pretty obviously a leftwing bias though.

Actually the BBC admitted that "left-wing" made up 102 of 200 audience members, so 51%. And even then that is if you include the Lib Dems - who position themselves deliberately as central - as left wing. 58 were Tory or UKIP supporters. The rest were undecided.

The actual makeup was:
-5 Labour
-5 Tory
-4 Lib Dem
-3 UKIP
-2 SNP
-2 Green
-1 Plaid

So 10 would be "left wing" (45% of decided voters, 36% of the total audience), 4 would be centre ground, 8 would be right wing (36% of the decided voters, 29% of total audience). And the rest of the audience were undecided.

And ITV has confirmed it used the same distribution as well. So clearly the BBC didn't select its audience any differently to the other debates.

Which leads me back to the idea that it is all "the right" getting in a fluster about something because they performed badly.

What could have given a bigger left wing bias would have been the panel - which was predominantly left wing.


Interesting. Seems perfectly fair then. Like I said before, this was likely a pre-planned piece by Nigel to appeal to right wing voters. Looks like it worked.

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 20 Apr 15 5.12pm

Quote imbored at 20 Apr 2015 5.03pm
Interesting. Seems perfectly fair then. Like I said before, this was likely a pre-planned piece by Nigel to appeal to right wing voters. Looks like it worked.

Yes I would say so. The only thing is that the maths doesn't seem to work.

160 decided voters with a split of 22 between the voters which means you wouldn't end up with whole numbers. But I presume they found some way around that.

That's the numbers in the Telegraph anyway
[Link]


Edited by OknotOK (20 Apr 2015 5.12pm)

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Hoof Hearted 21 Apr 15 11.32am

Quote OknotOK at 20 Apr 2015 4.46pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 20 Apr 2015 3.51pm

Quote OknotOK at 20 Apr 2015 1.40pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 2.24pm

Fair point. The audience should (if it *should* be anything at all) a reasonable reflection of society. The BBC is doing its job if it just randomly selects from the applicants. What they tend to do is pick a mixture. Often it's the mad lefties who are just louder than the rest (empty vessels make the most noise).

Same applies to the questions they select. I'm often a bit suspicious about the questions they choose (I'm basing all my comments on 'Any Questions' because sometimes they seem deliberately chosen to appeal to lefties. But they're just the ones I notice. The ones which appeal to right-wingers I probably just think are sensible!

I agree that audiences for these sort of things should in principle be balanced or selected randomly. But in this instance I actually think any real anger over the audience selection is a bit unnecessary as this debate will primarily have helped shape the view points of left-wing voters, so the questions and audience being primarily left wing (which does appear to have been the case), seems much less important.

I actually don't know what the selection criteria was on the questions though - there could have been a bias.

Then "lefties" could argue it was just levelling up the fairly obvious bias shown in the Sky debates - especially by the rather fawning Kay Burley.

Will be interesting to see if the final "debate" on QT is framed with a similar audience and slant of questioning.


On the night Dimbleby insisted that the audience selection was fair and had been carefully selected by an independent polling company.

Since then the BBC have admitted that people with leftwing views/opinions made up 67% of the audience... so Farage was right to highlight it... it was pretty obviously a leftwing bias though.

Actually the BBC admitted that "left-wing" made up 102 of 200 audience members, so 51%. And even then that is if you include the Lib Dems - who position themselves deliberately as central - as left wing. 58 were Tory or UKIP supporters. The rest were undecided.

The actual makeup was:
-5 Labour
-5 Tory
-4 Lib Dem
-3 UKIP
-2 SNP
-2 Green
-1 Plaid

So 10 would be "left wing" (45% of decided voters, 36% of the total audience), 4 would be centre ground, 8 would be right wing (36% of the decided voters, 29% of total audience). And the rest of the audience were undecided.

And ITV has confirmed it used the same distribution as well. So clearly the BBC didn't select its audience any differently to the other debates.

Which leads me back to the idea that it is all "the right" getting in a fluster about something because they performed badly.

What could have given a bigger left wing bias would have been the panel - which was predominantly left wing.


I got my information from BBC News 2 days after the debate.... they definitely said 67% of the audience were left wing supporters.

Where is your breakdown from?

By the way I never said the BBC selected the audience... but whoever it was it was biased towards the left wing.

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 21 Apr 15 11.35am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Apr 2015 11.32am

I got my information from BBC News 2 days after the debate.... they definitely said 67% of the audience were left wing supporters.

Where is your breakdown from?

By the way I never said the BBC selected the audience... but whoever it was it was biased towards the left wing.

My numbers are per the Telegraph link I posted. It was also on the BBC. If you included the Lib Dems along with Labour, SNP, Greens, and Plaid then it would get to 102 as "left wing". This was of a total of 160 decided voters so would be 64% of decided voters. But there were an additional 20% (40 voters) who were undecided.

And as the article clearly shows, the audience was no more biased to left wing than the ITV debates were - which no one complained about. And are selected by an independent party.

Edited by OknotOK (21 Apr 2015 11.36am)

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Hoof Hearted 21 Apr 15 4.18pm

Quote OknotOK at 21 Apr 2015 11.35am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Apr 2015 11.32am

I got my information from BBC News 2 days after the debate.... they definitely said 67% of the audience were left wing supporters.

Where is your breakdown from?

By the way I never said the BBC selected the audience... but whoever it was it was biased towards the left wing.

My numbers are per the Telegraph link I posted. It was also on the BBC. If you included the Lib Dems along with Labour, SNP, Greens, and Plaid then it would get to 102 as "left wing". This was of a total of 160 decided voters so would be 64% of decided voters. But there were an additional 20% (40 voters) who were undecided.

And as the article clearly shows, the audience was no more biased to left wing than the ITV debates were - which no one complained about. And are selected by an independent party.

Edited by OknotOK (21 Apr 2015 11.36am)


The pie chart near the bottom shows a hefty bias towards "left leaning" ?

You appear to be putting your own interpretation on what the article shows.

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 21 Apr 15 4.35pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Apr 2015 4.18pm

Quote OknotOK at 21 Apr 2015 11.35am

My numbers are per the Telegraph link I posted. It was also on the BBC. If you included the Lib Dems along with Labour, SNP, Greens, and Plaid then it would get to 102 as "left wing". This was of a total of 160 decided voters so would be 64% of decided voters. But there were an additional 20% (40 voters) who were undecided.

And as the article clearly shows, the audience was no more biased to left wing than the ITV debates were - which no one complained about. And are selected by an independent party.

Edited by OknotOK (21 Apr 2015 11.36am)


The pie chart near the bottom shows a hefty bias towards "left leaning" ?

You appear to be putting your own interpretation on what the article shows.

No I'm not. I'm stating facts as set out in the article

Quote
An ITV spokesman said the audience for its seven-way debate reflected the same proportions.

You have chosen to selectively highlight sections of my post to suggest I was putting my own interpretation.

I quite clearly said the article shows the audience was no more biased than the ITV debates were. Given ITV said their audience was based on exactly the same proportions, that is simply facts. Given people weren't making a fuss about the ITV debates being left-wing, it suggests actually the fuss is people using their own bias against the BBC.

As I indicated further up the audience did appear to be more left wing:

Quote
so the questions and audience being primarily left wing (which does appear to have been the case)


Edited by OknotOK (21 Apr 2015 4.42pm)

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Hoof Hearted 21 Apr 15 4.50pm

Quote OknotOK at 21 Apr 2015 4.35pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Apr 2015 4.18pm

Quote OknotOK at 21 Apr 2015 11.35am

My numbers are per the Telegraph link I posted. It was also on the BBC. If you included the Lib Dems along with Labour, SNP, Greens, and Plaid then it would get to 102 as "left wing". This was of a total of 160 decided voters so would be 64% of decided voters. But there were an additional 20% (40 voters) who were undecided.

And as the article clearly shows, the audience was no more biased to left wing than the ITV debates were - which no one complained about. And are selected by an independent party.

Edited by OknotOK (21 Apr 2015 11.36am)


The pie chart near the bottom shows a hefty bias towards "left leaning" ?

You appear to be putting your own interpretation on what the article shows.

No I'm not. I'm stating facts as set out in the article

Quote
An ITV spokesman said the audience for its seven-way debate reflected the same proportions.

You have chosen to selectively highlight sections of my post to suggest I was putting my own interpretation.

I quite clearly said the article shows the audience was no more biased than the ITV debates were. Given ITV said their audience was based on exactly the same proportions, that is simply facts. Given people weren't making a fuss about the ITV debates being left-wing, it suggests actually the fuss is people using their own bias against the BBC.

As I indicated further up the audience did appear to be more left wing:

Quote
so the questions and audience being primarily left wing (which does appear to have been the case)


Edited by OknotOK (21 Apr 2015 4.42pm)


All I know is that the article you linked from The Telegraph showed a pie chart with a heavy bias towards "left leaning".... which appears to be approximately 67% which I quoted from the BBC news report I saw a few days ago.

All the other stuff you've said is irrelevant and akin to political speech designed to confuse and undermine the opposition.

Farage was right.

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 21 Apr 15 4.53pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Apr 2015 4.50pm

All I know is that the article you linked from The Telegraph showed a pie chart with a heavy bias towards "left leaning".... which appears to be approximately 67% which I quoted from the BBC news report I saw a few days ago.

All the other stuff you've said is irrelevant and akin to political speech designed to confuse and undermine the opposition.

Farage was right.

You've convinced me. Farage is right. UKIP is right. I'm switching my vote

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

imbored Flag UK 21 Apr 15 5.19pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Apr 2015 4.50pm

Quote OknotOK at 21 Apr 2015 4.35pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Apr 2015 4.18pm

Quote OknotOK at 21 Apr 2015 11.35am

My numbers are per the Telegraph link I posted. It was also on the BBC. If you included the Lib Dems along with Labour, SNP, Greens, and Plaid then it would get to 102 as "left wing". This was of a total of 160 decided voters so would be 64% of decided voters. But there were an additional 20% (40 voters) who were undecided.

And as the article clearly shows, the audience was no more biased to left wing than the ITV debates were - which no one complained about. And are selected by an independent party.

Edited by OknotOK (21 Apr 2015 11.36am)


The pie chart near the bottom shows a hefty bias towards "left leaning" ?

You appear to be putting your own interpretation on what the article shows.

No I'm not. I'm stating facts as set out in the article

Quote
An ITV spokesman said the audience for its seven-way debate reflected the same proportions.

You have chosen to selectively highlight sections of my post to suggest I was putting my own interpretation.

I quite clearly said the article shows the audience was no more biased than the ITV debates were. Given ITV said their audience was based on exactly the same proportions, that is simply facts. Given people weren't making a fuss about the ITV debates being left-wing, it suggests actually the fuss is people using their own bias against the BBC.

As I indicated further up the audience did appear to be more left wing:

Quote
so the questions and audience being primarily left wing (which does appear to have been the case)


Edited by OknotOK (21 Apr 2015 4.42pm)


All I know is that the article you linked from The Telegraph showed a pie chart with a heavy bias towards "left leaning".... which appears to be approximately 67% which I quoted from the BBC news report I saw a few days ago.

All the other stuff you've said is irrelevant and akin to political speech designed to confuse and undermine the opposition.

Farage was right.


It can be interpreted multiple ways but realistically half of Labour aren't left leaning so we'd have to factor that in too. The Telegraph just shoved them into a 'left leaning' category of its own making, it doesn't become gospel as a result. The guy posting here has his spin on it, they have their spin on it and so on.

 

Hoof Hearted 22 Apr 15 9.41am

Quote imbored at 21 Apr 2015 5.19pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Apr 2015 4.50pm

Quote OknotOK at 21 Apr 2015 4.35pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Apr 2015 4.18pm

Quote OknotOK at 21 Apr 2015 11.35am

My numbers are per the Telegraph link I posted. It was also on the BBC. If you included the Lib Dems along with Labour, SNP, Greens, and Plaid then it would get to 102 as "left wing". This was of a total of 160 decided voters so would be 64% of decided voters. But there were an additional 20% (40 voters) who were undecided.

And as the article clearly shows, the audience was no more biased to left wing than the ITV debates were - which no one complained about. And are selected by an independent party.

Edited by OknotOK (21 Apr 2015 11.36am)


The pie chart near the bottom shows a hefty bias towards "left leaning" ?

You appear to be putting your own interpretation on what the article shows.

No I'm not. I'm stating facts as set out in the article

Quote
An ITV spokesman said the audience for its seven-way debate reflected the same proportions.

You have chosen to selectively highlight sections of my post to suggest I was putting my own interpretation.

I quite clearly said the article shows the audience was no more biased than the ITV debates were. Given ITV said their audience was based on exactly the same proportions, that is simply facts. Given people weren't making a fuss about the ITV debates being left-wing, it suggests actually the fuss is people using their own bias against the BBC.

As I indicated further up the audience did appear to be more left wing:

Quote
so the questions and audience being primarily left wing (which does appear to have been the case)


Edited by OknotOK (21 Apr 2015 4.42pm)


All I know is that the article you linked from The Telegraph showed a pie chart with a heavy bias towards "left leaning".... which appears to be approximately 67% which I quoted from the BBC news report I saw a few days ago.

All the other stuff you've said is irrelevant and akin to political speech designed to confuse and undermine the opposition.

Farage was right.


It can be interpreted multiple ways but realistically half of Labour aren't left leaning so we'd have to factor that in too. The Telegraph just shoved them into a 'left leaning' category of its own making, it doesn't become gospel as a result. The guy posting here has his spin on it, they have their spin on it and so on.


You didn't need "spin" to observe that the overwhelming majority of the audience were anti UKIP and it was obvious that Dimbleby's denial of any audience rigging was not the case.

It can only be interpreted one way.

FFS!

 

DanH Flag SW2 22 Apr 15 9.51am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 22 Apr 2015 9.41am

Quote imbored at 21 Apr 2015 5.19pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Apr 2015 4.50pm

Quote OknotOK at 21 Apr 2015 4.35pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Apr 2015 4.18pm

Quote OknotOK at 21 Apr 2015 11.35am

My numbers are per the Telegraph link I posted. It was also on the BBC. If you included the Lib Dems along with Labour, SNP, Greens, and Plaid then it would get to 102 as "left wing". This was of a total of 160 decided voters so would be 64% of decided voters. But there were an additional 20% (40 voters) who were undecided.

And as the article clearly shows, the audience was no more biased to left wing than the ITV debates were - which no one complained about. And are selected by an independent party.

Edited by OknotOK (21 Apr 2015 11.36am)


The pie chart near the bottom shows a hefty bias towards "left leaning" ?

You appear to be putting your own interpretation on what the article shows.

No I'm not. I'm stating facts as set out in the article

Quote
An ITV spokesman said the audience for its seven-way debate reflected the same proportions.

You have chosen to selectively highlight sections of my post to suggest I was putting my own interpretation.

I quite clearly said the article shows the audience was no more biased than the ITV debates were. Given ITV said their audience was based on exactly the same proportions, that is simply facts. Given people weren't making a fuss about the ITV debates being left-wing, it suggests actually the fuss is people using their own bias against the BBC.

As I indicated further up the audience did appear to be more left wing:

Quote
so the questions and audience being primarily left wing (which does appear to have been the case)


Edited by OknotOK (21 Apr 2015 4.42pm)


All I know is that the article you linked from The Telegraph showed a pie chart with a heavy bias towards "left leaning".... which appears to be approximately 67% which I quoted from the BBC news report I saw a few days ago.

All the other stuff you've said is irrelevant and akin to political speech designed to confuse and undermine the opposition.

Farage was right.


It can be interpreted multiple ways but realistically half of Labour aren't left leaning so we'd have to factor that in too. The Telegraph just shoved them into a 'left leaning' category of its own making, it doesn't become gospel as a result. The guy posting here has his spin on it, they have their spin on it and so on.


You didn't need "spin" to observe that the overwhelming majority of the audience were anti UKIP and it was obvious that Dimbleby's denial of any audience rigging was not the case.

It can only be interpreted one way.

FFS!


Think you'll find the overwhelming majority of the population are anti UKIP too.

 

Hoof Hearted 22 Apr 15 10.09am

Quote DanH at 22 Apr 2015 9.51am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 22 Apr 2015 9.41am

Quote imbored at 21 Apr 2015 5.19pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Apr 2015 4.50pm

Quote OknotOK at 21 Apr 2015 4.35pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Apr 2015 4.18pm

Quote OknotOK at 21 Apr 2015 11.35am

My numbers are per the Telegraph link I posted. It was also on the BBC. If you included the Lib Dems along with Labour, SNP, Greens, and Plaid then it would get to 102 as "left wing". This was of a total of 160 decided voters so would be 64% of decided voters. But there were an additional 20% (40 voters) who were undecided.

And as the article clearly shows, the audience was no more biased to left wing than the ITV debates were - which no one complained about. And are selected by an independent party.

Edited by OknotOK (21 Apr 2015 11.36am)


The pie chart near the bottom shows a hefty bias towards "left leaning" ?

You appear to be putting your own interpretation on what the article shows.

No I'm not. I'm stating facts as set out in the article

Quote
An ITV spokesman said the audience for its seven-way debate reflected the same proportions.

You have chosen to selectively highlight sections of my post to suggest I was putting my own interpretation.

I quite clearly said the article shows the audience was no more biased than the ITV debates were. Given ITV said their audience was based on exactly the same proportions, that is simply facts. Given people weren't making a fuss about the ITV debates being left-wing, it suggests actually the fuss is people using their own bias against the BBC.

As I indicated further up the audience did appear to be more left wing:

Quote
so the questions and audience being primarily left wing (which does appear to have been the case)


Edited by OknotOK (21 Apr 2015 4.42pm)


All I know is that the article you linked from The Telegraph showed a pie chart with a heavy bias towards "left leaning".... which appears to be approximately 67% which I quoted from the BBC news report I saw a few days ago.

All the other stuff you've said is irrelevant and akin to political speech designed to confuse and undermine the opposition.

Farage was right.


It can be interpreted multiple ways but realistically half of Labour aren't left leaning so we'd have to factor that in too. The Telegraph just shoved them into a 'left leaning' category of its own making, it doesn't become gospel as a result. The guy posting here has his spin on it, they have their spin on it and so on.


You didn't need "spin" to observe that the overwhelming majority of the audience were anti UKIP and it was obvious that Dimbleby's denial of any audience rigging was not the case.

It can only be interpreted one way.

FFS!


Think you'll find the overwhelming majority of the population are anti UKIP too.


Yes Dan... it's amazing how many people have their head in the sand regarding the complete break down of our infrastructure due to mass immigration.

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 22 Apr 15 12.18pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 22 Apr 2015 9.41am

You didn't need "spin" to observe that the overwhelming majority of the audience were anti UKIP and it was obvious that Dimbleby's denial of any audience rigging was not the case.

It can only be interpreted one way.

FFS!

Yes, the majority of the audience was anti-UKIP. That doesn't mean it would have been left wing by the way as the majority of Tory voters *should* be anti-UKIP.

But to suggest there was some undue BBC bias in selecting a "left wing" audience is factually incorrect. No spin. No interpretation. Just fact. That truly can only be interpreted one way.

Farage deliberately played up to it to make himself seem anti-establishment so the "bias" worked for him anyway. It will have motivated his core support.

Anyway, like I said I will be interested to see the format for the QT "debate" when the panel will not be predominantly left wing (even by the weak definition that includes the Lib Dems as left wing).

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

ghosteagle Flag 22 Apr 15 12.46pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 22 Apr 2015 10.09am

Quote DanH at 22 Apr 2015 9.51am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 22 Apr 2015 9.41am

Quote imbored at 21 Apr 2015 5.19pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Apr 2015 4.50pm

Quote OknotOK at 21 Apr 2015 4.35pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Apr 2015 4.18pm

Quote OknotOK at 21 Apr 2015 11.35am

My numbers are per the Telegraph link I posted. It was also on the BBC. If you included the Lib Dems along with Labour, SNP, Greens, and Plaid then it would get to 102 as "left wing". This was of a total of 160 decided voters so would be 64% of decided voters. But there were an additional 20% (40 voters) who were undecided.

And as the article clearly shows, the audience was no more biased to left wing than the ITV debates were - which no one complained about. And are selected by an independent party.

Edited by OknotOK (21 Apr 2015 11.36am)


The pie chart near the bottom shows a hefty bias towards "left leaning" ?

You appear to be putting your own interpretation on what the article shows.

No I'm not. I'm stating facts as set out in the article

Quote
An ITV spokesman said the audience for its seven-way debate reflected the same proportions.

You have chosen to selectively highlight sections of my post to suggest I was putting my own interpretation.

I quite clearly said the article shows the audience was no more biased than the ITV debates were. Given ITV said their audience was based on exactly the same proportions, that is simply facts. Given people weren't making a fuss about the ITV debates being left-wing, it suggests actually the fuss is people using their own bias against the BBC.

As I indicated further up the audience did appear to be more left wing:

Quote
so the questions and audience being primarily left wing (which does appear to have been the case)


Edited by OknotOK (21 Apr 2015 4.42pm)


All I know is that the article you linked from The Telegraph showed a pie chart with a heavy bias towards "left leaning".... which appears to be approximately 67% which I quoted from the BBC news report I saw a few days ago.

All the other stuff you've said is irrelevant and akin to political speech designed to confuse and undermine the opposition.

Farage was right.


It can be interpreted multiple ways but realistically half of Labour aren't left leaning so we'd have to factor that in too. The Telegraph just shoved them into a 'left leaning' category of its own making, it doesn't become gospel as a result. The guy posting here has his spin on it, they have their spin on it and so on.


You didn't need "spin" to observe that the overwhelming majority of the audience were anti UKIP and it was obvious that Dimbleby's denial of any audience rigging was not the case.

It can only be interpreted one way.

FFS!


Think you'll find the overwhelming majority of the population are anti UKIP too.


Yes Dan... it's amazing how many people have their head in the sand regarding the complete break down of our infrastructure due to mass immigration.


I got on a bus yesterday, so the infrastructure hasn't completely broken down Still, no need to let the truth get in the way of some baseless xenophobia eh?

 

npn Flag Crowborough 22 Apr 15 1.12pm

Lefty studio audience members are always more vocal. No idea why, but if you watch/listen to any of the popular TV debate shows you'll see it - Question Time, Any Questions, etc.

Some seem to believe that shouting down the opposition means you've won the argument. This may stem from the fact that people tend to move towards the right as they get older, so maybe the right wingers tend to be more mature?

Not sure, but my point is that the fact that the audience were vocally anti-Farage needn't necessarily mean a bias in the crowd, just that the right wingers would be more likely to shake their heads, or perhaps raise an eyebrow, but largely stay politely quiet and respectful when something they disagree with, whereas the student union types will hoot and holler.

Just personal perception, nothing I can back up with figures, but the left (or at least their supporters) do tend to be less conducive to good debate (take Nick Griffin on QT as an example - there for the taking, policies to be exposed and ridiculed, but just greeted with rent-a-mob booing and panellists turning their backs on him like sulking kids, and actually ended up looking good by comparison)

Edited by npn (22 Apr 2015 1.13pm)

 

DanH Flag SW2 22 Apr 15 1.45pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 22 Apr 2015 10.09am

Quote DanH at 22 Apr 2015 9.51am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 22 Apr 2015 9.41am

Quote imbored at 21 Apr 2015 5.19pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Apr 2015 4.50pm

Quote OknotOK at 21 Apr 2015 4.35pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Apr 2015 4.18pm

Quote OknotOK at 21 Apr 2015 11.35am

My numbers are per the Telegraph link I posted. It was also on the BBC. If you included the Lib Dems along with Labour, SNP, Greens, and Plaid then it would get to 102 as "left wing". This was of a total of 160 decided voters so would be 64% of decided voters. But there were an additional 20% (40 voters) who were undecided.

And as the article clearly shows, the audience was no more biased to left wing than the ITV debates were - which no one complained about. And are selected by an independent party.

Edited by OknotOK (21 Apr 2015 11.36am)


The pie chart near the bottom shows a hefty bias towards "left leaning" ?

You appear to be putting your own interpretation on what the article shows.

No I'm not. I'm stating facts as set out in the article

Quote
An ITV spokesman said the audience for its seven-way debate reflected the same proportions.

You have chosen to selectively highlight sections of my post to suggest I was putting my own interpretation.

I quite clearly said the article shows the audience was no more biased than the ITV debates were. Given ITV said their audience was based on exactly the same proportions, that is simply facts. Given people weren't making a fuss about the ITV debates being left-wing, it suggests actually the fuss is people using their own bias against the BBC.

As I indicated further up the audience did appear to be more left wing:

Quote
so the questions and audience being primarily left wing (which does appear to have been the case)


Edited by OknotOK (21 Apr 2015 4.42pm)


All I know is that the article you linked from The Telegraph showed a pie chart with a heavy bias towards "left leaning".... which appears to be approximately 67% which I quoted from the BBC news report I saw a few days ago.

All the other stuff you've said is irrelevant and akin to political speech designed to confuse and undermine the opposition.

Farage was right.


It can be interpreted multiple ways but realistically half of Labour aren't left leaning so we'd have to factor that in too. The Telegraph just shoved them into a 'left leaning' category of its own making, it doesn't become gospel as a result. The guy posting here has his spin on it, they have their spin on it and so on.


You didn't need "spin" to observe that the overwhelming majority of the audience were anti UKIP and it was obvious that Dimbleby's denial of any audience rigging was not the case.

It can only be interpreted one way.

FFS!


Think you'll find the overwhelming majority of the population are anti UKIP too.


Yes Dan... it's amazing how many people have their head in the sand regarding the complete break down of our infrastructure due to mass immigration.


I pop to Berlin over the weekend and there's a total breakdown in 4 days? F*ck me that happened quickly.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 22 Apr 15 2.24pm

Quote npn at 22 Apr 2015 1.12pm

Lefty studio audience members are always more vocal. No idea why, but if you watch/listen to any of the popular TV debate shows you'll see it - Question Time, Any Questions, etc.

Some seem to believe that shouting down the opposition means you've won the argument. This may stem from the fact that people tend to move towards the right as they get older, so maybe the right wingers tend to be more mature?

Not sure, but my point is that the fact that the audience were vocally anti-Farage needn't necessarily mean a bias in the crowd, just that the right wingers would be more likely to shake their heads, or perhaps raise an eyebrow, but largely stay politely quiet and respectful when something they disagree with, whereas the student union types will hoot and holler.

Just personal perception, nothing I can back up with figures, but the left (or at least their supporters) do tend to be less conducive to good debate (take Nick Griffin on QT as an example - there for the taking, policies to be exposed and ridiculed, but just greeted with rent-a-mob booing and panellists turning their backs on him like sulking kids, and actually ended up looking good by comparison)

Edited by npn (22 Apr 2015 1.13pm)


I agree. That bint having a shout at Cameron in the ITV one, for example.

 


Optimistic as ever

Page 12 of 13 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Leader's debates