This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| derben |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote serial thriller at 06 Jun 2015 5.34pm
Quote derben at 06 Jun 2015 1.50pm
Quote serial thriller at 06 Jun 2015 1.43pm
I just wanna make a couple of more points. What is racism? Well of course racism is about discrimination on the basis of one's race. As a couple of posts earlier in the thread stated though, it is often something that one is unaware of, and thus must constantly challenge, because it can be pervasive and insidious. The video I posted originally is brilliant because Akala very acutely and intelligently highlights how racism is not just an individual act, like some drunkard shouting n***ger, but is institutionalised in a way which is much harder to determine. Interestingly this is backed up by this piece recently, which shows how even one of the most prominent institutions which makes up the British state - the police - is not only institutionally racist but to some degree self-aware of it: [Link] When we are trying to determine whether Britain as a nation is racist, the prejudices of other countries are irrelevant. It becomes an easy deflector for our vices, just to come out and say 'but they're worse'. There either is discrimination against people of differing ethnicities or there isn't, and when you see the stop and search numbers based on ethnic background, you realise that a broad acceptance that people who are black and brown are more dangerous is still very apparent, not just in terms of police but in terms of the public in general as the chief of police says above. You can accept that this country still has a racist hangover from our imperial history and still love this country. In fact, caring enough to realise social deficiencies is a fundamental part of wanting to achieve the best for us. As I say, racism, sexism and all forms of prejudice are something we constantly have to be looking out for not just in others but in ourselves. What should we do if we find ourselves thinking discriminatory thoughts? Turn ourselves in at the nearest police station and confess a thought-crime? (Oh, I forgot, that's no good is it - the police are institutionally racist themselves) Who do we turn to? Surely in this day and age, the time has come for some new sort of organisation that we could throw ourselves on for mercy - could call it Ministry of Love perhaps. Also "all forms of prejudice are something we constantly have to be looking out for". We are prejudice when we vote in an election, we do not vote for someone on the grounds of his political beliefs. We are all prejudiced on here in favour of Crystal Palace FC.
And if you can't see the difference between supporting a different football team and hating someone because they're black/gay/a woman then I give up. I said thinking discriminatory thoughts rather than racist - is all discrimination racist? I have crossed the road (after having a word with myself) when I've seen a group of young black men coming towards me. I've also crossed the road when I've seen a group of young white men coming towards me. Probably no need in either case, but prudent I think. Perhaps I should cross the road a bit quicker when it is a black group as, generally speaking, black people run faster! Is my crossing the road more quickly, racist, or judicious discrimination? I think the hatred that fans of football teams show towards the fans of rival football teams is far worse than most perceived racial discrimination. Edited by derben (07 Jun 2015 8.29am)
|
|
| Steptoe |
|
|---|---|
|
- Edited by Steptoe (07 Jun 2015 10.43am)
|
|
|
I thought this was a thread about everyone in Britain being "Racist".
always a Norwood boy, where ever I live. |
|
|
Given that we are, according to the current anthropological axiom, all descended from common ancestry (and therefore all of the same race irrespective of skin colour, country of origin etc.) how can racism, as we define it, even be a possibility? Did anyone watch that recent documentary on The Beeb about the two Chinese orphan twin girls? Edited by lankygit (07 Jun 2015 5.47am) Edited by lankygit (07 Jun 2015 5.49am)
Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link] |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote TheJudge at 06 Jun 2015 6.08pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Jun 2015 4.19pm
Quote TheJudge at 05 Jun 2015 9.47pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 05 Jun 2015 1.05pm
Quote TheJudge at 05 Jun 2015 12.29pm
You are not talking about numbers. The Romans and Normans influenced the country because the took control of government by force. Because no one actually has any real knowledge of the actual numbers. Certainly the number were presumably sufficient for say William to defeat Harold militarily and put down the Northern Rebellion shortly after. And of course once settled they brought family over and servants, and over time began to marry into the local populations. The roman army of Claudius invasion was four legions, about 20,000 troops and around 20,000 auxilleries. The estimated population of the UK at the time is around 4m. Which is pretty big. Notably when the Doomesday census put the population of England, during the 11th century at between 1.5m and 2m - Estimates of Williams Army are between 8,000 and 12,000 men. Later backed by about 8000 initial settlers given lands and titles by William etc. So not exactly insignificant numbers, with a population even of 2m. Edited by jamiemartin721 (05 Jun 2015 1.10pm)
That's not what you said though, it was about numbers - they weren't insignificant. Actually we all voted for it, we elected the political parties that were part of the EU agreements. We didn't have a referendum, but no one actually really seemed to care about it, until the economy bit it (ie when there wasn't a competition for the jobs). But the Roman soldiers all went home as there weren't many Normans. The only real significance is that they both changed our culture enormously. What do you think the 318,000 arriving here every year will do ? Actually my point originally was with the idea you presented of a British Culture and that it is eroded by migration (rather than simply changed). You presented its effect on culture as negative, where as I was attempting to demonstrate its impact is simply to change cultural groups in the UK in much the same way that culture just changes over time (and that migration has a positive and negative effect on British Culture). Probably, but they'd have been replaced by new legions and a lot would have stayed and of course larger numbers of settlers would have arrived each year, including Roman beuracrats and their families etc. Currently net migration is 318,000 a year, about half a million people come to the UK each year and 314,000 leave. Ideally, we need to bring those two numbers closer together. 2014 saw the lowest number of applications for citizenship since 2002.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 06 Jun 2015 6.22pm
Quote TheJudge at 06 Jun 2015 6.08pm
But the Roman soldiers all went home as there weren't many Normans. The only real significance is that they both changed our culture enormously. What do you think the 318,000 arriving here every year will do ?
I wonder if the Normans said that? Apparently we had a problem with our cultural life not being exciting enough before large scale immigration....Mmmm..I don't remember that....In fact what I remember was a more cohesive society more comfortable with its lot compared to now.......Certainly among the working class. We should be celebrating how all these immigrants are doing jobs which.....apparently our own population are refusing to do. Apparently our own population wish to stay on the dole rather than have a job......That's the implication from the left on immigration even when they criticise the right for attacking the welfare 'undeserving'. You know personally I've never met a young British person who when presented with a job opportunity that would pay their bills and give them a life actually turned it down.....I'm sure they exist but not in anything like the numbers suggested. But I have met immigrants who are happy to work for low wages in large rental accommodation so that they can hoard their cash, regularly send it out of the country to dependents and after they have built up a reasonable war chest go home to buy property. Good for them.....But compared to how a working class British worker spends their cash it's a poor substitute. Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Jun 2015 6.55pm) So why aren't the UK workers taking those jobs? It ultimately because they can't afford to and don't have the capacity to do so (ie travel to the areas of work). Essentially the problem has never actually been the migrants, but the way in which corporations and governments in the UK have allowed a situation to occur, which is ultimately driven by profitability (ie keeping wages low). This has ultimately undermined the British Working class and defined its cultural experience, than simply migrants. Of course now governments want to present it as a problem of migration. But it never was, it was the failure of governments to ensure that wages in the UK were determined fairly in line with costs of living, rather than driven by corporate profitability. The failure to use the minimum wage to make jobs as attractive to naturalised unemploed workers as migrant workers was the great betrayal of Labour, which the Conservatives have simply continued.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Quote derben at 07 Jun 2015 8.21am
Quote lankygit at 07 Jun 2015 5.29am
Given that we are, according to the current anthropological axiom, all descended from common ancestry (and therefore all of the same race irrespective of skin colour, country of origin etc.) how can racism, as we define it, even be a possibility? Did anyone watch that recent documentary on The Beeb about the two Chinese orphan twin girls? Edited by lankygit (07 Jun 2015 5.47am) Edited by lankygit (07 Jun 2015 5.49am) Chinese takeaways - were there prawn crackers in with them?
Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link] |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.