You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Richard Dawkins Hero
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Richard Dawkins Hero


Page 12 of 14 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 19 Jun 15 12.53pm

The important thing with chaotic systems is that they are both at the same time chaotic and disordered (neither is dominant) what matters is the point of scale at which you interact.

How we measure something, and the methodology by which we measure something, will inevitably affect our results, especially when dealing with hypothetical concepts (such as in behavior). In psychology we see this a lot, where classical research and empiricism breaks down entirely when critical qualitative methods, such as discursive and phenomenological methods are applied, even with some of the most respected and well known research.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

TheJudge Flag 19 Jun 15 4.27pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 19 Jun 2015 12.53pm

The important thing with chaotic systems is that they are both at the same time chaotic and disordered (neither is dominant) what matters is the point of scale at which you interact.

How we measure something, and the methodology by which we measure something, will inevitably affect our results, especially when dealing with hypothetical concepts (such as in behavior). In psychology we see this a lot, where classical research and empiricism breaks down entirely when critical qualitative methods, such as discursive and phenomenological methods are applied, even with some of the most respected and well known research.


This is where we become lost in what is quantifiable and what is real. Science's inability to fully comprehend or have the ability to quantify or express is the limiting factor. Much in the same way that quantum mechanics seems all but unfathomable, the laws of nature, which must include the quantum level, may as well be magic if it is beyond our understanding.
We may dip into the nature of things and view it on a limited level by studying biology, psychology, chemistry or physics but the bigger picture is still out of reach and remains hypothetical.
Is it possible to see beyond the apparently chaotic behavior or the quantum level ? Is quantum really the quantum ?

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 20 Jun 15 7.15pm

Quote TheJudge at 19 Jun 2015 4.27pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 19 Jun 2015 12.53pm

The important thing with chaotic systems is that they are both at the same time chaotic and disordered (neither is dominant) what matters is the point of scale at which you interact.

How we measure something, and the methodology by which we measure something, will inevitably affect our results, especially when dealing with hypothetical concepts (such as in behavior). In psychology we see this a lot, where classical research and empiricism breaks down entirely when critical qualitative methods, such as discursive and phenomenological methods are applied, even with some of the most respected and well known research.


This is where we become lost in what is quantifiable and what is real. Science's inability to fully comprehend or have the ability to quantify or express is the limiting factor. Much in the same way that quantum mechanics seems all but unfathomable, the laws of nature, which must include the quantum level, may as well be magic if it is beyond our understanding.
We may dip into the nature of things and view it on a limited level by studying biology, psychology, chemistry or physics but the bigger picture is still out of reach and remains hypothetical.
Is it possible to see beyond the apparently chaotic behavior or the quantum level ? Is quantum really the quantum ?

I think that sciences create models of reality, rather than being exact representations. I suspect existence before translation through sensory data closely resembles a more 'chaotic system', and that in order to function we construct meaningful represenations of it, rather than 'experience it' as it truly is.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

TheJudge Flag 20 Jun 15 8.04pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 20 Jun 2015 7.15pm

Quote TheJudge at 19 Jun 2015 4.27pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 19 Jun 2015 12.53pm

The important thing with chaotic systems is that they are both at the same time chaotic and disordered (neither is dominant) what matters is the point of scale at which you interact.

How we measure something, and the methodology by which we measure something, will inevitably affect our results, especially when dealing with hypothetical concepts (such as in behavior). In psychology we see this a lot, where classical research and empiricism breaks down entirely when critical qualitative methods, such as discursive and phenomenological methods are applied, even with some of the most respected and well known research.


This is where we become lost in what is quantifiable and what is real. Science's inability to fully comprehend or have the ability to quantify or express is the limiting factor. Much in the same way that quantum mechanics seems all but unfathomable, the laws of nature, which must include the quantum level, may as well be magic if it is beyond our understanding.
We may dip into the nature of things and view it on a limited level by studying biology, psychology, chemistry or physics but the bigger picture is still out of reach and remains hypothetical.
Is it possible to see beyond the apparently chaotic behavior or the quantum level ? Is quantum really the quantum ?

I think that sciences create models of reality, rather than being exact representations. I suspect existence before translation through sensory data closely resembles a more 'chaotic system', and that in order to function we construct meaningful represenations of it, rather than 'experience it' as it truly is.



Since observation effects the quantum level according to current understanding, that makes reality a very tricky customer. I don't like the idea of a chaotic reality as that implies that there is no solution to the puzzle beyond accepting that there is no solution.
That's almost as unsatisfactory as blaming God to my mind.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 24 Jun 15 11.49am

Quote TheJudge at 20 Jun 2015 8.04pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 20 Jun 2015 7.15pm

Quote TheJudge at 19 Jun 2015 4.27pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 19 Jun 2015 12.53pm

The important thing with chaotic systems is that they are both at the same time chaotic and disordered (neither is dominant) what matters is the point of scale at which you interact.

How we measure something, and the methodology by which we measure something, will inevitably affect our results, especially when dealing with hypothetical concepts (such as in behavior). In psychology we see this a lot, where classical research and empiricism breaks down entirely when critical qualitative methods, such as discursive and phenomenological methods are applied, even with some of the most respected and well known research.


This is where we become lost in what is quantifiable and what is real. Science's inability to fully comprehend or have the ability to quantify or express is the limiting factor. Much in the same way that quantum mechanics seems all but unfathomable, the laws of nature, which must include the quantum level, may as well be magic if it is beyond our understanding.
We may dip into the nature of things and view it on a limited level by studying biology, psychology, chemistry or physics but the bigger picture is still out of reach and remains hypothetical.
Is it possible to see beyond the apparently chaotic behavior or the quantum level ? Is quantum really the quantum ?

I think that sciences create models of reality, rather than being exact representations. I suspect existence before translation through sensory data closely resembles a more 'chaotic system', and that in order to function we construct meaningful represenations of it, rather than 'experience it' as it truly is.



Since observation effects the quantum level according to current understanding, that makes reality a very tricky customer. I don't like the idea of a chaotic reality as that implies that there is no solution to the puzzle beyond accepting that there is no solution.
That's almost as unsatisfactory as blaming God to my mind.

But that is what the evidence suggest, that the method of observation and measurement scale used, will affect the outcome and results; this presents the idea seen in post-modern science outlooks, that rather than constructing a view of reality, scientific methods construct a model of reality based on our observations and measurements (which actually fits better with experimental vs applied science dichotomy).

Scientifically speaking there is no real basis to assume otherwise, as the chaotic and fuzzy systems present a solution to the macro vs micro scale that fits both levels, and works.

Science isn't about truth, its about predictable and highly probable outcomes. The mistake of modernism was to assume that the scientist is somehow entirely objective and separated from the experimental methodology (and as we experience the world subjectively, we can never truly ever separate our bias entirely).

In truth, science has never really been anything other than the construction of models of high probability over low probability.

As such the Quantum and relative are both acceptable models.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

TheJudge Flag 27 Jun 15 10.35am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 24 Jun 2015 11.49am

Quote TheJudge at 20 Jun 2015 8.04pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 20 Jun 2015 7.15pm

Quote TheJudge at 19 Jun 2015 4.27pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 19 Jun 2015 12.53pm

The important thing with chaotic systems is that they are both at the same time chaotic and disordered (neither is dominant) what matters is the point of scale at which you interact.

How we measure something, and the methodology by which we measure something, will inevitably affect our results, especially when dealing with hypothetical concepts (such as in behavior). In psychology we see this a lot, where classical research and empiricism breaks down entirely when critical qualitative methods, such as discursive and phenomenological methods are applied, even with some of the most respected and well known research.


This is where we become lost in what is quantifiable and what is real. Science's inability to fully comprehend or have the ability to quantify or express is the limiting factor. Much in the same way that quantum mechanics seems all but unfathomable, the laws of nature, which must include the quantum level, may as well be magic if it is beyond our understanding.
We may dip into the nature of things and view it on a limited level by studying biology, psychology, chemistry or physics but the bigger picture is still out of reach and remains hypothetical.
Is it possible to see beyond the apparently chaotic behavior or the quantum level ? Is quantum really the quantum ?

I think that sciences create models of reality, rather than being exact representations. I suspect existence before translation through sensory data closely resembles a more 'chaotic system', and that in order to function we construct meaningful represenations of it, rather than 'experience it' as it truly is.



Since observation effects the quantum level according to current understanding, that makes reality a very tricky customer. I don't like the idea of a chaotic reality as that implies that there is no solution to the puzzle beyond accepting that there is no solution.
That's almost as unsatisfactory as blaming God to my mind.

But that is what the evidence suggest, that the method of observation and measurement scale used, will affect the outcome and results; this presents the idea seen in post-modern science outlooks, that rather than constructing a view of reality, scientific methods construct a model of reality based on our observations and measurements (which actually fits better with experimental vs applied science dichotomy).

Scientifically speaking there is no real basis to assume otherwise, as the chaotic and fuzzy systems present a solution to the macro vs micro scale that fits both levels, and works.

Science isn't about truth, its about predictable and highly probable outcomes. The mistake of modernism was to assume that the scientist is somehow entirely objective and separated from the experimental methodology (and as we experience the world subjectively, we can never truly ever separate our bias entirely).

In truth, science has never really been anything other than the construction of models of high probability over low probability.

As such the Quantum and relative are both acceptable models.



Hard to disagree with any of that.

Science stands very little chance of revealing the great mystery of existence. Human perception and the limited reach of scientific measure will always be a barrier.
Existence seems to be the creation of the complex from the simple and order from chaos. The exact process might aways evade us. For that matter, reality might not actually be real.

I hope at least that it will always remain a good topic for debate and that humanity resists the ever present danger of dark age ignorance peddled by organised religion.

 

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 27 Jun 15 11.29am

Quote TheJudge at 27 Jun 2015 10.35am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 24 Jun 2015 11.49am

Quote TheJudge at 20 Jun 2015 8.04pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 20 Jun 2015 7.15pm

Quote TheJudge at 19 Jun 2015 4.27pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 19 Jun 2015 12.53pm

The important thing with chaotic systems is that they are both at the same time chaotic and disordered (neither is dominant) what matters is the point of scale at which you interact.

How we measure something, and the methodology by which we measure something, will inevitably affect our results, especially when dealing with hypothetical concepts (such as in behavior). In psychology we see this a lot, where classical research and empiricism breaks down entirely when critical qualitative methods, such as discursive and phenomenological methods are applied, even with some of the most respected and well known research.


This is where we become lost in what is quantifiable and what is real. Science's inability to fully comprehend or have the ability to quantify or express is the limiting factor. Much in the same way that quantum mechanics seems all but unfathomable, the laws of nature, which must include the quantum level, may as well be magic if it is beyond our understanding.
We may dip into the nature of things and view it on a limited level by studying biology, psychology, chemistry or physics but the bigger picture is still out of reach and remains hypothetical.
Is it possible to see beyond the apparently chaotic behavior or the quantum level ? Is quantum really the quantum ?

I think that sciences create models of reality, rather than being exact representations. I suspect existence before translation through sensory data closely resembles a more 'chaotic system', and that in order to function we construct meaningful represenations of it, rather than 'experience it' as it truly is.



Since observation effects the quantum level according to current understanding, that makes reality a very tricky customer. I don't like the idea of a chaotic reality as that implies that there is no solution to the puzzle beyond accepting that there is no solution.
That's almost as unsatisfactory as blaming God to my mind.

But that is what the evidence suggest, that the method of observation and measurement scale used, will affect the outcome and results; this presents the idea seen in post-modern science outlooks, that rather than constructing a view of reality, scientific methods construct a model of reality based on our observations and measurements (which actually fits better with experimental vs applied science dichotomy).

Scientifically speaking there is no real basis to assume otherwise, as the chaotic and fuzzy systems present a solution to the macro vs micro scale that fits both levels, and works.

Science isn't about truth, its about predictable and highly probable outcomes. The mistake of modernism was to assume that the scientist is somehow entirely objective and separated from the experimental methodology (and as we experience the world subjectively, we can never truly ever separate our bias entirely).

In truth, science has never really been anything other than the construction of models of high probability over low probability.

As such the Quantum and relative are both acceptable models.



Hard to disagree with any of that.

Science stands very little chance of revealing the great mystery of existence. Human perception and the limited reach of scientific measure will always be a barrier.
Existence seems to be the creation of the complex from the simple and order from chaos. The exact process might aways evade us. For that matter, reality might not actually be real.

I hope at least that it will always remain a good topic for debate and that humanity resists the ever present danger of dark age ignorance peddled by organised religion.


Unlike the clear sighted religious view.
And next, a debate on what colour shoes pixies wear.

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 28 Jun 15 11.22am

Quote Catfish at 27 Jun 2015 11.29am

Quote TheJudge at 27 Jun 2015 10.35am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 24 Jun 2015 11.49am

Quote TheJudge at 20 Jun 2015 8.04pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 20 Jun 2015 7.15pm

Quote TheJudge at 19 Jun 2015 4.27pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 19 Jun 2015 12.53pm

The important thing with chaotic systems is that they are both at the same time chaotic and disordered (neither is dominant) what matters is the point of scale at which you interact.

How we measure something, and the methodology by which we measure something, will inevitably affect our results, especially when dealing with hypothetical concepts (such as in behavior). In psychology we see this a lot, where classical research and empiricism breaks down entirely when critical qualitative methods, such as discursive and phenomenological methods are applied, even with some of the most respected and well known research.


This is where we become lost in what is quantifiable and what is real. Science's inability to fully comprehend or have the ability to quantify or express is the limiting factor. Much in the same way that quantum mechanics seems all but unfathomable, the laws of nature, which must include the quantum level, may as well be magic if it is beyond our understanding.
We may dip into the nature of things and view it on a limited level by studying biology, psychology, chemistry or physics but the bigger picture is still out of reach and remains hypothetical.
Is it possible to see beyond the apparently chaotic behavior or the quantum level ? Is quantum really the quantum ?

I think that sciences create models of reality, rather than being exact representations. I suspect existence before translation through sensory data closely resembles a more 'chaotic system', and that in order to function we construct meaningful represenations of it, rather than 'experience it' as it truly is.



Since observation effects the quantum level according to current understanding, that makes reality a very tricky customer. I don't like the idea of a chaotic reality as that implies that there is no solution to the puzzle beyond accepting that there is no solution.
That's almost as unsatisfactory as blaming God to my mind.

But that is what the evidence suggest, that the method of observation and measurement scale used, will affect the outcome and results; this presents the idea seen in post-modern science outlooks, that rather than constructing a view of reality, scientific methods construct a model of reality based on our observations and measurements (which actually fits better with experimental vs applied science dichotomy).

Scientifically speaking there is no real basis to assume otherwise, as the chaotic and fuzzy systems present a solution to the macro vs micro scale that fits both levels, and works.

Science isn't about truth, its about predictable and highly probable outcomes. The mistake of modernism was to assume that the scientist is somehow entirely objective and separated from the experimental methodology (and as we experience the world subjectively, we can never truly ever separate our bias entirely).

In truth, science has never really been anything other than the construction of models of high probability over low probability.

As such the Quantum and relative are both acceptable models.



Hard to disagree with any of that.

Science stands very little chance of revealing the great mystery of existence. Human perception and the limited reach of scientific measure will always be a barrier.
Existence seems to be the creation of the complex from the simple and order from chaos. The exact process might aways evade us. For that matter, reality might not actually be real.

I hope at least that it will always remain a good topic for debate and that humanity resists the ever present danger of dark age ignorance peddled by organised religion.


Unlike the clear sighted religious view.
And next, a debate on what colour shoes pixies wear.

Its always important to understand the limitations of an approach, otherwise you can easily end up mistaking assumptions for truth.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

reborn 29 Jun 15 9.30am

Especially for Mr Dawkins

20130414-214529.jpg Attachment: 20130414-214529.jpg (19.04Kb)

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 29 Jun 15 10.15am

Quote reborn at 29 Jun 2015 9.30am

Especially for Mr Dawkins

Indeed, and its quite sad, because when he started out he really wasn't, he was a refuter of critics of evolutionary theory, not a self appointed agitator of an atheist movement and provocator of religion.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 29 Jun 15 10.23am

Dawkins isn't an arsehole.

I'd just like to say that because the image is annoying.

He at least doesn't try pushing fairy tales onto children as truth. He can prove the information that he pushes.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 29 Jun 15 10.48am

Quote Stirlingsays at 29 Jun 2015 10.23am

Dawkins isn't an arsehole.

I'd just like to say that because the image is annoying.

He at least doesn't try pushing fairy tales onto children as truth. He can prove the information that he pushes.

He is a bit of an arse... But not compared to many.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 29 Jun 15 10.51am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 29 Jun 2015 10.48am

Quote Stirlingsays at 29 Jun 2015 10.23am

Dawkins isn't an arsehole.

I'd just like to say that because the image is annoying.

He at least doesn't try pushing fairy tales onto children as truth. He can prove the information that he pushes.

He is a bit of an arse... But not compared to many.



Fair enough.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

reborn 29 Jun 15 7.36pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 29 Jun 2015 10.23am

Dawkins isn't an arsehole.

I'd just like to say that because the image is annoying.

He at least doesn't try pushing fairy tales onto children as truth. He can prove the information that he pushes.

1) He cant actually, much of the Theory of Evolution has blanks filled in with best guess scenarios

2)We clearly base what is an arsehole on different criteria

[Link]

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

steviebarton Flag Gosberton, Lincolnshire 29 Jun 15 7.57pm

Dawkins is certainly not universally admired in the 'scientific community'; not least because his gift of rational argument has been distorted by his prejudices. He also falls into the trap of believing that all truth = scientific truth, which is a delusion of its own. What he has achieved is to compel Christian academics to review evidence scrupulously, and to avoid sloppy arguments, and for that we should be appreciative.

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 29 Jun 15 10.47pm

The Bible: So Misunderstood It's a Sin
[Link]

The Bible has more than one story of creation; four actually, one involving God fighting a dragon. Many important elements, like the Three Kings, the virgin birth, the ascension, the parable about casting the first stone and David slaying Goliath were all added later. It's been translated, edited, rewritten and re-interpreted countless times.

People who study the Bible - like the person who wrote this non-jusgmental article - know this. People who cherry-pick the Bible for their own devices get pretty badly pantsed by the author.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Jun 15 9.40am

Quote reborn at 29 Jun 2015 7.36pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 29 Jun 2015 10.23am

Dawkins isn't an arsehole.

I'd just like to say that because the image is annoying.

He at least doesn't try pushing fairy tales onto children as truth. He can prove the information that he pushes.

1) He cant actually, much of the Theory of Evolution has blanks filled in with best guess scenarios

2)We clearly base what is an arsehole on different criteria

[Link]

1) it really hasn't - Of course a best guess scenario, or theory backed by a reasonable argument, is of course more reliable and valid than one that doesn't fit within the existing model and is backed by no evidence other than pointing at holes. Typically people who use the 'evolution can't explain everything' generally don't;
a) Understand evolutionary theory and population genetics.
b) Misunderstand scientific methodology
c) haven't understood the statement and evidence presented.

2) He's not entirely wrong, I disagree with his view in regards to downs syndrome, but its a personal view, and one that isn't entirely without some rational merit. However in relation to many very serious medical and physiological problems he's right. How anyone allows their child to go to term with disorders such as Harlequin-type ichthyosis (for example) is more likely acting out of selfish personal reasons than the well being of their child. Notably in cases of severe downs syndrome, the same applies.

I think its immoral to not consider termination of a pregnancy due to fetal defects, because often people tend to act on a 'there might be a miracle', or otherwise selfish reasons.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

reborn 30 Jun 15 12.53pm

So you agree that to have a Downs Syndrome baby is morally wrong Jamie.

Yes or No?

(I know you struggle with short answers)

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Jun 15 1.17pm

Quote reborn at 30 Jun 2015 12.53pm

So you agree that to have a Downs Syndrome baby is morally wrong Jamie.

Yes or No?

(I know you struggle with short answers)

I think the context is central. You can't reduce moral or ethical questions to a yes or no answer. I'd say yes, but the important part is the bit following (I think its morally questionable to have children, let alone ones with severe disabilities).

Personally I believe having children is morally wrong, and selfish, given the population of the planet is absurdly out of kilter, it can only add to the misery, both of humans and a death sentence to countless other species.

Ultimately we cull or neuter or otherwise control the populations of other species and yet we have spread like a virus across the planet, destroying species, eco-systems and ultimately ourselves, increasingly as resources run low.

The options ultimately, for humanity will be a cull or population birth control or species collapse. of the three, birth control seem the more humane.

So I don't have children. I wouldn't think twice about aborting a fetus, downes or otherwise, truth be told


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Jun 15 1.19pm

Quote reborn at 30 Jun 2015 12.53pm

So you agree that to have a Downs Syndrome baby is morally wrong Jamie.

Yes or No?

(I know you struggle with short answers)

Short answer, if depends on the severity of the Downs Syndrome and the suffering of the child, I'd guess. I've known people with Downes who lived relatively good lives, and of others who suffered terrible short lives.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 12 of 14 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Richard Dawkins Hero