You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Southampton Match Thread
November 16 2026 12.00pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Southampton Match Thread


Page 12 of 13 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
Username Flag Horsham 22 Sep 16 10.27am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The reason, and I'm answering other posters in this sentence but the discussion is a follow up to several, Dann played and got injured and for that matter Delaney played and nearly got injured is that Tomkins is injured and we have have 3 centre halves. This is not a criticism but a fact. We also only have 6 defenders plus fryers so you can answer with that if Kelly or Ward got injured.

I'm sorry but we're paying for not backing up the squad enough already. I didn't expect us to be fully backed up with 2 players for every position, but when it was an obvious concern we paid for inadequate backup in midfield last 2nd half of the season it was also obvious this Summer there might be a problem in defence and also attack. Forwards can cost in the £15 mil bracket so if you don't get what you really want, Remy who is proven but not full primed I understand. Hopefully he'll be ready before Benteke maybe cannot play for what I hope will be very temporary.

But it is obvious, Souare car crash or not, because he could be injured himself so that isn't an excuse, 6 defenders isn't enough, and an unready or ready when he has to play at RB Flamini and makeshift LB in Ledley will both stretch things in a midfield that was a concern to begin with.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (22 Sep 2016 8.46am)

Hang on. There is a limit of 25 players to a squad. You seem to be saying that we don't have enough defenders, midfielders or attackers?


 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

james03 Flag Bangkok 22 Sep 16 10.36am

Originally posted by Painter

What riches of Europe, I understood there is no European place available in this cup anymore, it's been devalued.

Please advise where you got this information from. I have not seen any withdrawal of a Europa League place for the League Cup winners. All reports indicate to me that winning this competition still gets you through to the third qualifying round.

 


The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. Groucho Marx

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Sep 16 10.37am

Originally posted by citizensmudge

You need to look a bit further than what you think Rudi.We have the same amount of defenders currently as we had in the squad for the second half of last season.

Dann....Delaney....Tomkins....Ward....Souare....Kelly ....Fryers.

That is 2 LB's 2 RB's 3 CB's (with Kelly able to play anywhere across the back)

You then have 10 in midfield,an area of concern as well according to you and out of those you have Ledley who is left footed and Flamini who is right footed both of whom have experience of playing at full back off their respective stronger foot.Take those 2 away and you are still left with Cabaye and McArthur as DM's and they are arguably our strongest pairing anyway.You then obviously have our attacking midfield players and the 5 lads in the squad who would be classed as forwards.Appiah and Cambell are included and perhaps that could be seen as a spot wasted not withstanding the fact that it was scoring goals that let us down last season.

My point is when you look at that squad on paper and the options it gives you at the back and in midfield in my opinion it looks a very strong group of players and one that should comfortably see it through till January.When you consider we have strengthened in the areas we all knew we needed to and left some cash to spend in the mid season window.

10 in midfield has got to be a typo. I'd say we have 4 prem able middle of midfielders. Cabaye, Jimmac, Ledley and Punch who would then leave a whole at number 10 and Flamini who isn't ready. So that's 4 plus 1 for 2 positions or 3 positions which we are really counting if you play 3 or even 4-2-3-1 or similar seeing as we always do. 5 players for 3 positions and 6 players for 4 defensive positions. Maybe cutting it fine and telling Lady Luck nah we'll take our chances again. Maybe, just maybe, we are 1 defender short and 6 is not enough. I'd be interested to know how many other clubs cross their fingers on injuries in areas they're fully aware of and not just once.

P.S - I don't and I cannot accept anyone counting Fryers as a 7th defender. He is one mistake we cannot correct.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Sep 16 10.38am

Originally posted by Username

Hang on. There is a limit of 25 players to a squad. You seem to be saying that we don't have enough defenders, midfielders or attackers?


Do you think we're fully equipped then in defence?

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Sep 16 10.44am

Originally posted by james03

Please advise where you got this information from. I have not seen any withdrawal of a Europa League place for the League Cup winners. All reports indicate to me that winning this competition still gets you through to the third qualifying round.

It's still a bullsh1t competition to English teams because of the money in the prem and btw if the money wasn't in the prem we wouldn't be able to compete in the Europa league after giving it a go.

A group stage at this stage of the season would kill us unless we had 25 top quality players. We'd be certain for relegation.

 


COYP

Midlands Eagle Flag 22 Sep 16 10.44am

Originally posted by Dan1994

Right, I was at the game last night and I'll give a breakdown of what I thought were positives and negatives:

Positives
- We're out of the EFL Trophy, which is good given how thin our squad so painfully obviously is.

Negatives
- Our fringe players are terrible, and Sako, Mutch and Fryers (and preferably Wickham) need to leave.

How much of the terribleness of our fringe players is down to a lack of match practice and now that we are out of the EFL Trophy they will get even less so if asked to step up for a League game they will be even more rusty

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Sep 16 10.52am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

How much of the terribleness of our fringe players is down to a lack of match practice and now that we are out of the EFL Trophy they will get even less so if asked to step up for a League game they will be even more rusty

I'd say that any more than one of those in the side and we will notice the drop in quality far too much. I was in the Wickham camp but I don't know what's got to him. Maybe knowing he won't get a sniff as long as Benteke is playing or it's the final minutes and we're desperate but that header from Hennessey's kick he was muscled off the ball for didn't look good. Not to mention the knife through butter moment from centre circle to in on goal in 2 passes.

 


COYP

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 22 Sep 16 11.12am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

How much of the terribleness of our fringe players is down to a lack of match practice and now that we are out of the EFL Trophy they will get even less so if asked to step up for a League game they will be even more rusty

That is a very good point, but I think the fact we still had to play Dann and Zaha shows our squad depth is limited. The players who suffer from the lack of games in our squad aren't good enough for us (Fryers, Mutch and Sako). The only people who lose out are the youngsters, which Pards has made clear he doesn't want to play.

 


[Link]

Username Flag Horsham 22 Sep 16 11.15am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Do you think we're fully equipped then in defence?


My point is that you are saying we're under-equipped in every area, to which the only response would be to sign loads more players and go over the 25.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Sep 16 11.18am

Originally posted by Dan1994

That is a very good point, but I think the fact we still had to play Dann and Zaha shows our squad depth is limited. The players who suffer from the lack of games in our squad aren't good enough for us (Fryers, Mutch and Sako). The only people who lose out are the youngsters, which Pards has made clear he doesn't want to play.

In last night's squad, Southampton had 4 'Home Grown' players, I think the oldest of which is 22.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Sep 16 11.20am

Originally posted by Username


My point is that you are saying we're under-equipped in every area, to which the only response would be to sign loads more players and go over the 25.

We are carrying Fryers that's why. If we had a decent cover and not him that would be enough and the concern for until Tomkins or Dann are back wouldn't be so bad. I bet we could loan him out for part of his wages. Now we're short he's not even a consideration so why in the squad in the 1st place?

Edited by Rudi Hedman (22 Sep 2016 11.20am)

 


COYP

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 22 Sep 16 11.25am

Originally posted by Willo

In last night's squad, Southampton had 4 'Home Grown' players, I think the oldest of which is 22.

I meant 'losing out' by us going out of the EFL Cup, which doesn't matter for us as Pards clearly doesn't want to play our home-grown players.

 


[Link]

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Sep 16 11.27am

Originally posted by Dan1994

I meant 'losing out' by us going out of the EFL Cup, which doesn't matter for us as Pards clearly doesn't want to play our home-grown players.

The ones closer to 1st team football are on loan so he can't.

Choice of 2 league cup games for 4 months or week in week out competitive and physical 3rd or in time 2nd tier football to get them and see if they can hack it. Lampard, Beckham etc all had to do it.

 


COYP

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 22 Sep 16 11.33am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The ones closer to 1st team football are on loan so he can't.

Choice of 2 league cup games for 4 months or week in week out competitive and physical 3rd or in time 2nd tier football to get them and see if they can hack it. Lampard, Beckham etc all had to do it.

Williams, Boateng and Kaikai have already done that several times, though. The few times they played for the firs-team, they looked up for it. Not gonna lie, but I'd rather Williams over Mutch and Kaikai over Sako.

 


[Link]

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Sep 16 11.40am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The ones closer to 1st team football are on loan so he can't.

Choice of 2 league cup games for 4 months or week in week out competitive and physical 3rd or in time 2nd tier football to get them and see if they can hack it. Lampard, Beckham etc all had to do it.

Lampard went on loan to Swansea and Beckham to Preston.


 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Sep 16 11.41am

Originally posted by Dan1994

Williams, Boateng and Kaikai have already done that several times, though. The few times they played for the firs-team, they looked up for it. Not gonna lie, but I'd rather Williams over Mutch and Kaikai over Sako.

Boateng you have a point but for him to get a regular run he'd be waiting for periods of 3 of the top 5 midfielders to be unavailable. Then when one of them is back he's out of the team again whereas they can get 30 or more, hopefully 40 games on loan.

We're almost in that position now with Tomkins and Dann out, Fryers being a waste of time and Ledley or Flamini possibly filling in at full back but Tomkins and/or Dann will be back within 2 and 3 weeks so Boateng would get 2 goes and out again.

 


COYP

paperhat Flag croydon 22 Sep 16 2.04pm

Originally posted by cpj

1. typo - you know what I meant (aren't you clever!).
2. how have I had a go at Mandanda? I've only seen him once so to say I haven't yet formed an opinion is a fair comment. Certainly fairer than your racist comment!

I didn't say you did have a go at Mandanda, I clearly eluded to the fact that you would wait in the wings for him to make a mistake, then dive (pardon the pun) to the defense of your beloved WH whilst taking the opportunity to have a pop at Pardew at the same time.

If any clarity is required with the above, please refer to your numerous posts on the highlighted subjects.

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


cpj Flag Kent 22 Sep 16 2.43pm

Originally posted by paperhat

I didn't say you did have a go at Mandanda, I clearly eluded to the fact that you would wait in the wings for him to make a mistake, then dive (pardon the pun) to the defense of your beloved WH whilst taking the opportunity to have a pop at Pardew at the same time.

If any clarity is required with the above, please refer to your numerous posts on the highlighted subjects.

Then you are wrong, and you have me mistaken for Brentmeister General and his unnatural hatred for Hennessey. I have no feelings either way - I just want the best players for Palace and last season Hennessey was the best goalkeeper we had and I argued that fact. Now he probably isn't.

 

victor43 Flag St. Albans 22 Sep 16 3.44pm

Originally posted by Dan1994

That is a very good point, but I think the fact we still had to play Dann and Zaha shows our squad depth is limited. The players who suffer from the lack of games in our squad aren't good enough for us (Fryers, Mutch and Sako). The only people who lose out are the youngsters, which Pards has made clear he doesn't want to play.

I really don't see how they are losing out by missing ONE league cup game against very good opposition (chances are we'd still lose).

So if they're not on loan and they're out of the cup, what do they do from now until Jan? Nothing!

None of them are ready yet for the Premier League so they should be out on loan at lower leagues, which they are.

If they are good enough he will play them.

Wouldn't mind seeing Dreher in a couple of games mind but tough to know when to put him in.

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Sep 16 3.50pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

We are carrying Fryers that's why. If we had a decent cover and not him that would be enough and the concern for until Tomkins or Dann are back wouldn't be so bad. I bet we could loan him out for part of his wages. Now we're short he's not even a consideration so why in the squad in the 1st place?

Edited by Rudi Hedman (22 Sep 2016 11.20am)

Fryers has been on the bench in the last two league games. Maybe he is back in with a shout of redemption.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 12 of 13 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Southampton Match Thread