You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ref: Palace v Burnley
November 16 2026 9.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ref: Palace v Burnley


Page 12 of 14 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 May 17 8.50am

I don't for a minute accept that Clattenburg acted "unprofesionally".
He happened to bump into Ferguson, the cameras were rolling and all he did was to act in a friendly manner.What was he supposed to do - turn his back and be rude ?

Do you honestly believe that there is a 'Berlin Wall' between managers and referees before games with both parties NOT allowed to be sociable with one another or indeed be in each other's company ? You don't see it on TV but it does happen.There might be a handshake, a bit of banter, some friendly chit-chat that's all, certainly nothing designed to influence the referee's decisions in the game.

We lost a cup final having taken the lead in the second half and couldn't beat 10 men in the end.All down to our failings yet people go on about Clattenburg being sociable to a former manager !!!!! Incredulous.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 03 May 17 8.55am

Originally posted by Willo

NOT "Out of order at all".

I have expressed my honest opinions in my own way and I shall treat some of the risible allegations with the contempt they deserve.

And I have already commented in detail about the incidents in the Final so I really dont need to plough the same "Acres" until the rhetorical soil acquires the texture of sub-standard mince.

You certainly will NOT rile the old "Billy Goat" in me by some of the ludicrous and totally inaccurate allegations which in all honesty have the heady ether of effluvia.Broadbrush, blustery bombastications and risible canards appear to be "Order of the day" as far as you are concerned with high-grade waffle also on your agenda.

At the end of the day I argue my 'Case' free from ad-hominem personal attacks against someone's honesty and integrity which in truth poison the well of debate.

On that note I shall now go to my bed, free in the knowledge that like some on here I have NOT propogated palbable tosh as part of an agenda of personal vilification.

I am sure you will be delighted to be informed that I shall NOT dignify any of your posts with a response as they are as inaccurate as they are risible and one's time can be spent more constructively than by replying to such hogwash.
Any further posts of yours regarding "Yours Truly" shall go unanswered as I have NO desire to place your comments into the 'Spotlight'.Sorry to disappoint you.



Edited by Willo (03 May 2017 12.43am)


Oh Ive just got it, you are posting in the style of that bloke who used to present that Old Time Music Hall on TV!!

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 03 May 17 8.56am

Originally posted by Willo

I don't for a minute accept that Clattenburg acted "unprofesionally".
He happened to bump into Ferguson, the cameras were rolling and all he did was to act in a friendly manner.What was he supposed to do - turn his back and be rude ?

Do you honestly believe that there is a 'Berlin Wall' between managers and referees before games with both parties NOT allowed to be sociable with one another or indeed be in each other's company ? You don't see it on TV but it does happen.There might be a handshake, a bit of banter, some friendly chit-chat that's all, certainly nothing designed to influence the referee's decisions in the game.

We lost a cup final having taken the lead in the second half and couldn't beat 10 men in the end.All down to our failings yet people go on about Clattenburg being sociable to a former manager !!!!! Incredulous.

So, if you were up in court & just before your hearing the judge came up & hugged the prosecuting barrister like he was one of his best mates you'd not think that "unprofessional"?

After the event, fine. Before, misguided at best.

Edited by Nobbybm (03 May 2017 8.58am)

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 May 17 9.09am

Originally posted by Nobbybm


So, if you were up in court & just before your hearing the judge came up & hugged the prosecuting barrister like he was one of his best mates you'd not think that "unprofessional"?

After the event, fine. Before, misguided at best.

Edited by Nobbybm (03 May 2017 8.58am)

Let's deal in the reality, NOT some "Dreamt up" hypothetical situation.

I've commented on what happened and explained that such 'Meetings' between managers and referees before a game DO happen as they can trod the same paths.

What was Clattenburg to do ? Put his hand to the camera , or do an "About-turn" and shun someone he has clearly spoken to on numerous occasions.And Ferguson wasn't even the manager of the team !

At the end of the day, if we had won that game this topic would never have occurred.


Edited by Willo (03 May 2017 9.11am)

 

PremierPalace Flag 03 May 17 9.24am

Originally posted by Willo

I don't for a minute accept that Clattenburg acted "unprofesionally".
He happened to bump into Ferguson, the cameras were rolling and all he did was to act in a friendly manner.What was he supposed to do - turn his back and be rude ?

Do you honestly believe that there is a 'Berlin Wall' between managers and referees before games with both parties NOT allowed to be sociable with one another or indeed be in each other's company ? You don't see it on TV but it does happen.There might be a handshake, a bit of banter, some friendly chit-chat that's all, certainly nothing designed to influence the referee's decisions in the game.

We lost a cup final having taken the lead in the second half and couldn't beat 10 men in the end.All down to our failings yet people go on about Clattenburg being sociable to a former manager !!!!! Incredulous.

Oh come on - Ferguson was well known for his effect on referees and decisions. What happened before the game was not them 'bumping into each other' and saying "how do you do, old chap?" and shaking hands. They had a hug and a laugh and Ferguson pretended to stuff a wad of cash into Clattenburg's top pocket. That is unprofessional. It's not rude to tell Ferguson that this sort of joke before an FA Cup Final is not appropriate. But more to the point, why is their relationship such that Ferguson felt that it was okay to do that in the first place? They are clearly to chummy for him to think that's acceptable. It is one thing to be sociable, and it is another to be friends with each other. As I, and other posters have said, this would not stand in any other job where you have to be impartial. If a judge was seen being 'sociable' in this way, it would cause outcry.

Such blind following is dangerous, and reminds me of Orwell's "Animal Farm" (based on Stalin and the Russian Revolution) where the animals blindly follow those that were designated to lead and make the rules. The rules could then change subtly to allow the leaders to act as they wished. It is dangerous when people with that much power are given free reign over anything, much like how referees at most get 'demoted' a league, but never have to explain their controversial decisions.

You make any form of debate pointless, as you are so willing to understand things from a referees point of view, but fail to see it from the most basic angle, the unbiased truth. If it were an incident that happened before a match against Watford, Brighton, Chelsea, Arsenal, Liverpool, Millwall (all teams I do not like) I would be saying the same. It was wrong of him, and of Ferguson.

I've attached a photo of that incident (I can only seem to attach one at a time), showing it was more than one friendly greeting as Ferguson pretends to stuff a wad into Clattenburg's pocket as the impartial referee enjoys being touched by his idol, his eyes glowing like an infant.

There is another one where Clattenburg looks at Ferguson with adoration, as shown in the picture where he is pointing at him like h is posing for a picture with his idol.

ferguson-and-clattenburg.jpg Attachment: ferguson-and-clattenburg.jpg (49.52Kb)

 

PremierPalace Flag 03 May 17 9.25am

Originally posted by Willo

Let's deal in the reality, NOT some "Dreamt up" hypothetical situation.

I've commented on what happened and explained that such 'Meetings' between managers and referees before a game DO happen as they can trod the same paths.

What was Clattenburg to do ? Put his hand to the camera , or do an "About-turn" and shun someone he has clearly spoken to on numerous occasions.And Ferguson wasn't even the manager of the team !

At the end of the day, if we had won that game this topic would never have occurred.


Edited by Willo (03 May 2017 9.11am)

Politely shake his hand, say hello, and walk away.
As the post you replied to said, in the case of barristers and judges this would be wrong before the event, and the often have met numerous times and know each other on a personal level, but when you are there to do an impartial job, you should not be sucked into such things beforehand

Edited by PremierPalace (03 May 2017 9.28am)

 

PremierPalace Flag 03 May 17 9.30am

Originally posted by Willo

What a load of old hogwash and rhetorical grandstanding in equal measures.
Certainly chimerical and a rambling farrago of nonsense.
I'm certainly not going to dignify the post by responding to the points raised.
I believe the propogation of absolute tosh is NOT worthy of any considered response.

Edited by Willo (02 May 2017 11.13pm)

I thought you didn't do 'ad hominem' attacks? Yet you refuse to respond to my point, just attack the thought of it.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 May 17 9.34am

Originally posted by PremierPalace

Politely shake his hand, say hello, and walk away.
As the post you replied to said, in the case of barristers and judges this would be wrong before the event, and the often have met numerous times and know each other on a personal level, but when you are there to do an impartial job, you should not be sucked into such things beforehand

Edited by PremierPalace (03 May 2017 9.28am)

Easier said than done when someone is being very friendly and effusive and merely engaging in a bit of banter.

The Anti-Clattenburg faction will drag up all sorts of things to criticise him.At the end of the day, like him or loathe him he is considered one of the top referees in the world, unpalatable as it is to those on here.

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 03 May 17 9.38am

Originally posted by Willo

Let's deal in the reality, NOT some "Dreamt up" hypothetical situation.

I've commented on what happened and explained that such 'Meetings' between managers and referees before a game DO happen as they can trod the same paths.

What was Clattenburg to do ? Put his hand to the camera , or do an "About-turn" and shun someone he has clearly spoken to on numerous occasions.And Ferguson wasn't even the manager of the team !

At the end of the day, if we had won that game this topic would never have occurred.


Edited by Willo (03 May 2017 9.11am)

It's about context. As has been said, a polite handshake to all present would have been appropriate.

In my working life I )like many others) have to manage any potential conflicts of interest and this is very relevant to the argument - any referee is the same. It would appear that you believe this does not apply to Mr C when, clearly, it does.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 May 17 9.38am

Originally posted by PremierPalace


I thought you didn't do 'ad hominem' attacks? Yet you refuse to respond to my point, just attack the thought of it.

Yes I argue my case free from personal slurs unlike many on HOL who have chosen to trod this path with such attacks against me.

I have responded to numerous points on here - I don't have to spend hours on end just answering questions or passing comments many of which I have made over and over again to the extent I feel like a gramophone record that has got stuck in the groove.

I am campaigning for the Conservatives in the local elections on Thursday so I shall be out on that 'Campaign Trail' shortly.HOL will be a "Willo Free" zone and I suspect for many that will be bliss.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 May 17 9.45am

Originally posted by Nobbybm

It's about context. As has been said, a polite handshake to all present would have been appropriate.

In my working life I )like many others) have to manage any potential conflicts of interest and this is very relevant to the argument - any referee is the same. It would appear that you believe this does not apply to Mr C when, clearly, it does.

Even I with my limited intelligence understands what this means.

Clattenburg happened to get involved in a situation not of his making and I would argue this point if it was any other referee.And I repeat - referees and managers paths do happen to cross before games but not intentionally.

Just waiting for the comments on HOL "Clattenburg's decision making was influenced by Ferguson " Dear oh dear.Mountains and molehills spring to mind.

Anyway, off on the 'Campaign Trail' now !

 

PremierPalace Flag 03 May 17 10.17am

Originally posted by Willo

Easier said than done when someone is being very friendly and effusive and merely engaging in a bit of banter.

The Anti-Clattenburg faction will drag up all sorts of things to criticise him.At the end of the day, like him or loathe him he is considered one of the top referees in the world, unpalatable as it is to those on here.

Not really. If he can't just shake a man's hand politely, and remind that man that anything more would not be right then he is weak and should not be officiating FA Cup Finals as he Is clearly not strong enough to run a game ignore football

 

Michaelawt85 Flag Bexley 03 May 17 10.17am

Originally posted by EagleLee79

Agree with this.

Refs need to stop being so 'pally pally' with players and just be a referee who can do their job properly. Take no s*** from players like Rooney who are constantly moaning in his ear all the time when things arent going his way. Tell him to f*** off and let him do HIS job or book the c***!

Think it's all part of the society we live in. Every f***er wants a social media presence , to show off, living in a me me me world. Football is all part and parcel of it.

 


When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC

PremierPalace Flag 03 May 17 10.18am

Originally posted by Willo

Yes I argue my case free from personal slurs unlike many on HOL who have chosen to trod this path with such attacks against me.

I have responded to numerous points on here - I don't have to spend hours on end just answering questions or passing comments many of which I have made over and over again to the extent I feel like a gramophone record that has got stuck in the groove.

I am campaigning for the Conservatives in the local elections on Thursday so I shall be out on that 'Campaign Trail' shortly.HOL will be a "Willo Free" zone and I suspect for many that will be bliss.

And how do you think politics would be if everyone debated like you have been on here?

 

chateauferret Flag 03 May 17 10.25am

Originally posted by PremierPalace

And how do you think politics would be if everyone debated like you have been on here?

I wholehartedly recommend Scotland for your holidays this year

 


============
The Ferret
============

PremierPalace Flag 03 May 17 10.39am

Originally posted by chateauferret

I wholehartedly recommend Scotland for your holidays this year

Fair point!

Edited by PremierPalace (03 May 2017 12.32pm)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 03 May 17 11.08am

Originally posted by Willo

Yes I argue my case free from personal slurs unlike many on HOL who have chosen to trod this path with such attacks against me.

I have responded to numerous points on here - I don't have to spend hours on end just answering questions or passing comments many of which I have made over and over again to the extent I feel like a gramophone record that has got stuck in the groove.

I am campaigning for the Conservatives in the local elections on Thursday so I shall be out on that 'Campaign Trail' shortly.HOL will be a "Willo Free" zone and I suspect for many that will be bliss.

1) Replying to well constructed posts as "hogwash" and rhetoric grandstanding" just because you disagree could be construed as a slur on that poster.
2) You are correct, you dont have to spend your time answering questions..it is something you choose to do and seem to get some sort of perverse pleasure in dismissing/undermining comments that you happen not to agree with.
I know Premier Palace who is a young University student who loves Palace and is a Season Ticket holder. To dismiss his arguments in the way you did is both rude and unacceptable, perhaps an apology would be in order! Oh I forgot you never say anything out of order.

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 03 May 17 12.46pm

Originally posted by Willo

Even I with my limited intelligence understands what this means.

Clattenburg happened to get involved in a situation not of his making and I would argue this point if it was any other referee.And I repeat - referees and managers paths do happen to cross before games but not intentionally.

Just waiting for the comments on HOL "Clattenburg's decision making was influenced by Ferguson " Dear oh dear.Mountains and molehills spring to mind.

Anyway, off on the 'Campaign Trail' now !

Not in my thought process. All I've pointed out is that, in my opinion, Mr C's actions prior to the game were unprofessional in so far as he is required to appear impartial whether in the tunnel or on the pitch. Whether he is or not is moot, he must at least appear to be and his actions certainly didn't portray that.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 03 May 17 1.09pm

Originally posted by Willo

Even I with my limited intelligence understands what this means.

Clattenburg happened to get involved in a situation not of his making and I would argue this point if it was any other referee.And I repeat - referees and managers paths do happen to cross before games but not intentionally.

Just waiting for the comments on HOL "Clattenburg's decision making was influenced by Ferguson " Dear oh dear.Mountains and molehills spring to mind.

Anyway, off on the 'Campaign Trail' now !


How do you know that?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 03 May 17 1.20pm

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle


How do you know that?

Because it is darling Mark. The one who has now chased the Saudi dollar, in the words of Kevin Keegan "I would love it" if allegations are now published (with proof) I am sure Willo would still find an excuse for him.

 

Page 12 of 14 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ref: Palace v Burnley